Exodus 2017

taniwharugby

kiwiinmelb

There is talk , Shields , who carries an English passport due to his parents , which would make him eligible almost straight away ,

is being pursued by England ,

Billy Tell

@kiwiinmelb said in Exodus 2017:

There is talk , Shields , who carries an English passport due to his parents , which would make him eligible almost straight away ,

is being pursued by England ,

Almost modern poetry, I like your style.

(no surprises that shields is weighing up his options)

jegga

@Billy-Tell said in Exodus 2017:

@kiwiinmelb said in Exodus 2017:

There is talk , Shields , who carries an English passport due to his parents , which would make him eligible almost straight away ,

is being pursued by England ,

Almost modern poetry, I like your style.

(no surprises that shields is weighing up his options)

You want it as Haiku?

Brad Shields may be gone
He has English ancestry
Can play six and eight

reprobate

@jegga i think all exodus posts should be presented as haiku from now on. it somehow makes the shit news easier to take.

jegga

@reprobate said in Exodus 2017:

@jegga i think all exodus posts should be presented as haiku from now on. it somehow makes the shit news easier to take.

I agree with you
The exodus continues
And it often hurts

Rapido

There was a loose forward named Brad Shields.
Who's granny was allegedly from Macclesfield.
That makes him England eligible.
This limerick is terrible.
But it numbs the pain until the hurt of our depth depletion is healed.

Bones

He's no doubt taken one look at the handling the AB's have shown this year and thought "well fuck playing with that shambles".

Margin_Walker

@kiwiinmelb said in Exodus 2017:

There is talk , Shields , who carries an English passport due to his parents , which would make him eligible almost straight away ,

is being pursued by England ,

Sounds like it's more a case of his agent touting him around the place, than him being pursued by England to be fair.

Crucial

Eddie will grab anyone he can in his search for experienced depth. He knows he only has a number of games left to get his ducks in a row and while producing a good 20 or so players he is quite light in places.

Margin_Walker

Sure, he'd be an option. But I doubt he's being pursued by anyone in the England setup.

Wouldn't surprise me if he made a move north though. Seems to be out of the frame AB wise and could earn a decent wedge in the current market.

Stockcar86

Don't they have enough big loose forwards with tits for hands in England already?

Frye

@Stockcar86 said in Exodus 2017:

Don't they have enough big loose forwards with tits for hands in England already?

They pick Teimana Harrison.

There depth isn't amazing by any means.

Rapido

I had nothing to do at work yesterday, for your benefit I went through Wikipedia to work out how many nz players are currently earning their way in the foreign leagues.

Total is 224.

France Top 14: 51
English Premiership; 39
Pro 12: 32
French D2: 39 (but 3 of the teams had no data)
Japan Top League (& Sunwolves): 48
English Championship: 8 ( I only counted from Leeds & Bristol, the rest aren't really pro)
Super Rugby (Aus and SAF teams): 7

Now my counting system is what I consider NZ 'products'. So plenty are under other nations flags.

So I include guys like ; Payne, Joe Tekori, Atonio, Aki, Blair Cowan, Dylan Hartley, Tameifuna, Sa'u, even Aussie born Sekope Kepu, etc ,

But I exclude those I consider NZ polished, rather than NZ Products (eg any scholarship guys whether they played for NZ, the Islands, or double poaches ) e.g. David Smith, Fekitoa, Nili Latu, Halai , Nathan Hughes, Tongan Thor, Henry Speight. Alapati Leiua, Etc

I've heard the Saffa lament about "300 overseas players" a bit recently. So wanted to get a comparison to see how much bigger their problem is (although I think their real problem is quality - they're not retaining the Dan Carter, Read, Nonu level player for a 10 year stretch like NZ has been able to)

Also, What I was interested in. Is if NZ rugby was an isolated bubble with no outside pressures, or inwards flows (such as AFL). How many pro players are out there on top of the 5 SR teams we currently have plus the impossible to quantify NPC level players who still have local dreams and haven't buggered off yet.

However. On the quality side - There were 10 guys in the Japanese league, and 17 in the French D2 I'd never heard of, with no wiki profile, but they had NZ flags as their nationality. Also I don't think there would be a place for 37 year old outside backs like Bryce Robins etc in NZ pro rugby, as well as some of the ancient but formerly well known players in France and England- e.g. A Jamie MacIntosh, Census Johnston etc who I assume are squad role players these days required for long grinding seasons.

Bones

Frank Halai is a hooker now? What the?

Stockcar86

@bones said in Exodus 2017:

Frank Halai is a hooker now? What the?

Foot race him versus Aumua please

canefan

Can't argue with Charlie's reasoning. I just hope he keeps a highly promising local player from getting exposed as a test prospect wherever he goes

Rapido

Piutau and Fekitoa, both young and 'exiled' with their test careers over mid 20s. But both would be able to switch via the Olympic loophole to Tonga if they wanted to.

Seems money is motivating factor and both come from huuuuuuuge double digit sibling immediate families. Let alone extended family, then village .....

Play some Olympic qualifying 7s tournaments before 2019.

ARHS

@rapido

I did a study too, for all worldwide pro clubs/provinces/franchises and got 253 kiwis and 221 South Africans. Only 113 Australians, but that is why their issue in fielding 5 strong Super rugby squads nonetheless. What is hugely worrying though is 128 Tongans, 123 Fijians and 96 Samoans. No wonder the depth in super rugby is being diluted heavily. That is a huge number overall - and reaches 1000 players if you add 45 Argentinians, 9 Namibians, 4 Japanese and 8 other Pacific Islanders. That is a huge number of players choosing to play 'overseas'.

Rapido

@arhs said in Exodus 2017:

What is hugely worrying though is 128 Tongans, 123 Fijians and 96 Samoans

Hi.
I don't agree with this part though.

I don't think it's hugely worrying. It's good that Tier 2 players get contracts in the pro leagues.

Even if I'm a bit contemptuous of the Top14's ability to improve players and not turn them to either lard or immobile balls of roids.

There's only 5 fully pro teams in NZ for example, with limits on non-NZ qualified players. Similar with all the SH unions with pro teams.

There are worries ( project players, clubs comps during int windows, the lax eligibility laws), but this area of the world simply produces too many players than it can pay.

The Silver Fern

Exodus 2017