2017 School Rugby
-
@Stargazer said in 2017 School Rugby:
Bloody hell, Hastings Boys is killing Palmy boys at the moment. It's a massacre!
Score?
-
@Stargazer said in 2017 School Rugby:
Bloody hell, Hastings Boys is killing Palmy boys at the moment. It's a massacre!
Score?
-
PNBHS have had the Polson Banner for the last 3 years. Looks like it might go back to where it belongs when NBHS play them this year
-
PNBHS have had the Polson Banner for the last 3 years. Looks like it might go back to where it belongs when NBHS play them this year
@Stockcar86 said in 2017 School Rugby:
PNBHS have had the Polson Banner for the last 3 years. Looks like it might go back to where it belongs when NBHS play them this year
And then Napier should man up and put it on the line against Hastings.
No doubt they'd get it straight back again next year when our two years of glory are over.
-
Central North Island (1st XV) results - 10 June:
Te Aute College 32, Lindisfarne College 36
St John’s (Hastings) 3, Wanganui Collegiate 52
Wesley College 38, Rathkeale College 7
St. Peter’s (Cambridge) 21, Francis Douglas MC 38
St Paul’s Collegiate 26, Feilding HS 15 -
@Stockcar86 said in 2017 School Rugby:
PNBHS have had the Polson Banner for the last 3 years. Looks like it might go back to where it belongs when NBHS play them this year
And then Napier should man up and put it on the line against Hastings.
No doubt they'd get it straight back again next year when our two years of glory are over.
@Nepia said in 2017 School Rugby:
@Stockcar86 said in 2017 School Rugby:
PNBHS have had the Polson Banner for the last 3 years. Looks like it might go back to where it belongs when NBHS play them this year
And then Napier should man up and put it on the line against Hastings.
No doubt they'd get it straight back again next year when our two years of glory are over.
Hastings 2nd XV is going pretty well, too:
Hastings BHS 2nd XV (36), Palmerston North BHS 2nd XV (0)Colts lost though:
Hastings BHS U15 (19), Palmerston North BHS U15 (50) -
Central North Island (1st XV) results - 10 June:
Te Aute College 32, Lindisfarne College 36
St John’s (Hastings) 3, Wanganui Collegiate 52
Wesley College 38, Rathkeale College 7
St. Peter’s (Cambridge) 21, Francis Douglas MC 38
St Paul’s Collegiate 26, Feilding HS 15@Stargazer
I would be really interested to see how many times Lindisfarne has beaten TA. When I was there (early 2000's) pretty sure we hadn't ever beaten them. They happened to be strong when we were strong and when they were weak they were terrible and played 2nd 15 or lower grade. Even mid 2000's they had a couple of guys from NBHS go there just for rugby and created a strong team around that and came 3rd behind NBHSHBHS 1sts that year from memory. -
My most vivid (watching) rugby memories from school was the agro between NBHS and TA. We really didn't like each other (back in the early-mid 80's). Best moment was when an all in fight had started. Pod Turner had been taken under the grandstand 5 minutes earlier with an injury, but can came running back out to join in. Rugby was different in those days...
-
@Rapido said in 2017 School Rugby:
That's really quite sad.
Need to form a Super 1 comp now instead?
Hamilton Boys look like they'll be decent competition.
@Nepia said in 2017 School Rugby:
@Rapido said in 2017 School Rugby:
That's really quite sad.
Need to form a Super 1 comp now instead?
Hamilton Boys look like they'll be decent competition.
A Super 2 then. Yay.
The Super 8 has come into being because those big fish provincial schools are too big for their local comps.
Where do we go now?
I realise I'm hating on excellence. But geez, that's worrying. They pumped St Pats as well from the Wellington comp so the answer isn't there.
-
@Nepia said in 2017 School Rugby:
@Rapido said in 2017 School Rugby:
That's really quite sad.
Need to form a Super 1 comp now instead?
Hamilton Boys look like they'll be decent competition.
A Super 2 then. Yay.
The Super 8 has come into being because those big fish provincial schools are too big for their local comps.
Where do we go now?
I realise I'm hating on excellence. But geez, that's worrying. They pumped St Pats as well from the Wellington comp so the answer isn't there.
@Rapido said in 2017 School Rugby:
@Nepia said in 2017 School Rugby:
@Rapido said in 2017 School Rugby:
That's really quite sad.
Need to form a Super 1 comp now instead?
Hamilton Boys look like they'll be decent competition.
A Super 2 then. Yay.
The Super 8 has come into being because those big fish provincial schools are too big for their local comps.
Where do we go now?
I realise I'm hating on excellence. But geez, that's worrying. They pumped St Pats as well from the Wellington comp so the answer isn't there.
These things happen occasionally, one team in Super 8 will go on a roll and then it will pull back.
Hastings have been posting some pretty crazy scores in the last two years though.
-
That Hastings team features eight Year 14s (that's Form 8 under the old terminology) so their success this year should be taken with a grain of salt.
When they played (and smoked) MAGS in pre-season the MAGS coach looked at Hasting's team sheet before the game and remarked that it was an identical team to that which they beat in the National Final the year before.
-
Looks like super 8 is falling into a pattern that happens in the Auckland comp.. generally it's about 6-7 schools who have a genuine shot of making the top 4.. rest try to avoid relegation matches..
There's a cycle usually though.. however since the tv broadcasting St Kent's is a regular in playoffs.. they used to be rubbish
-
Looks like super 8 is falling into a pattern that happens in the Auckland comp.. generally it's about 6-7 schools who have a genuine shot of making the top 4.. rest try to avoid relegation matches..
There's a cycle usually though.. however since the tv broadcasting St Kent's is a regular in playoffs.. they used to be rubbish
@mimic Yeah St Kents were quite strong in the late 90s and early 00s making a few Auckland finals and winning one (they had the likes of Lavea twins, Rokocoko, Afoas, Kaino) then they really regressed and actually got demoted into the 2nd tier. Then there was a huge focus/$ put into their rugby program and have had some pretty sustained success (and now coached by one of the Lavea twins, whilst the other coaches Kings).
-
That Hastings team features eight Year 14s (that's Form 8 under the old terminology) so their success this year should be taken with a grain of salt.
When they played (and smoked) MAGS in pre-season the MAGS coach looked at Hasting's team sheet before the game and remarked that it was an identical team to that which they beat in the National Final the year before.
@Wurzel said in 2017 School Rugby:
That Hastings team features eight Year 14s (that's Form 8 under the old terminology) so their success this year should be taken with a grain of salt.
When they played (and smoked) MAGS in pre-season the MAGS coach looked at Hasting's team sheet before the game and remarked that it was an identical team to that which they beat in the National Final the year before.
It's true that there are several Year 14s in the Hastings BHS squad, however, most of them have all played a year up last year. Only one or two of those Year 14s become 19 this year, all the others are just 17 year-olds turning 18 this year.
I've seen a lot of comments in social media dismissing the success of Hastings as cheating within the rules or playing with players that turn 19 this year, but that's just sour grapes. The fact is that, while they have the advantage of playing in a group that hasn't changed much since last year, they are not playing with a group of players that is older than those of other teams. They also have one or two 16 year olds in the team by the way.
I have also seen accusations of Hastings poaching players from outside the region with scholarships, clearly showing that they know nothing about the school. It's a low decile that can't afford scholarships and almost all off these players are home grown. Before anyone mentions him, Kini Naholo started school in Hastings last year and his school fees etc are paid for by Waisake. I don't know how and why he ended up there (another brother plays in Taranaki), but Waisake moved to NZ to live with their uncle in Wanganui, who wanted him to get a proper education in NZ and his brothers have followed his move.
-
@KiwiMurph Yeah.. they put a lot of money into their scholarships..
I think their first xv is the only good team they have.. schools like mags, Auckland grammar, sacred heart and de la salle generally have strong teams coming up the age groups
