RWC warmup - England v Wales
-
He didn't communicate that well and the penalty when Wales had an advantage was weird, but apart from that the ref was pretty good overall. Particularly as he's stlll young and relatively inexperienced.
@Victor-Meldrew said in RWC warmup - England v Wales:
He didn't communicate that well and the penalty when Wales had an advantage was weird, but apart from that the ref was pretty good overall. Particularly as he's stlll young and relatively inexperienced.
100% this
Massive improvement since his debut
-
I sincerely hope not
-
The team I feel sorry for is Scotland, they are likely to exit at the pool stage whereas one of these two will likely make a semi-final.
@chimoaus said in RWC warmup - England v Wales:
The team I feel sorry for is Scotland, they are likely to exit at the pool stage whereas one of these two will likely make a semi-final.
It's cyclical
They underperformed last time and got the seeding which was in place for ALL teams
-
Quite a good article rom Oliver Brown pointing out the future pitfalls in the Farrell Red Card rescinding.
"The long-form version of the ruling is needed urgently, if only to explain how the committee navigated a way past World Rugby’s decree that mitigation is irrelevant in the event of “always illegal” foul play. If the answers are inadequate, then both Six Nations and World Rugby need to appeal. For rugby’s sake, Farrell’s absolution cannot stand. The least that a man like (Steve) Thompson, who has revealed how his battle with dementia once led to him being placed on suicide watch, is owed is for the sport to act with conviction and consistency when it comes to players’ brains.
Farrell’s escape suggests that it is doing anything but. An alarming precedent has been set, one that you can fully expect to see invoked once the class-action lawsuits start rolling in. It is far from melodramatic to suggest that the children who idolise Farrell will also be highly confused by what they have seen, and that they will have all one question when their tackling is next criticised. “Owen did it, so why can’t I?”
Rugby must think hard about whether this is a future it is prepared to contemplate. Otherwise it will, quite frankly, reap what it sows.
-
The one thing that's been overlooked in this is how tactically astute and professional Farrell is
He recognised that Basham was the only Welsh player able to carry the ball across the gain line and set England on their heels
Farrell nullified Basham by any means necessary
If Basham had stayed on the pitch Wales would have cantered home
Once he left and didn't return because of HIA, Wales had no go forward despite the numerical advantage
Begrudgingly, you can't coach that
-
The one thing that's been overlooked in this is how tactically astute and professional Farrell is
He recognised that Basham was the only Welsh player able to carry the ball across the gain line and set England on their heels
Farrell nullified Basham by any means necessary
If Basham had stayed on the pitch Wales would have cantered home
Once he left and didn't return because of HIA, Wales had no go forward despite the numerical advantage
Begrudgingly, you can't coach that
@MiketheSnow said in RWC warmup - England v Wales:
The one thing that's been overlooked in this is how tactically astute and professional Farrell is
He recognised that Basham was the only Welsh player able to carry the ball across the gain line and set England on their heels
Farrell nullified Basham by any means necessary
If Basham had stayed on the pitch Wales would have cantered home
Once he left and didn't return because of HIA, Wales had no go forward despite the numerical advantage
Begrudgingly, you can't coach that
Not sure Owen is that cerebral
-
@MiketheSnow said in RWC warmup - England v Wales:
The one thing that's been overlooked in this is how tactically astute and professional Farrell is
He recognised that Basham was the only Welsh player able to carry the ball across the gain line and set England on their heels
Farrell nullified Basham by any means necessary
If Basham had stayed on the pitch Wales would have cantered home
Once he left and didn't return because of HIA, Wales had no go forward despite the numerical advantage
Begrudgingly, you can't coach that
Not sure Owen is that cerebral
-
@booboo how else do you explain his ability to have hardly even appeared before the judiciary, let alone coming out squeaky clean when he does?
-
Kinsella saying and Planet Rugby appearing to confirm World Rugby to appeal Farrell decision.
-
Kinsella saying and Planet Rugby appearing to confirm World Rugby to appeal Farrell decision.
-
@Victor-Meldrew absolute circus.
Perhaps it will jolt World Rugby to address the mess and inconsistences and improve things. I don't think I've seen such genuine anger from players, ex-players, referees and serious commentators as I've seen on this one.
