All Blacks v France I
-
Savea @7, Ioane @wing. Finally.
-
Disappointed DMac not steering the ship
-
Starting Barrett, Holland and Vaai could be the start of something. Certainly adds much needed grunt
-
Really hope tonight is a flogging. Razor deserves to be rewarded for these bold selections.
-
@KiwiMurph said in All Blacks v France I:
@reprobate said in All Blacks v France I:
You can't draw conclusions on small selected samples, otherwise week 1 playoff Hoskins is a legend, week 2 he's a useless piece of shit. And if playoffs are the be-all, where are our cantablacks?
I'm talking about this notion of DMac being the answer - not disputing Beauden has his issues too.
The fact is DMac has come up small 3 playoff years in a row.
I blame Laidlaw for not keeping Love at 10 this year and I'm championing Reihana - Reihana would have been in my AB squad - I would have done something like name him in the squad but release him for the Maori ABs and then have him rejoin the AB squad.
The difference is that Beauden has had years and years - that improvement is clearly never happening.
How many tests has McKenzie actually started at 10? And in far fewer opportunities he has shown glimpses of what we need - the attacking first half of Boks 1 last year, the improved control vs Ireland etc.@reprobate said in All Blacks v France I:
@KiwiMurph said in All Blacks v France I:
@reprobate said in All Blacks v France I:
You can't draw conclusions on small selected samples, otherwise week 1 playoff Hoskins is a legend, week 2 he's a useless piece of shit. And if playoffs are the be-all, where are our cantablacks?
I'm talking about this notion of DMac being the answer - not disputing Beauden has his issues too.
The fact is DMac has come up small 3 playoff years in a row.
I blame Laidlaw for not keeping Love at 10 this year and I'm championing Reihana - Reihana would have been in my AB squad - I would have done something like name him in the squad but release him for the Maori ABs and then have him rejoin the AB squad.
The difference is that Beauden has had years and years - that improvement is clearly never happening.
How many tests has McKenzie actually started at 10? And in far fewer opportunities he has shown glimpses of what we need - the attacking first half of Boks 1 last year, the improved control vs Ireland etc.Started 15 tests at 10.
Started 23 tests at 15. -
@pakman said in All Blacks v France I:
The Rieko I want to see tomorrow:
Hopefully Crotty and Goodhue give him some good ball to work with
@MN5 said in All Blacks v France I:
@pakman said in All Blacks v France I:
The Rieko I want to see tomorrow:
Hopefully Crotty and
Goodhuegive him some good ball to work withSonny Bill
Someone to play like 2017 Kieran Read would be handy too.
-
@Bones nice strawman but I never said DMac didn't play well, in fact after that match I said I wanted him as our starting 10 moving forward on account of his kicking game. I also said I would have started him this test with Beauden on the bench. My point was that starting Beauden wasn't particularly controversial as well given his good form this year, his experience, and his more direct running style which works better against test match defenses.
-
@Bones nice strawman but I never said DMac didn't play well, in fact after that match I said I wanted him as our starting 10 moving forward on account of his kicking game. I also said I would have started him this test with Beauden on the bench. My point was that starting Beauden wasn't particularly controversial as well given his good form this year, his experience, and his more direct running style which works better against test match defenses.
Beauden runs sideways a lot - especially when he's going to pass.
Love, Reihana, Plummer and Perofeta are all a lot more direct than the two in today's squad
-
@reprobate said in All Blacks v France I:
@KiwiMurph said in All Blacks v France I:
@reprobate said in All Blacks v France I:
You can't draw conclusions on small selected samples, otherwise week 1 playoff Hoskins is a legend, week 2 he's a useless piece of shit. And if playoffs are the be-all, where are our cantablacks?
I'm talking about this notion of DMac being the answer - not disputing Beauden has his issues too.
The fact is DMac has come up small 3 playoff years in a row.
I blame Laidlaw for not keeping Love at 10 this year and I'm championing Reihana - Reihana would have been in my AB squad - I would have done something like name him in the squad but release him for the Maori ABs and then have him rejoin the AB squad.
The difference is that Beauden has had years and years - that improvement is clearly never happening.
How many tests has McKenzie actually started at 10? And in far fewer opportunities he has shown glimpses of what we need - the attacking first half of Boks 1 last year, the improved control vs Ireland etc.Started 15 tests at 10.
Started 23 tests at 15.@ACT-Crusader said in All Blacks v France I:
@reprobate said in All Blacks v France I:
@KiwiMurph said in All Blacks v France I:
@reprobate said in All Blacks v France I:
You can't draw conclusions on small selected samples, otherwise week 1 playoff Hoskins is a legend, week 2 he's a useless piece of shit. And if playoffs are the be-all, where are our cantablacks?
I'm talking about this notion of DMac being the answer - not disputing Beauden has his issues too.
The fact is DMac has come up small 3 playoff years in a row.
I blame Laidlaw for not keeping Love at 10 this year and I'm championing Reihana - Reihana would have been in my AB squad - I would have done something like name him in the squad but release him for the Maori ABs and then have him rejoin the AB squad.
The difference is that Beauden has had years and years - that improvement is clearly never happening.
How many tests has McKenzie actually started at 10? And in far fewer opportunities he has shown glimpses of what we need - the attacking first half of Boks 1 last year, the improved control vs Ireland etc.Started 15 tests at 10.
Started 23 tests at 15.So if we compare that to Beauden playing how many at 10 without ever looking like anything other than an individual star fullback playing out of position?
And compare it to how many tests Mounga took to find his feet - and particularly how many in a row without them chopping back to Barrett every few tests?
McKenzie is getting fucked around, to the detriment of the ABs. Brilliant footy player BB, but i think our coaches selecting him at 10 has stifled our play for far too long. -
Is this today? Like in about 3.5 hours' time?
It's fucking hard to keep track of this shit in a weird time zone. And fucking Murica's birthday, give me a "hell yeah".
I had a plan of: fucking around all day, do some cooking prep, do a tour of a few breweries, see if I can see any fireworks, go home, do some drunken cooking.
Now I have to add an entire AllBlacks game to the end of that, starting at midnight? -
Is this today? Like in about 3.5 hours' time?
It's fucking hard to keep track of this shit in a weird time zone. And fucking Murica's birthday, give me a "hell yeah".
I had a plan of: fucking around all day, do some cooking prep, do a tour of a few breweries, see if I can see any fireworks, go home, do some drunken cooking.
Now I have to add an entire AllBlacks game to the end of that, starting at midnight? -
I’m going to need to juggle this game while on a boat from Albania to Corfu.
Man life is complicated sometimes
@voodoo said in All Blacks v France I:
I’m going to need to juggle this game while on a boat from Albania to Corfu.
Man life is complicated sometimes
Pop over to Crete, I'll buy you a beer.
-
@voodoo said in All Blacks v France I:
I’m going to need to juggle this game while on a boat from Albania to Corfu.
Man life is complicated sometimes
Pop over to Crete, I'll buy you a beer.
@Bones said in All Blacks v France I:
@voodoo said in All Blacks v France I:
I’m going to need to juggle this game while on a boat from Albania to Corfu.
Man life is complicated sometimes
Pop over to Crete, I'll buy you a beer.
Ah that explains the FB messages coming through at a normal ( Greek ) time. I just assumed you were a British based insomniac
-
@Bones said in All Blacks v France I:
@voodoo said in All Blacks v France I:
I’m going to need to juggle this game while on a boat from Albania to Corfu.
Man life is complicated sometimes
Pop over to Crete, I'll buy you a beer.
Ah that explains the FB messages coming through at a normal ( Greek ) time. I just assumed you were a British based insomniac
@MN5 said in All Blacks v France I:
@Bones said in All Blacks v France I:
@voodoo said in All Blacks v France I:
I’m going to need to juggle this game while on a boat from Albania to Corfu.
Man life is complicated sometimes
Pop over to Crete, I'll buy you a beer.
Ah that explains the FB messages coming through at a normal ( Greek ) time. I just assumed you were a British based insomniac
London based Arab/Kiwi being Cretan.
