Preseason - Highlanders v Hurricanes
-
@Canes4life Mind you the U20s played him at 15 as did The Bay if memory serves me correct. But like you I would love to see him get a run. Seem to recall me raving about him and Roigard after Levin game last year as well.
I definitely think we have a tendecy in NZ to not put to much pressure on young fellas as game drivers.@Dan54 Godfrey seems like a cool customer though, I don't think he would be too overawed if he had to run the team at 10.
-
-
@Canes4life Mind you the U20s played him at 15 as did The Bay if memory serves me correct. But like you I would love to see him get a run. Seem to recall me raving about him and Roigard after Levin game last year as well.
I definitely think we have a tendecy in NZ to not put to much pressure on young fellas as game drivers.@Dan54 said in Preseason - Highlanders v Hurricanes:
@Canes4life Mind you the U20s played him at 15 as did The Bay if memory serves me correct. But like you I would love to see him get a run. Seem to recall me raving about him and Roigard after Levin game last year as well.
I definitely think we have a tendecy in NZ to not put to much pressure on young fellas as game drivers.I still think Godfrey is a long way off as a super rugby first. I still think Cameron as the starting option and Barrett as the backup. But who next. Not Morgan. He was ordinary a few years back and is worse now. I would give Love a shot and then Godfrey
-
I think the only reasonable conclusion from this game is that the Highlanders are back, and they WILL win Super Rugby.
@frugby said in Preseason - Highlanders v Hurricanes:
I think the only reasonable conclusion from this game is that the Highlanders are back, and they WILL win Super Rugby.
This is our year baby!!!!
-
@Dan54 said in Preseason - Highlanders v Hurricanes:
@Canes4life Mind you the U20s played him at 15 as did The Bay if memory serves me correct. But like you I would love to see him get a run. Seem to recall me raving about him and Roigard after Levin game last year as well.
I definitely think we have a tendecy in NZ to not put to much pressure on young fellas as game drivers.I still think Godfrey is a long way off as a super rugby first. I still think Cameron as the starting option and Barrett as the backup. But who next. Not Morgan. He was ordinary a few years back and is worse now. I would give Love a shot and then Godfrey
@Winger why is he a long way off? He showed a year ago that he was capable of running the cutter in that pre season game against the Saders. Hawkes Bay need to start playing him at 10 over McClutchie. Clearly no one wants the latter and IMO Godfrey has a way higher ceiling.
The Canes either need to ply Love at 10 or Godfrey. We need 10s that have the capability of setting our backline alight. If we keep Morgan and Cameron in that position we will be winning F all. Hopefully Laidlaw figures this out early in his tenure.
-
@Winger why is he a long way off? He showed a year ago that he was capable of running the cutter in that pre season game against the Saders. Hawkes Bay need to start playing him at 10 over McClutchie. Clearly no one wants the latter and IMO Godfrey has a way higher ceiling.
The Canes either need to ply Love at 10 or Godfrey. We need 10s that have the capability of setting our backline alight. If we keep Morgan and Cameron in that position we will be winning F all. Hopefully Laidlaw figures this out early in his tenure.
@Canes4life said in Preseason - Highlanders v Hurricanes:
If we keep Morgan and Cameron in that position we will be winning F all. Hopefully Laidlaw figures this out early in his tenure.
I wouldn't give up on Cameron yet. At his best he's close to AB quality. The coaches just need to work on his consistency
Morgan is a waste of time. He's had lots of opportunities and is barely good enough for NPC rugby
Love and Godfrey have the skills required but Im still unsure whether either will be top quality firsts. But would give Love the opportunity first. Godfrey still has lots of time but both playing first at NPC level would certainly help
But this will be a great test for Laidlaw. Sort it out and he might have awinning future. Not just another average coach who makes up the numbers
-
@frugby said in Preseason - Highlanders v Hurricanes:
I think the only reasonable conclusion from this game is that the Highlanders are back, and they WILL win Super Rugby.
This is our year baby!!!!
@Kiwiwomble said in Preseason - Highlanders v Hurricanes:
@frugby said in Preseason - Highlanders v Hurricanes:
I think the only reasonable conclusion from this game is that the Highlanders are back, and they WILL win Super Rugby.
This is our year baby!!!!
Some luck with injuries and they could surprise this year
-
@Winger why is he a long way off? He showed a year ago that he was capable of running the cutter in that pre season game against the Saders. Hawkes Bay need to start playing him at 10 over McClutchie. Clearly no one wants the latter and IMO Godfrey has a way higher ceiling.
The Canes either need to ply Love at 10 or Godfrey. We need 10s that have the capability of setting our backline alight. If we keep Morgan and Cameron in that position we will be winning F all. Hopefully Laidlaw figures this out early in his tenure.
@Canes4life said in Preseason - Highlanders v Hurricanes:
@Winger why is he a long way off? He showed a year ago that he was capable of running the cutter in that pre season game against the Saders. Hawkes Bay need to start playing him at 10 over McClutchie. Clearly no one wants the latter and IMO Godfrey has a way higher ceiling.
The Canes either need to ply Love at 10 or Godfrey. We need 10s that have the capability of setting our backline alight. If we keep Morgan and Cameron in that position we will be winning F all. Hopefully Laidlaw figures this out early in his tenure.
Love looks like a All black FB in the making I hope he is not moved to First Five.
Cameron has always looked just a class down from a top First Five even when he was with the Crusaders he couldn't quite step up and he looks the same to me.
Godfrey I think is the one you throw in to 10 and let him grow way more up side than Cameron or Morgan. -
@Canes4life said in Preseason - Highlanders v Hurricanes:
@Winger why is he a long way off? He showed a year ago that he was capable of running the cutter in that pre season game against the Saders. Hawkes Bay need to start playing him at 10 over McClutchie. Clearly no one wants the latter and IMO Godfrey has a way higher ceiling.
The Canes either need to ply Love at 10 or Godfrey. We need 10s that have the capability of setting our backline alight. If we keep Morgan and Cameron in that position we will be winning F all. Hopefully Laidlaw figures this out early in his tenure.
Love looks like a All black FB in the making I hope he is not moved to First Five.
Cameron has always looked just a class down from a top First Five even when he was with the Crusaders he couldn't quite step up and he looks the same to me.
Godfrey I think is the one you throw in to 10 and let him grow way more up side than Cameron or Morgan.@Chris yeah I'd leave Love at FB aswell. For me our best and most exciting backline is:
- Roigard
- Godfrey
- Naholo
- Barrett
- Proctor
- Moorby
- Love (who can cover 10)
Then a bench of Perenara, Higgins and Sullivan for impact.
-
@Chris yeah I'd leave Love at FB aswell. For me our best and most exciting backline is:
- Roigard
- Godfrey
- Naholo
- Barrett
- Proctor
- Moorby
- Love (who can cover 10)
Then a bench of Perenara, Higgins and Sullivan for impact.
@Canes4life said in Preseason - Highlanders v Hurricanes:
@Chris yeah I'd leave Love at FB aswell. For me our best and most exciting backline is:
- Roigard
- Godfrey
- Naholo
- Barrett
- Proctor
- Moorby
- Love (who can cover 10)
Then a bench of Perenara, Higgins and Sullivan for impact.
Looks Sharpe to me dangerous back line.
-
@Canes4life said in Preseason - Highlanders v Hurricanes:
@Chris yeah I'd leave Love at FB aswell. For me our best and most exciting backline is:
- Roigard
- Godfrey
- Naholo
- Barrett
- Proctor
- Moorby
- Love (who can cover 10)
Then a bench of Perenara, Higgins and Sullivan for impact.
Looks Sharpe to me dangerous back line.
@Chris the problem with previous Canes coaches like Holland is that they never select our best. Hopefully Laidlaw comes to the party.
-
@Chris yeah I'd leave Love at FB aswell. For me our best and most exciting backline is:
- Roigard
- Godfrey
- Naholo
- Barrett
- Proctor
- Moorby
- Love (who can cover 10)
Then a bench of Perenara, Higgins and Sullivan for impact.
@Canes4life said in Preseason - Highlanders v Hurricanes:
@Chris yeah I'd leave Love at FB aswell. For me our best and most exciting backline is:
- Roigard
- Godfrey
- Naholo
- Barrett
- Proctor
- Moorby
- Love (who can cover 10)
Then a bench of Perenara, Higgins and Sullivan for impact.
How many games has Godfrey started at first in either super or NPC rugby.
-
@Canes4life said in Preseason - Highlanders v Hurricanes:
@Chris yeah I'd leave Love at FB aswell. For me our best and most exciting backline is:
- Roigard
- Godfrey
- Naholo
- Barrett
- Proctor
- Moorby
- Love (who can cover 10)
Then a bench of Perenara, Higgins and Sullivan for impact.
How many games has Godfrey started at first in either super or NPC rugby.
-
@Winger why is he a long way off? He showed a year ago that he was capable of running the cutter in that pre season game against the Saders. Hawkes Bay need to start playing him at 10 over McClutchie. Clearly no one wants the latter and IMO Godfrey has a way higher ceiling.
The Canes either need to ply Love at 10 or Godfrey. We need 10s that have the capability of setting our backline alight. If we keep Morgan and Cameron in that position we will be winning F all. Hopefully Laidlaw figures this out early in his tenure.
@Canes4life said in Preseason - Highlanders v Hurricanes:
@Winger why is he a long way off? He showed a year ago that he was capable of running the cutter in that pre season game against the Saders. Hawkes Bay need to start playing him at 10 over McClutchie. Clearly no one wants the latter and IMO Godfrey has a way higher ceiling.
The Canes either need to ply Love at 10 or Godfrey. We need 10s that have the capability of setting our backline alight. If we keep Morgan and Cameron in that position we will be winning F all. Hopefully Laidlaw figures this out early in his tenure.
If he was better than McClutchie we'd have played him there, we're a merit based organisation unlike others.
-
@Canes4life said in Preseason - Highlanders v Hurricanes:
@Winger why is he a long way off? He showed a year ago that he was capable of running the cutter in that pre season game against the Saders. Hawkes Bay need to start playing him at 10 over McClutchie. Clearly no one wants the latter and IMO Godfrey has a way higher ceiling.
The Canes either need to ply Love at 10 or Godfrey. We need 10s that have the capability of setting our backline alight. If we keep Morgan and Cameron in that position we will be winning F all. Hopefully Laidlaw figures this out early in his tenure.
If he was better than McClutchie we'd have played him there, we're a merit based organisation unlike others.
@Nepia well he must be better, he got a Super contract so that says a lot.
Tbh though I thought McClutchie hd a good year and was deserving of a spot somewhere. Defs prefer him over the hopeless Morgan.If Godfrey is serious about playing 10 going forward though he needs minutes there at NPC.
-
You don't have to throw Godfrey in at 10 straight away but there's definitely opportunities to work his way in there across the season
@KiwiMurph the fact he can cover 10/15 will be a big plus for him atleast having plenty of mins off the bench.
