Hurricanes v Blues
-
Thought this game highlighted the weakness of the NZ game right now. I thought it was bash, bash with little "rugby smarts" being shown. The one difference - Black's positional kicking out of hand (he really needs to nail those penalty kicks to the corner though). What a difference an experienced play maker would have made for either team!
-
Was at a function on Friday night with Grant Fox and Glenn Taylor, and Fox reckoned Blues would make finals but didn't have the squad to win.
Both said it was thier tight 5 making the difference this year with Taylor making special mention of Tuipuluto's form and also Robinson.
@taniwharugby said in Hurricanes v Blues:
Was at a function on Friday night with Grant Fox and Glenn Taylor, and Fox reckoned Blues would make finals but didn't have the squad to win.
Both said it was thier tight 5 making the difference this year with Taylor making special mention of Tuipuluto's form and also Robinson.
Tuipulotu has been consistently good since that Bledisloe cup game last year. It’s been a huge turnaround since that diet tweak
27 years old, just entering his prime as a tight forward
-
@taniwharugby said in Hurricanes v Blues:
Was at a function on Friday night with Grant Fox and Glenn Taylor, and Fox reckoned Blues would make finals but didn't have the squad to win.
Both said it was thier tight 5 making the difference this year with Taylor making special mention of Tuipuluto's form and also Robinson.
Tuipulotu has been consistently good since that Bledisloe cup game last year. It’s been a huge turnaround since that diet tweak
27 years old, just entering his prime as a tight forward
-
@taniwharugby said in Hurricanes v Blues:
Was at a function on Friday night with Grant Fox and Glenn Taylor, and Fox reckoned Blues would make finals but didn't have the squad to win.
Both said it was thier tight 5 making the difference this year with Taylor making special mention of Tuipuluto's form and also Robinson.
Tuipulotu has been consistently good since that Bledisloe cup game last year. It’s been a huge turnaround since that diet tweak
27 years old, just entering his prime as a tight forward
@Duluth He better be re-signed as I'm sure he's off contract at the end of the season.
-
@Duluth said in Hurricanes v Blues:
I didn't mind the kicking. The breakdown was a lottery with that ref. Holding the ball was a reasonable chance of a penalty to the defence.
The Canes were struggling to get the ball through the midfield so tackling was easyThe quality of the kicking could have been better though
Are you sure that the best way to take advantage of having three more players is to kick the ball away?
Surely holding onto the ball and playing with it ups yours odds considerably?@Crucial said in Hurricanes v Blues:
@Duluth said in Hurricanes v Blues:
I didn't mind the kicking. The breakdown was a lottery with that ref. Holding the ball was a reasonable chance of a penalty to the defence.
The Canes were struggling to get the ball through the midfield so tackling was easyThe quality of the kicking could have been better though
Are you sure that the best way to take advantage of having three more players is to kick the ball away?
Surely holding onto the ball and playing with it ups yours odds considerably?With a 3-man advantage, I think they could have got the ball into the wider channels where Telea, Rieko, Marchant and Perofeta were starting to look dangerous in the second half. Although a great win on the road, and after returning from RSA, it's still a bit of a missed opportunity to have gotten a BP.
-
Was at a function on Friday night with Grant Fox and Glenn Taylor, and Fox reckoned Blues would make finals but didn't have the squad to win.
Both said it was thier tight 5 making the difference this year with Taylor making special mention of Tuipuluto's form and also Robinson.
@taniwharugby said in Hurricanes v Blues:
Was at a function on Friday night with Grant Fox and Glenn Taylor, and Fox reckoned Blues would make finals but didn't have the squad to win.
Both said it was thier tight 5 making the difference this year with Taylor making special mention of Tuipuluto's form and also Robinson.
I think that's a pretty decent bet.
What I most didn't like about the Blues performance was that they were losing both the scrums and lineouts in the first 20 minutes and, while Parsons improves the lineout throwing, he's a weakness around the paddock. And scrums - I suspect there's other scrums more dominant that what the Canes have that would have to be matched in the play-offs.
However, there's still time for the Blues to get better in these aspects and they've got some physical specimens. And people like Nock are starting deliver on their promise.
The real wildcard is what Beauden can bring. He's the sort of player who turns five point losses into five point wins.
-
@taniwharugby said in Hurricanes v Blues:
Was at a function on Friday night with Grant Fox and Glenn Taylor, and Fox reckoned Blues would make finals but didn't have the squad to win.
Both said it was thier tight 5 making the difference this year with Taylor making special mention of Tuipuluto's form and also Robinson.
I think that's a pretty decent bet.
What I most didn't like about the Blues performance was that they were losing both the scrums and lineouts in the first 20 minutes and, while Parsons improves the lineout throwing, he's a weakness around the paddock. And scrums - I suspect there's other scrums more dominant that what the Canes have that would have to be matched in the play-offs.
However, there's still time for the Blues to get better in these aspects and they've got some physical specimens. And people like Nock are starting deliver on their promise.
The real wildcard is what Beauden can bring. He's the sort of player who turns five point losses into five point wins.
@Chris-B said in Hurricanes v Blues:
@taniwharugby said in Hurricanes v Blues:
Was at a function on Friday night with Grant Fox and Glenn Taylor, and Fox reckoned Blues would make finals but didn't have the squad to win.
Both said it was thier tight 5 making the difference this year with Taylor making special mention of Tuipuluto's form and also Robinson.
I think that's a pretty decent bet.
What I most didn't like about the Blues performance was that they were losing both the scrums and lineouts in the first 20 minutes and, while Parsons improves the lineout throwing, he's a weakness around the paddock. And scrums - I suspect there's other scrums more dominant that what the Canes have that would have to be matched in the play-offs.
However, there's still time for the Blues to get better in these aspects and they've got some physical specimens. And people like Nock are starting deliver on their promise.
The real wildcard is what Beauden can bring. He's the sort of player who turns five point losses into five point wins.
I'm fascinated to see how Leon integrates him into the team, particularly with Black and Perofeta doing pretty decent jobs in his two positions. Will they start him at the back and then move him closer in late in games when there are likely to be more attacking opportunities or vice versa?
-
@taniwharugby said in Hurricanes v Blues:
Was at a function on Friday night with Grant Fox and Glenn Taylor, and Fox reckoned Blues would make finals but didn't have the squad to win.
Both said it was thier tight 5 making the difference this year with Taylor making special mention of Tuipuluto's form and also Robinson.
I think that's a pretty decent bet.
What I most didn't like about the Blues performance was that they were losing both the scrums and lineouts in the first 20 minutes and, while Parsons improves the lineout throwing, he's a weakness around the paddock. And scrums - I suspect there's other scrums more dominant that what the Canes have that would have to be matched in the play-offs.
However, there's still time for the Blues to get better in these aspects and they've got some physical specimens. And people like Nock are starting deliver on their promise.
The real wildcard is what Beauden can bring. He's the sort of player who turns five point losses into five point wins.
@Chris-B said in Hurricanes v Blues:
@taniwharugby said in Hurricanes v Blues:
Was at a function on Friday night with Grant Fox and Glenn Taylor, and Fox reckoned Blues would make finals but didn't have the squad to win.
Both said it was thier tight 5 making the difference this year with Taylor making special mention of Tuipuluto's form and also Robinson.
I think that's a pretty decent bet.
What I most didn't like about the Blues performance was that they were losing both the scrums and lineouts in the first 20 minutes and, while Parsons improves the lineout throwing, he's a weakness around the paddock. And scrums - I suspect there's other scrums more dominant that what the Canes have that would have to be matched in the play-offs.
However, there's still time for the Blues to get better in these aspects and they've got some physical specimens. And people like Nock are starting deliver on their promise.
The real wildcard is what Beauden can bring. He's the sort of player who turns five point losses into five point wins.
IMO best Blues starting front row is Mafileo/Efkund/Karl T. Lineout throwing an issue. LH lock not clear, but think Goodhue may be best compromise for scrum and lineout. Spoilt for choice at loosie, but Robinson's workrate and lineout make him the cornerstone for me.
-
Here’s a quote from the coach,
It's a tired and subdued changing shed," coach Leon MacDonald said. "I think the guys are spent. A win away from home is normally cause for celebrations but I think they nearly want to lie down on the groundPuts the travel factor in perspective in my opinion.
-
@Chris-B said in Hurricanes v Blues:
@taniwharugby said in Hurricanes v Blues:
Was at a function on Friday night with Grant Fox and Glenn Taylor, and Fox reckoned Blues would make finals but didn't have the squad to win.
Both said it was thier tight 5 making the difference this year with Taylor making special mention of Tuipuluto's form and also Robinson.
I think that's a pretty decent bet.
What I most didn't like about the Blues performance was that they were losing both the scrums and lineouts in the first 20 minutes and, while Parsons improves the lineout throwing, he's a weakness around the paddock. And scrums - I suspect there's other scrums more dominant that what the Canes have that would have to be matched in the play-offs.
However, there's still time for the Blues to get better in these aspects and they've got some physical specimens. And people like Nock are starting deliver on their promise.
The real wildcard is what Beauden can bring. He's the sort of player who turns five point losses into five point wins.
IMO best Blues starting front row is Mafileo/Efkund/Karl T. Lineout throwing an issue. LH lock not clear, but think Goodhue may be best compromise for scrum and lineout. Spoilt for choice at loosie, but Robinson's workrate and lineout make him the cornerstone for me.
@pakman said in Hurricanes v Blues:
@Chris-B said in Hurricanes v Blues:
@taniwharugby said in Hurricanes v Blues:
Was at a function on Friday night with Grant Fox and Glenn Taylor, and Fox reckoned Blues would make finals but didn't have the squad to win.
Both said it was thier tight 5 making the difference this year with Taylor making special mention of Tuipuluto's form and also Robinson.
I think that's a pretty decent bet.
What I most didn't like about the Blues performance was that they were losing both the scrums and lineouts in the first 20 minutes and, while Parsons improves the lineout throwing, he's a weakness around the paddock. And scrums - I suspect there's other scrums more dominant that what the Canes have that would have to be matched in the play-offs.
However, there's still time for the Blues to get better in these aspects and they've got some physical specimens. And people like Nock are starting deliver on their promise.
The real wildcard is what Beauden can bring. He's the sort of player who turns five point losses into five point wins.
IMO best Blues starting front row is Mafileo/Efkund/Karl T. Lineout throwing an issue. LH lock not clear, but think Goodhue may be best compromise for scrum and lineout. Spoilt for choice at loosie, but Robinson's workrate and lineout make him the cornerstone for me.
What's your rationale for Mafileo starting ahead of Ofa? Who would you have on the bench (and which side is he playing).
Someone needs to take on a project to make up a table of NZ props and which side(s) they play on. I'm starting to forget the guys who can play both sides and young guys like Lindenmuth I have to google.
-
My two cents without reading the thread.
I take my hat off to the Blues, they were outstanding on defence in that first half and managed to stop any of our momentum, especially after a blistering start.
I felt we were just getting on top before the red card occurred and with half an hour left it was the Blues match to lose.
Overall a fairly messy game. I think the big thing for Blues fans to celebrate is that they managed to get over the line. I feel if it was the Blues of a couple of seasons ago they would have found a way to lose on Saturday.
Canes will need to lick their wounds fast as it doesn't get any easier over the next two weekends. For the Blues, they are sitting pretty with two winnable games next, a bye after that and then Beauden's return.
From a Canes perspective I feel Fifita should get the axe and I'd like to see Blackwell pack down on the side of the scrum. I'm sick of Fifita's brain explosions and there should be consequences,
-
@pakman said in Hurricanes v Blues:
@Chris-B said in Hurricanes v Blues:
@taniwharugby said in Hurricanes v Blues:
Was at a function on Friday night with Grant Fox and Glenn Taylor, and Fox reckoned Blues would make finals but didn't have the squad to win.
Both said it was thier tight 5 making the difference this year with Taylor making special mention of Tuipuluto's form and also Robinson.
I think that's a pretty decent bet.
What I most didn't like about the Blues performance was that they were losing both the scrums and lineouts in the first 20 minutes and, while Parsons improves the lineout throwing, he's a weakness around the paddock. And scrums - I suspect there's other scrums more dominant that what the Canes have that would have to be matched in the play-offs.
However, there's still time for the Blues to get better in these aspects and they've got some physical specimens. And people like Nock are starting deliver on their promise.
The real wildcard is what Beauden can bring. He's the sort of player who turns five point losses into five point wins.
IMO best Blues starting front row is Mafileo/Efkund/Karl T. Lineout throwing an issue. LH lock not clear, but think Goodhue may be best compromise for scrum and lineout. Spoilt for choice at loosie, but Robinson's workrate and lineout make him the cornerstone for me.
What's your rationale for Mafileo starting ahead of Ofa? Who would you have on the bench (and which side is he playing).
Someone needs to take on a project to make up a table of NZ props and which side(s) they play on. I'm starting to forget the guys who can play both sides and young guys like Lindenmuth I have to google.
@Chris-B said in Hurricanes v Blues:
@pakman said in Hurricanes v Blues:
@Chris-B said in Hurricanes v Blues:
@taniwharugby said in Hurricanes v Blues:
Was at a function on Friday night with Grant Fox and Glenn Taylor, and Fox reckoned Blues would make finals but didn't have the squad to win.
Both said it was thier tight 5 making the difference this year with Taylor making special mention of Tuipuluto's form and also Robinson.
I think that's a pretty decent bet.
What I most didn't like about the Blues performance was that they were losing both the scrums and lineouts in the first 20 minutes and, while Parsons improves the lineout throwing, he's a weakness around the paddock. And scrums - I suspect there's other scrums more dominant that what the Canes have that would have to be matched in the play-offs.
However, there's still time for the Blues to get better in these aspects and they've got some physical specimens. And people like Nock are starting deliver on their promise.
The real wildcard is what Beauden can bring. He's the sort of player who turns five point losses into five point wins.
IMO best Blues starting front row is Mafileo/Efkund/Karl T. Lineout throwing an issue. LH lock not clear, but think Goodhue may be best compromise for scrum and lineout. Spoilt for choice at loosie, but Robinson's workrate and lineout make him the cornerstone for me.
What's your rationale for Mafileo starting ahead of Ofa? Who would you have on the bench (and which side is he playing).
Someone needs to take on a project to make up a table of NZ props and which side(s) they play on. I'm starting to forget the guys who can play both sides and young guys like Lindenmuth I have to google.
I think Mafileo is a better TH, and Ofa great off bench. I'd ideally have Hodgman and Ofa (TH) on bench.
-
My two cents without reading the thread.
I take my hat off to the Blues, they were outstanding on defence in that first half and managed to stop any of our momentum, especially after a blistering start.
I felt we were just getting on top before the red card occurred and with half an hour left it was the Blues match to lose.
Overall a fairly messy game. I think the big thing for Blues fans to celebrate is that they managed to get over the line. I feel if it was the Blues of a couple of seasons ago they would have found a way to lose on Saturday.
Canes will need to lick their wounds fast as it doesn't get any easier over the next two weekends. For the Blues, they are sitting pretty with two winnable games next, a bye after that and then Beauden's return.
From a Canes perspective I feel Fifita should get the axe and I'd like to see Blackwell pack down on the side of the scrum. I'm sick of Fifita's brain explosions and there should be consequences,
@Canes4life said in Hurricanes v Blues:
My two cents without reading the thread.
I take my hat off to the Blues, they were outstanding on defence in that first half and managed to stop any of our momentum, especially after a blistering start.
I felt we were just getting on top before the red card occurred and with half an hour left it was the Blues match to lose.
Overall a fairly messy game. I think the big thing for Blues fans to celebrate is that they managed to get over the line. I feel if it was the Blues of a couple of seasons ago they would have found a way to lose on Saturday.
Canes will need to lick their wounds fast as it doesn't get any easier over the next two weekends. For the Blues, they are sitting pretty with two winnable games next, a bye after that and then Beauden's return.
From a Canes perspective I feel Fifita should get the axe and I'd like to see Blackwell pack down on the side of the scrum. I'm sick of Fifita's brain explosions and there should be consequences,
It's hard to tell what would have happened without the red card, but I was more worried when the Canes went to the backs than the forwards. The Blues pack was beating up the Canes and I think we were seeing the rewards for that, in fact I think it directly lead to the multiple instances of foul play (only two shoulder charges were called, there were more than that) asthey tried to muscle up.
The fatigue even with a numerical advantage was a huge factor, so we may not have been able to hold on.
-
@taniwharugby said in Hurricanes v Blues:
Was at a function on Friday night with Grant Fox and Glenn Taylor, and Fox reckoned Blues would make finals but didn't have the squad to win.
Both said it was thier tight 5 making the difference this year with Taylor making special mention of Tuipuluto's form and also Robinson.
I think that's a pretty decent bet.
What I most didn't like about the Blues performance was that they were losing both the scrums and lineouts in the first 20 minutes and, while Parsons improves the lineout throwing, he's a weakness around the paddock. And scrums - I suspect there's other scrums more dominant that what the Canes have that would have to be matched in the play-offs.
However, there's still time for the Blues to get better in these aspects and they've got some physical specimens. And people like Nock are starting deliver on their promise.
The real wildcard is what Beauden can bring. He's the sort of player who turns five point losses into five point wins.
@Chris-B said in Hurricanes v Blues:
@taniwharugby said in Hurricanes v Blues:
Was at a function on Friday night with Grant Fox and Glenn Taylor, and Fox reckoned Blues would make finals but didn't have the squad to win.
Both said it was thier tight 5 making the difference this year with Taylor making special mention of Tuipuluto's form and also Robinson.
I think that's a pretty decent bet.
What I most didn't like about the Blues performance was that they were losing both the scrums and lineouts in the first 20 minutes and, while Parsons improves the lineout throwing, he's a weakness around the paddock. And scrums - I suspect there's other scrums more dominant that what the Canes have that would have to be matched in the play-offs.
However, there's still time for the Blues to get better in these aspects and they've got some physical specimens. And people like Nock are starting deliver on their promise.
The real wildcard is what Beauden can bring. He's the sort of player who turns five point losses into five point wins.
I'd be surprised if the Canes make the finals without Beauden. He's done exactly that time and time again the past couple of seasons and has made us look a lot better than we are.
You can say what you like about his credentials as a test 10, but in the more open Super rugby he's an absolutely superstar in that position and is regularly the difference.
-
@Chris-B said in Hurricanes v Blues:
@taniwharugby said in Hurricanes v Blues:
Was at a function on Friday night with Grant Fox and Glenn Taylor, and Fox reckoned Blues would make finals but didn't have the squad to win.
Both said it was thier tight 5 making the difference this year with Taylor making special mention of Tuipuluto's form and also Robinson.
I think that's a pretty decent bet.
What I most didn't like about the Blues performance was that they were losing both the scrums and lineouts in the first 20 minutes and, while Parsons improves the lineout throwing, he's a weakness around the paddock. And scrums - I suspect there's other scrums more dominant that what the Canes have that would have to be matched in the play-offs.
However, there's still time for the Blues to get better in these aspects and they've got some physical specimens. And people like Nock are starting deliver on their promise.
The real wildcard is what Beauden can bring. He's the sort of player who turns five point losses into five point wins.
I'd be surprised if the Canes make the finals without Beauden. He's done exactly that time and time again the past couple of seasons and has made us look a lot better than we are.
You can say what you like about his credentials as a test 10, but in the more open Super rugby he's an absolutely superstar in that position and is regularly the difference.
The standard is a bit lower this year so the Canes still have a good chance of making the playoffs.
That was the first derby match, we'll know where they really stand after these two away games (Chiefs, Crusaders)Barrett is probably worth a freakish try (scored or set up for someone else) per match. Thats enough to turn close matches
Also, without him, who has the authority to tell TJ to clam the fuck down?
-
My two cents without reading the thread.
I take my hat off to the Blues, they were outstanding on defence in that first half and managed to stop any of our momentum, especially after a blistering start.
I felt we were just getting on top before the red card occurred and with half an hour left it was the Blues match to lose.
Overall a fairly messy game. I think the big thing for Blues fans to celebrate is that they managed to get over the line. I feel if it was the Blues of a couple of seasons ago they would have found a way to lose on Saturday.
Canes will need to lick their wounds fast as it doesn't get any easier over the next two weekends. For the Blues, they are sitting pretty with two winnable games next, a bye after that and then Beauden's return.
From a Canes perspective I feel Fifita should get the axe and I'd like to see Blackwell pack down on the side of the scrum. I'm sick of Fifita's brain explosions and there should be consequences,
@Canes4life said in Hurricanes v Blues:
From a Canes perspective I feel Fifita should get the axe and I'd like to see Blackwell pack down on the side of the scrum. I'm sick of Fifita's brain explosions and there should be consequences.
We don't always agree (especially around the propping situation) but in this instance I would be absolutely delighted to see him banished back to club rugby. Purely from an Axemens (who were rather average in the commemorative 150th anniversary of the first ever club rugby match played in NZ against the Nelson RFC on Saturday) selfish point of view he would look good running around Hataitai Park away from the TV cameras! The specialist TMO panel (selected and trained by myself!) up there are superb at their unofficial assistance they give the referee in determining any doubt he/she (we have same good female refs in Wgtn) might have about things.
-
@Canes4life said in Hurricanes v Blues:
From a Canes perspective I feel Fifita should get the axe and I'd like to see Blackwell pack down on the side of the scrum. I'm sick of Fifita's brain explosions and there should be consequences.
We don't always agree (especially around the propping situation) but in this instance I would be absolutely delighted to see him banished back to club rugby. Purely from an Axemens (who were rather average in the commemorative 150th anniversary of the first ever club rugby match played in NZ against the Nelson RFC on Saturday) selfish point of view he would look good running around Hataitai Park away from the TV cameras! The specialist TMO panel (selected and trained by myself!) up there are superb at their unofficial assistance they give the referee in determining any doubt he/she (we have same good female refs in Wgtn) might have about things.
