Skip to content
  • Categories
Collapse

The Silver Fern

  • Tipping
  • Team Sheets
  • Highlights
  • Results
    • All Blacks

      Search every All Blacks Test. Filter results by year, opposition, location, venue, city and RWC stage

    • Super Rugby

      Search every Super Rugby since match 1996

    • NPC

      Search NPC results. Only first division matches from 1976-2005. All results from the 14 team competition (2006-present) are included

2019 Rugby World Cup

Scheduled Pinned Locked Moved Sports Talk
rwc
1.2k Posts 90 Posters 102.1k Views 6 Watching
  • Oldest to Newest
  • Newest to Oldest
  • Most Votes
Reply
  • Reply as topic
Log in to reply
This topic has been deleted. Only users with topic management privileges can see it.
  • WingerW Winger

    What a complete shambles this has become.

    It makes the RWC organizers look like incompetent fools

    ACT CrusaderA Offline
    ACT CrusaderA Offline
    ACT Crusader
    wrote on last edited by
    #906

    @Winger said in 2019 Rugby World Cup:

    What a complete shambles this has become.

    It makes the RWC organizers look like incompetent fools

    I think the organisers have been v. good.

    1 Reply Last reply
    1
    • taniwharugbyT taniwharugby

      @pukunui some big old sliding fantasy world doors there...in this world, we lose to the Boks and then they lose to Italy?

      Then, our cancelled game v Italy is somehow bankable despite us losing to Boks and them losing to Italy?

      Yea I'd be pissed if it happened to us, but by the same token what else do you do?

      WR have made the call (imo 24 hours too early - what is the 'phoon looking like now?) and unfortunately it is what it is.

      I am surprised the French aren't making more of it, their game was the most pivotal of the 2 canned.

      pukunuiP Offline
      pukunuiP Offline
      pukunui
      wrote on last edited by
      #907

      @dogmeat said in 2019 Rugby World Cup:

      @pukunui I'd say that your multiple scenario's are way out into Fantasy Land.

      For a start you have Italy beating the Boks who have beaten us - OK both those have happened before - perfect storm etc but then us beating the team that beat the team that beat us is a bankable BP win? Bit of a failure of logic there

      @taniwharugby said in 2019 Rugby World Cup:

      @pukunui some big old sliding fantasy world doors there...in this world, we lose to the Boks and then they lose to Italy?

      Then, our cancelled game v Italy is somehow bankable despite us losing to Boks and them losing to Italy?

      Yea I'd be pissed if it happened to us, but by the same token what else do you do?

      WR have made the call (imo 24 hours too early - what is the 'phoon looking like now?) and unfortunately it is what it is.

      I am surprised the French aren't making more of it, their game was the most pivotal of the 2 canned.

      Fantasy? The Boks were tipped by many to beat us in that first game.
      And the Boks have never lost to a lower ranked team then come very close to tipping us out in a RWC before have they? That just wouldn’t happen. Did you guys watch in 2015?

      How about 2016 when Italy DID beat the boks?

      Let me guess, you guys don’t think Ireland are a threat anymore because they got ambushed by Japan a couple of weeks ago.

      And yes ABs vs Italy is always a bankable win.
      To not also secure a BP while doing it with a Quarter final place on the line would be one of the biggest failures in AB history.
      In the 20 years we have only failed to put 40 on them 2 times from 11 games. Both in 2009 with very B grade starting teams. The last two scores have been in the 60’s.

      taniwharugbyT ACT CrusaderA 2 Replies Last reply
      0
      • pukunuiP pukunui

        @dogmeat said in 2019 Rugby World Cup:

        @pukunui I'd say that your multiple scenario's are way out into Fantasy Land.

        For a start you have Italy beating the Boks who have beaten us - OK both those have happened before - perfect storm etc but then us beating the team that beat the team that beat us is a bankable BP win? Bit of a failure of logic there

        @taniwharugby said in 2019 Rugby World Cup:

        @pukunui some big old sliding fantasy world doors there...in this world, we lose to the Boks and then they lose to Italy?

        Then, our cancelled game v Italy is somehow bankable despite us losing to Boks and them losing to Italy?

        Yea I'd be pissed if it happened to us, but by the same token what else do you do?

        WR have made the call (imo 24 hours too early - what is the 'phoon looking like now?) and unfortunately it is what it is.

        I am surprised the French aren't making more of it, their game was the most pivotal of the 2 canned.

        Fantasy? The Boks were tipped by many to beat us in that first game.
        And the Boks have never lost to a lower ranked team then come very close to tipping us out in a RWC before have they? That just wouldn’t happen. Did you guys watch in 2015?

        How about 2016 when Italy DID beat the boks?

        Let me guess, you guys don’t think Ireland are a threat anymore because they got ambushed by Japan a couple of weeks ago.

        And yes ABs vs Italy is always a bankable win.
        To not also secure a BP while doing it with a Quarter final place on the line would be one of the biggest failures in AB history.
        In the 20 years we have only failed to put 40 on them 2 times from 11 games. Both in 2009 with very B grade starting teams. The last two scores have been in the 60’s.

        taniwharugbyT Offline
        taniwharugbyT Offline
        taniwharugby
        wrote on last edited by
        #908

        @pukunui newsflash...we beat SA and they thumped Italy.

        So no need to worry about your fantasy world where we lost to SA then they turn around and lose to Italy.

        In the real world, yes Italy was a 5 points guaranteed (Parisse says I am disrespecting Italy) but I was talking about your fantasy world where Italy were on fire after beating a Bok side that rolled us.

        pukunuiP SammyCS 2 Replies Last reply
        1
        • SnowyS Snowy

          @taniwharugby As would we be, which was the point. I think. Maybe...

          pukunuiP Offline
          pukunuiP Offline
          pukunui
          wrote on last edited by
          #909

          @Snowy said in 2019 Rugby World Cup:

          @taniwharugby As would we be, which was the point. I think. Maybe...

          Umm yeah i think that was the point. Can’t remember now. Too busy arguing about hypothetical situations.

          1 Reply Last reply
          1
          • jeggaJ jegga

            @pukunui said in 2019 Rugby World Cup:

            I wonder if people would be as ok with this situation if it was the ABs being knocked out because they didn’t get to play the last game.

            Eg. We lose the first game against boks by 8.
            Italy then beats Boks. Assuming everyone picks up BP wins over Canada and Namibia. Then what should have been a pretty bankable BP win against Italy to get into the Quarters is declared a draw instead.
            Bye bye Two time defending champs.
            This place would go into meltdown.

            That scenario isn’t out of the rhelms of possibly. Not like, you know, a typhoon during typhoon season. That would never happen.

            Realms

            Also if we were that shit I’d be stoked that our rwc ended early .

            pukunuiP Offline
            pukunuiP Offline
            pukunui
            wrote on last edited by
            #910

            @jegga said in 2019 Rugby World Cup:

            @pukunui said in 2019 Rugby World Cup:

            I wonder if people would be as ok with this situation if it was the ABs being knocked out because they didn’t get to play the last game.

            Eg. We lose the first game against boks by 8.
            Italy then beats Boks. Assuming everyone picks up BP wins over Canada and Namibia. Then what should have been a pretty bankable BP win against Italy to get into the Quarters is declared a draw instead.
            Bye bye Two time defending champs.
            This place would go into meltdown.

            That scenario isn’t out of the rhelms of possibly. Not like, you know, a typhoon during typhoon season. That would never happen.

            Realms

            Also if we were that shit I’d be stoked that our rwc ended early .

            “That shit” as in we lost a pool game to the Boks? Doesn’t take much of a slide to have that happen. Plenty were predicting it.

            jeggaJ 1 Reply Last reply
            0
            • pukunuiP pukunui

              @dogmeat said in 2019 Rugby World Cup:

              @pukunui I'd say that your multiple scenario's are way out into Fantasy Land.

              For a start you have Italy beating the Boks who have beaten us - OK both those have happened before - perfect storm etc but then us beating the team that beat the team that beat us is a bankable BP win? Bit of a failure of logic there

              @taniwharugby said in 2019 Rugby World Cup:

              @pukunui some big old sliding fantasy world doors there...in this world, we lose to the Boks and then they lose to Italy?

              Then, our cancelled game v Italy is somehow bankable despite us losing to Boks and them losing to Italy?

              Yea I'd be pissed if it happened to us, but by the same token what else do you do?

              WR have made the call (imo 24 hours too early - what is the 'phoon looking like now?) and unfortunately it is what it is.

              I am surprised the French aren't making more of it, their game was the most pivotal of the 2 canned.

              Fantasy? The Boks were tipped by many to beat us in that first game.
              And the Boks have never lost to a lower ranked team then come very close to tipping us out in a RWC before have they? That just wouldn’t happen. Did you guys watch in 2015?

              How about 2016 when Italy DID beat the boks?

              Let me guess, you guys don’t think Ireland are a threat anymore because they got ambushed by Japan a couple of weeks ago.

              And yes ABs vs Italy is always a bankable win.
              To not also secure a BP while doing it with a Quarter final place on the line would be one of the biggest failures in AB history.
              In the 20 years we have only failed to put 40 on them 2 times from 11 games. Both in 2009 with very B grade starting teams. The last two scores have been in the 60’s.

              ACT CrusaderA Offline
              ACT CrusaderA Offline
              ACT Crusader
              wrote on last edited by
              #911

              @pukunui likewise the ABs were tipped by many to win that as well. Dry powder and all that. Two new wingers and a more settled back row.

              pukunuiP 1 Reply Last reply
              1
              • taniwharugbyT taniwharugby

                @pukunui newsflash...we beat SA and they thumped Italy.

                So no need to worry about your fantasy world where we lost to SA then they turn around and lose to Italy.

                In the real world, yes Italy was a 5 points guaranteed (Parisse says I am disrespecting Italy) but I was talking about your fantasy world where Italy were on fire after beating a Bok side that rolled us.

                pukunuiP Offline
                pukunuiP Offline
                pukunui
                wrote on last edited by
                #912

                @taniwharugby said in 2019 Rugby World Cup:

                @pukunui newsflash...we beat SA and they thumped Italy.

                So no need to worry about your fantasy world where we lost to SA then they turn around and lose to Italy.

                In the real world, yes Italy was a 5 points guaranteed (Parisse says I am disrespecting Italy) but I was talking about your fantasy world where Italy were on fire after beating a Bok side that rolled us.

                I get that. But i hate it when people have a whinge about something only when it screws them over but are ok with it if it is someone else. This situation should never have happened in the first place.

                And again back in hypothetical land. I would never put it past the Boks to play well against us then be utter shit the next week against someone else. They do that every year in TRC.

                1 Reply Last reply
                1
                • taniwharugbyT taniwharugby

                  @pukunui newsflash...we beat SA and they thumped Italy.

                  So no need to worry about your fantasy world where we lost to SA then they turn around and lose to Italy.

                  In the real world, yes Italy was a 5 points guaranteed (Parisse says I am disrespecting Italy) but I was talking about your fantasy world where Italy were on fire after beating a Bok side that rolled us.

                  SammyCS Offline
                  SammyCS Offline
                  SammyC
                  wrote on last edited by
                  #913

                  @taniwharugby said in 2019 Rugby World Cup:

                  @pukunui newsflash...we beat SA and they thumped Italy.

                  So no need to worry about your fantasy world where we lost to SA then they turn around and lose to Italy.

                  In the real world, yes Italy was a 5 points guaranteed (Parisse says I am disrespecting Italy) but I was talking about your fantasy world where Italy were on fire after beating a Bok side that rolled us.

                  Exactly!

                  Don’t worry about it, it was never going to happen.

                  Apparently people are going to die as a result of this typhoon. Rugby is just a game.

                  1 Reply Last reply
                  7
                  • pukunuiP pukunui

                    @jegga said in 2019 Rugby World Cup:

                    @pukunui said in 2019 Rugby World Cup:

                    I wonder if people would be as ok with this situation if it was the ABs being knocked out because they didn’t get to play the last game.

                    Eg. We lose the first game against boks by 8.
                    Italy then beats Boks. Assuming everyone picks up BP wins over Canada and Namibia. Then what should have been a pretty bankable BP win against Italy to get into the Quarters is declared a draw instead.
                    Bye bye Two time defending champs.
                    This place would go into meltdown.

                    That scenario isn’t out of the rhelms of possibly. Not like, you know, a typhoon during typhoon season. That would never happen.

                    Realms

                    Also if we were that shit I’d be stoked that our rwc ended early .

                    “That shit” as in we lost a pool game to the Boks? Doesn’t take much of a slide to have that happen. Plenty were predicting it.

                    jeggaJ Offline
                    jeggaJ Offline
                    jegga
                    wrote on last edited by
                    #914

                    @pukunui said in 2019 Rugby World Cup:

                    @jegga said in 2019 Rugby World Cup:

                    @pukunui said in 2019 Rugby World Cup:

                    I wonder if people would be as ok with this situation if it was the ABs being knocked out because they didn’t get to play the last game.

                    Eg. We lose the first game against boks by 8.
                    Italy then beats Boks. Assuming everyone picks up BP wins over Canada and Namibia. Then what should have been a pretty bankable BP win against Italy to get into the Quarters is declared a draw instead.
                    Bye bye Two time defending champs.
                    This place would go into meltdown.

                    That scenario isn’t out of the rhelms of possibly. Not like, you know, a typhoon during typhoon season. That would never happen.

                    Realms

                    Also if we were that shit I’d be stoked that our rwc ended early .

                    “That shit” as in we lost a pool game to the Boks? Doesn’t take much of a slide to have that happen. Plenty were predicting it.

                    Who was predicting it?

                    pukunuiP 1 Reply Last reply
                    0
                    • ACT CrusaderA ACT Crusader

                      @pukunui likewise the ABs were tipped by many to win that as well. Dry powder and all that. Two new wingers and a more settled back row.

                      pukunuiP Offline
                      pukunuiP Offline
                      pukunui
                      wrote on last edited by
                      #915

                      @ACT-Crusader said in 2019 Rugby World Cup:

                      @pukunui likewise the ABs were tipped by many to win that as well. Dry powder and all that. Two new wingers and a more settled back row.

                      And? That doesn’t mean that the Boks had no chance of beating us. The results between us over the last few years have been bloody close.

                      1 Reply Last reply
                      0
                      • jeggaJ jegga

                        @pukunui said in 2019 Rugby World Cup:

                        @jegga said in 2019 Rugby World Cup:

                        @pukunui said in 2019 Rugby World Cup:

                        I wonder if people would be as ok with this situation if it was the ABs being knocked out because they didn’t get to play the last game.

                        Eg. We lose the first game against boks by 8.
                        Italy then beats Boks. Assuming everyone picks up BP wins over Canada and Namibia. Then what should have been a pretty bankable BP win against Italy to get into the Quarters is declared a draw instead.
                        Bye bye Two time defending champs.
                        This place would go into meltdown.

                        That scenario isn’t out of the rhelms of possibly. Not like, you know, a typhoon during typhoon season. That would never happen.

                        Realms

                        Also if we were that shit I’d be stoked that our rwc ended early .

                        “That shit” as in we lost a pool game to the Boks? Doesn’t take much of a slide to have that happen. Plenty were predicting it.

                        Who was predicting it?

                        pukunuiP Offline
                        pukunuiP Offline
                        pukunui
                        wrote on last edited by
                        #916

                        @jegga said in 2019 Rugby World Cup:

                        @pukunui said in 2019 Rugby World Cup:

                        @jegga said in 2019 Rugby World Cup:

                        @pukunui said in 2019 Rugby World Cup:

                        I wonder if people would be as ok with this situation if it was the ABs being knocked out because they didn’t get to play the last game.

                        Eg. We lose the first game against boks by 8.
                        Italy then beats Boks. Assuming everyone picks up BP wins over Canada and Namibia. Then what should have been a pretty bankable BP win against Italy to get into the Quarters is declared a draw instead.
                        Bye bye Two time defending champs.
                        This place would go into meltdown.

                        That scenario isn’t out of the rhelms of possibly. Not like, you know, a typhoon during typhoon season. That would never happen.

                        Realms

                        Also if we were that shit I’d be stoked that our rwc ended early .

                        “That shit” as in we lost a pool game to the Boks? Doesn’t take much of a slide to have that happen. Plenty were predicting it.

                        Who was predicting it?

                        The whole Northern hemisphere rugby media for one. Our last game against them was a draw.
                        Some very short memories on this thread.

                        jeggaJ ACT CrusaderA 2 Replies Last reply
                        2
                        • M Offline
                          M Offline
                          Machpants
                          wrote on last edited by Machpants
                          #917

                          An interesting point, na throw away line in the Torygraph, was that 'preparations to move the England France game were well underway' when it was realised it was going to have to be two, possibly three, games moved. That was impossible. So to make it consistent they canned them both, and have no contingency for the third. So I guess the much vaunted contingency plans talked about pre cup, if this article is correct, only really covered one game getting into trouble.

                          antipodeanA 1 Reply Last reply
                          0
                          • pukunuiP pukunui

                            @jegga said in 2019 Rugby World Cup:

                            @pukunui said in 2019 Rugby World Cup:

                            @jegga said in 2019 Rugby World Cup:

                            @pukunui said in 2019 Rugby World Cup:

                            I wonder if people would be as ok with this situation if it was the ABs being knocked out because they didn’t get to play the last game.

                            Eg. We lose the first game against boks by 8.
                            Italy then beats Boks. Assuming everyone picks up BP wins over Canada and Namibia. Then what should have been a pretty bankable BP win against Italy to get into the Quarters is declared a draw instead.
                            Bye bye Two time defending champs.
                            This place would go into meltdown.

                            That scenario isn’t out of the rhelms of possibly. Not like, you know, a typhoon during typhoon season. That would never happen.

                            Realms

                            Also if we were that shit I’d be stoked that our rwc ended early .

                            “That shit” as in we lost a pool game to the Boks? Doesn’t take much of a slide to have that happen. Plenty were predicting it.

                            Who was predicting it?

                            The whole Northern hemisphere rugby media for one. Our last game against them was a draw.
                            Some very short memories on this thread.

                            jeggaJ Offline
                            jeggaJ Offline
                            jegga
                            wrote on last edited by
                            #918

                            @pukunui said in 2019 Rugby World Cup:

                            @jegga said in 2019 Rugby World Cup:

                            @pukunui said in 2019 Rugby World Cup:

                            @jegga said in 2019 Rugby World Cup:

                            @pukunui said in 2019 Rugby World Cup:

                            I wonder if people would be as ok with this situation if it was the ABs being knocked out because they didn’t get to play the last game.

                            Eg. We lose the first game against boks by 8.
                            Italy then beats Boks. Assuming everyone picks up BP wins over Canada and Namibia. Then what should have been a pretty bankable BP win against Italy to get into the Quarters is declared a draw instead.
                            Bye bye Two time defending champs.
                            This place would go into meltdown.

                            That scenario isn’t out of the rhelms of possibly. Not like, you know, a typhoon during typhoon season. That would never happen.

                            Realms

                            Also if we were that shit I’d be stoked that our rwc ended early .

                            “That shit” as in we lost a pool game to the Boks? Doesn’t take much of a slide to have that happen. Plenty were predicting it.

                            Who was predicting it?

                            The whole Northern hemisphere rugby media for one. Our last game against them was a draw.
                            Some very short memories on this thread.

                            Ah. For a minute there I thought you meant people who’s opinions were actually worth something.

                            pukunuiP 1 Reply Last reply
                            0
                            • jeggaJ jegga

                              @pukunui said in 2019 Rugby World Cup:

                              @jegga said in 2019 Rugby World Cup:

                              @pukunui said in 2019 Rugby World Cup:

                              @jegga said in 2019 Rugby World Cup:

                              @pukunui said in 2019 Rugby World Cup:

                              I wonder if people would be as ok with this situation if it was the ABs being knocked out because they didn’t get to play the last game.

                              Eg. We lose the first game against boks by 8.
                              Italy then beats Boks. Assuming everyone picks up BP wins over Canada and Namibia. Then what should have been a pretty bankable BP win against Italy to get into the Quarters is declared a draw instead.
                              Bye bye Two time defending champs.
                              This place would go into meltdown.

                              That scenario isn’t out of the rhelms of possibly. Not like, you know, a typhoon during typhoon season. That would never happen.

                              Realms

                              Also if we were that shit I’d be stoked that our rwc ended early .

                              “That shit” as in we lost a pool game to the Boks? Doesn’t take much of a slide to have that happen. Plenty were predicting it.

                              Who was predicting it?

                              The whole Northern hemisphere rugby media for one. Our last game against them was a draw.
                              Some very short memories on this thread.

                              Ah. For a minute there I thought you meant people who’s opinions were actually worth something.

                              pukunuiP Offline
                              pukunuiP Offline
                              pukunui
                              wrote on last edited by
                              #919

                              @jegga said in 2019 Rugby World Cup:

                              @pukunui said in 2019 Rugby World Cup:

                              @jegga said in 2019 Rugby World Cup:

                              @pukunui said in 2019 Rugby World Cup:

                              @jegga said in 2019 Rugby World Cup:

                              @pukunui said in 2019 Rugby World Cup:

                              I wonder if people would be as ok with this situation if it was the ABs being knocked out because they didn’t get to play the last game.

                              Eg. We lose the first game against boks by 8.
                              Italy then beats Boks. Assuming everyone picks up BP wins over Canada and Namibia. Then what should have been a pretty bankable BP win against Italy to get into the Quarters is declared a draw instead.
                              Bye bye Two time defending champs.
                              This place would go into meltdown.

                              That scenario isn’t out of the rhelms of possibly. Not like, you know, a typhoon during typhoon season. That would never happen.

                              Realms

                              Also if we were that shit I’d be stoked that our rwc ended early .

                              “That shit” as in we lost a pool game to the Boks? Doesn’t take much of a slide to have that happen. Plenty were predicting it.

                              Who was predicting it?

                              The whole Northern hemisphere rugby media for one. Our last game against them was a draw.
                              Some very short memories on this thread.

                              Ah. For a minute there I thought you meant people who’s opinions were actually worth something.

                              Maybe predicting wasn’t the right word for them. “Hoping like hell” would probably be more appropriate.

                              1 Reply Last reply
                              1
                              • pukunuiP pukunui

                                @jegga said in 2019 Rugby World Cup:

                                @pukunui said in 2019 Rugby World Cup:

                                @jegga said in 2019 Rugby World Cup:

                                @pukunui said in 2019 Rugby World Cup:

                                I wonder if people would be as ok with this situation if it was the ABs being knocked out because they didn’t get to play the last game.

                                Eg. We lose the first game against boks by 8.
                                Italy then beats Boks. Assuming everyone picks up BP wins over Canada and Namibia. Then what should have been a pretty bankable BP win against Italy to get into the Quarters is declared a draw instead.
                                Bye bye Two time defending champs.
                                This place would go into meltdown.

                                That scenario isn’t out of the rhelms of possibly. Not like, you know, a typhoon during typhoon season. That would never happen.

                                Realms

                                Also if we were that shit I’d be stoked that our rwc ended early .

                                “That shit” as in we lost a pool game to the Boks? Doesn’t take much of a slide to have that happen. Plenty were predicting it.

                                Who was predicting it?

                                The whole Northern hemisphere rugby media for one. Our last game against them was a draw.
                                Some very short memories on this thread.

                                ACT CrusaderA Offline
                                ACT CrusaderA Offline
                                ACT Crusader
                                wrote on last edited by
                                #920

                                @pukunui said in 2019 Rugby World Cup:

                                @jegga said in 2019 Rugby World Cup:

                                @pukunui said in 2019 Rugby World Cup:

                                @jegga said in 2019 Rugby World Cup:

                                @pukunui said in 2019 Rugby World Cup:

                                I wonder if people would be as ok with this situation if it was the ABs being knocked out because they didn’t get to play the last game.

                                Eg. We lose the first game against boks by 8.
                                Italy then beats Boks. Assuming everyone picks up BP wins over Canada and Namibia. Then what should have been a pretty bankable BP win against Italy to get into the Quarters is declared a draw instead.
                                Bye bye Two time defending champs.
                                This place would go into meltdown.

                                That scenario isn’t out of the rhelms of possibly. Not like, you know, a typhoon during typhoon season. That would never happen.

                                Realms

                                Also if we were that shit I’d be stoked that our rwc ended early .

                                “That shit” as in we lost a pool game to the Boks? Doesn’t take much of a slide to have that happen. Plenty were predicting it.

                                Who was predicting it?

                                The whole Northern hemisphere rugby media for one. Our last game against them was a draw.
                                Some very short memories on this thread.

                                Don’t think the memories are short, just questioning your theory/predictions.

                                pukunuiP 1 Reply Last reply
                                1
                                • M Machpants

                                  An interesting point, na throw away line in the Torygraph, was that 'preparations to move the England France game were well underway' when it was realised it was going to have to be two, possibly three, games moved. That was impossible. So to make it consistent they canned them both, and have no contingency for the third. So I guess the much vaunted contingency plans talked about pre cup, if this article is correct, only really covered one game getting into trouble.

                                  antipodeanA Online
                                  antipodeanA Online
                                  antipodean
                                  wrote on last edited by
                                  #921

                                  @Machpants said in 2019 Rugby World Cup:

                                  An interesting point, na throw away line in the Torygraph, was that 'preparations to move the England France game were well underway' when it was realised it was going to have to be two, possibly three, games moved. That was impossible. So to make it consistent they canned them both, and have no contingency for the third. So I guess the much vaunted contingency plans talked about pre cup, if this article is correct, only really covered one game getting into trouble.

                                  Which makes sense because I challenge anyone to develop a scenario to fix this weekend's problems.

                                  taniwharugbyT jeggaJ pukunuiP 3 Replies Last reply
                                  0
                                  • antipodeanA antipodean

                                    @Machpants said in 2019 Rugby World Cup:

                                    An interesting point, na throw away line in the Torygraph, was that 'preparations to move the England France game were well underway' when it was realised it was going to have to be two, possibly three, games moved. That was impossible. So to make it consistent they canned them both, and have no contingency for the third. So I guess the much vaunted contingency plans talked about pre cup, if this article is correct, only really covered one game getting into trouble.

                                    Which makes sense because I challenge anyone to develop a scenario to fix this weekend's problems.

                                    taniwharugbyT Offline
                                    taniwharugbyT Offline
                                    taniwharugby
                                    wrote on last edited by
                                    #922

                                    @antipodean Brodie wades out and scares the bejeebus out of Hagibis!!

                                    nzzpN 1 Reply Last reply
                                    2
                                    • antipodeanA antipodean

                                      @Machpants said in 2019 Rugby World Cup:

                                      An interesting point, na throw away line in the Torygraph, was that 'preparations to move the England France game were well underway' when it was realised it was going to have to be two, possibly three, games moved. That was impossible. So to make it consistent they canned them both, and have no contingency for the third. So I guess the much vaunted contingency plans talked about pre cup, if this article is correct, only really covered one game getting into trouble.

                                      Which makes sense because I challenge anyone to develop a scenario to fix this weekend's problems.

                                      jeggaJ Offline
                                      jeggaJ Offline
                                      jegga
                                      wrote on last edited by
                                      #923

                                      @antipodean said in 2019 Rugby World Cup:

                                      @Machpants said in 2019 Rugby World Cup:

                                      An interesting point, na throw away line in the Torygraph, was that 'preparations to move the England France game were well underway' when it was realised it was going to have to be two, possibly three, games moved. That was impossible. So to make it consistent they canned them both, and have no contingency for the third. So I guess the much vaunted contingency plans talked about pre cup, if this article is correct, only really covered one game getting into trouble.

                                      Which makes sense because I challenge anyone to develop a scenario to fix this weekend's problems.

                                      Yeah it’s easy for the internet experts to proclaim they could do better, this is the worst possible result for wr and I doubt it was an easy call to make

                                      1 Reply Last reply
                                      4
                                      • ACT CrusaderA ACT Crusader

                                        @pukunui said in 2019 Rugby World Cup:

                                        @jegga said in 2019 Rugby World Cup:

                                        @pukunui said in 2019 Rugby World Cup:

                                        @jegga said in 2019 Rugby World Cup:

                                        @pukunui said in 2019 Rugby World Cup:

                                        I wonder if people would be as ok with this situation if it was the ABs being knocked out because they didn’t get to play the last game.

                                        Eg. We lose the first game against boks by 8.
                                        Italy then beats Boks. Assuming everyone picks up BP wins over Canada and Namibia. Then what should have been a pretty bankable BP win against Italy to get into the Quarters is declared a draw instead.
                                        Bye bye Two time defending champs.
                                        This place would go into meltdown.

                                        That scenario isn’t out of the rhelms of possibly. Not like, you know, a typhoon during typhoon season. That would never happen.

                                        Realms

                                        Also if we were that shit I’d be stoked that our rwc ended early .

                                        “That shit” as in we lost a pool game to the Boks? Doesn’t take much of a slide to have that happen. Plenty were predicting it.

                                        Who was predicting it?

                                        The whole Northern hemisphere rugby media for one. Our last game against them was a draw.
                                        Some very short memories on this thread.

                                        Don’t think the memories are short, just questioning your theory/predictions.

                                        pukunuiP Offline
                                        pukunuiP Offline
                                        pukunui
                                        wrote on last edited by
                                        #924

                                        @ACT-Crusader said in 2019 Rugby World Cup:

                                        @pukunui said in 2019 Rugby World Cup:

                                        @jegga said in 2019 Rugby World Cup:

                                        @pukunui said in 2019 Rugby World Cup:

                                        @jegga said in 2019 Rugby World Cup:

                                        @pukunui said in 2019 Rugby World Cup:

                                        I wonder if people would be as ok with this situation if it was the ABs being knocked out because they didn’t get to play the last game.

                                        Eg. We lose the first game against boks by 8.
                                        Italy then beats Boks. Assuming everyone picks up BP wins over Canada and Namibia. Then what should have been a pretty bankable BP win against Italy to get into the Quarters is declared a draw instead.
                                        Bye bye Two time defending champs.
                                        This place would go into meltdown.

                                        That scenario isn’t out of the rhelms of possibly. Not like, you know, a typhoon during typhoon season. That would never happen.

                                        Realms

                                        Also if we were that shit I’d be stoked that our rwc ended early .

                                        “That shit” as in we lost a pool game to the Boks? Doesn’t take much of a slide to have that happen. Plenty were predicting it.

                                        Who was predicting it?

                                        The whole Northern hemisphere rugby media for one. Our last game against them was a draw.
                                        Some very short memories on this thread.

                                        Don’t think the memories are short, just questioning your theory/predictions.

                                        Ok, one last time.

                                        • Boks beating us in the first game. Not unthinkable. We drew this year, they also beat us last year.

                                        • Boks then losing to Italy. Also not unthinkable but less likely. Boks lost to Japan at the last RWC, they then ran us to within a penalty in the Semi. They also lost to Italy in 2016.

                                        • ABs vs Italy being canned for weather. Instead of being any easy BP win for ABs. Look at the stats i posted. The less likely outcome would be if the ABs missed out on a BP given their record over last 20 years.

                                        Im not making these points to give sympathy to italy.
                                        Im saying there would be MUCH more outrage if we were put in the position Scotland could find themselves in. It is hypocritical to say meh just because someone else is getting fucked THIS TIME.

                                        antipodeanA 1 Reply Last reply
                                        2
                                        • antipodeanA antipodean

                                          @Machpants said in 2019 Rugby World Cup:

                                          An interesting point, na throw away line in the Torygraph, was that 'preparations to move the England France game were well underway' when it was realised it was going to have to be two, possibly three, games moved. That was impossible. So to make it consistent they canned them both, and have no contingency for the third. So I guess the much vaunted contingency plans talked about pre cup, if this article is correct, only really covered one game getting into trouble.

                                          Which makes sense because I challenge anyone to develop a scenario to fix this weekend's problems.

                                          pukunuiP Offline
                                          pukunuiP Offline
                                          pukunui
                                          wrote on last edited by
                                          #925

                                          @antipodean said in 2019 Rugby World Cup:

                                          @Machpants said in 2019 Rugby World Cup:

                                          An interesting point, na throw away line in the Torygraph, was that 'preparations to move the England France game were well underway' when it was realised it was going to have to be two, possibly three, games moved. That was impossible. So to make it consistent they canned them both, and have no contingency for the third. So I guess the much vaunted contingency plans talked about pre cup, if this article is correct, only really covered one game getting into trouble.

                                          Which makes sense because I challenge anyone to develop a scenario to fix this weekend's problems.

                                          Play the next day? Change venue a couple of days in advance? Extend the group stages by a week to allow for reserve days (before it starts obviously)?
                                          There are plenty of options. They chose to just cancel games instead.

                                          Now we are hearing about some sort of contingency plans despite it being written in the rules that they can’t play on a different day.

                                          antipodeanA jeggaJ 2 Replies Last reply
                                          1
                                          Reply
                                          • Reply as topic
                                          Log in to reply
                                          • Oldest to Newest
                                          • Newest to Oldest
                                          • Most Votes


                                          • Login

                                          • Don't have an account? Register

                                          • Search
                                          • First post
                                            Last post
                                          0
                                          • Categories
                                          • Search