Blues v Waratahs
-
@Bones said in Blues v Waratahs:
@antipodean said in Blues v Waratahs:
@Bones said in Blues v Waratahs:
@antipodean said in Blues v Waratahs:
@Bones said in Blues v Waratahs:
@hydro11 said in Blues v Waratahs:
@Bones said in Blues v Waratahs:
@hydro11 said in Blues v Waratahs:
@KiwiMurph said in Blues v Waratahs:
Fucking stupid from Ofa
Well-reffed, I though. Not much else Ofa could do there.
He's not in control, reckless and lucky.
If the player stays upright, it is just a good tackle. It depends whether you think Ofa has time to change.
No he doesn't, because he's not in control. He didn't give himself time to change, that's exactly it.
What time is he supposed to give himself when in the space of one step the attacker dives to ground?
Come on man, it's really simple. This day and age, you can't fly in uncontrolled hoping you get lucky with the hit. I don't have a problem with the outcome in this instance, but Ofa left himself no out if that went wrong.
"uncontrolled"? You are delusional if you think players can adapt within that timeframe other than by making completely passive tackles.
Adapt within the timeframe he gave himself when he went flying in? So if he can't adapt when he goes flying in out of control, the option might be to not go flying in our of control. Or hey keep doing it until it goes wrong.
So you're arguing for players to defend on their heels giving themselves all possible time to "adapt". Thanks for the soccer mum input.
@antipodean said in Blues v Waratahs:
@Bones said in Blues v Waratahs:
@antipodean said in Blues v Waratahs:
@Bones said in Blues v Waratahs:
@antipodean said in Blues v Waratahs:
@Bones said in Blues v Waratahs:
@hydro11 said in Blues v Waratahs:
@Bones said in Blues v Waratahs:
@hydro11 said in Blues v Waratahs:
@KiwiMurph said in Blues v Waratahs:
Fucking stupid from Ofa
Well-reffed, I though. Not much else Ofa could do there.
He's not in control, reckless and lucky.
If the player stays upright, it is just a good tackle. It depends whether you think Ofa has time to change.
No he doesn't, because he's not in control. He didn't give himself time to change, that's exactly it.
What time is he supposed to give himself when in the space of one step the attacker dives to ground?
Come on man, it's really simple. This day and age, you can't fly in uncontrolled hoping you get lucky with the hit. I don't have a problem with the outcome in this instance, but Ofa left himself no out if that went wrong.
"uncontrolled"? You are delusional if you think players can adapt within that timeframe other than by making completely passive tackles.
Adapt within the timeframe he gave himself when he went flying in? So if he can't adapt when he goes flying in out of control, the option might be to not go flying in our of control. Or hey keep doing it until it goes wrong.
So you're arguing for players to defend on their heels giving themselves all possible time to "adapt". Thanks for the soccer mum input.
No, I'm clearly not, but you know that. You do you bud..
-
Darry with that missed tackle
-
Anyone thought Zarn Sullivan could be a bloody good 12?
@Yeahtheboys said in Blues v Waratahs:
Anyone thought Zarn Sullivan could be a bloody good 12?
Runs good lines, can pass. Not a small lad. :thumbs_up:
-
That pass was cool
-
@Machpants trace that try all the way back to a nothing kick from you know who
-
Hoskins has been busy all night
-
@KiwiMurph couple of nice touches recently from Plummer
-
@KiwiMurph couple of nice touches recently from Plummer
@Steven-Harris said in Blues v Waratahs:
@KiwiMurph couple of nice touches recently from Plummer
He runs very direct and had a big lower body in his frame.
-
That didn't look right. If the defending team has to release a tackled player the attacking team shouldn't then be able to drive them forward.
@Bovidae said in Blues v Waratahs:
That didn't look right. If the defending team has to release a tackled player the attacking team shouldn't then be able to drive them forward.
They’ve come in to support their man, they’re not obliged to let him go like the tacklers are
-
That didn't look right. If the defending team has to release a tackled player the attacking team shouldn't then be able to drive them forward.
@Bovidae said in Blues v Waratahs:
That didn't look right. If the defending team has to release a tackled player the attacking team shouldn't then be able to drive them forward.
How can a team actually legally defend in that situation?
-
@Bovidae said in Blues v Waratahs:
That didn't look right. If the defending team has to release a tackled player the attacking team shouldn't then be able to drive them forward.
They’ve come in to support their man, they’re not obliged to let him go like the tacklers are
@Gunner said in Blues v Waratahs:
@Bovidae said in Blues v Waratahs:
That didn't look right. If the defending team has to release a tackled player the attacking team shouldn't then be able to drive them forward.
They’ve come in to support their man, they’re not obliged to let him go like the tacklers are
If Sotutu's knees are on the ground (a tackle) he shouldn't be able get up again.
-
@Bovidae said in Blues v Waratahs:
That didn't look right. If the defending team has to release a tackled player the attacking team shouldn't then be able to drive them forward.
How can a team actually legally defend in that situation?
@ACT-Crusader said in Blues v Waratahs:
@Bovidae said in Blues v Waratahs:
That didn't look right. If the defending team has to release a tackled player the attacking team shouldn't then be able to drive them forward.
How can a team actually legally defend in that situation?
You can't, some tries you can't stop, that's fine
-
@Bovidae said in Blues v Waratahs:
That didn't look right. If the defending team has to release a tackled player the attacking team shouldn't then be able to drive them forward.
They’ve come in to support their man, they’re not obliged to let him go like the tacklers are
@Gunner said in Blues v Waratahs:
@Bovidae said in Blues v Waratahs:
That didn't look right. If the defending team has to release a tackled player the attacking team shouldn't then be able to drive them forward.
They’ve come in to support their man, they’re not obliged to let him go like the tacklers are
If they had realeased him, they wouldn’t have had the opportunity for a drive.
-
I'd feel much more assured if Sullivan was at 10
