Stormers V Chiefs
-
I guess it's consistent to give YC for 'shoulder against head' contact, but it shows this rule is over the top.
Edit: After some thought, the YC was unfair. YC/RC is for intentional or reckless. This looked accidental. Penalty would have been enough.
-
@gt12 said in Stormers V Chiefs:
Come on Jaco.
Fuck you TMO!!!!
Yeah - Jaco trying his best to be sensible, the TMO... well...
@Kruse said in Stormers V Chiefs:
Jaco seems fine... I'm not particularly optimistic about the assistants or TMO though.
-
Without making judgments about that particular ruling, I really don't like the partisan nature of the TMOs. Particularly in South Africa.
@antipodean said in Stormers V Chiefs:
Without making judgments about that particular ruling, I really don't like the partisan nature of the TMOs. Particularly in South Africa.
And Japan... but obviously not with such an impact on games.
But yeah, at Super Rugby level, I assume that "up and coming", or "next tier" refs are being used as Assistants and TMOs... which is fair enough. But as such, I'd want to see more decisiveness from the "senior" ref on the field, and over-ruling them when required.
Sure - in the past people have ridiculed the on-field ref when he's over-ruled the TMO, but I think that's better than an "apprentice" having the power to change a game, with the more experienced guy letting it go for the sake of not ruining their confidence.
