Rugby Commentators/Presenters
-
I think some of the comms people are very good game analysts, but shit at commentating.
-
Still like Nisbo. Far and away my favourite commentator.
@billy-tell said in NZ Rugby Commentators:
Still like Nisbo. Far and away my favourite commentator.
Nisbo still the man IMHO. Agree Rikki Swannell the best of the next generation. Not sold on TJ or Meg though.
-
-
A good commentator is often like a good referee. When they do a good job you barely even notice they’re there. Unfortunately that’s exceedingly rare these days.
-
@bones said in NZ Rugby Commentators:
Well I'm now firmly on board the Beaver Bandwagon.
What an inspirational photo ! Did you get teary eyed posting it ? I did just looking at it !
The Beaver in the Bourne, shit doesn’t get better than that
-
@mn5 and Chats! Although he was probably only there to pick everyone up from the airport and drop them back.
-
@bones said in NZ Rugby Commentators:
@mn5 and Chats! Although he was probably only there to pick everyone up from the airport and drop them back.
I would pay big money just to sit in a cab and talk cricket with chats. I bet he has some yarns
@mn5 said in NZ Rugby Commentators:
@bones said in NZ Rugby Commentators:
@mn5 and Chats! Although he was probably only there to pick everyone up from the airport and drop them back.
I would pay big money just to sit in a cab and talk cricket with chats. I bet he has some yarns
Cab fare isn't that big even for a Scotsman is it? Just book him for a blat around mate!
-
@mn5 said in NZ Rugby Commentators:
@bones said in NZ Rugby Commentators:
@mn5 and Chats! Although he was probably only there to pick everyone up from the airport and drop them back.
I would pay big money just to sit in a cab and talk cricket with chats. I bet he has some yarns
Cab fare isn't that big even for a Scotsman is it? Just book him for a blat around mate!
@bones said in NZ Rugby Commentators:
@mn5 said in NZ Rugby Commentators:
@bones said in NZ Rugby Commentators:
@mn5 and Chats! Although he was probably only there to pick everyone up from the airport and drop them back.
I would pay big money just to sit in a cab and talk cricket with chats. I bet he has some yarns
Cab fare isn't that big even for a Scotsman is it? Just book him for a blat around mate!
Good point. I’d charge it to my work expense account.
-
I like Nisbo. Perhaps its just familiarity but I enjoy his commentary.
Justin Marshall annoys me no end. He acts like he is the "knowledgable expert" and yet he doesn't understand basic laws of rugby.
Personally I always like Mexted as a colour commentator. They should bring him back.
-
@yeetyaah said in NZ Rugby Commentators:
Hames makes some outrageous claims at times.
Hames is often critical of referees' decisions, which is surprising as he is a ref himself. No idea if he is any good though.
@bovidae said in NZ Rugby Commentators:
@yeetyaah said in NZ Rugby Commentators:
Hames makes some outrageous claims at times.
Hames is often critical of referees' decisions, which is surprising as he is a ref himself. No idea if he is any good though.
At least he knows what he’s talking about on the scrum ones.
-
I like Nisbo. Perhaps its just familiarity but I enjoy his commentary.
Justin Marshall annoys me no end. He acts like he is the "knowledgable expert" and yet he doesn't understand basic laws of rugby.
Personally I always like Mexted as a colour commentator. They should bring him back.
@damo said in NZ Rugby Commentators:
I like Nisbo. Perhaps its just familiarity but I enjoy his commentary.
Justin Marshall annoys me no end. He acts like he is the "knowledgable expert" and yet he doesn't understand basic laws of rugby.
Personally I always like Mexted as a colour commentator. They should bring him back.
You probably wish Philip Sherry still read the news too
-
Jeff McTainsh is probably the guy Sky needs to use more. Maybe Nigel Yalden does more TV commentary.
I'll add that a lot of the former players used in supporting roles are terrible too.
@bovidae said in NZ Rugby Commentators:
Jeff McTainsh is probably the guy Sky needs to use more. Maybe Nigel Yalden does more TV commentary.
I'll add that a lot of the former players used in supporting roles are terrible too
I can usually tolerate below standard play by play calling (including mistakes) if the “expert” analysis is insightful and balanced. But that has been pretty underwhelming for a few years now (RIP JD).
Mute is your friend.
-
Well I don't get too excited over who is commentating games. I maybe different, but I quite enjoy Ken Laban, mainly because I get impression he loves the game and actually goes to a lot of school and club rugby when off air. I also enjoy Hames whoI find has interesting points of view from refs decisions at times. TJ , Nesbitt etc I can take or leave, when I watch rugby I kind of take more interest in what players are doing more than commentators.
In saying that I find Justin Marshall a bit annoying when he rants about decisions that quite often he has got wrong. Point things out but don't harp I tend to think. Still I have just got back form 20 odd years in Aus and had a diet of Kearnsire and Marto etc who at times tried their hardest to be comedians, which doesn't work. -
Well I don't get too excited over who is commentating games. I maybe different, but I quite enjoy Ken Laban, mainly because I get impression he loves the game and actually goes to a lot of school and club rugby when off air. I also enjoy Hames whoI find has interesting points of view from refs decisions at times. TJ , Nesbitt etc I can take or leave, when I watch rugby I kind of take more interest in what players are doing more than commentators.
In saying that I find Justin Marshall a bit annoying when he rants about decisions that quite often he has got wrong. Point things out but don't harp I tend to think. Still I have just got back form 20 odd years in Aus and had a diet of Kearnsire and Marto etc who at times tried their hardest to be comedians, which doesn't work.@dan54 said in NZ Rugby Commentators:
Well I don't get too excited over who is commentating games. I maybe different, but I quite enjoy Ken Laban, mainly because I get impression he loves the game and actually goes to a lot of school and club rugby when off air. I also enjoy Hames whoI find has interesting points of view from refs decisions at times. TJ , Nesbitt etc I can take or leave, when I watch rugby I kind of take more interest in what players are doing more than commentators.
In saying that I find Justin Marshall a bit annoying when he rants about decisions that quite often he has got wrong. Point things out but don't harp I tend to think. Still I have just got back form 20 odd years in Aus and had a diet of Kearnsire and Marto etc who at times tried their hardest to be comedians, which doesn't work.When does therapy start?
-
Ken Laban is the best with his fantastic pronunciations followed by Rikki Swannell. Not many good expert commentators sadly, too much of a boys club on sky. Bring back Jon Preston, that man knows his stuff.
