All Blacks v Springboks I
-
@Frank said in All Blacks v Springboks I:
@brodean said in All Blacks v Springboks I:
@KiwiMurph said in All Blacks v Springboks I:
@Wurzel said in All Blacks v Springboks I:
Speaking of Dagg and ex players not being critical of current ABs, evidently he’s not a Rieko fan… and wasn’t when they played together
https://www.instagram.com/reel/DNzZXjXQrKw/?igsh=MXdhMTk1NWUzcW01aw==
Finally someone says something. Thank heavens.
The fact in a decade Rieko hasn't developed the skills to take the high ball or develop a kicking game says a lot.
It also says a lot about these coaches.
They talk about both sides of the ball but throw Rieko on the wing when presumably they know he struggles under the high ball. If they don't know - and if their plan was to play Rieko on the wing - then why weren't they using the pre AB squad naming camp in BOP and the French series trainings to really test out Rieko under the high ball.
There are some things Rieko has improved on in his career - defensively he has gotten much better and his passing has improved compared to where it was when he first came on the scene.
But it screams of Razor not having the sack to drop a guy that the NZR signed to a deal through to the 2027 RWC.
He doesn't need a highball game at centre and he didn't need a kicking game with Havili and JB being his main two partners.
Does need to know how to pass well though doesn't he.
See it as a close call between him and Proctor however.
He passes just fine - not perfect, but fine. The issue he has is the same one that Proctor is facing now - a lack of time and space with which to use the ball. This is primarily the result of how this and the last regime structured their backline attack and also the two blokes inside him who can’t pass for shit either.
I don’t know if there is a centre in NZ who could, under those conditions, throw the kind of perfectly timed flat spiral passes to wide wingers and fullbacks that people seem to be expecting here - not Rieko and not Proctor either.
As for the comment earlier about Rieko tucking and ducking, that is totally fair and quite frustrating. But, I think it is also fair to suggest that this is something he has developed to get himself over the gain line and not get smashed by his opposing centres when playing so flat and flat footed as part of our backline structure.
@junior said in All Blacks v Springboks I:
This is primarily the result of how this and the last regime structured their backline attack and also the two blokes inside him who can’t pass for shit either.
Yeah, his lack of distribution skill is the fault of every coach and every player that has ever played inside him. Nothing to do with him at all............
-
@Mr-Fish said in All Blacks v Springboks I:
Anton Lienert-Brown is probably the best distributing centre in NZ - just saying...
When he's not in the bin?
@canefan said in All Blacks v Springboks I:
@Mr-Fish said in All Blacks v Springboks I:
Anton Lienert-Brown is probably the best distributing centre in NZ - just saying...
When he's not in the bin?
See, none of our contenders are perfect, ALB can't stay on the field, Rieko can't pass and Proctor can't
walk on waterdefend.
-
@canefan said in All Blacks v Springboks I:
@Mr-Fish said in All Blacks v Springboks I:
Anton Lienert-Brown is probably the best distributing centre in NZ - just saying...
When he's not in the bin?
See, none of our contenders are perfect, ALB can't stay on the field, Rieko can't pass and Proctor can't
walk on waterdefend.@Nepia said in All Blacks v Springboks I:
@canefan said in All Blacks v Springboks I:
@Mr-Fish said in All Blacks v Springboks I:
Anton Lienert-Brown is probably the best distributing centre in NZ - just saying...
When he's not in the bin?
See, none of our contenders are perfect, ALB can't stay on the field, Rieko can't pass and Proctor can't
walk on waterdefend.And Leicester is laughing
-
@Frank said in All Blacks v Springboks I:
@brodean said in All Blacks v Springboks I:
@KiwiMurph said in All Blacks v Springboks I:
@Wurzel said in All Blacks v Springboks I:
Speaking of Dagg and ex players not being critical of current ABs, evidently he’s not a Rieko fan… and wasn’t when they played together
https://www.instagram.com/reel/DNzZXjXQrKw/?igsh=MXdhMTk1NWUzcW01aw==
Finally someone says something. Thank heavens.
The fact in a decade Rieko hasn't developed the skills to take the high ball or develop a kicking game says a lot.
It also says a lot about these coaches.
They talk about both sides of the ball but throw Rieko on the wing when presumably they know he struggles under the high ball. If they don't know - and if their plan was to play Rieko on the wing - then why weren't they using the pre AB squad naming camp in BOP and the French series trainings to really test out Rieko under the high ball.
There are some things Rieko has improved on in his career - defensively he has gotten much better and his passing has improved compared to where it was when he first came on the scene.
But it screams of Razor not having the sack to drop a guy that the NZR signed to a deal through to the 2027 RWC.
He doesn't need a highball game at centre and he didn't need a kicking game with Havili and JB being his main two partners.
Does need to know how to pass well though doesn't he.
See it as a close call between him and Proctor however.
He passes just fine - not perfect, but fine. The issue he has is the same one that Proctor is facing now - a lack of time and space with which to use the ball. This is primarily the result of how this and the last regime structured their backline attack and also the two blokes inside him who can’t pass for shit either.
I don’t know if there is a centre in NZ who could, under those conditions, throw the kind of perfectly timed flat spiral passes to wide wingers and fullbacks that people seem to be expecting here - not Rieko and not Proctor either.
As for the comment earlier about Rieko tucking and ducking, that is totally fair and quite frustrating. But, I think it is also fair to suggest that this is something he has developed to get himself over the gain line and not get smashed by his opposing centres when playing so flat and flat footed as part of our backline structure.
@junior said in All Blacks v Springboks I:
@Frank said in All Blacks v Springboks I:
@brodean said in All Blacks v Springboks I:
@KiwiMurph said in All Blacks v Springboks I:
@Wurzel said in All Blacks v Springboks I:
Speaking of Dagg and ex players not being critical of current ABs, evidently he’s not a Rieko fan… and wasn’t when they played together
https://www.instagram.com/reel/DNzZXjXQrKw/?igsh=MXdhMTk1NWUzcW01aw==
Finally someone says something. Thank heavens.
The fact in a decade Rieko hasn't developed the skills to take the high ball or develop a kicking game says a lot.
It also says a lot about these coaches.
They talk about both sides of the ball but throw Rieko on the wing when presumably they know he struggles under the high ball. If they don't know - and if their plan was to play Rieko on the wing - then why weren't they using the pre AB squad naming camp in BOP and the French series trainings to really test out Rieko under the high ball.
There are some things Rieko has improved on in his career - defensively he has gotten much better and his passing has improved compared to where it was when he first came on the scene.
But it screams of Razor not having the sack to drop a guy that the NZR signed to a deal through to the 2027 RWC.
He doesn't need a highball game at centre and he didn't need a kicking game with Havili and JB being his main two partners.
Does need to know how to pass well though doesn't he.
See it as a close call between him and Proctor however.
He passes just fine - not perfect, but fine. The issue he has is the same one that Proctor is facing now - a lack of time and space with which to use the ball. This is primarily the result of how this and the last regime structured their backline attack and also the two blokes inside him who can’t pass for shit either.
I don’t know if there is a centre in NZ who could, under those conditions, throw the kind of perfectly timed flat spiral passes to wide wingers and fullbacks that people seem to be expecting here - not Rieko and not Proctor either.
As for the comment earlier about Rieko tucking and ducking, that is totally fair and quite frustrating. But, I think it is also fair to suggest that this is something he has developed to get himself over the gain line and not get smashed by his opposing centres when playing so flat and flat footed as part of our backline structure.
If it's a center who can pass well both ways, its ALB.
As a starter, the YC risk may go down?Edit, I see these points have been covered.
-
I thought Ennor's big improvements in super this year was his heads up play and handling. Carry on in that manner and he could get up to half a dozen games before being discarded because he didn't look to the manor born.
@Bones said in All Blacks v Springboks I:
I thought Ennor's big improvements in super this year was his heads up play and handling. Carry on in that manner and he could get up to half a dozen games before being discarded because he didn't look to the manor born.
Yeah, if we have to pick a Crusader centre it would be Ennor for me. I once described him as a poor man's Rieko, but he has looked an improved player the last couple of years.
As for big LF, when he left he couldn't pass for shit. Has that changed?
-
@Bones said in All Blacks v Springboks I:
I thought Ennor's big improvements in super this year was his heads up play and handling. Carry on in that manner and he could get up to half a dozen games before being discarded because he didn't look to the manor born.
Yeah, if we have to pick a Crusader centre it would be Ennor for me. I once described him as a poor man's Rieko, but he has looked an improved player the last couple of years.
As for big LF, when he left he couldn't pass for shit. Has that changed?
@Crazy-Horse said in All Blacks v Springboks I:
@Bones said in All Blacks v Springboks I:
I thought Ennor's big improvements in super this year was his heads up play and handling. Carry on in that manner and he could get up to half a dozen games before being discarded because he didn't look to the manor born.
Yeah, if we have to pick a Crusader centre it would be Ennor for me. I once described him as a poor man's Rieko, but he has looked an improved player the last couple of years.
As for big LF, when he left he couldn't pass for shit. Has that changed?
He'll fit right in then!
-
@Bones said in All Blacks v Springboks I:
I thought Ennor's big improvements in super this year was his heads up play and handling. Carry on in that manner and he could get up to half a dozen games before being discarded because he didn't look to the manor born.
Yeah, if we have to pick a Crusader centre it would be Ennor for me. I once described him as a poor man's Rieko, but he has looked an improved player the last couple of years.
As for big LF, when he left he couldn't pass for shit. Has that changed?
@Crazy-Horse thought he was looking quite rapid this year too.
-
@Bones said in All Blacks v Springboks I:
I thought Ennor's big improvements in super this year was his heads up play and handling. Carry on in that manner and he could get up to half a dozen games before being discarded because he didn't look to the manor born.
Yeah, if we have to pick a Crusader centre it would be Ennor for me. I once described him as a poor man's Rieko, but he has looked an improved player the last couple of years.
As for big LF, when he left he couldn't pass for shit. Has that changed?
@Crazy-Horse said in All Blacks v Springboks I:
As for big LF, when he left he couldn't pass for shit
Not a skill required for the ABs. No problem.
-
@taniwharugby said in All Blacks v Springboks I:
@KiwiMurph i wonder if the Boks will kick to us?
Well it's not like we didn't also miss an absolute shitload of tackles... making it a tough choice for them to run it or kick it.
Bit of a masterstroke really, they won't know what to do.@reprobate said in All Blacks v Springboks I:
@taniwharugby said in All Blacks v Springboks I:
@KiwiMurph i wonder if the Boks will kick to us?
Well it's not like we didn't also miss an absolute shitload of tackles... making it a tough choice for them to run it or kick it.
Bit of a masterstroke really, they won't know what to do.Boks missed a lot of tackles against the Aussies on the weekend as well - 30. In terms of overall tackle completion, their rate was lower than the ABs.
Both teams were guilty of a passive defensive line through decent periods. They took and made their kicks.
This points to another problem with that match - fat too much defending and in the wrong end of he park. It was taking its toll and put huge pressure on us for long periods.
Against the Boks if we can get down our end I think they are vulnerable defensively too.
-
@junior said in All Blacks v Springboks I:
This is primarily the result of how this and the last regime structured their backline attack and also the two blokes inside him who can’t pass for shit either.
Yeah, his lack of distribution skill is the fault of every coach and every player that has ever played inside him. Nothing to do with him at all............
@Frank said in All Blacks v Springboks I:
@junior said in All Blacks v Springboks I:
This is primarily the result of how this and the last regime structured their backline attack and also the two blokes inside him who can’t pass for shit either.
Yeah, his lack of distribution skill is the fault of every coach and every player that has ever played inside him. Nothing to do with him at all............
Way to take one sentence from my post, remove all context, and miss the point completely.
-
Going to be interesting,
Before the Argie 2 game ,I honestly thought we might be on a upwards trajectory mainly due to the forwards , tight 5 in particular. Then we served up that pile of dog shit where it feels like any progress all came undone .
I suspect Rassie will target that tight 5 and holland in particular to see if he can find a chink and a barrage of high balls are coming our way , if we play the same back 3 I think we are in trouble.
If Clarke isn’t ready , I’d play love ( he’s 24 now if he’s not ready yet when is he ready ? ) at 15 Jordan at 14 , can narawa play 11 .? What is carter like under the high ball ?
