All Blacks v France Test 3
-
@victor-meldrew DMac is a very mixed bag. Two intercepts, some mixed kicking options, poor kick off, plus some great running. Still doesn’t look to setup players outside him but very good at beating defenders.
@kev I think he needs a brick shithouse playing alongside him -SBW (or SWB) is a perfect foil for him - like James Lowe used to be in the Chiefs
-
@kirwan still too many errors for me. I wouldn't want him in the wet or a tight game, against a forward dominant team. Like last week.
@machpants said in All Blacks v France Test 3:
@kirwan still too many errors for me. I wouldn't want him in the wet or a tight game, against a forward dominant team. Like last week.
I still prefer him at fullback, in the old B.B. supersub role
-
@kev I think he needs a brick shithouse playing alongside him -SBW (or SWB) is a perfect foil for him - like James Lowe used to be in the Chiefs
@shadowtrooper agree it’s about balance in a team.
-
@machpants said in All Blacks v France Test 3:
@kirwan still too many errors for me. I wouldn't want him in the wet or a tight game, against a forward dominant team. Like last week.
I still prefer him at fullback, in the old B.B. supersub role
@kirwan said in All Blacks v France Test 3:
@machpants said in All Blacks v France Test 3:
@kirwan still too many errors for me. I wouldn't want him in the wet or a tight game, against a forward dominant team. Like last week.
I still prefer him at fullback, in the old B.B. supersub role
That will be his role , tonight was about getting experience to cover an emergency I reckon
-
@taniwharugby Is Ben Smith still going to be in the team next year?
@tim said in All Blacks v France Test 3:
@taniwharugby Is Ben Smith still going to be in the team next year?
Not based on this series.
-
@victor-meldrew DMac is a very mixed bag. Two intercepts, some mixed kicking options, poor kick off, plus some great running. Still doesn’t look to setup players outside him but very good at beating defenders.
Same thing can be said for BB TBH. But a better kicking option. Considering it's his 1st start at 10, be was pretty good.
-
I would be happy to see Cane and Todd with Akira at 8
-
I would be happy to see Cane and Todd with Akira at 8
@shadowtrooper I'd like to see Cane and Todd with Taufua at 8.
-
@kev said in All Blacks v France Test 3:
@victor-meldrew DMac is a very mixed bag. Two intercepts, some mixed kicking options, poor kick off, plus some great running. Still doesn’t look to setup players outside him but very good at beating defenders.
Cruden was our last 10 who actively looked at setting up players outside him - BB and DMac look to make the break first and then feed (and kick pass for BB) and in general it works!
-
Not bad at all. I'd written off SB before the AB season but he was my MoM today. Hope he can back that up and it's not just one week on one week off.
Have never been much of a Todd fan, but he's good, really good.
I think DMac is potentially a very good 10. He just needs a couple of years playing there every week. Still a bit too scatterbrained, but he's worth sticking with.
-
@machpants said in All Blacks v France Test 3:
@kirwan still too many errors for me. I wouldn't want him in the wet or a tight game, against a forward dominant team. Like last week.
I still prefer him at fullback, in the old B.B. supersub role
@kirwan said in All Blacks v France Test 3:
@machpants said in All Blacks v France Test 3:
@kirwan still too many errors for me. I wouldn't want him in the wet or a tight game, against a forward dominant team. Like last week.
I still prefer him at fullback, in the old B.B. supersub role
Pretty successful series at developing 10 options. Dmac looks the goods in the old BB role and can probably start if needed. With these three playing this well, we are looking much better for 2019.
I think B Smith might have to go to wing for the Landers, and get a bit of form there. I can’t see him keeping Jordie out of 15 all the way to the WC anyway.
-
@stargazer said in All Blacks v France Test 3:
Bloody hell. What a horrendous pass from Naholo.
In the running for worst on ground
@mariner4life said in All Blacks v France Test 3:
@stargazer said in All Blacks v France Test 3:
Bloody hell. What a horrendous pass from Naholo.
In the running for worst on ground
You warming to BFA 14 Jordie 15 yet?
-
I would be happy to see Cane and Todd with Akira at 8
@shadowtrooper said in All Blacks v France Test 3:
I would be happy to see Cane and Todd with Akira at 8
Would get a lot of turnovers.
-
@shadowtrooper I'd like to see Cane and Todd with Taufua at 8.
@stargazer said in All Blacks v France Test 3:
@shadowtrooper I'd like to see Cane and Todd with Taufua at 8.
You hate winning lineouts?
-
@stargazer said in All Blacks v France Test 3:
@shadowtrooper I'd like to see Cane and Todd with Taufua at 8.
You hate winning lineouts?
-
We win people complain, we play with lots out people complain, come on fern sort yourself out!!!!
we have not played for at least year with our first choice team (Lions 1st test?) yet have won.
What did Naholo do for the abuse? for me it shows NMS is maybe never going to wear black again, Naholo D up, he got over the advantage line with ever touch, play didnt go his way a lot but he did what the team asked.
You think with a bit more power back, say BBBR, Squire (Yes), Coles, Read up front I like what we showed. SBW came back and played awesome. Don't think you could ask more from the team that ran out.
For me Barrett p.o.d. Todd showed why he should be in for Savea, SBW best back. Mackenzie played well but evry now and the has a howler but will be better for it. -
@mariner4life I'm assuming big Brodie will be back soon.
@stargazer said in All Blacks v France Test 3:
@mariner4life I'm assuming big Brodie will be back soon.
2 guys doesn't win you test lineouts. Ask Australia for the last 4 years
-
@stargazer said in All Blacks v France Test 3:
Next time more time for Mo'unga, hopefully. This was just good for getting rid of debut nerves. Played well during the little time he got on the field.
I’m no fan of DMac, but Mounga is now firmly in third place on the back of that performance.
-
@stargazer said in All Blacks v France Test 3:
@mariner4life I'm assuming big Brodie will be back soon.
2 guys doesn't win you test lineouts. Ask Australia for the last 4 years
@mariner4life The Crusaders have been using Taufua in the line-out. Their line-out has working very well this season.
