10. 2025 TOTY FIRST FIVE-EIGHTH
-
This might be an A N Other winner. I really can't think of anyone that stands out above all others.
The Saffer guy looks to have all the gifts but has not done much so far, very much early days. Does he get it on potential?
NZ 10s? Nah.
Aus? Do me a favour. It's been a revolving door with the stand in JOC being the pick of a pretty bare cupboard.
Ntamack has been injured and a bit hot and cold.
Russell is too many rocks and not enough diamonds, even if those diamonds are very sparkly.
England? No one has had the reigns for long enough or shown the all round consistency necessary
Ireland similar.
Wales? Do we even know any of their names?
Argies? Well if they settled on Carreras he would have a good chance, but they haven't so he doesn't
Allan and Garbisi seem to be swapping around too much for either to make a claim.
A N Other it is then.
-
@Catogrande said in 10. 2025 TOTY FIRST FIVE-EIGHTH:
This might be an A N Other winner. I really can't think of anyone that stands out above all others.
The Saffer guy looks to have all the gifts but has not done much so far, very much early days. Does he get it on potential?
NZ 10s? Nah.
Aus? Do me a favour. It's been a revolving door with the stand in JOC being the pick of a pretty bare cupboard.
Ntamack has been injured and a bit hot and cold.
Russell is too many rocks and not enough diamonds, even if those diamonds are very sparkly.
England? No one has had the reigns for long enough or shown the all round consistency necessary
Ireland similar.
Wales? Do we even know any of their names?
Argies? Well if they settled on Carreras he would have a good chance, but they haven't so he doesn't
Allan and Garbisi seem to be swapping around too much for either to make a claim.
A N Other it is then.
Agree on all of that.
The thing with the Springbok kid is that Pollard has still played quite a bit this season at 10. I guess all the rest have been a bit up and down or downright poor, the rugby world are so keen to talk about the next potential great 10. Long way to go for sure.
-
@Catogrande said in 10. 2025 TOTY FIRST FIVE-EIGHTH:
This might be an A N Other winner. I really can't think of anyone that stands out above all others.
The Saffer guy looks to have all the gifts but has not done much so far, very much early days. Does he get it on potential?
NZ 10s? Nah.
Aus? Do me a favour. It's been a revolving door with the stand in JOC being the pick of a pretty bare cupboard.
Ntamack has been injured and a bit hot and cold.
Russell is too many rocks and not enough diamonds, even if those diamonds are very sparkly.
England? No one has had the reigns for long enough or shown the all round consistency necessary
Ireland similar.
Wales? Do we even know any of their names?
Argies? Well if they settled on Carreras he would have a good chance, but they haven't so he doesn't
Allan and Garbisi seem to be swapping around too much for either to make a claim.
A N Other it is then.
Like your theory. Uruguay had 6 wins in 2025 anyone watch any of their games and know who their 10 is? Almost feel this would be the next best case and given results maybe a tier 2 deserves it given the protest vote
-
Georgian 10 has been consistently good
-
Points lost for not knowing their names.
-
@Catogrande said in 10. 2025 TOTY FIRST FIVE-EIGHTH:
Points lost for not knowing their names.
Couldn’t spell them
-
@MiketheSnow said in 10. 2025 TOTY FIRST FIVE-EIGHTH:
@Catogrande said in 10. 2025 TOTY FIRST FIVE-EIGHTH:
Points lost for not knowing their names.
Couldn’t spell them
Whasanadze?
-
@Catogrande said in 10. 2025 TOTY FIRST FIVE-EIGHTH:
Points lost for not knowing their names.
the funny part is I could have written anything and I doubt many would have pulled me up.. doh!
-
@bayimports Yep. 15 letter with only 1 recurring vowel would have done it.
-
@Catogrande said in 10. 2025 TOTY FIRST FIVE-EIGHTH:
A N Other it is then.
I'm not arguing your points but the rules state (I just clarified with myself) that we must nominate and vote for actual players.
Only in the event of nobody voting will AN Other be selected.
-
SFM and it's not even close. Not sure about an above suggestion that he hasn't done much this year. He's not played every game, but few players (particular South Africans) have. There's still room for improvement in various areas but he's unqualified stionably excellent already.
-
-
@sparky said in 10. 2025 TOTY FIRST FIVE-EIGHTH:
Before you vote for SFM, ask yourself how good would Finn Russell (and others) look behind the Springbok pack?
That could be said about every player
The counter is would players like Russell get in to the SA side
-
@sparky said in 10. 2025 TOTY FIRST FIVE-EIGHTH:
Before you vote for SFM, ask yourself how good would Finn Russell (and others) look behind their pack?
More mythical speak and the whole forwards are the bestest on the planet and no back could look good without the platter being served for them. I’ve seen Finn Russell play some big games with the Scottish pack looking all sorts of ordinary. Saw Dan Carter play well whilst the AB forwards were off the boil.
It’s possible, it happens more than some think. And backs win matches…..
-
-
@Mr-Fish said in 10. 2025 TOTY FIRST FIVE-EIGHTH:
@booboo said in 10. 2025 TOTY FIRST FIVE-EIGHTH:
Nominations closed. Vote in the OP.
No poll in this one!
Showing for me on both laptop and phone.
Check the top of page 1 ... we're currently on page 2
