Highlanders v B&I Lions
-
@taniwharugby said in Highlanders v B&I Lions:
@Stockcar86 said in Highlanders v B&I Lions:
@Billy-Tell said in Highlanders v B&I Lions:
A few Qs from the match
Did Jared Payne really grow up playing rugby in NZ?
He was great playing for Northland, then playing for Chiefs under Foster then Blues under Lam beat all the flair out of him
think he played for the Chiefs prior to coming to Northland, then went to saders first, then to the Blues.
He actually played really well initially for the Blues - then the games he played after he had announced he was overseas it was like he had one foot on the plane.
@KiwiMurph yep, pretty sure after he had an awesome season of ITM and then started brilliantly in the super season there was even whispers of him being an outside shot in Black, then he signed on the green line and then....
-
@Salacious-Crumb said in Highlanders v B&I Lions:
Farrell's penalty miss was key.
It was more than just a penalty miss.
Stop reminding me.
Poor bastard
@MiketheSnow said in Highlanders v B&I Lions:
Poor bastard
Kiwi sphincters were watertight every time ball came near him. Thinking about it Lions were returning from their historic 71 triumph, ABs had some rough years losing to Poms then 76 Bok series, people were shitting themselves. Farrell played the first two test matches a win-and a loss, got the heave. Very-very tight series, 4th test decided by a single-point for the series win.
1st 16-12
2nd 9-13
3rd 19-7
4th 10-9 -
@MiketheSnow said in Highlanders v B&I Lions:
Poor bastard
Kiwi sphincters were watertight every time ball came near him. Thinking about it Lions were returning from their historic 71 triumph, ABs had some rough years losing to Poms then 76 Bok series, people were shitting themselves. Farrell played the first two test matches a win-and a loss, got the heave. Very-very tight series, 4th test decided by a single-point for the series win.
1st 16-12
2nd 9-13
3rd 19-7
4th 10-9Laurie Knight scored the winning try in the last minutes of the 4th test at Eden Park. I was in temporary seating in front of the North Stand and we all jumped about so much it collapsed.
Poor old Colin Farrell. Even for Auckland he was pretty hit and miss although for the times he was a counter-attacking fullback. We certainly has some shocking fullbacks after Karam went to league
Main v2 & Fawcett I'm gonna score more off the field than on it in 76 Duncan Robertosn Bevan Wilson seemed like a rugby god after that lot
-
@pakman what did I say, had a look at my posts and unsure whioch one this relates to
@taniwharugby The Highlanders played the way Braveheart would have wished them to! Very inspiring.
-
I don't mind Kayes that much. His cunning-Alinghi joke that @booboo referred to was terrible enough for us to still remember years and years later. Particularly terrible because he was asked a question about what the news headline following a rugby game would be, and he decided it was time to use a joke he had clearly saved up that wasn't funny, relevant, or appropriate.
On the other hand, I liked that he growled at Ali Williams and SBW when they were doing their lame press conference routine.
-
@No-Quarter said in Highlanders v B&I Lions:
It was a shame Joseph was the one to knock it on at the end there, he played really well tonight.
I thought the pass to him looked forward anyway.
@Bovidae said in Highlanders v B&I Lions:
@No-Quarter said in Highlanders v B&I Lions:
It was a shame Joseph was the one to knock it on at the end there, he played really well tonight.
I thought the pass to him looked forward anyway.
Watched it again and it looked okay to me, other than it being thrown at a hundred miles an hour....
I actually thought that was the right play for the Lions rather than go the maul off the lineout. The lineout was a fair ways out and the Lions were making decent yards through Joseph and others.
-
@Bovidae said in Highlanders v B&I Lions:
@No-Quarter said in Highlanders v B&I Lions:
It was a shame Joseph was the one to knock it on at the end there, he played really well tonight.
I thought the pass to him looked forward anyway.
Watched it again and it looked okay to me, other than it being thrown at a hundred miles an hour....
I actually thought that was the right play for the Lions rather than go the maul off the lineout. The lineout was a fair ways out and the Lions were making decent yards through Joseph and others.
@ACT-Crusader said in Highlanders v B&I Lions:
@Bovidae said in Highlanders v B&I Lions:
@No-Quarter said in Highlanders v B&I Lions:
It was a shame Joseph was the one to knock it on at the end there, he played really well tonight.
I thought the pass to him looked forward anyway.
Watched it again and it looked okay to me, other than it being thrown at a hundred miles an hour....
I actually thought that was the right play for the Lions rather than go the maul off the lineout. The lineout was a fair ways out and the Lions were making decent yards through Joseph and others.
They didn't need a 5 pointer though. I was sure they'd maul for a penalty.
-
Laurie Knight scored the winning try in the last minutes of the 4th test at Eden Park. I was in temporary seating in front of the North Stand and we all jumped about so much it collapsed.
Poor old Colin Farrell. Even for Auckland he was pretty hit and miss although for the times he was a counter-attacking fullback. We certainly has some shocking fullbacks after Karam went to league
Main v2 & Fawcett I'm gonna score more off the field than on it in 76 Duncan Robertosn Bevan Wilson seemed like a rugby god after that lot
@dogmeat said in Highlanders v B&I Lions:
Laurie Knight scored the winning try in the last minutes of the 4th test at Eden Park. I was in temporary seating in front of the North Stand and we all jumped about so much it collapsed.
-
@Bovidae said in Highlanders v B&I Lions:
@No-Quarter said in Highlanders v B&I Lions:
It was a shame Joseph was the one to knock it on at the end there, he played really well tonight.
I thought the pass to him looked forward anyway.
Watched it again and it looked okay to me, other than it being thrown at a hundred miles an hour....
I actually thought that was the right play for the Lions rather than go the maul off the lineout. The lineout was a fair ways out and the Lions were making decent yards through Joseph and others.
@ACT-Crusader I looked at the direction of the pass relative to the 22 m line. Forward pass to me but a moot point now.
-
@pakman said in Highlanders v B&I Lions:
My dad jumped out of his armchair and took out the chandelier above!
Scrums binding in a heartbeat, Bevan Wilson kicking with the point of his toe, that is some classic old-time rugby. That kick-and-chase by Bill Osborne was crucial.
-
@pakman said in Highlanders v B&I Lions:
My dad jumped out of his armchair and took out the chandelier above!
Scrums binding in a heartbeat, Bevan Wilson kicking with the point of his toe, that is some classic old-time rugby. That kick-and-chase by Bill Osborne was crucial.
@Salacious-Crumb said in Highlanders v B&I Lions:
Scrums binding in a heartbeat
Was it because both packs were so keen for the renewal of clandestine punching etc?
How did such less-than-peak-condition sportsmen cope without the 1-minute break that is the modern scrum?
(Maybe the repeated 1-minute pile-up that was the old-fashioned ruck?)
Unless 'Shoe-pie' was on the menu ...
Skip to 14:16 for a bit of old-school shoe-pie served to Lions John Dawes for being on the wrong side of a ruck -
Staggering stat from the Landers v Lions game.
For a so called 2nd string Lions team,they had over 700 x test caps across the 23,The Landers had around 40 x test caps,Malakai Fekitoa with 23 of those test caps..don't quite subscribe to some who have been calling the Landers that took the field B Team,there was still a decent bit of quality put out on the paddock,in fact if they were a Mitre 10 cup side,they would take a bit of knocking off..The words over paid athletes gets thrown around quite a bit,but in the case of this Lions team that took the field,you do wonder..! -
given the standing of this guy, you'd think he would know the rules of where the off-side line is, hint, it isn't the middle of the ruck!
https://www.rugbypass.com/article/video-refereeing-decisions-gift-highlanders-victory-lions
-
They are marginally offside, which is very common nowadays. The line is a little misleading as it goes over the top of the ruck where it should disappear underneath it, making it appear like it goes through the middle when it would actually be closer to the back.
-
They are marginally offside, which is very common nowadays. The line is a little misleading as it goes over the top of the ruck where it should disappear underneath it, making it appear like it goes through the middle when it would actually be closer to the back.
@No-Quarter See what you mean, but reckon it is definitely more through the middle of the ruck, not at the back, see it goes through the middle of a highlander player on the right, he isn't near the back (of the Lions side) not to mention the Highlanders guy standing in an off-side position not part f the ruck.
I thnk that seems a deliberate (smart so far) tactic of the Lions, all in a straight line, all very flat or pushing the off-side line so a look up by the ref sees them all in a line so seems on-side.
Point is, the off side call was technically correct, yes plenty of times it is let go, so I guess you cant complain when one does get called when it is correct, however minor.
-
given the standing of this guy, you'd think he would know the rules of where the off-side line is, hint, it isn't the middle of the ruck!
https://www.rugbypass.com/article/video-refereeing-decisions-gift-highlanders-victory-lions
@taniwharugby said in Highlanders v B&I Lions:
given the standing of this guy, you'd think he would know the rules of where the off-side line is, hint, it isn't the middle of the ruck!
I agree.
Some fair points, but overall tears of impotent rage... they taste sweet.
Why didn't a Cantab make one of those from Saturday night? Highlight cynical play, dodgy scrum penalties and imaginary offside lines all night
-
given the standing of this guy, you'd think he would know the rules of where the off-side line is, hint, it isn't the middle of the ruck!
https://www.rugbypass.com/article/video-refereeing-decisions-gift-highlanders-victory-lions
His analysis has someone returning on side, having no participation in the play and Webb throwing a shitter of a pass that goes to ground. For some reason, he wants a penalty awarded as a result. People who don't know the laws shouldn't make videos analysing refereeing decisions.
@No-Quarter said in Highlanders v B&I Lions:
They are marginally offside, which is very common nowadays. The line is a little misleading as it goes over the top of the ruck where it should disappear underneath it, making it appear like it goes through the middle when it would actually be closer to the back.
Nah, by the letter of the law he's clearly offside.
-
His analysis has someone returning on side, having no participation in the play and Webb throwing a shitter of a pass that goes to ground. For some reason, he wants a penalty awarded as a result. People who don't know the laws shouldn't make videos analysing refereeing decisions.
@No-Quarter said in Highlanders v B&I Lions:
They are marginally offside, which is very common nowadays. The line is a little misleading as it goes over the top of the ruck where it should disappear underneath it, making it appear like it goes through the middle when it would actually be closer to the back.
Nah, by the letter of the law he's clearly offside.
@antipodean said in Highlanders v B&I Lions:
His analysis has someone returning on side, having no participation in the play and Webb throwing a shitter of a pass that goes to ground. For some reason, he wants a penalty awarded as a result. People who don't know the laws shouldn't make videos analysing refereeing decisions.
@No-Quarter said in Highlanders v B&I Lions:
They are marginally offside, which is very common nowadays. The line is a little misleading as it goes over the top of the ruck where it should disappear underneath it, making it appear like it goes through the middle when it would actually be closer to the back.
Nah, by the letter of the law he's clearly offside.
Yeah, I wasn't saying they were onside, just the picture is a little deceptive. Can't argue with the call.
I remember the play where Webb threw the shitter of a pass - it looked like he was in two minds as to whether he would try and milk a penalty by throwing it into the retiring player, or spin it wide and go for the try. Ended up just throwing it to ground so did neither.
