RWC: All Blacks v South Africa (Pool B)
-
@Rapido although a couple of forward passes they got away with made up...one was on one of Colbys electric runs...think was the last few mins they were over the ball for an age and didnt get it.
I know it's hard to look with both eyes open at the time but I think both teams can feel aggrieved/lucky with some calls.
@taniwharugby said in RWC: All Blacks v South Africa (Pool B):
@Rapido although a couple of forward passes they got away with made up...one was on one of Colbys electric runs...think was the last few mins they were over the ball for an age and didnt get it.
I know it's hard to look with both eyes open at the time but I think both teams can feel aggrieved/lucky with some calls.
Yes. My post wasn't an attempt at a list of Garces mistakes. Was an attempt to think of other instances that could have added to NZ penalty count in an otherwise remarkable discipline effort by NZ. Although I did drift into the knockons.
My list in my head of Garces mistakes and missed fouls favouring SAF is longer - but then obviously one of my eyes is bigger than the other.... most already been discussed anyway.
-
@sparky One of the most impressive things in that movement was A Smith line he ran after his pass. He made a direct line to where Reece would likely be if he made a break, turns out he did and Smith was in the perfect place to take a pass and link to Savea. Its those little things that make the difference.
-
Also as mentioned elsewhere aren't all the forwards in front of A Smith offside and have to retreat until Smith puts them onside? They all literally start moving forward after the kick. A Smith in fact never gets in front of the forwards. I must admit I don't know the exact rules but this might be one of those that is ignored in todays game due to all the box kicking?
-
Also as mentioned elsewhere aren't all the forwards in front of A Smith offside and have to retreat until Smith puts them onside? They all literally start moving forward after the kick. A Smith in fact never gets in front of the forwards. I must admit I don't know the exact rules but this might be one of those that is ignored in todays game due to all the box kicking?
@chimoaus said in RWC: All Blacks v South Africa (Pool B):
Also as mentioned elsewhere aren't all the forwards in front of A Smith offside and have to retreat until Smith puts them onside? They all literally start moving forward after the kick. A Smith in fact never gets in front of the forwards. I must admit I don't know the exact rules but this might be one of those that is ignored in todays game due to all the box kicking?
No they are put onside immediately by the blindsided winger and also Read on the openside. It doesn't have to be the kicker that puts them on, just a player who was behind the kicker.
They wouldn't have to retreat anyway, just not move forward (unless they are within 10 m from the line of touch where the ball lands.
-
@sparky One of the most impressive things in that movement was A Smith line he ran after his pass. He made a direct line to where Reece would likely be if he made a break, turns out he did and Smith was in the perfect place to take a pass and link to Savea. Its those little things that make the difference.
@chimoaus said in RWC: All Blacks v South Africa (Pool B):
@sparky One of the most impressive things in that movement was A Smith line he ran after his pass. He made a direct line to where Reece would likely be if he made a break, turns out he did and Smith was in the perfect place to take a pass and link to Savea. Its those little things that make the difference.
Also loved how quickly he unloaded to Ardie. Knows Ardie is the better carrier, but even more, knows he is better off supporting and clearing the ball quickly from the next ruck.
-
Thought Bridge had a pretty ordinary game eh. A couple of nice touches but more ugly moments, including one where he seemed to almost be avoiding attempting to catch a kick. He really shouldn't be being beaten by a midget in the air.
@Bones said in RWC: All Blacks v South Africa (Pool B):
Thought Bridge had a pretty ordinary game eh. A couple of nice touches but more ugly moments, including one where he seemed to almost be avoiding attempting to catch a kick. He really shouldn't be being beaten by a midget in the air.
Really, I thought he was pretty solid. I'll have to rewatch. I love the lines he runs in support, genuine pace and smarts. He's obviously more Howlett than Rokocoko, but I think he did enough to earn his spot for the big dance in the QF
-
@Bones said in RWC: All Blacks v South Africa (Pool B):
Thought Bridge had a pretty ordinary game eh. A couple of nice touches but more ugly moments, including one where he seemed to almost be avoiding attempting to catch a kick. He really shouldn't be being beaten by a midget in the air.
Really, I thought he was pretty solid. I'll have to rewatch. I love the lines he runs in support, genuine pace and smarts. He's obviously more Howlett than Rokocoko, but I think he did enough to earn his spot for the big dance in the QF
@voodoo dont speak too soon we are only 3 typhoons away from missing the 1/4s!
-
@sparky
Top rated comment on that highlight claims Reece's pass to Smith was forward. Dummies don't even know backward from the hand = not forward.@Frank said in RWC: All Blacks v South Africa (Pool B):
@sparky
Top rated comment on that highlight claims Reece's pass to Smith was forward. Dummies don't even know backward from the hand = not forward.Saffas are some of the worst at understanding the forward pass rule in my experience. I think they should all be forced to watch the IRB video before commenting on forward passes in future.
-
Good game? Worth watching a replay?
@mariner4life said in RWC: All Blacks v South Africa (Pool B):
Good game? Worth watching a replay?
Yes. Excellent 2nd 20 mins, final 15 mins, we were tested and came through well
-
@chimoaus said in RWC: All Blacks v South Africa (Pool B):
@sparky One of the most impressive things in that movement was A Smith line he ran after his pass. He made a direct line to where Reece would likely be if he made a break, turns out he did and Smith was in the perfect place to take a pass and link to Savea. Its those little things that make the difference.
Also loved how quickly he unloaded to Ardie. Knows Ardie is the better carrier, but even more, knows he is better off supporting and clearing the ball quickly from the next ruck.
@voodoo said in RWC: All Blacks v South Africa (Pool B):
@chimoaus said in RWC: All Blacks v South Africa (Pool B):
@sparky One of the most impressive things in that movement was A Smith line he ran after his pass. He made a direct line to where Reece would likely be if he made a break, turns out he did and Smith was in the perfect place to take a pass and link to Savea. Its those little things that make the difference.
Also loved how quickly he unloaded to Ardie. Knows Ardie is the better carrier, but even more, knows he is better off supporting and clearing the ball quickly from the next ruck.
I read someone saying Ardie is this rwcs Kaino, that’s pretty high praise
-
https://www.nzherald.co.nz/sport/news/article.cfm?c_id=4&objectid=12269880
Bloody lucky that this stupid rule didn't cost us the game
-
-
@voodoo said in RWC: All Blacks v South Africa (Pool B):
@chimoaus said in RWC: All Blacks v South Africa (Pool B):
@sparky One of the most impressive things in that movement was A Smith line he ran after his pass. He made a direct line to where Reece would likely be if he made a break, turns out he did and Smith was in the perfect place to take a pass and link to Savea. Its those little things that make the difference.
Also loved how quickly he unloaded to Ardie. Knows Ardie is the better carrier, but even more, knows he is better off supporting and clearing the ball quickly from the next ruck.
I read someone saying Ardie is this rwcs Kaino, that’s pretty high praise
@jegga said in RWC: All Blacks v South Africa (Pool B):
@voodoo said in RWC: All Blacks v South Africa (Pool B):
@chimoaus said in RWC: All Blacks v South Africa (Pool B):
@sparky One of the most impressive things in that movement was A Smith line he ran after his pass. He made a direct line to where Reece would likely be if he made a break, turns out he did and Smith was in the perfect place to take a pass and link to Savea. Its those little things that make the difference.
Also loved how quickly he unloaded to Ardie. Knows Ardie is the better carrier, but even more, knows he is better off supporting and clearing the ball quickly from the next ruck.
I read someone saying Ardie is this rwcs Kaino, that’s pretty high praise
He is one of those really frustrating players.
In that, whenever you see him fight for every single inch of ground, with immense leg drive , on every single carry or defensive play, you're reminded how frustrating it is that all our other more gifted athletes don't do the same.
-
I see some are having a moan about the 'disrespect' shown during the Haka by opposition fans.
Fark some people are so precious they need to pull their farking heads in.
It is sport, fans can react how they like.
@taniwharugby said in RWC: All Blacks v South Africa (Pool B):
I see some are having a moan about the 'disrespect' shown during the Haka by opposition fans.
Fark some people are so precious they need to pull their farking heads in.
It is sport, fans can react how they like.
Reactions Update: No singing during the Tongan Sipi Tau, singing before but stopped when it was being done.
-
Hi all,
It’s funny how some things never change, back in the fern for the first time in a long hiatus and all the usual suspects are still active... respect.
Anyhoo tough game and happy to have that out of the way with a win. South Africa were impressive, had arguably the wrong tactics in the first half when they had decent ball, but will happily take that.
Scott Barrett was immense early on and Ardie was a machine and George Bridge reminds me of a young Ben Smith/Cory Jane with his aerial nouse.
For any if the foreign media/coaches complaining about rough calls, clearly Garces missed a lot from both sides, we just converted more of the opportunities we had even with little early ball and am glad the debarkle surrounding Sam Cane HIA didn’t cost us.
Saying all that the Boks weren’t bad when they opened up and Kolbe had fricken spiders on him. If they actually decide to play attacking rugby, we may see them later in the comp.
Great win, still have work ons, which we want including our scum and line out. I know it was extravagant but would love to see them try the move with the throw to Reece again, if executed that would have really created gaps.
Lastly, I had the team leaked via a friend the night before, I called BS but for the first time ever this tip was spot on. It still could have been luck, but if correct they said Retallick could have played if required. Expect to see him back soon then.
Cheers all, thanks for the views, loving it sitting in an airport.
@bayimports welcome back. Does the timing of your return have anything to do with a certain 20+ win against the Taniwha today
-
Thought Bridge had a pretty ordinary game eh. A couple of nice touches but more ugly moments, including one where he seemed to almost be avoiding attempting to catch a kick. He really shouldn't be being beaten by a midget in the air.
@Bones said in RWC: All Blacks v South Africa (Pool B):
Thought Bridge had a pretty ordinary game eh. A couple of nice touches but more ugly moments, including one where he seemed to almost be avoiding attempting to catch a kick. He really shouldn't be being beaten by a midget in the air.
Yeah, we did miss an in form Rieko on the left, he offers a lot more on attack and is as good defensively. Hope they try and play him into some form in the next 3 games.
