Highlanders vs Blues
-
@mariner4life He did a fantastic job piloting the command module for Apollo XI?
As I recall he was pretty outstanding vs the BIL.
@chris-b said in Highlanders vs Blues:
@mariner4life He did a fantastic job piloting the command module for Apollo XI?
As I recall he was pretty outstanding vs the BIL.
Yes - his best game was against the European side and his worst games were in the fast-paced NZ derbies. His lack of pace/athletic ability gets exposed badly in NZ derbies.
-
@chris-b said in Highlanders vs Blues:
@mariner4life He did a fantastic job piloting the command module for Apollo XI?
As I recall he was pretty outstanding vs the BIL.
Yes - his best game was against the European side and his worst games were in the fast-paced NZ derbies. His lack of pace/athletic ability gets exposed badly in NZ derbies.
-
Highlanders have named a defensive midfield , by leaving Matt Faddes on the bench, although I'm slightly concerned about Tei taking on a much bigger SBW. While Blues fans may be happy with their forward pack, I can see the Highlsnders dominating there and disrupting ball to the Blues flashy backs. I'm going to say Highlanders by 12 to 18.
Daniel Lienert-Brown
Ash Dixon (cc)
Siate Tokolahi
Jackson Hemopo
Tom Franklin
Liam Squire
Dillon Hunt
Luke Whitelock
Aaron Smith
Lima Sopoaga
Tevita Li
Teihorangi Walden
Rob Thompson
Waisake Naholo
Ben Smith (cc)
Liam Coltman
Aki Seiuli
Tyrel Lomax
Dan Pryor
Elliot Dixon
Kayne Hammington
Fletcher Smith
Matt Faddes -
You just need the Highlanders to play down to the BILs level.
-
Highlanders have named a defensive midfield , by leaving Matt Faddes on the bench, although I'm slightly concerned about Tei taking on a much bigger SBW. While Blues fans may be happy with their forward pack, I can see the Highlsnders dominating there and disrupting ball to the Blues flashy backs. I'm going to say Highlanders by 12 to 18.
Daniel Lienert-Brown
Ash Dixon (cc)
Siate Tokolahi
Jackson Hemopo
Tom Franklin
Liam Squire
Dillon Hunt
Luke Whitelock
Aaron Smith
Lima Sopoaga
Tevita Li
Teihorangi Walden
Rob Thompson
Waisake Naholo
Ben Smith (cc)
Liam Coltman
Aki Seiuli
Tyrel Lomax
Dan Pryor
Elliot Dixon
Kayne Hammington
Fletcher Smith
Matt Faddes@southernmann said in Highlanders vs Blues:
While Blues fans may be happy with their forward pack, I can see the Highlsnders dominating there and disrupting ball to the Blues flashy backs. I'm going to say Highlanders by 12 to 18.
Don't sit on the fence - back your team!
-
@southernmann said in Highlanders vs Blues:
While Blues fans may be happy with their forward pack, I can see the Highlsnders dominating there and disrupting ball to the Blues flashy backs. I'm going to say Highlanders by 12 to 18.
Don't sit on the fence - back your team!
@kiwimurph I just can't see the Blues getting a lot of decent ball to play with. I also don't believe Bryn Gatland's style fits in with the rest of the Blues backline.
-
@mariner4life Kara Pryor is injured, Dan Pryor is at the Highlanders. Bond is at the Hurricanes.
@tim Murray Douglas was playing 6 and is at 'canes, Bond is currently overseas I believe.
v BOP that was Kara Pryors best game all season, but I think he had a niggly injury all season
-
A bunch of All Blacks mixed with daring debutants will open the Blues Investec Super Rugby season against the Highlanders in Dunedin on Friday.
Head coach Tana Umaga today named six current and three former All Blacks in his squad for the opener at Forsyth Barr Stadium, while there are four players to make their Super Rugby debuts and two others wearing the Blues jersey for the first time.
The Blues backline looks full of attacking flair, including Rieko Ioane, Matt Duffie, Sonny Bill Williams and George Moala, who cemented the Blues’ victory at the recent Brisbane Global 10s.
New captain Augustine Pulu starts at halfback inside Bryn Gatland, who has his fifth game for the Blues at first five, on the back of some strong performances last year.
Experienced James Parsons is flanked in the front row by All Black scrummaging powerhouse Ofa Tuungafasi and Alex Hodgman, who gets his second start after a standout season for Canterbury in the ITM Cup.
Scott Scrafton and Gerard Cowley-Tuioti, who proved themselves as a key pairing in Super Rugby last year, will start together in the middle row for the ninth time, with an in-form Akira Ioane at No8 with two North Harbour loose forwards in Murphy Taramai and Glenn Preston.
All Black Patrick Tuipulotu, back after a niggling injury, will come off the bench as well Blues newcomers Leni Apisai, Mike Tamoaieta, Jonathan Ruru, Daniel Kirkpatrick and loose forward brackets, Antonio Kiri Kiri and Sione Havili.
The Blues have 12 players not considered because of injury, including Jerome Kaino and Jimmy Tupou, who coach Umaga is giving an additional week to shake off minor injuries.
It is an important opening game for the Blues who enjoyed a productive pre-season that included the victory at Brisbane.
“Everyone is excited to get the season underway and I’m pleased with the attitude and application from our players in pre-season,” said Umaga.
“We continued to improve last year but we know that we need to do better against our fellow New Zealand teams, especially with two full derby rounds this year, and also deliver on those key moments in what is going to be a very tight and tough season.
“We have a few players with longer-term injuries, and some with lesser injuries that could have possibly played if pushed, but this is a long season and player welfare is really important.”
The team is:
Alex Hodgman, 2. James Parsons, 3. Ofa Tuungafasi, 4. Gerard Cowley-Tuioti, 5. Scott Scrafton, 6. Glenn Preston, 7. Murphy Taramai, 8. Akira Ioane; 9. Augustine Pulu
, 10. Bryn Gatland, 11. Rieko Ioane, 12. Sonny Bill Williams, 13. George Moala, 14. Matt Duffie,15. Michael Collins.
Reserves: 16. Leni Apisai, 17. Pauliasi Manu, 18. Michael Tamoaieta, 19. Patrick Tuipulotu, 20 Sione Havili/Antonio Kiri Kiri, 21. Jonathan Ruru, 22. Daniel Kirkpatrick, 23. Melani Nanai.Players not considered because of injury: Otere Black (knee), Blake Gibson (shoulder), Matt Moulds (knee), Dalton Papalii (hand), Stephen Perofeta (hand), Kara Pryor (ankle), TJ Faiane (calf), Jerome Kaino (ankle), Isaac Salmon (elbow), Jimmy Tupou (rib), Sione Mafileo (knee).
@daffy-jaffy said in Highlanders vs Blues:
James Parsons is flanked in the front row by All Black scrummaging powerhouse Ofa Tuungafasi
Haha
-
@daffy-jaffy said in Highlanders vs Blues:
James Parsons is flanked in the front row by All Black scrummaging powerhouse Ofa Tuungafasi
Haha
-
Collins is a FB version of Hadleigh Parkes imo - a decent whack of rugby nous and decent skills, but utterly lacking in pace. Vision doesn't do you much good if you can't drop the hammer (or give it full fucking jandel) and take that gap!
-
@kiwimurph said in Highlanders vs Blues:
@sammyc ?
Scrummaging powerhouse is a bit of an exaggeration
-
@kiwimurph said in Highlanders vs Blues:
@sammyc ?
Scrummaging powerhouse is a bit of an exaggeration
@sammyc said in Highlanders vs Blues:
@kiwimurph said in Highlanders vs Blues:
@sammyc ?
Scrummaging powerhouse is a bit of an exaggeration
Not when your loosehead prop in previous seasons has been Sam Prattley....
-
Happy enough with the tight five, it's what I would have picked.
The inexperienced loosies are all ok players but the chances of them all adapting to this level quickly are slim. Taramai had a few chances last year and couldn't replicate his NPC form, he needs to improve.
I would have been tempted to start GCT on the blindside and had 2 loosies on the bench.11-14 is good
Collins. Yuck. Maybe he got the nod because in its in Dunedin? But more likely it's just because the coach who cannot be criticised is a retard.
A lot depends on Gatland's form. He was shitty in the warm up matches. Fingers crossed that some of Pulu's passes are accurate.
-
Looks like our usual 4-6 point loss against fellow NZ opposition is coming up to start the season off. Pretty average looking side we've put out with the injuries we have but at the same time it's good to see some North Harbour boys get a go after a good Mitre 10 cup.
-
So ... Nanai. What's his downside?
Must have quite a big downside given he's missing out to a glue player.
@booboo said in Highlanders vs Blues:
So ... Nanai. What's his downside?
Must have quite a big downside given he's missing out to a glue player.
If you read the article it's about communication. Can be pretty key in some setups and you have to balance out what he may do in a possible opportunity against being more organised during most of the game.
As an ex player at top level in 12,13 and 14, T will have strong ideas about what he wants in communication from the back.
Factor in the stress at 10 and I can understand the reasoning. Whether the decision is correct will play out. -
@booboo said in Highlanders vs Blues:
So ... Nanai. What's his downside?
Must have quite a big downside given he's missing out to a glue player.
If you read the article it's about communication. Can be pretty key in some setups and you have to balance out what he may do in a possible opportunity against being more organised during most of the game.
As an ex player at top level in 12,13 and 14, T will have strong ideas about what he wants in communication from the back.
Factor in the stress at 10 and I can understand the reasoning. Whether the decision is correct will play out.@crucial The problem is this exact same approach failed in the NZ derbies last year. Collins lack of athletic ability got exposed in NZ derbies - Blues got away with it against the Aussie teams but not so the NZ derbies.
I just think the balance of the backline is off. Gatland has next to no running threat (he's 3rd string for a reason), SBW and Moala have distribution limitations and Collins is a carthorse at the back. I can't see the two All Black wingers getting the ball in any space.
