Hurricanes vs Chiefs

[Bones]

@antipodean said in Hurricanes vs Chiefs:

@Bones said in Hurricanes vs Chiefs:

@antipodean said in Hurricanes vs Chiefs:

@Bones said in Hurricanes vs Chiefs:

@antipodean said in Hurricanes vs Chiefs:

@Bones said in Hurricanes vs Chiefs:

That's moronic. Why wasn't it already a YC?

Advantage, so the penalty wasn't called.

Why does that matter? YC infringement is YC infringement.

It's not an infringement if it isn't called.

I've never heard that in my life. If a high tackle was made it shouldn't be carded it points are scored then right?

I suspect you're being deliberately obtuse, but I'll answer anyway: Until the penalty is awarded for offside, there's no infringement while advantage is in use, hence no sanction.

So because the try was scored, there's no infringement. That's what you're saying right? Not sure I'm the one being obtuse.

[antipodean]

@Bones said in Hurricanes vs Chiefs:

@antipodean said in Hurricanes vs Chiefs:

@Bones said in Hurricanes vs Chiefs:

@antipodean said in Hurricanes vs Chiefs:

@Bones said in Hurricanes vs Chiefs:

@antipodean said in Hurricanes vs Chiefs:

@Bones said in Hurricanes vs Chiefs:

That's moronic. Why wasn't it already a YC?

Advantage, so the penalty wasn't called.

Why does that matter? YC infringement is YC infringement.

It's not an infringement if it isn't called.

I've never heard that in my life. If a high tackle was made it shouldn't be carded it points are scored then right?

I suspect you're being deliberately obtuse, but I'll answer anyway: Until the penalty is awarded for offside, there's no infringement while advantage is in use, hence no sanction.

So because the try was scored, there's no infringement. That's what you're saying right? Not sure I'm the one being obtuse.

How long have you been watching rugby? Never noticed a team scoring and the commentary saying player X is lucky or otherwise they'd probably be facing a YC? Never seen a ref play advantage until today and decide the appropriate sanction when going back to the original offence?

There's no offence if the ref determines the non-offending team has gained an advantage. There's an entire section in the laws dealing with this.

[African Monkey]

Should have taken 3 Chiefs.

[African Monkey]

Ratima finding things difficult other than his try.

[Yeetyaah]

Did Cortez even touch that?

[Bones]

@antipodean said in Hurricanes vs Chiefs:

@Bones said in Hurricanes vs Chiefs:

@antipodean said in Hurricanes vs Chiefs:

@Bones said in Hurricanes vs Chiefs:

@antipodean said in Hurricanes vs Chiefs:

@Bones said in Hurricanes vs Chiefs:

@antipodean said in Hurricanes vs Chiefs:

@Bones said in Hurricanes vs Chiefs:

That's moronic. Why wasn't it already a YC?

Advantage, so the penalty wasn't called.

Why does that matter? YC infringement is YC infringement.

It's not an infringement if it isn't called.

I've never heard that in my life. If a high tackle was made it shouldn't be carded it points are scored then right?

I suspect you're being deliberately obtuse, but I'll answer anyway: Until the penalty is awarded for offside, there's no infringement while advantage is in use, hence no sanction.

So because the try was scored, there's no infringement. That's what you're saying right? Not sure I'm the one being obtuse.

How long have you been watching rugby? Never noticed a team scoring and the commentary saying player X is lucky or otherwise they'd probably be facing a YC? Never seen a ref play advantage until today and decide the appropriate sanction when going back to the original offence?

There's no offence if the ref determines the non-offending team has gained an advantage. There's an entire section in the laws dealing with this.

I've only been watching for 40 minutes Mr expert. So you've never seen anyone yellow carded for a previous infringement when a try has been scored? How long have you been watching rugby?

[Frank]

@Bones said in Hurricanes vs Chiefs:

So you've never seen anyone yellow carded for a previous infringement when a try has been scored?

Pretty sure I have seen that, a lot.

[antipodean]

@Bones said in Hurricanes vs Chiefs:

@antipodean said in Hurricanes vs Chiefs:

@Bones said in Hurricanes vs Chiefs:

@antipodean said in Hurricanes vs Chiefs:

@Bones said in Hurricanes vs Chiefs:

@antipodean said in Hurricanes vs Chiefs:

@Bones said in Hurricanes vs Chiefs:

@antipodean said in Hurricanes vs Chiefs:

@Bones said in Hurricanes vs Chiefs:

That's moronic. Why wasn't it already a YC?

Advantage, so the penalty wasn't called.

Why does that matter? YC infringement is YC infringement.

It's not an infringement if it isn't called.

I've never heard that in my life. If a high tackle was made it shouldn't be carded it points are scored then right?

I suspect you're being deliberately obtuse, but I'll answer anyway: Until the penalty is awarded for offside, there's no infringement while advantage is in use, hence no sanction.

So because the try was scored, there's no infringement. That's what you're saying right? Not sure I'm the one being obtuse.

How long have you been watching rugby? Never noticed a team scoring and the commentary saying player X is lucky or otherwise they'd probably be facing a YC? Never seen a ref play advantage until today and decide the appropriate sanction when going back to the original offence?

There's no offence if the ref determines the non-offending team has gained an advantage. There's an entire section in the laws dealing with this.

I've only been watching for 40 minutes Mr expert. So you've never seen anyone yellow carded for a previous infringement when a try has been scored? How long have you been watching rugby?

Name an instance when someone has been YC for offside when the non-offending team scores a try.

[Tim]

One point game.

[Tim]

Better kick from DMac.

[Mr Fish]

@antipodean said in Hurricanes vs Chiefs:

@Bones said in Hurricanes vs Chiefs:

@antipodean said in Hurricanes vs Chiefs:

@Bones said in Hurricanes vs Chiefs:

@antipodean said in Hurricanes vs Chiefs:

@Bones said in Hurricanes vs Chiefs:

@antipodean said in Hurricanes vs Chiefs:

@Bones said in Hurricanes vs Chiefs:

@antipodean said in Hurricanes vs Chiefs:

@Bones said in Hurricanes vs Chiefs:

That's moronic. Why wasn't it already a YC?

Advantage, so the penalty wasn't called.

Why does that matter? YC infringement is YC infringement.

It's not an infringement if it isn't called.

I've never heard that in my life. If a high tackle was made it shouldn't be carded it points are scored then right?

I suspect you're being deliberately obtuse, but I'll answer anyway: Until the penalty is awarded for offside, there's no infringement while advantage is in use, hence no sanction.

So because the try was scored, there's no infringement. That's what you're saying right? Not sure I'm the one being obtuse.

How long have you been watching rugby? Never noticed a team scoring and the commentary saying player X is lucky or otherwise they'd probably be facing a YC? Never seen a ref play advantage until today and decide the appropriate sanction when going back to the original offence?

There's no offence if the ref determines the non-offending team has gained an advantage. There's an entire section in the laws dealing with this.

I've only been watching for 40 minutes Mr expert. So you've never seen anyone yellow carded for a previous infringement when a try has been scored? How long have you been watching rugby?

Name an instance when someone has been YC for offside when the non-offending team scores a try.

I can't think of specific examples but I've definitely seen this before.

[Duluth]

Chiefs in front. I presume every Chiefs player should be in the ABs now

[Tim]

Great try. All Chiefs at the moment. Hurricanes defence can't stop their momentum.

[Tim]

@Duluth Sotutu will find it twice as hard to make the ABs now.

[Mr Fish]

It's just a couple of small errors from the Canes in bad positions and the Chiefs pouncing.

[Duluth]

@Tim said in Hurricanes vs Chiefs:

@Duluth Sotutu will find it twice as hard to make the ABs now.

Let’s be serious we all know Grace will get selected

[Toddy]

How was Ratima allowed to get up after being tackled

[Yeetyaah]

Kirifi wasn't even on the ball

[Tim]

@Toddy Yeah, that was a shocker.

[antipodean]

Narawa putting his own team under pressure by aimlessly running sideways away from support. Gives the Canes an opportunity to swing momentum.