Chiefs v Crusaders
-
@Bones said in Chiefs v Crusaders:
@Stargazer said in Chiefs v Crusaders:
@Bones I never said that Strange's arm didn't touch his nose. I just said that I didn't see a striking motion of his arm. It could - for example - have happened when he lost his balance in the ruck and fell, and in that motion his arm connected with Jordie's nose who was lying on the ground. But that's just guessing, because - as I said - the footage is unclear/doesn't show it.
Brilliant. His nose started bleeding after it was struck by Strange. Pretty simple. What did Strange go to the bin for?i've found footage of it. sickening
@mariner4life said in Chiefs v Crusaders:
@Bones said in Chiefs v Crusaders:
@Stargazer said in Chiefs v Crusaders:
@Bones I never said that Strange's arm didn't touch his nose. I just said that I didn't see a striking motion of his arm. It could - for example - have happened when he lost his balance in the ruck and fell, and in that motion his arm connected with Jordie's nose who was lying on the ground. But that's just guessing, because - as I said - the footage is unclear/doesn't show it.
Brilliant. His nose started bleeding after it was struck by Strange. Pretty simple. What did Strange go to the bin for?i've found footage of it. sickening
Can I see another angle please?
-
@Bones Maybe this is the reason why there was no further sanction. I can't see whether his fist hits Strange's face, maybe it didn't, but Jordie wasn't quite so innoncent in that scuffle. Strange's punch came after Jordie's (attempted or successful) punch.
@Stargazer said in Chiefs v Crusaders:
@Bones Maybe this is the reason why there was no further sanction. I can't see whether his fist hits Strange's face, maybe it didn't, but Jordie wasn't quite so innoncent in that scuffle. Strange's punch came after Jordie's (attempted or successful) punch.
Look at that big bully Jordie picking on the shorter Strange.
-
@Stargazer said in Chiefs v Crusaders:
@Bones Maybe this is the reason why there was no further sanction. I can't see whether his fist hits Strange's face, maybe it didn't, but Jordie wasn't quite so innoncent in that scuffle. Strange's punch came after Jordie's (attempted or successful) punch.
Look at that big bully Jordie picking on the shorter Strange.
@ACT-Crusader said in Chiefs v Crusaders:
@Stargazer said in Chiefs v Crusaders:
@Bones Maybe this is the reason why there was no further sanction. I can't see whether his fist hits Strange's face, maybe it didn't, but Jordie wasn't quite so innoncent in that scuffle. Strange's punch came after Jordie's (attempted or successful) punch.
Look at that big bully Jordie picking on the shorter Strange.
You wouldn't catch the single digits having handbags like that.
-
Great to see Taavao and Ah Kuoi back. I feel like Vaai should have way more than 5 next to his name!
-
@Bones He got yellow because the AR said he saw him striking(?) (I don't remeber the exact word he used) Jordie with his (fore)arm. Maybe the Citing Commissioner, after watching other camera angles - concluded that the AR was wrong, or that it was completely accidental, or that it was so low-end that it didn't require a citing and that the yellow card was enough.
I don't know why it's so hard to grasp. Look at the footage yourself, and you'll see it's very unclear what happened when Jordie was at the bottom of that pile of bodies.
@Stargazer said in Chiefs v Crusaders:
@Bones He got yellow because the AR said he saw him striking(?) (I don't remeber the exact word he used) Jordie with his (fore)arm. Maybe the Citing Commissioner, after watching other camera angles - concluded that the AR was wrong, or that it was completely accidental, or that it was so low-end that it didn't require a citing and that the yellow card was enough.
I don't know why it's so hard to grasp. Look at the footage yourself, and you'll see it's very unclear what happened when Jordie was at the bottom of that pile of bodies.
I may have made it up in my mind but wasn't there a shot in replay of Strange connecting with Jordie while holding his collar while standing up? Jersey punch thing like they do in AFL.
-
@Stargazer said in Chiefs v Crusaders:
@Bones He got yellow because the AR said he saw him striking(?) (I don't remeber the exact word he used) Jordie with his (fore)arm. Maybe the Citing Commissioner, after watching other camera angles - concluded that the AR was wrong, or that it was completely accidental, or that it was so low-end that it didn't require a citing and that the yellow card was enough.
I don't know why it's so hard to grasp. Look at the footage yourself, and you'll see it's very unclear what happened when Jordie was at the bottom of that pile of bodies.
I may have made it up in my mind but wasn't there a shot in replay of Strange connecting with Jordie while holding his collar while standing up? Jersey punch thing like they do in AFL.
@booboo said in Chiefs v Crusaders:
@Stargazer said in Chiefs v Crusaders:
@Bones He got yellow because the AR said he saw him striking(?) (I don't remeber the exact word he used) Jordie with his (fore)arm. Maybe the Citing Commissioner, after watching other camera angles - concluded that the AR was wrong, or that it was completely accidental, or that it was so low-end that it didn't require a citing and that the yellow card was enough.
I don't know why it's so hard to grasp. Look at the footage yourself, and you'll see it's very unclear what happened when Jordie was at the bottom of that pile of bodies.
I may have made it up in my mind but wasn't there a shot in replay of Strange connecting with Jordie while holding his collar while standing up? Jersey punch thing like they do in AFL.
No.
-
@Bones I would have done the same thing if this had been a scuffle between Matt Duffie and Par Pari Parkinson, or Sean Wainui and James Blackwell. I just want the truth.
@Stargazer said in Chiefs v Crusaders:
@Bones I would have done the same thing if this had been a scuffle between Matt Duffie and Par Pari Parkinson, or Sean Wainui and James Blackwell. I just want the truth.
You can't handle the truth!
-
@Bones said in Chiefs v Crusaders:
@Stargazer said in Chiefs v Crusaders:
@Tim I'm not surprised. I watched the "incident" several times and it was only TJP with his usual theatrics screaming it was a punch (which was repeated by the commentators), and an AR saying something liket Strange's (fore?)arm hitting Jordie's face/nose. On the images that were shown by Sky, you can with some imagination (it wasn't in close-up) see that Strange's arm touches Jordie's face, but you can't see any striking motion. They didn't show any replay of the incident (the ref didn't go to the TMO), so I can only assume that other camera angles showed that there was nothing in it.
Poor old Jordie with his nose spraying blood for no reason again
he should get that looked at. He might have Ebola
maybe @Snowy can diagnose?
@mariner4life said in Chiefs v Crusaders:
@Bones said in Chiefs v Crusaders:
@Stargazer said in Chiefs v Crusaders:
@Tim I'm not surprised. I watched the "incident" several times and it was only TJP with his usual theatrics screaming it was a punch (which was repeated by the commentators), and an AR saying something liket Strange's (fore?)arm hitting Jordie's face/nose. On the images that were shown by Sky, you can with some imagination (it wasn't in close-up) see that Strange's arm touches Jordie's face, but you can't see any striking motion. They didn't show any replay of the incident (the ref didn't go to the TMO), so I can only assume that other camera angles showed that there was nothing in it.
Poor old Jordie with his nose spraying blood for no reason again
he should get that looked at. He might have Ebola
maybe @Snowy can diagnose?
Definitely Ebola. Most symptoms lead to that as a diagnosis. Anything else is really quite unlikely.
-
So this boils down to;
Stargazer: Was no punch
Bones: Yes there was
Stargazer: Definitely was no punch, reviewed the evidence, no shot of a punch
Bones: Here is the image of the punch
Stargazer: Jordie hit him first
Thanks for the entertainment guys!
-
So this boils down to;
Stargazer: Was no punch
Bones: Yes there was
Stargazer: Definitely was no punch, reviewed the evidence, no shot of a punch
Bones: Here is the image of the punch
Stargazer: Jordie hit him first
Thanks for the entertainment guys!
@Kirwan said in Chiefs v Crusaders:
So this boils down to;
Stargazer: Was no punch
Bones: Yes there was
Stargazer: Definitely was no punch, reviewed the evidence, no shot of a punch
Bones: Here is the image of the punch
Stargazer: Jordie hit him first
Thanks for the entertainment guys!
ACT Crusader: We were robbed last week
-
So this boils down to;
Stargazer: Was no punch
Bones: Yes there was
Stargazer: Definitely was no punch, reviewed the evidence, no shot of a punch
Bones: Here is the image of the punch
Stargazer: Jordie hit him first
Thanks for the entertainment guys!
@Kirwan said in Chiefs v Crusaders:
So this boils down to;
Stargazer: Was no punch
Bones: Yes there was
Stargazer: Definitely was no punch, reviewed the evidence, no shot of a punch
Bones: Here is the image of the punch
Stargazer: Jordie hit him first
Thanks for the entertainment guys!
I had more fun on this thread yesterday than I am likely to during the game
-
It's also been a while since we've had arrows and screenshots to back an argument.
Reminds of when I posted the shot of the Lions game showing the ball at the back of the ruck when Kev and Tana cleaned out that whining git. UK Media were trying to claim the ball had gone.
Edit: Eek, that was 15 fucking years ago.
-
It's also been a while since we've had arrows and screenshots to back an argument.
Reminds of when I posted the shot of the Lions game showing the ball at the back of the ruck when Kev and Tana cleaned out that whining git. UK Media were trying to claim the ball had gone.
Edit: Eek, that was 15 fucking years ago.
@Kirwan said in Chiefs v Crusaders:
It's also been a while since we've had arrows and screenshots to back an argument.
Reminds of when I posted the shot of the Lions game showing the ball at the back of the ruck when Kev and Tana cleaned out that whining git. UK Media were trying to claim the ball had gone.
Edit: Eek, that was 15 fucking years ago.
The timestamp post was my fav of the lot. That was gold
-
It's also been a while since we've had arrows and screenshots to back an argument.
Reminds of when I posted the shot of the Lions game showing the ball at the back of the ruck when Kev and Tana cleaned out that whining git. UK Media were trying to claim the ball had gone.
Edit: Eek, that was 15 fucking years ago.
-
@Stargazer said in Chiefs v Crusaders:
@Bones Maybe this is the reason why there was no further sanction. I can't see whether his fist hits Strange's face, maybe it didn't, but Jordie wasn't quite so innoncent in that scuffle. Strange's punch came after Jordie's (attempted or successful) punch.
Look at that big bully Jordie picking on the shorter Strange.
@ACT-Crusader said in Chiefs v Crusaders:
@Stargazer said in Chiefs v Crusaders:
@Bones Maybe this is the reason why there was no further sanction. I can't see whether his fist hits Strange's face, maybe it didn't, but Jordie wasn't quite so innoncent in that scuffle. Strange's punch came after Jordie's (attempted or successful) punch.
Look at that big bully Jordie picking on the shorter Strange.
Isn't Jordie's nose already bleeding in this photo
-
@Bones I would have done the same thing if this had been a scuffle between Matt Duffie and Par Pari Parkinson, or Sean Wainui and James Blackwell. I just want the truth.
@Stargazer said in Chiefs v Crusaders:
@Bones I would have done the same thing if this had been a scuffle between Matt Duffie and Par Pari Parkinson, or Sean Wainui and James Blackwell. I just want the truth.
You can't HANDLE the truth!!!!
