SR T-T FINAL: Blues v Highlanders
-
@act-crusader Nah pretty hard to give that one yellow when Nareki's contact forced the slip imo.
If it got given yellow however, I could see the reasoning behind it but penalty only fair call imo.
@african-monkey said in SR T-T FINAL: Blues v Highlanders:
@act-crusader Nah pretty hard to give that one yellow when Nareki's contact forced the slip imo.
If it got given yellow however, I could see the reasoning behind it but penalty only fair call imo.
But it was Heem's contact that forced the slip....hence Nareki getting bumped off away from the contact...
-
@gt12 said in SR T-T FINAL: Blues v Highlanders:
@bones said in SR T-T FINAL: Blues v Highlanders:
@gunner said in SR T-T FINAL: Blues v Highlanders:
I’m behind the play, but I’m unsure how Dixon’s tackle is only yellow.
No malice he says, but most red cards we see these days have no malice, so it’s irrelevant.
Just wait until you see a red mitigated to a penalty
I cannot believe that we started at red when a guy literally tripped over, versus yellow for a tackle where a guy aimed with force to hit the key playmaker of the opposite team in the head with his shoulder.
To be fair, the shoulder to head did start at red, they just wrongly mitigated it down to yellow saying it wasn't directly to the head.
@anonymous said in SR T-T FINAL: Blues v Highlanders:
@gt12 said in SR T-T FINAL: Blues v Highlanders:
@bones said in SR T-T FINAL: Blues v Highlanders:
@gunner said in SR T-T FINAL: Blues v Highlanders:
I’m behind the play, but I’m unsure how Dixon’s tackle is only yellow.
No malice he says, but most red cards we see these days have no malice, so it’s irrelevant.
Just wait until you see a red mitigated to a penalty
I cannot believe that we started at red when a guy literally tripped over, versus yellow for a tackle where a guy aimed with force to hit the key playmaker of the opposite team in the head with his shoulder.
To be fair, the shoulder to head did start at red, they just wrongly mitigated it down to yellow saying it wasn't directly to the head.
I’m talking about the discussion on here - without checking the thread it felt like the starting point was (generally) YC unless you were supporting the Blues while the Heem one was almost automatically RC - when he literally fell over.
@stargazer said in SR T-T FINAL: Blues v Highlanders:
@anonymous said in SR T-T FINAL: Blues v Highlanders:
@gt12 said in SR T-T FINAL: Blues v Highlanders:
@bones said in SR T-T FINAL: Blues v Highlanders:
@gunner said in SR T-T FINAL: Blues v Highlanders:
I’m behind the play, but I’m unsure how Dixon’s tackle is only yellow.
No malice he says, but most red cards we see these days have no malice, so it’s irrelevant.
Just wait until you see a red mitigated to a penalty
I cannot believe that we started at red when a guy literally tripped over, versus yellow for a tackle where a guy aimed with force to hit the key playmaker of the opposite team in the head with his shoulder.
To be fair, the shoulder to head did start at red, they just wrongly mitigated it down to yellow saying it wasn't directly to the head.
If it wasn't direct contact to the head, the starting point isn't red, but yellow.
You guys saying this must have seen different footage to the replays I saw. His shoulder literally smashes into the guy’s head. With force. Intentional force.
-
@african-monkey said in SR T-T FINAL: Blues v Highlanders:
@act-crusader Nah pretty hard to give that one yellow when Nareki's contact forced the slip imo.
If it got given yellow however, I could see the reasoning behind it but penalty only fair call imo.
But it was Heem's contact that forced the slip....hence Nareki getting bumped off away from the contact...
@bones Caused by Nareki running him off the ball.
-
@act-crusader Nah pretty hard to give that one yellow when Nareki's contact forced the slip imo.
If it got given yellow however, I could see the reasoning behind it but penalty only fair call imo.
@african-monkey said in SR T-T FINAL: Blues v Highlanders:
@act-crusader Nah pretty hard to give that one yellow when Nareki's contact forced the slip imo.
If it got given yellow however, I could see the reasoning behind it but penalty only fair call imo.
Heem made the contact from what I saw. Heem’s play was in the careless category and we’ve seen that punished with cards when a player is in the air and there’s been a collision like that.
-
@african-monkey said in SR T-T FINAL: Blues v Highlanders:
@act-crusader Nah pretty hard to give that one yellow when Nareki's contact forced the slip imo.
If it got given yellow however, I could see the reasoning behind it but penalty only fair call imo.
But it was Heem's contact that forced the slip....hence Nareki getting bumped off away from the contact...
@bones said in SR T-T FINAL: Blues v Highlanders:
@african-monkey said in SR T-T FINAL: Blues v Highlanders:
@act-crusader Nah pretty hard to give that one yellow when Nareki's contact forced the slip imo.
If it got given yellow however, I could see the reasoning behind it but penalty only fair call imo.
But it was Heem's contact that forced the slip....hence Nareki getting bumped off away from the contact...
Clear that Heem changed his line and initiated contact. He then fell over and took out legs of jumper. Yellow all day.
-
Game still over. Highlanders endeavour just isn't gonna overcome blues power. Especially with these mistakes and poor decisions by leaders.
One thing I've noticed about Parkinson which must count heavily (geddit) against him...his concrete boots look even heavier than the ones Papalii used to wear.
Nareki playing his way out of AB selection musings.
-
@anonymous said in SR T-T FINAL: Blues v Highlanders:
@gt12 said in SR T-T FINAL: Blues v Highlanders:
@bones said in SR T-T FINAL: Blues v Highlanders:
@gunner said in SR T-T FINAL: Blues v Highlanders:
I’m behind the play, but I’m unsure how Dixon’s tackle is only yellow.
No malice he says, but most red cards we see these days have no malice, so it’s irrelevant.
Just wait until you see a red mitigated to a penalty
I cannot believe that we started at red when a guy literally tripped over, versus yellow for a tackle where a guy aimed with force to hit the key playmaker of the opposite team in the head with his shoulder.
To be fair, the shoulder to head did start at red, they just wrongly mitigated it down to yellow saying it wasn't directly to the head.
I’m talking about the discussion on here - without checking the thread it felt like the starting point was (generally) YC unless you were supporting the Blues while the Heem one was almost automatically RC - when he literally fell over.
@stargazer said in SR T-T FINAL: Blues v Highlanders:
@anonymous said in SR T-T FINAL: Blues v Highlanders:
@gt12 said in SR T-T FINAL: Blues v Highlanders:
@bones said in SR T-T FINAL: Blues v Highlanders:
@gunner said in SR T-T FINAL: Blues v Highlanders:
I’m behind the play, but I’m unsure how Dixon’s tackle is only yellow.
No malice he says, but most red cards we see these days have no malice, so it’s irrelevant.
Just wait until you see a red mitigated to a penalty
I cannot believe that we started at red when a guy literally tripped over, versus yellow for a tackle where a guy aimed with force to hit the key playmaker of the opposite team in the head with his shoulder.
To be fair, the shoulder to head did start at red, they just wrongly mitigated it down to yellow saying it wasn't directly to the head.
If it wasn't direct contact to the head, the starting point isn't red, but yellow.
You guys saying this must have seen different footage to the replays I saw. His shoulder literally smashes into the guy’s head. With force. Intentional force.
@gt12 Yeah Dixon's contact was blatant but hey, it is what it is.
-
@kiwimurph said in SR T-T FINAL: Blues v Highlanders:
Not sure why Christie kept kicking with the Blues up a man at the time.
Especially when they’re on attack only 35-40m out from the tryline. Idiot.
Also can’t remember which commentator was saying he’s the best kicking 9 in the Blues squad - his kicking has been awful.
Nock is head and shoulders better than the other two 9s when it comes to the box kick. And he can’t even get a game. -
@bones Caused by Nareki running him off the ball.
@african-monkey said in SR T-T FINAL: Blues v Highlanders:
@bones Caused by Nareki running him off the ball.
Nareki maintains his line.
-
@kiwimurph said in SR T-T FINAL: Blues v Highlanders:
Not sure why Christie kept kicking with the Blues up a man at the time.
Especially when they’re on attack only 35-40m out from the tryline. Idiot.
Also can’t remember which commentator was saying he’s the best kicking 9 in the Blues squad - his kicking has been awful.
Nock is head and shoulders better than the other two 9s when it comes to the box kick. And he can’t even get a game.@gunner Was Marshall who then he and TJ went on to hint that he'll be the 3rd choice ABs halfback on Monday.....
-
Half time
Refereeing is a goddamn joke. Offsides ignored, swimming up the side of mauls permitted, clear red card turns out to be yellow and a clear yellow into a penalty.
Christie: Slow to rucks, even slower to move the ball. Box kicks are contestable because they're only going forwards 10m which begs the question; why bother?
-
@kiwimurph said in SR T-T FINAL: Blues v Highlanders:
Not sure why Christie kept kicking with the Blues up a man at the time.
Especially when they’re on attack only 35-40m out from the tryline. Idiot.
Also can’t remember which commentator was saying he’s the best kicking 9 in the Blues squad - his kicking has been awful.
Nock is head and shoulders better than the other two 9s when it comes to the box kick. And he can’t even get a game.@gunner said in SR T-T FINAL: Blues v Highlanders:
@kiwimurph said in SR T-T FINAL: Blues v Highlanders:
Not sure why Christie kept kicking with the Blues up a man at the time.
Especially when they’re on attack only 35-40m out from the tryline. Idiot.
Also can’t remember which commentator was saying he’s the best kicking 9 in the Blues squad - his kicking has been awful.
Nock is head and shoulders better than the other two 9s when it comes to the box kick. And he can’t even get a game.Ta$man Mako$ and Ruru fetish.
-
@african-monkey said in SR T-T FINAL: Blues v Highlanders:
@bones Caused by Nareki running him off the ball.
Nareki maintains his line.
@kev We're never gonna agree but I saw it differently.
-
@kev We're never gonna agree but I saw it differently.
@african-monkey said in SR T-T FINAL: Blues v Highlanders:
@kev We're never gonna agree but I saw it differently.
-
@gunner Was Marshall who then he and TJ went on to hint that he'll be the 3rd choice ABs halfback on Monday.....
@african-monkey said in SR T-T FINAL: Blues v Highlanders:
@gunner Was Marshall who then he and TJ went on to hint that he'll be the 3rd choice ABs halfback on Monday.....
🤮🤮🤮
-
@anonymous said in SR T-T FINAL: Blues v Highlanders:
@gt12 said in SR T-T FINAL: Blues v Highlanders:
@bones said in SR T-T FINAL: Blues v Highlanders:
@gunner said in SR T-T FINAL: Blues v Highlanders:
I’m behind the play, but I’m unsure how Dixon’s tackle is only yellow.
No malice he says, but most red cards we see these days have no malice, so it’s irrelevant.
Just wait until you see a red mitigated to a penalty
I cannot believe that we started at red when a guy literally tripped over, versus yellow for a tackle where a guy aimed with force to hit the key playmaker of the opposite team in the head with his shoulder.
To be fair, the shoulder to head did start at red, they just wrongly mitigated it down to yellow saying it wasn't directly to the head.
If it wasn't direct contact to the head, the starting point isn't red, but yellow.
@stargazer said in SR T-T FINAL: Blues v Highlanders:
@anonymous said in SR T-T FINAL: Blues v Highlanders:
@gt12 said in SR T-T FINAL: Blues v Highlanders:
@bones said in SR T-T FINAL: Blues v Highlanders:
@gunner said in SR T-T FINAL: Blues v Highlanders:
I’m behind the play, but I’m unsure how Dixon’s tackle is only yellow.
No malice he says, but most red cards we see these days have no malice, so it’s irrelevant.
Just wait until you see a red mitigated to a penalty
I cannot believe that we started at red when a guy literally tripped over, versus yellow for a tackle where a guy aimed with force to hit the key playmaker of the opposite team in the head with his shoulder.
To be fair, the shoulder to head did start at red, they just wrongly mitigated it down to yellow saying it wasn't directly to the head.
If it wasn't direct contact to the head, the starting point isn't red, but yellow.
If high contact is by the tackler's shoulder or head, which it was, then the starting point is red.
-
@bones Caused by Nareki running him off the ball.
@african-monkey said in SR T-T FINAL: Blues v Highlanders:
@bones Caused by Nareki running him off the ball.
Eh? End on footage clearly shows Heem veering in to Nareki running straight, then they go shoulder to shoulder and either Heem wins, or Nareki isn't careless and realises he's going to collide with a player in the air so veers off. Heem falls over due to not being able to lean on Nareki.
