'Super Rugby' 2021
-
I also don't get the ARU position.
They have 4 teams, currently, not 5.
Surely, from the 2 CEOs perspective - it's a case of comparing the 2 TV deals. Working out how many teams each can support with that money to create competive squads against each other, and competitive salaries against prospective NH deals.
I'm not thrilled that this is where it is at (still only 5 NZ teams and having to join with Australia). But diluting it with 2 weak Australian teams in expansion cities will be awful.
Honestly. Who can possibly go for war for a team call "Western" with nickname called "Force" who wear the same kit as 2 of the other 9 definites. Get the fuck out you bland fluffybunnies.
@Rapido said in 'Super Rugby' 2021:
I also don't get the ARU position.
They have 4 teams, currently, not 5.
Surely, from the 2 CEOs perspective - it's a case of comparing the 2 TV deals. Working out how many teams each can support with that money to create competive squads against each other, and competitive salaries against prospective NH deals.
I'm not thrilled that this is where it is at (still only 5 NZ teams and having to join with Australia). But diluting it with 2 weak Australian teams in expansion cities will be awful.
Honestly. Who can possibly go for war for a team call "Western" with nickname called "Force" who wear the same kit as 2 of the other 9 definites. Get the fuck out you bland fluffybunnies.
I can see why the Aussies want 5 sides.
Their broadcast deal is so low that they want 5 teams to at least keep up a national presence and so they can have content to sell to the broadcaster.
Otherwise they might as well go it alone with their own domestic comp.
Arguably the Force have the best fanbase of all the Aussie teams.
-
if RA are so adamant they have five good team then lets run two separate comps and the top 2 teams from each can meet in a playoff series, see how the results and their finances go
-
This from Wayne Smith this morning in the Australian:
The Pumas appear to be deserting in droves to French clubs but reports that SA rugby could relocate its interests to the northern hemisphere appear to be wildly incorrect. SA rugby could take the form of a beefed-up Currie Cup but it is understood that private equity fund CVC could be pursuing the Springboks as it has done the Six Nations and the Premiership in England.
Private equity is set to also play a huge role in Australian rugby in the future, with Silver Lake and US fund Providence both circling the game, but there is little doubt that the most highly valued competition would involve five teams each from Australia and NZ. In that way, administrators from both nations would be able to alleviate their funding issues without needing to sell the farm.
There are a lot of “ifs’ in RA plans but officials also believe massive opportunities are starting to open up. If they are able to secure the Super Rugby competition format they are hoping for, plus a private equity deal and a reasonable deal with broadcasters – who also have stipulated they see a trans- Ta$man series as the only viable option – then it could be that rugby gets back in the game.
Understandably, RA does not want to go through the same turmoil it experienced in 2017 when it culled the Force from Super Rugby. The Rebels were the other team facing the axe then but, with McLennan now committed to Forrest and the Perth club, Melbourne would be prime targets if RA decided to revisit dumping a team.
But that won’t happen, for a variety of reasons. Not least is the massive support the Victorian government gives to rugby and the important role it would play in a 2027 World Cup in Australia.
Given that NSW and Queensland are “untouchable”, that only leaves the Brumbies which are understood to be at the top of the list of Australian teams wanted by New Zealand.
-
if RA are so adamant they have five good team then lets run two separate comps and the top 2 teams from each can meet in a playoff series, see how the results and their finances go
@Kiwiwomble said in 'Super Rugby' 2021:
if RA are so adamant they have five good team then lets run two separate comps and the top 2 teams from each can meet in a playoff series, see how the results and their finances go
That works for me. I won't bother with much of the Aussie comp though.
Probably the three good teams.
-
@Kiwiwomble said in 'Super Rugby' 2021:
if RA are so adamant they have five good team then lets run two separate comps and the top 2 teams from each can meet in a playoff series, see how the results and their finances go
That works for me. I won't bother with much of the Aussie comp though.
Probably the three good teams.
@Snowy said in 'Super Rugby' 2021:
@Kiwiwomble said in 'Super Rugby' 2021:
if RA are so adamant they have five good team then lets run two separate comps and the top 2 teams from each can meet in a playoff series, see how the results and their finances go
That works for me. I won't bother with much of the Aussie comp though.
Probably the three good teams.
only real down side for me personally would be how unlikely it would be for the highlanders and rebels to meeting in melbourne...
-
This from Wayne Smith this morning in the Australian:
The Pumas appear to be deserting in droves to French clubs but reports that SA rugby could relocate its interests to the northern hemisphere appear to be wildly incorrect. SA rugby could take the form of a beefed-up Currie Cup but it is understood that private equity fund CVC could be pursuing the Springboks as it has done the Six Nations and the Premiership in England.
Private equity is set to also play a huge role in Australian rugby in the future, with Silver Lake and US fund Providence both circling the game, but there is little doubt that the most highly valued competition would involve five teams each from Australia and NZ. In that way, administrators from both nations would be able to alleviate their funding issues without needing to sell the farm.
There are a lot of “ifs’ in RA plans but officials also believe massive opportunities are starting to open up. If they are able to secure the Super Rugby competition format they are hoping for, plus a private equity deal and a reasonable deal with broadcasters – who also have stipulated they see a trans- Ta$man series as the only viable option – then it could be that rugby gets back in the game.
Understandably, RA does not want to go through the same turmoil it experienced in 2017 when it culled the Force from Super Rugby. The Rebels were the other team facing the axe then but, with McLennan now committed to Forrest and the Perth club, Melbourne would be prime targets if RA decided to revisit dumping a team.
But that won’t happen, for a variety of reasons. Not least is the massive support the Victorian government gives to rugby and the important role it would play in a 2027 World Cup in Australia.
Given that NSW and Queensland are “untouchable”, that only leaves the Brumbies which are understood to be at the top of the list of Australian teams wanted by New Zealand.
@barbarian said in 'Super Rugby' 2021:
Understandably, RA does not want to go through the same turmoil it experienced in 2017 when it culled the Force from Super Rugby.
Then they should stop trying to add shit teams. FFS.
-
if RA are so adamant they have five good team then lets run two separate comps and the top 2 teams from each can meet in a playoff series, see how the results and their finances go
@Kiwiwomble said in 'Super Rugby' 2021:
if RA are so adamant they have five good team then lets run two separate comps and the top 2 teams from each can meet in a playoff series, see how the results and their finances go
That would be awesome.
Best rugby-wise for me.
Would be an 8 team NZ comp, 8 team Aus comp, 8 team Saf comp, 8 team South American comp (SLAR)
7 home an away games, plus local playoffs.
Top 2, or Top 1, from each meet in Super Rugby Champions League (in one location, say Perth, or rotating each year). SLAR teams would get smashed, I don't care as long as the comp is mathematically balanced and genuine. They would last 1 match and be knocked out.
In real world. Where money counts.
NZRU angling for 8 team Trans- Ta$man comp, hoping to join with Japan for a Pacific Champions League. -
@barbarian said in 'Super Rugby' 2021:
Understandably, RA does not want to go through the same turmoil it experienced in 2017 when it culled the Force from Super Rugby.
Then they should stop trying to add shit teams. FFS.
@Snowy said in 'Super Rugby' 2021:
@barbarian said in 'Super Rugby' 2021:
Understandably, RA does not want to go through the same turmoil it experienced in 2017 when it culled the Force from Super Rugby.
Then they should stop trying to add shit teams. FFS.
its also why i wouldnt be adverse to rebranding all the teams, this would be a new comp, lets remove the appearance of connections to the old one
-
@Snowy said in 'Super Rugby' 2021:
@barbarian said in 'Super Rugby' 2021:
Understandably, RA does not want to go through the same turmoil it experienced in 2017 when it culled the Force from Super Rugby.
Then they should stop trying to add shit teams. FFS.
its also why i wouldnt be adverse to rebranding all the teams, this would be a new comp, lets remove the appearance of connections to the old one
@Kiwiwomble said in 'Super Rugby' 2021:
@Snowy said in 'Super Rugby' 2021:
@barbarian said in 'Super Rugby' 2021:
Understandably, RA does not want to go through the same turmoil it experienced in 2017 when it culled the Force from Super Rugby.
Then they should stop trying to add shit teams. FFS.
its also why i wouldnt be adverse to rebranding all the teams, this would be a new comp, lets remove the appearance of connections to the old one
Nah, not for me. I like the old "rivalries". It keeps the banter going.
-
@Kiwiwomble said in 'Super Rugby' 2021:
@Snowy said in 'Super Rugby' 2021:
@barbarian said in 'Super Rugby' 2021:
Understandably, RA does not want to go through the same turmoil it experienced in 2017 when it culled the Force from Super Rugby.
Then they should stop trying to add shit teams. FFS.
its also why i wouldnt be adverse to rebranding all the teams, this would be a new comp, lets remove the appearance of connections to the old one
Nah, not for me. I like the old "rivalries". It keeps the banter going.
@Snowy fair enough, i honestly dont think that would stop though, a lot of that came out of our old NPC rivalries so there would just be a natural progression, it would just be anther way to draw a line under it
-
@Snowy fair enough, i honestly dont think that would stop though, a lot of that came out of our old NPC rivalries so there would just be a natural progression, it would just be anther way to draw a line under it
-
@Kiwiwomble Still plenty on here that are seriously NPC based with loyalties to teams.
It takes a long time to adopt a new team, it seems.
@Snowy said in 'Super Rugby' 2021:
@Kiwiwomble Still plenty on here that are seriously NPC based with loyalties to teams.
It takes a long time to adopt a new team, it seems.
not for @Nepia
-
@Snowy fair enough, i honestly dont think that would stop though, a lot of that came out of our old NPC rivalries so there would just be a natural progression, it would just be anther way to draw a line under it
@Kiwiwomble said in 'Super Rugby' 2021:
enough, i honestly dont think that would stop though, a lot of that came out of our old NPC rivalries so there would just be a natural progression, it would just be anther way to draw a line under it
I dont really have any affiliation or 'love' for the Chiefs (who we were part of initially) or the Blues (who we are part of now) I support all NZ sides equally haha
-
@Snowy said in 'Super Rugby' 2021:
@Kiwiwomble Still plenty on here that are seriously NPC based with loyalties to teams.
It takes a long time to adopt a new team, it seems.
not for @Nepia
@mariner4life said in 'Super Rugby' 2021:
@Snowy said in 'Super Rugby' 2021:
@Kiwiwomble Still plenty on here that are seriously NPC based with loyalties to teams.
It takes a long time to adopt a new team, it seems.
not for @Nepia
I should have said "franchise" @nepia is pretty solid about his NPC team. Which was what I was getting at.
-
@mariner4life said in 'Super Rugby' 2021:
@Snowy said in 'Super Rugby' 2021:
@Kiwiwomble Still plenty on here that are seriously NPC based with loyalties to teams.
It takes a long time to adopt a new team, it seems.
not for @Nepia
I should have said "franchise" @nepia is pretty solid about his NPC team. Which was what I was getting at.
@Snowy said in 'Super Rugby' 2021:
@mariner4life said in 'Super Rugby' 2021:
@Snowy said in 'Super Rugby' 2021:
@Kiwiwomble Still plenty on here that are seriously NPC based with loyalties to teams.
It takes a long time to adopt a new team, it seems.
not for @Nepia
I should have said "franchise" @nepia is pretty solid about his NPC team. Which was what I was getting at.
i probably am too, think i would rather otago won than the highlanders,
i still like being able to trace that guy that went to the highschool and then that club and got the call up to the team
I love how Fumi tanaka and Horie rocked up in dunners with little other than Tony Brown saying it would be great for their rugby, picked a clb, played a whole clubs season...got picked for Otago, played a whole NPC season...then got super call ups
-
@Kiwiwomble said in 'Super Rugby' 2021:
enough, i honestly dont think that would stop though, a lot of that came out of our old NPC rivalries so there would just be a natural progression, it would just be anther way to draw a line under it
I dont really have any affiliation or 'love' for the Chiefs (who we were part of initially) or the Blues (who we are part of now) I support all NZ sides equally haha
@taniwharugby said in 'Super Rugby' 2021:
@Kiwiwomble said in 'Super Rugby' 2021:
enough, i honestly dont think that would stop though, a lot of that came out of our old NPC rivalries so there would just be a natural progression, it would just be anther way to draw a line under it
I dont really have any affiliation or 'love' for the Chiefs (who we were part of initially) or the Blues (who we are part of now) I support all NZ sides equally haha
bullshit!!! you were balls deep on teh Blues when they looked like winning the comp...
I've been following the Chiefs for what, 25 years now? That's long enough to get attached. Starting again would be retarded.
I've been a Bay supporter my whole life, but in reality only consciously about 10 years more than that.
The Chiefs are now as much a part of my supporter identity as any team.
-
@Snowy said in 'Super Rugby' 2021:
@mariner4life said in 'Super Rugby' 2021:
@Snowy said in 'Super Rugby' 2021:
@Kiwiwomble Still plenty on here that are seriously NPC based with loyalties to teams.
It takes a long time to adopt a new team, it seems.
not for @Nepia
I should have said "franchise" @nepia is pretty solid about his NPC team. Which was what I was getting at.
i probably am too, think i would rather otago won than the highlanders,
i still like being able to trace that guy that went to the highschool and then that club and got the call up to the team
I love how Fumi tanaka and Horie rocked up in dunners with little other than Tony Brown saying it would be great for their rugby, picked a clb, played a whole clubs season...got picked for Otago, played a whole NPC season...then got super call ups
@Kiwiwomble said in 'Super Rugby' 2021:
i probably am too, think i would rather otago won than the highlanders
Yep. Auckland for me. I was at Eden park every weekend with my Dad as a kid. At the supporters club, knew the players, great memories. I like the Blues and I'm invested but it takes a shitload of time to get there.
-
@taniwharugby said in 'Super Rugby' 2021:
@Kiwiwomble said in 'Super Rugby' 2021:
enough, i honestly dont think that would stop though, a lot of that came out of our old NPC rivalries so there would just be a natural progression, it would just be anther way to draw a line under it
I dont really have any affiliation or 'love' for the Chiefs (who we were part of initially) or the Blues (who we are part of now) I support all NZ sides equally haha
bullshit!!! you were balls deep on teh Blues when they looked like winning the comp...
I've been following the Chiefs for what, 25 years now? That's long enough to get attached. Starting again would be retarded.
I've been a Bay supporter my whole life, but in reality only consciously about 10 years more than that.
The Chiefs are now as much a part of my supporter identity as any team.
@mariner4life said in 'Super Rugby' 2021:
bullshit!!! you were balls deep on teh Blues when they looked like winning the comp...
When was that? I bet you cant find posts of mine pumping them as my team...fluffybunny!
-
@taniwharugby said in 'Super Rugby' 2021:
@Kiwiwomble said in 'Super Rugby' 2021:
enough, i honestly dont think that would stop though, a lot of that came out of our old NPC rivalries so there would just be a natural progression, it would just be anther way to draw a line under it
I dont really have any affiliation or 'love' for the Chiefs (who we were part of initially) or the Blues (who we are part of now) I support all NZ sides equally haha
bullshit!!! you were balls deep on teh Blues when they looked like winning the comp...
I've been following the Chiefs for what, 25 years now? That's long enough to get attached. Starting again would be retarded.
I've been a Bay supporter my whole life, but in reality only consciously about 10 years more than that.
The Chiefs are now as much a part of my supporter identity as any team.
@mariner4life said in 'Super Rugby' 2021:
Starting again would be retarded.
-
@Kiwiwomble said in 'Super Rugby' 2021:
i probably am too, think i would rather otago won than the highlanders
Yep. Auckland for me. I was at Eden park every weekend with my Dad as a kid. At the supporters club, knew the players, great memories. I like the Blues and I'm invested but it takes a shitload of time to get there.
@Snowy said in 'Super Rugby' 2021:
@Kiwiwomble said in 'Super Rugby' 2021:
i probably am too, think i would rather otago won than the highlanders
Yep. Auckland for me. I was at Eden park every weekend with my Dad as a kid. At the supporters club, knew the players, great memories. I like the Blues and I'm invested but it takes a shitload of time to get there.
John leslie and paul cooke coached my highschool team (whilst playing for otago)...there was just better connection with the community then
