Highlanders vs Blues
-
@kiwimurph said in Highlanders vs Blues:
@sammyc ?
Scrummaging powerhouse is a bit of an exaggeration
-
@kiwimurph said in Highlanders vs Blues:
@sammyc ?
Scrummaging powerhouse is a bit of an exaggeration
@sammyc said in Highlanders vs Blues:
@kiwimurph said in Highlanders vs Blues:
@sammyc ?
Scrummaging powerhouse is a bit of an exaggeration
Not when your loosehead prop in previous seasons has been Sam Prattley....
-
Happy enough with the tight five, it's what I would have picked.
The inexperienced loosies are all ok players but the chances of them all adapting to this level quickly are slim. Taramai had a few chances last year and couldn't replicate his NPC form, he needs to improve.
I would have been tempted to start GCT on the blindside and had 2 loosies on the bench.11-14 is good
Collins. Yuck. Maybe he got the nod because in its in Dunedin? But more likely it's just because the coach who cannot be criticised is a retard.
A lot depends on Gatland's form. He was shitty in the warm up matches. Fingers crossed that some of Pulu's passes are accurate.
-
Looks like our usual 4-6 point loss against fellow NZ opposition is coming up to start the season off. Pretty average looking side we've put out with the injuries we have but at the same time it's good to see some North Harbour boys get a go after a good Mitre 10 cup.
-
So ... Nanai. What's his downside?
Must have quite a big downside given he's missing out to a glue player.
@booboo said in Highlanders vs Blues:
So ... Nanai. What's his downside?
Must have quite a big downside given he's missing out to a glue player.
If you read the article it's about communication. Can be pretty key in some setups and you have to balance out what he may do in a possible opportunity against being more organised during most of the game.
As an ex player at top level in 12,13 and 14, T will have strong ideas about what he wants in communication from the back.
Factor in the stress at 10 and I can understand the reasoning. Whether the decision is correct will play out. -
@booboo said in Highlanders vs Blues:
So ... Nanai. What's his downside?
Must have quite a big downside given he's missing out to a glue player.
If you read the article it's about communication. Can be pretty key in some setups and you have to balance out what he may do in a possible opportunity against being more organised during most of the game.
As an ex player at top level in 12,13 and 14, T will have strong ideas about what he wants in communication from the back.
Factor in the stress at 10 and I can understand the reasoning. Whether the decision is correct will play out.@crucial The problem is this exact same approach failed in the NZ derbies last year. Collins lack of athletic ability got exposed in NZ derbies - Blues got away with it against the Aussie teams but not so the NZ derbies.
I just think the balance of the backline is off. Gatland has next to no running threat (he's 3rd string for a reason), SBW and Moala have distribution limitations and Collins is a carthorse at the back. I can't see the two All Black wingers getting the ball in any space.
-
@crucial The problem is this exact same approach failed in the NZ derbies last year. Collins lack of athletic ability got exposed in NZ derbies - Blues got away with it against the Aussie teams but not so the NZ derbies.
I just think the balance of the backline is off. Gatland has next to no running threat (he's 3rd string for a reason), SBW and Moala have distribution limitations and Collins is a carthorse at the back. I can't see the two All Black wingers getting the ball in any space.
Umaga made the same comments about Collins last year and he barely played in pre season. Does that mean he's happy with what he saw last year??
Also Collins is hardly some experienced older head. I think you would get the same attributes from Duffie at the back but with a significant quality upgrade.
Nanai is at his best on the wing where being a ball hog is less of an issue.
-
Umaga made the same comments about Collins last year and he barely played in pre season. Does that mean he's happy with what he saw last year??
Also Collins is hardly some experienced older head. I think you would get the same attributes from Duffie at the back but with a significant quality upgrade.
Nanai is at his best on the wing where being a ball hog is less of an issue.
-
This is a massive game for the Blues. Our competition is basically the battle for 4/5 in the NZ conference. Last year we lost two tight ones; hoping this time to get up and get a win.
Fark me though, it feels too soon for footy. Last year our season was over before the cricket season finished
-
Why did Nanai re-sign with us last year?
Backrow looks underwhelming, but Taramai has had a good pre-season, so hopefully he's due for a better second season.
Rieko and Duffie might have to get their attacking opportunities from kicks.
@duluth said in Highlanders vs Blues:
Fingers crossed that some of Pulu's passes are accurate.
Most fans would want most of their halfback's passes to be accurate, but we just want 'some'.
I could live with some bad passes if he played with tempo.
-
Why did Nanai re-sign with us last year?
Backrow looks underwhelming, but Taramai has had a good pre-season, so hopefully he's due for a better second season.
Rieko and Duffie might have to get their attacking opportunities from kicks.
@duluth said in Highlanders vs Blues:
Fingers crossed that some of Pulu's passes are accurate.
Most fans would want most of their halfback's passes to be accurate, but we just want 'some'.
I could live with some bad passes if he played with tempo.
@dice surely with Pulu, it should be hopefully Pulu simply passes, good bad or otherwise...
-
Lienert-Brown probably shoulda passed
He still would have had plenty of work to do, but I’m with you. I was screaming at em to pass it.
Probably can’t hear me from Tokyo.
-
You know how you don't miss something till it is gone?
The opposite applies to Justin Marshall
