SRA Round 10: Blues v Chiefs

KiwiMurph

@stargazer said in SRA Round 10: Blues v Chiefs:

@kiwimurph Did I say that?

Didn't say you did.

Damo

@chris said in SRA Round 10: Blues v Chiefs:

@antipodean said in SRA Round 10: Blues v Chiefs:

@nepia said in SRA Round 10: Blues v Chiefs:

You have to go past it

That's not correct. The law doesn't say that.

You can only be off side if the ball goes forward the TMO ruled it went backwards so he is not offside.

Do you have a law reference for that?

Steven Harris

@kev I tried to get him up to Northland the year Auckland won the Mitre 10 cup , out of loyalty he stayed with Auckland although he thought about it ..spoke to him last Saturday.., he said it’s now definitely an option , got another a year on his contract ..

Stargazer

@kiwimurph And I shouldn't have to. I asked a question.

Chris

@antipodean said in SRA Round 10: Blues v Chiefs:

@chris said in SRA Round 10: Blues v Chiefs:

@antipodean said in SRA Round 10: Blues v Chiefs:

@nepia said in SRA Round 10: Blues v Chiefs:

You have to go past it

That's not correct. The law doesn't say that.

You can only be off side if the ball goes forward the TMO ruled it went backwards so he is not offside.

Wrong. I've already quoted the law.

So you can be offside picking up a ball that went backwards.
Is that an Australian Law

antipodean

@chris said in SRA Round 10: Blues v Chiefs:

@antipodean said in SRA Round 10: Blues v Chiefs:

@chris said in SRA Round 10: Blues v Chiefs:

@antipodean said in SRA Round 10: Blues v Chiefs:

@nepia said in SRA Round 10: Blues v Chiefs:

You have to go past it

That's not correct. The law doesn't say that.

You can only be off side if the ball goes forward the TMO ruled it went backwards so he is not offside.

Wrong. I've already quoted the law.

So you can be offside picking up a ball that went backwards.
Is that an Australian Law

World Rugby https://www.world.rugby/the-game/laws/law/10

Let me make this perfectly clear - you have to be put onside in that circumstance. Running past an imaginary line where the ball was is not being put onside.

KiwiMurph

@stargazer said in SRA Round 10: Blues v Chiefs:

@kiwimurph And I shouldn't have to. I asked a question.

Way to miss my point.

Anonymous

@antipodean said in SRA Round 10: Blues v Chiefs:

@gt12 said in SRA Round 10: Blues v Chiefs:

@anonymous said in SRA Round 10: Blues v Chiefs:

@damo said in SRA Round 10: Blues v Chiefs:

@arhs said in SRA Round 10: Blues v Chiefs:

How is it offside if ball goes back? These referrals are an absolute farce

That's irrelevant.

If you are in front of the last team mate to play the ball you are offside until put onside.

Does retreating to the point they last touched the ball not count as putting yourself onside?

That’s my understanding too, as if the ball was touched by someone and went backwards you’d have to go behind that point to then pick it up, therefore youre not offside?

No. The laws make it clear you have to be put onside:
Other than under Law 10.4c, an offside player can be put onside when:

An onside team-mate of that player moves past the offside player and is within or has re-entered the playing area

An opponent of that player:
* Carries the ball five metres; or
* Passes the ball; or
* Kicks the ball; or*
Law 10.4c refers to kicks. So you have to be put onside by an onside team mate or an action of the opposing team.

That's referring to how players can be put onside (by other players), not how they can put themselves onside.

antipodean

@anonymous said in SRA Round 10: Blues v Chiefs:

@antipodean said in SRA Round 10: Blues v Chiefs:
@gt12 said in SRA Round 10: Blues v Chiefs:

@anonymous said in SRA Round 10: Blues v Chiefs:

@damo said in SRA Round 10: Blues v Chiefs:

@arhs said in SRA Round 10: Blues v Chiefs:

How is it offside if ball goes back? These referrals are an absolute farce

That's irrelevant.

If you are in front of the last team mate to play the ball you are offside until put onside.

Does retreating to the point they last touched the ball not count as putting yourself onside?

That’s my understanding too, as if the ball was touched by someone and went backwards you’d have to go behind that point to then pick it up, therefore youre not offside?

No. The laws make it clear you have to be put onside:
Other than under Law 10.4c, an offside player can be put onside when:

An onside team-mate of that player moves past the offside player and is within or has re-entered the playing area

An opponent of that player:
* Carries the ball five metres; or
* Passes the ball; or
* Kicks the ball; or*
Law 10.4c refers to kicks. So you have to be put onside by an onside team mate or an action of the opposing team.
That's referring to how players can be put onside (by other players), not how they can put themselves onside.

Quote where the law says you can put yourself onside.

Chris

@antipodean said in SRA Round 10: Blues v Chiefs:

@chris said in SRA Round 10: Blues v Chiefs:

@antipodean said in SRA Round 10: Blues v Chiefs:

@chris said in SRA Round 10: Blues v Chiefs:

@antipodean said in SRA Round 10: Blues v Chiefs:

@nepia said in SRA Round 10: Blues v Chiefs:

You have to go past it

That's not correct. The law doesn't say that.

You can only be off side if the ball goes forward the TMO ruled it went backwards so he is not offside.

Wrong. I've already quoted the law.

So you can be offside picking up a ball that went backwards.
Is that an Australian Law

World Rugby https://www.world.rugby/the-game/laws/law/10

Let me make this perfectly clear - you have to be put onside in that circumstance. Running past an imaginary line where the ball was in not being put onside.

FUuuuuuck I fucken hate it when you are fuckenbright

@antipodean said in SRA Round 10: Blues v Chiefs:

@chris said in SRA Round 10: Blues v Chiefs:

@antipodean said in SRA Round 10: Blues v Chiefs:

@chris said in SRA Round 10: Blues v Chiefs:

@antipodean said in SRA Round 10: Blues v Chiefs:

@nepia said in SRA Round 10: Blues v Chiefs:

You have to go past it

That's not correct. The law doesn't say that.

You can only be off side if the ball goes forward the TMO ruled it went backwards so he is not offside.

Wrong. I've already quoted the law.

So you can be offside picking up a ball that went backwards.
Is that an Australian Law

World Rugby https://www.world.rugby/the-game/laws/law/10

Let me make this perfectly clear - you have to be put onside in that circumstance. Running past an imaginary line where the ball was is not being put onside.

Fuuuuck I hate it when you are fucken right

KiwiMurph

Much better from zarn

KiwiMurph

These referrals need to be binned

hydro11

@kiwimurph said in SRA Round 10: Blues v Chiefs:

These referrals need to be binned

Got the right decision earlier.

Victor Meldrew

@kiwimurph said in SRA Round 10: Blues v Chiefs:

These referrals need to be binned

Nah. Gives me time to make coffee for me, the missus and her sister...

Bones

@kiwimurph said in SRA Round 10: Blues v Chiefs:

These referrals need to be binned

That's another really dumb one. What made him think that was a good idea?

gt12

@hydro11 said in SRA Round 10: Blues v Chiefs:

@kiwimurph said in SRA Round 10: Blues v Chiefs:

These referrals need to be binned

Got the right decision earlier.

Only if they ruled that the ball went forward, which is what the Captain’s challenge was for.

Bones

@victor-meldrew said in SRA Round 10: Blues v Chiefs:

@kiwimurph said in SRA Round 10: Blues v Chiefs:

These referrals need to be binned

Nah. Gives me time to make coffee for me, the missus and her sister...

Glad you had a good Friday night.

Yeetyaah

Too many weet bix for Otere

Machpants

"Oh another one! Blues have said that they scored but the ref says that they were short.

I assume that now the TMO will say that the try was not scored but that last Tuesday one of the Chiefs players crossed a road without waiting for the lights so it’ll be a penalty try and red card"

An Ozzie view

Bones

@kiwimurph said in SRA Round 10: Blues v Chiefs:

Much better from zarn

Would've liked Ioane to give him a one on one earlier.

The Silver Fern

SRA Round 10: Blues v Chiefs