Star Wars VII ****contains spoilers****
-
@Rancid-Schnitzel said in Star Wars VII ****contains spoilers****:
Yep
Outstanding nerd theory and a tough one to argue which makes my tenuous defence of all things SW even tougher.
One thing I like in all shows/movies I watch is things to be consistent “within their own universe” so to speak.
Snoke got cut in half. Died. Sweet as.
Darth Maul cut in half. Survives but perhaps I can put that down to the cauterising nature of the sabre and how fucken tough his race is ( clutching at straws )
Count Dooku gave Obi Wan and Anakin some glancing blows but part of that I put down to him not being fully embraced in the dark side and giving them a chance ( also worth noting he had cut Anakins hand off )
Obi Wan slices up Anakin ( just limbs, no vital organs ) and leaves him burning and he very barely survives. I can dig that.
But then we get to THIS shit ? ( it was a cool scene I’ll give it that )
No WAY does she survive this.
-
@MN5 said in Star Wars VII ****contains spoilers****:
@Rancid-Schnitzel said in Star Wars VII ****contains spoilers****:
Yep
Outstanding nerd theory and a tough one to argue which makes my tenuous defence of all things SW even tougher.
One thing I like in all shows/movies I watch is things to be consistent “within their own universe” so to speak.
Snoke got cut in half. Died. Sweet as.
Darth Maul cut in half. Survives but perhaps I can put that down to the cauterising nature of the sabre and how fucken tough his race is ( clutching at straws )
Count Dooku gave Obi Wan and Anakin some glancing blows but part of that I put down to him not being fully embraced in the dark side and giving them a chance ( also worth noting he had cut Anakins hand off )
Obi Wan slices up Anakin ( just limbs, no vital organs ) and leaves him burning and he very barely survives. I can dig that.
But then we get to THIS shit ? ( it was a cool scene I’ll give it that )
No WAY does she survive this.
I always found the DM thing absolutely ridiculous. Very surprised Lucas signed off on that. You get run through with a lightsaber that has to be the end. It's an absolute pisstake now and anyone who claims otherwise is delusional.
-
@Rancid-Schnitzel said in Star Wars VII ****contains spoilers****:
@MN5 said in Star Wars VII ****contains spoilers****:
@Rancid-Schnitzel said in Star Wars VII ****contains spoilers****:
Yep
Outstanding nerd theory and a tough one to argue which makes my tenuous defence of all things SW even tougher.
One thing I like in all shows/movies I watch is things to be consistent “within their own universe” so to speak.
Snoke got cut in half. Died. Sweet as.
Darth Maul cut in half. Survives but perhaps I can put that down to the cauterising nature of the sabre and how fucken tough his race is ( clutching at straws )
Count Dooku gave Obi Wan and Anakin some glancing blows but part of that I put down to him not being fully embraced in the dark side and giving them a chance ( also worth noting he had cut Anakins hand off )
Obi Wan slices up Anakin ( just limbs, no vital organs ) and leaves him burning and he very barely survives. I can dig that.
But then we get to THIS shit ? ( it was a cool scene I’ll give it that )
No WAY does she survive this.
I always found the DM thing absolutely ridiculous. Very surprised Lucas signed off on that. You get run through with a lightsaber that has to be the end. It's an absolute pisstake now and anyone who claims otherwise is delusional.
Again, a tough race and the hatred fuelled by the dark side would be enough to keep him going. I accept that one.
Wannabe chicks on speeder bikes with silly coloured hair ? Fuck no.
-
Perhaps we should get the opinion of an imaginary physician from the imaginary universe with the imaginary physical-laws to weigh in.
And yes... I understand that "oh, that doesn't seem like it makes sense"... but also I get that "this is a series of made up stories (originally) aimed at children".
And... ah, actually... Fuck it. If you care that much... go for it. I kinda feel a little envious that somebody can give the smidgeon of a shit about anything like this. -
This post is deleted!
-
This post is deleted!
-
This post is deleted!
-
This post is deleted!
-
This post is deleted!
-
Damn, looks like I missed a good shitfight? There's a swathe of deleted posts.
I'm going to wait for all of Ashoka to drop before watching. I am worried about reports it's hard to follow if Clone Wars and Rebels haven't been watched. But I'll give as go, although I'm really not a fan of the Filoni (we were never going to click, the lover of the prequels and the hater of the prequels
), but it will fill the Star Wars gap until Andor returns. -
@Nepia said in Star Wars VII ****contains spoilers****:
Damn, looks like I missed a good shitfight? There's a swathe of deleted posts.
I'm going to wait for all of Ashoka to drop before watching. I am worried about reports it's hard to follow if Clone Wars and Rebels haven't been watched. But I'll give as go, although I'm really not a fan of the Filoni (we were never going to click, the lover of the prequels and the hater of the prequels
), but it will fill the Star Wars gap until Andor returns.There's still time for you to binge watch rebels and SWCW while you wait
-
@Nepia is filoni a prequel "lover"?....i always kind of thought he liked the idea....and wanted to fix all the stuff they got wrong, Maul for example
-
@canefan said in Star Wars VII ****contains spoilers****:
@Nepia said in Star Wars VII ****contains spoilers****:
Damn, looks like I missed a good shitfight? There's a swathe of deleted posts.
I'm going to wait for all of Ashoka to drop before watching. I am worried about reports it's hard to follow if Clone Wars and Rebels haven't been watched. But I'll give as go, although I'm really not a fan of the Filoni (we were never going to click, the lover of the prequels and the hater of the prequels
), but it will fill the Star Wars gap until Andor returns.There's still time for you to binge watch rebels and SWCW while you wait
-
-
@canefan i havent watched yet either, mrs womble was interested and so were waiting to finish some other things...then she said she wasn't bothered so i can jump in shortly, i love CW and Rebels all in for complete fan service
-
