Highlanders v Force
-
@Machpants said in Highlanders v Force:
Jesus's that's ridiculous
Upright in the tackle
what a load of shit - he almost fell over! -
What's he supposed to do with the sudden change of direction etc? ... But YC for consistency in this day and age...
-
Can remember a league test in Palmerston North where the ball went missing for about 3 or 4 minutes ..
@Steven-Harris said in Highlanders v Force:
Can remember a league test in Palmerston North where the ball went missing for about 3 or 4 minutes ..
they almost ran out! None were coming back to the game
-
What's he supposed to do with the sudden change of direction etc? ... But YC for consistency in this day and age...
@Mattasaurus said in Highlanders v Force:
What's he supposed to do with the sudden change of direction etc
I don't like that reasoning, the answer is not make a dangerous tackle. However if a guy nearly falling over is considered upright then there's something wrong.
-
The Force kicker looks a bit 'special' when he kicks for goal.
-
What's he supposed to do with the sudden change of direction etc? ... But YC for consistency in this day and age...
@Mattasaurus If you arent in a position to make a safe tackle you don't make a tackle, obviously.
-
@Mattasaurus said in Highlanders v Force:
What's he supposed to do with the sudden change of direction etc
I don't like that reasoning, the answer is not make a dangerous tackle. However if a guy nearly falling over is considered upright then there's something wrong.
-
@Bones I also dont like that it is called 'foul play'
To me, foul indicates dirty play
@taniwharugby said in Highlanders v Force:
@Bones I also dont like that it is called 'foul play'
To me, foul indicates dirty play
High tackles were pretty dirty in my day
-
@taniwharugby said in Highlanders v Force:
@Bones I also dont like that it is called 'foul play'
To me, foul indicates dirty play
High tackles were pretty dirty in my day
-
@Bones well, with your lid I expect people were trying to improve it
@taniwharugby said in Highlanders v Force:
@Bones well, with your lid I expect people were trying to improve it
They would've had quite the challenge on their hands.
-
Can remember a league test in Palmerston North where the ball went missing for about 3 or 4 minutes ..
@Steven-Harris said in Highlanders v Force:
Can remember a league test in Palmerston North where the ball went missing for about 3 or 4 minutes ..
The Scarlet Manuka?
-
@taniwharugby said in Highlanders v Force:
@Bones I also dont like that it is called 'foul play'
To me, foul indicates dirty play
High tackles were pretty dirty in my day
@Bones said in Highlanders v Force:
@taniwharugby said in Highlanders v Force:
@Bones I also dont like that it is called 'foul play'
To me, foul indicates dirty play
High tackles were pretty dirty in my day
Watch it at normal speed...
Certainly no malice.. Not deliberately head hunting..
Im guessing it's being implied that he was beaten, therefore shouldn't attempt the tackle.. As he wasn't going to be able to get low enough.
-
@Steven-Harris said in Highlanders v Force:
Can remember a league test in Palmerston North where the ball went missing for about 3 or 4 minutes ..
they almost ran out! None were coming back to the game
@nzzp ..plenty of bogans in the crowd that night
-
Gilbert is not really playing like a normal 10
-
Makalio having difficulty getting onside.
-
Of interest, in u10 grade and below tackle, the tackle height must now be below the sternum... I believe the intent is to carry this through the older grades in coming seasons too
Not sure if specifics, just what we were told at small Blacks course.
-
Makalio having difficulty getting onside.
@antipodean said in Highlanders v Force:
Makalio having difficulty getting onside.
He looks like he's carrying an excess 10 kegs
-
Of interest, in u10 grade and below tackle, the tackle height must now be below the sternum... I believe the intent is to carry this through the older grades in coming seasons too
Not sure if specifics, just what we were told at small Blacks course.
@Mattasaurus pretty sure it is U18 and below
-
@Bones said in Highlanders v Force:
@taniwharugby said in Highlanders v Force:
@Bones I also dont like that it is called 'foul play'
To me, foul indicates dirty play
High tackles were pretty dirty in my day
Watch it at normal speed...
Certainly no malice.. Not deliberately head hunting..
Im guessing it's being implied that he was beaten, therefore shouldn't attempt the tackle.. As he wasn't going to be able to get low enough.
@Mattasaurus said in Highlanders v Force:
@Bones said in Highlanders v Force:
@taniwharugby said in Highlanders v Force:
@Bones I also dont like that it is called 'foul play'
To me, foul indicates dirty play
High tackles were pretty dirty in my day
Watch it at normal speed...
Certainly no malice.. Not deliberately head hunting..
Im guessing it's being implied that he was beaten, therefore shouldn't attempt the tackle.. As he wasn't going to be able to get low enough.
Not sure what you're arguing with here. Normal speed or not, it's penalty at best, Dickson was really low. "what's he supposed to do" is not a defence though
