Force v Blues
-
@Crucial True, but even so, I'd rather see us go with Akira at 8 and Plumtree at 6. Segner is a 7 and only a 7.
@African-Monkey said in Force v Blues:
@Crucial True, but even so, I'd rather see us go with Akira at 8 and Plumtree at 6. Segner is a 7 and only a 7.
Akira was only ever going to play half an hour at most. This was juggling resources.
Just odd to be making demands of selections when you aren't party to player management needs. -
@African-Monkey said in Force v Blues:
@Crucial True, but even so, I'd rather see us go with Akira at 8 and Plumtree at 6. Segner is a 7 and only a 7.
Akira was only ever going to play half an hour at most. This was juggling resources.
Just odd to be making demands of selections when you aren't party to player management needs. -
@Crucial True, but even so, I'd rather see us go with Akira at 8 and Plumtree at 6. Segner is a 7 and only a 7.
@African-Monkey said in Force v Blues:
True, but even so, I'd rather see us go with Akira at 8 and Plumtree at 6. Segner is a 7 and only a 7.
Plumtree looked good at 8 in the preseason. Shame we haven’t seen that when Sotutu doesn’t play.
I suspect he’s missing out because he’s off contract next year and is likely leaving
-
@Crucial Akira played most of the game though.....
Did you watch the game?
@African-Monkey said in Force v Blues:
@Crucial Akira played most of the game though.....
Did you watch the game?
Watched about the first twenty and it looks like it was a good option to go to bed.
I was going by this report which sounds as if it was wrong (or badly written)
"Ioane put in a solid shift at No 6, before departing in the 26th minute with a try and 22 metres on 7 carries to his name; "
-
@Crucial True, but even so, I'd rather see us go with Akira at 8 and Plumtree at 6. Segner is a 7 and only a 7.
@African-Monkey said in Force v Blues:
@Crucial True, but even so, I'd rather see us go with Akira at 8 and Plumtree at 6. Segner is a 7 and only a 7.
Segner's future isn't at 7.
He's still just a kid - but, needs to add a few kgs and he'll be Kieran Read dimensions.
-
@African-Monkey said in Force v Blues:
@Crucial Akira played most of the game though.....
Did you watch the game?
Watched about the first twenty and it looks like it was a good option to go to bed.
I was going by this report which sounds as if it was wrong (or badly written)
"Ioane put in a solid shift at No 6, before departing in the 26th minute with a try and 22 metres on 7 carries to his name; "
-
@African-Monkey said in Force v Blues:
@Crucial True, but even so, I'd rather see us go with Akira at 8 and Plumtree at 6. Segner is a 7 and only a 7.
Segner's future isn't at 7.
He's still just a kid - but, needs to add a few kgs and he'll be Kieran Read dimensions.
@Chris-B Really? If I'm wrong then so be it, ill put my hand up, but I don't see how he could be anything other than a 7 from what I've seen.
Good player but too short to ever be a long term 6 or 8.
Also needs to improve his ball carrying.
-
@Chris-B Really? If I'm wrong then so be it, ill put my hand up, but I don't see how he could be anything other than a 7 from what I've seen.
Good player but too short to ever be a long term 6 or 8.
Also needs to improve his ball carrying.
@African-Monkey said in Force v Blues:
@Chris-B Really? If I'm wrong then so be it, ill put my hand up, but I don't see how he could be anything other than a 7 from what I've seen.
Good player but too short to ever be a long term 6 or 8.
Yep I like the kid at 7 too AM, by geez I keep saying how much I like the kid, he never stops, tackles and back on feet looking to see next job etc , a lot to like, and I reckon very handy 7, although he not bad at 8.
-
@gt12 said in Force v Blues:
That was bullshit. They drop it, Angus dreams up a penalty.
To be fair to Gardner the touchies are often calling the offsides and I'm pretty sure he got the call for that one. He also made a good call with Eklund which the TMO was wanting a penalty.
-
The Blues in that second half were painful to watch. Talk about giving away possession and fuck me that has to be one of the worst performances of a reserved hooker ever. Literally couldn't throw it in and gets pinged for a high shot.
They were lucky not to lose with all the fuck ups they made.
In saying that the scrum was dominant and I would be happy for Hodge and Ofa to start for ABs.
The engine in that pack was Luke Romano who has to be the transfer of the year, his workrate was unreal. Akira played well but looked like a few meat pies heavier than last year.
I thought Segner played well, he kept the ball at the base well, tackled well.
Overall just too many errors, penalties and turnovers. -
@African-Monkey said in Force v Blues:
@Chris-B Really? If I'm wrong then so be it, ill put my hand up, but I don't see how he could be anything other than a 7 from what I've seen.
Good player but too short to ever be a long term 6 or 8.
Yep I like the kid at 7 too AM, by geez I keep saying how much I like the kid, he never stops, tackles and back on feet looking to see next job etc , a lot to like, and I reckon very handy 7, although he not bad at 8.
@Dan54 Yeah I'd say that he can cover 8 at a pinch, but definitely not long term imo.
-
@Chris-B Really? If I'm wrong then so be it, ill put my hand up, but I don't see how he could be anything other than a 7 from what I've seen.
Good player but too short to ever be a long term 6 or 8.
Also needs to improve his ball carrying.
@African-Monkey said in Force v Blues:
@Chris-B Really? If I'm wrong then so be it, ill put my hand up, but I don't see how he could be anything other than a 7 from what I've seen.
Good player but too short to ever be a long term 6 or 8.
Also needs to improve his ball carrying.
Wiki says he 1.92? I think that is taller than current test 6 Ethan Blackadder and taller than 40+ test player Messam. So not sure if he really is too short.
-
@African-Monkey said in Force v Blues:
@Chris-B Really? If I'm wrong then so be it, ill put my hand up, but I don't see how he could be anything other than a 7 from what I've seen.
Good player but too short to ever be a long term 6 or 8.
Also needs to improve his ball carrying.
Wiki says he 1.92? I think that is taller than current test 6 Ethan Blackadder and taller than 40+ test player Messam. So not sure if he really is too short.
@Nepia The same height as Sotutu, Grace, Mikaele-Tu'u. I think it is bulk rather than height he will need to continue as a 6/8 option. New young players often arrive considerably muscled up for their second season at this level so it will be interesting to see his physique change for next season.
-
@Nepia The same height as Sotutu, Grace, Mikaele-Tu'u. I think it is bulk rather than height he will need to continue as a 6/8 option. New young players often arrive considerably muscled up for their second season at this level so it will be interesting to see his physique change for next season.
@Daffy-Jaffy said in Force v Blues:
@Nepia The same height as Sotutu, Grace, Mikaele-Tu'u. I think it is bulk rather than height he will need to continue as a 6/8 option. New young players often arrive considerably muscled up for their second season at this level so it will be interesting to see his physique change for next season.
I was only responding to @African-Monkey's discussion about height. Yeah, he's only 20, he's got time to bulk up.
-
@African-Monkey said in Force v Blues:
@Chris-B Really? If I'm wrong then so be it, ill put my hand up, but I don't see how he could be anything other than a 7 from what I've seen.
Good player but too short to ever be a long term 6 or 8.
Also needs to improve his ball carrying.
Wiki says he 1.92? I think that is taller than current test 6 Ethan Blackadder and taller than 40+ test player Messam. So not sure if he really is too short.
-
@Nepia Interesting, looks a lot shorter than that to me but could be wrong.
@African-Monkey said in Force v Blues:
@Nepia Interesting, looks a lot shorter than that to me but could be wrong.
He didn't look short next to Papali'i who is a cm taller (according to Wiki caveat of course).
-
@African-Monkey said in Force v Blues:
@Nepia Interesting, looks a lot shorter than that to me but could be wrong.
He didn't look short next to Papali'i who is a cm taller (according to Wiki caveat of course).
@Nepia said in Force v Blues:
@African-Monkey said in Force v Blues:
@Nepia Interesting, looks a lot shorter than that to me but could be wrong.
He didn't look short next to Papali'i who is a cm taller (according to Wiki caveat of course).
I actually thought that last night Nepia, I remember being surprised as I thought he was shorter by a fair bit.
-
@Chris-B Really? If I'm wrong then so be it, ill put my hand up, but I don't see how he could be anything other than a 7 from what I've seen.
Good player but too short to ever be a long term 6 or 8.
Also needs to improve his ball carrying.
@African-Monkey He's only 20 so far from the finished article.
According to his stats a centimetre shorter than Read, which looks about right.
He doesn't look fast enough to be a 7 to me, so pack a bit of weight on him and play him as a 6/8.
-
@gt12 said in Force v Blues:
That was bullshit. They drop it, Angus dreams up a penalty.
To be fair to Gardner the touchies are often calling the offsides and I'm pretty sure he got the call for that one. He also made a good call with Eklund which the TMO was wanting a penalty.
@chimoaus said in Force v Blues:
@gt12 said in Force v Blues:
That was bullshit. They drop it, Angus dreams up a penalty.
To be fair to Gardner the touchies are often calling the offsides and I'm pretty sure he got the call for that one. He also made a good call with Eklund which the TMO was wanting a penalty.
The crowd called a few for him too
-
Probably a typo and was meant to be 66 mins
He did exactly what was expected. MacDonald said before the match that he expected a good hour out of him before he 'falls off a cliff'. Aussie coverage gave him man of the match
@Duluth said in Force v Blues:
Probably a typo and was meant to be 66 mins
He did exactly what was expected. MacDonald said before the match that he expected a good hour out of him before he 'falls off a cliff'. Aussie coverage gave him man of the match
Yes it was almost70mins
