QF Chiefs v Blues
-
@gt12 said in QF Chiefs v Blues:
@African-Monkey said in QF Chiefs v Blues:
@Duluth said in QF Chiefs v Blues:
@Chris-B said in QF Chiefs v Blues:
If it's only 50-50, I reckon you're better off kicking for the corner, expecting you'll either be able to score a try or get a better penalty shot at goal - and winding more time off the clock with the Blues pinned
Yes, if they had a functioning lineout
Yeah people forget that the Chiefs lineout was a mess.
That's not true.
Even taking that into account (running at about 70% which is terrible), we should have gone for the corner. The kick was a far lower percentage play than a line out, and we would have kept them deep in their half off set piece, at a minimum.
I'm prepared to die on this hill.
Fair enough. I personally thought it was the right decision to go for 3 but I do see the other side of the argument to it.
-
@African-Monkey said in QF Chiefs v Blues:
@Duluth said in QF Chiefs v Blues:
@Chris-B said in QF Chiefs v Blues:
If it's only 50-50, I reckon you're better off kicking for the corner, expecting you'll either be able to score a try or get a better penalty shot at goal - and winding more time off the clock with the Blues pinned
Yes, if they had a functioning lineout
Yeah people forget that the Chiefs lineout was a mess.
That's a worry given so many of their forwards are ABs or in the frame.
-
Can't give you an upvote, but I can appreciate why it was considered the right idea.
From my feeling, we had had no ball and little territory and were exiting terribly (which is not like us at all this year).
It felt to me like we needed to go win the game.
Although I understand the idea to take the 3 across the game, I personally thought we should have gone for it more because every time it was telling the Blues that their defence was working.
We never broke them down and were always at risk of giving up points when they were in our half.
-
@nostrildamus said in QF Chiefs v Blues:
@African-Monkey said in QF Chiefs v Blues:
@Duluth said in QF Chiefs v Blues:
@Chris-B said in QF Chiefs v Blues:
If it's only 50-50, I reckon you're better off kicking for the corner, expecting you'll either be able to score a try or get a better penalty shot at goal - and winding more time off the clock with the Blues pinned
Yes, if they had a functioning lineout
Yeah people forget that the Chiefs lineout was a mess.
That's a worry given so many of their forwards are ABs or in the frame.
Did you watch the game?
-
No, and feel free to lambast me. Just going off what the previous poster said about lineouts. Are you saying their lineouts weren't a mess?
-
@nostrildamus said in QF Chiefs v Blues:
No, and feel free to lambast me. Just going off what the previous poster said about lineouts. Are you saying their lineouts weren't a mess?
Injuries all over the place fucked them up and we finished with a bunch of hybrids on the park and a midfielder packing the scrum at 6.
Lord lasted all of 5 minutes.
It was a fucking mess. -
@gt12 said in QF Chiefs v Blues:
Injuries all over the place fucked them up and we finished with a bunch of hybrids on the park and a midfielder packing the scrum at 6.
Lord lasted all of 5 minutes.
It was a fucking mess.I haven't read the thread but this game showed how sorely missed Jacobson was. He is a quality defender and puts pressure on the opposition at the breakdown by winning turnovers. Just as importantly, it completely stuffed up the loose forward rotation when Parker limped off as Boshier had already been subbed. Normally, one of Parker or Finau would have been replaced by Sititi.
-
@gt12 said in QF Chiefs v Blues:
@nostrildamus said in QF Chiefs v Blues:
No, and feel free to lambast me. Just going off what the previous poster said about lineouts. Are you saying their lineouts weren't a mess?
Injuries all over the place fucked them up and we finished with a bunch of hybrids on the park and a midfielder packing the scrum at 6.
Lord lasted all of 5 minutes.
It was a fucking mess.The lineout was a mess multiple times when Taukei'aho, Vaa'i, Ah Kuoi, Parker and Finau were all on the field together before the injuries.
-
@gt12 said in QF Chiefs v Blues:
@nostrildamus said in QF Chiefs v Blues:
No, and feel free to lambast me. Just going off what the previous poster said about lineouts. Are you saying their lineouts weren't a mess?
Injuries all over the place fucked them up and we finished with a bunch of hybrids on the park and a midfielder packing the scrum at 6.
Lord lasted all of 5 minutes.
It was a fucking mess.I see, thank you.
I am concerned about the ABs lineout (and not against Chiefs per se) as I thought our lineout improved in the late Foster era then started struggling under Razor/Ryan (I thought we started well against the English but I may have the order of games wrong). And Super Rugby doesn't seem a very useful gauge of lineout skill for those of us (like me) who only have time to see a few games before we head back into the international season. -
@brodean said in QF Chiefs v Blues:
@gt12 said in QF Chiefs v Blues:
@nostrildamus said in QF Chiefs v Blues:
No, and feel free to lambast me. Just going off what the previous poster said about lineouts. Are you saying their lineouts weren't a mess?
Injuries all over the place fucked them up and we finished with a bunch of hybrids on the park and a midfielder packing the scrum at 6.
Lord lasted all of 5 minutes.
It was a fucking mess.The lineout was a mess multiple times when Taukei'aho, Vaa'i, Ah Kuoi, Parker and Finau were all on the field together before the injuries.
Can't argue with that, but that's the huge weakness of starting with two hybrids at lock. Especially against that Blues team who are excellent at contesting - both Pat T and McWHannel are great at it and McWhannel probably knows the Chiefs systems and calls too.
For us, when Vaii is paired alongside a real lineout operator, we do better. We missed Lord who hopefully could have come on and sorted things out a bit.
I'm also not convinced that we put out our best lifters (probably Norris?). Overall, the idea to finish strongly got well fucked up with the injury to Jacobson (reduced our starting strength) and Lord etc.
-
-
@frugby said in QF Chiefs v Blues:
@Tim If Papalii put on 5kg, he could turn himself into a bastard of a blindside.
I always assumed long tern he'd be a 6 so was surprised when he specialised at 7, but I guess it was the best way for the Blues to keep their best loosies on the park.
