All Black captains winning %
-
Shows why you can sometimes read too much into stats, I mean loved Buck as captain and player, but he was captaining ABs when the rest of world was so far behind, and so poor in may cases it was stupid. I always thought even the first WC was such a foregone conclusion, I struggle to look bac on it as very good tournament. As in instance I will remember going to a local park in Levin to watch Wales have a trainig run (Wales were beaten semi-finalists) , the locals were asked to supply a few front rowers etc for opposition, there were 2 local senior first players propping (not sure but one may of been a rep player for Horowhenua), the hooker was from my club's 2nd team, and Derek Quinnell (I think forward coach for Wales) actually first asked our players to ease up a bit as Welsh pack was getting done. As I say they were deserved semi finalists, and rest of team were no better than their forwards, it was embarassing to see quality of teams from team from particularly Britain , but rest of world seemed so far behind us in skills! Test rugby became very boring for a few years! I think at times we have had outstanding captains etc, just that era you couldn't tell, the likes of Richie etc were great, and I thought his whole attitude to game and training was exceptional, and one of reasons he was best player I have seen.
-
Since the OP seems like a thinly veiled Cane takedown and Whitelock (and Suitcase) fluff then we really need to a do a deeper analysis.
e.g.:
What's Whitelock's Foster only stats?
And how many of the Cane losses included Whitelock in the team as a senior player?
-
Are these stats accounting for the relative opposition?
-
@ARHS said in All Black captains winning %:
Would have thought Taine Randell, Anton Oliver and Fred Allen had difficult patches as captain. Are their stats there? Wouldn't have thought Cane would be much below 70%. He had a draw too.
Taine endured 1998
-
@booboo said in All Black captains winning %:
@ARHS said in All Black captains winning %:
Would have thought Taine Randell, Anton Oliver and Fred Allen had difficult patches as captain. Are their stats there? Wouldn't have thought Cane would be much below 70%. He had a draw too.
Taine endured 1998
Yep. None of the captains would have excelled during the period he had if appointed at his age.
-
@booboo said in All Black captains winning %:
@ARHS said in All Black captains winning %:
Would have thought Taine Randell, Anton Oliver and Fred Allen had difficult patches as captain. Are their stats there? Wouldn't have thought Cane would be much below 70%. He had a draw too.
Taine endured 1998
As did we.....
-
On the current guys:
Sam Whitelock has played 18 games as captain and won 14 of them (78%) - not sure where 83% comes from?
He has played 14 games as captain against T1 sides and won 10 of them (71%).Sam Cane has played 19 games as captain and won 12 of them (63%).
He has played 17 games as captain against T1 sides and won 10 of them (59%).But under Foster, Whitelock has played nine games as captain against T1 sides and won six of them (67%).
Under Foster, Cane has played 15 games as captain against T1 sides and won eight of them (53%). -
@ARHS said in All Black captains winning %:
Would have thought Taine Randell, Anton Oliver and Fred Allen had difficult patches as captain. Are their stats there? Wouldn't have thought Cane would be much below 70%. He had a draw too.
Interesting that Sam Whitelock rates higher than Mourie & Whineray as I'd rate those two as near the top of the pile based on their legacy.
In Whineray's case the team Lochore inherited was utterly dominant for 7 or 8 years and in Mourie's case, he took on an absolute crock of shite that was the 70's AB's and moulded them into a bloody good team. Ditto for McCaw who used the 2007 game that didn't happen as motivation for a super-human effort in 2011.
-
-
@Victor-Meldrew said in All Black captains winning %:
@ARHS said in All Black captains winning %:
Would have thought Taine Randell, Anton Oliver and Fred Allen had difficult patches as captain. Are their stats there? Wouldn't have thought Cane would be much below 70%. He had a draw too.
Interesting that Sam Whitelock rates higher than Mourie & Whineray as I'd rate those two as near the top of the pile based on their legacy.
In Whineray's case the team Lochore inherited was utterly dominant for 7 or 8 years and in Mourie's case, he took on an absolute crock of shite that was the 70's AB's and moulded them into a bloody good team. Ditto for McCaw who used the 2007 game that didn't happen as motivation for a super-human effort in 2011.
Function of only playing tests against the full IRB member countries?
ie., no PIs, Japan, Italy, even Argentina to pad the stats.
-
@booboo said in All Black captains winning %:
@Victor-Meldrew said in All Black captains winning %:
@ARHS said in All Black captains winning %:
Would have thought Taine Randell, Anton Oliver and Fred Allen had difficult patches as captain. Are their stats there? Wouldn't have thought Cane would be much below 70%. He had a draw too.
Interesting that Sam Whitelock rates higher than Mourie & Whineray as I'd rate those two as near the top of the pile based on their legacy.
In Whineray's case the team Lochore inherited was utterly dominant for 7 or 8 years and in Mourie's case, he took on an absolute crock of shite that was the 70's AB's and moulded them into a bloody good team. Ditto for McCaw who used the 2007 game that didn't happen as motivation for a super-human effort in 2011.
Function of only playing tests against the full IRB member countries?
ie., no PIs, Japan, Italy, even Argentina to pad the stats.
Good point, so possibly. But I guess with Whineray and (to a lesser extent) Mourie you need to factor in plenty of easier games to build combinations and teamwork.
-
@Dan54 said in All Black captains winning %:
Shows why you can sometimes read too much into stats, I mean loved Buck as captain and player, but he was captaining ABs when the rest of world was so far behind, and so poor in may cases it was stupid. I always thought even the first WC was such a foregone conclusion,
Not that Buck captained the 1st RWC.
Shelford was a remarkable captain, the best I have ever seen, as an on-field captain (because there were some issues in the other parts of the role). Sure the ABs were almost unbeatable anyway, but his sacking saw a period of almost immediate decline, much of that around direction, because the players were largely the same.
North Harbour were in a different league when he played for them. So much more steel.
He did great things with Northampton too.
-
-
@Rapido said in All Black captains winning %:
@canefan said in All Black captains winning %:
Buck must have the highest win %? I can't remember him losing a game
Just 1 draw, 2nd test v Aus 1988. Won 13, drew 1.
Or do you mean "games" as in the tests + games metric?
Nope. Figured it was a draw. He presided over a glorious era in AB rugby.
-
@Mr-Fish said in All Black captains winning %:
On the current guys:
Sam Whitelock has played 18 games as captain and won 14 of them (78%) - not sure where 83% comes from?
He has played 14 games as captain against T1 sides and won 10 of them (71%).Sam Cane has played 19 games as captain and won 12 of them (63%).
He has played 17 games as captain against T1 sides and won 10 of them (59%).But under Foster, Whitelock has played nine games as captain against T1 sides and won six of them (67%).
Under Foster, Cane has played 15 games as captain against T1 sides and won eight of them (53%).Isn't it possibly complicated by the pre-Ryan and Ryan-coaching forward periods?
