RWC Week 4: All Blacks v Italy
-
@DaGrubster after following different teams in different codes, it’s almost hard to explain in words when they have nailed that winning culture .
But it’s just like they are all so well connected and become one when it comes to executing the game plan, all on the same page together .
I think Penrith in the nrl are a great example.
Ireland look to have it, but in saying that , it’s never infallible, all teams still have an off day and can trip up.
I don’t think it is a conscious thing, it is just something that happens through playing together winning together and finding ways to win together when perhaps they shouldn’t have.
It’s an intangible thing, much like the All Black aura. But Ireland certainly have this now.
Like many great AB sides have before them.
The current one doesn’t. That doesn’t mean they can’t win though.
-
Few posts above that I agree with but couldn’t quote / reply to them all. I think the ABs stand a very decent chance of turning the Irish over in the QFs. You still have excellent forwards and excellent players and it isn’t that hard to imagine it clicking for you in a game or two. Good players don’t become bad overnight and given the current atmosphere it isn’t hard to imagine the ABs getting up and following instructions to win a game with lots of grunt / discipline and a little bit of razzle dazzle thrown in. You won the 3N for crying out loud
The difficulty for the ABs will be to do it three games in a row against excellent sides. I agree Ireland are the most consistently good, I think France are capable of a higher peak but without quite the same consistency and I think the Saffas beat most teams on most days. Who wins the final is anyone’s guess but if I was an AB fan I’d still very much believe it was possible.
England, of course, just aren’t very good
-
One advantage we have is that Ireland effectively have 2 knockout matches before the qtr final.
The ABs have one against Italy.
Ireland going into a 3rd knock out match at the stage they have never got past before, May pray on their minds and mean they are a little off perhaps?
Ireland have the most hurdles to overcome out of all the teams, even France who have at least got to finals before.
There is a reason why the top nations win and almost monopolise world cups. In football, it’s Brazil, Germany, Italy, Argentina that have the mentality to do it even when they haven’t done it for 20 years.
In rugby it’s NZ, SA and Oz and once by England.
In netball it’s Oz and NZ.
It just seems that certain nations are supposed to win World cups. Whether it is IP, being the best side, expectation, holding their nerve, or something else.
It’s common across lots of sports - it will be incredibly hard for Ireland or France to win this World Cup for the first time.
-
NB. Modern rugby matches are decided by
Discipline
Breakdown
Set piece
Defence
Goal kicking
Kicking out of hand
…
…
…
Who plays at 15@Billy-Tell said in RWC Week 4: All Blacks v Italy:
NB. Modern rugby matches are decided by
Discipline
Breakdown
Set piece
Defence
Goal kicking
Kicking out of hand
…
…
…
Who plays at 15territory should be right near the top, and as well as discipline it is majorly impacted by who plays at 15.
-
One advantage we have is that Ireland effectively have 2 knockout matches before the qtr final.
The ABs have one against Italy.
Ireland going into a 3rd knock out match at the stage they have never got past before, May pray on their minds and mean they are a little off perhaps?
Ireland have the most hurdles to overcome out of all the teams, even France who have at least got to finals before.
There is a reason why the top nations win and almost monopolise world cups. In football, it’s Brazil, Germany, Italy, Argentina that have the mentality to do it even when they haven’t done it for 20 years.
In rugby it’s NZ, SA and Oz and once by England.
In netball it’s Oz and NZ.
It just seems that certain nations are supposed to win World cups. Whether it is IP, being the best side, expectation, holding their nerve, or something else.
It’s common across lots of sports - it will be incredibly hard for Ireland or France to win this World Cup for the first time.
@DaGrubster said in RWC Week 4: All Blacks v Italy:
One advantage we have is that Ireland effectively have 2 knockout matches before the qtr final.
The ABs have one against Italy.
Ireland going into a 3rd knock out match at the stage they have never got past before, May pray on their minds and mean they are a little off perhaps?
Ireland have the most hurdles to overcome out of all the teams, even France who have at least got to finals before.
There is a reason why the top nations win and almost monopolise world cups. In football, it’s Brazil, Germany, Italy, Argentina that have the mentality to do it even when they haven’t done it for 20 years.
In rugby it’s NZ, SA and Oz and once by England.
In netball it’s Oz and NZ.
It just seems that certain nations are supposed to win World cups. Whether it is IP, being the best side, expectation, holding their nerve, or something else.
It’s common across lots of sports - it will be incredibly hard for Ireland or France to win this World Cup for the first time.
Because Wales are going to win it
-
-
We are in the weird position of being on no-one's radar. Here is an excerpt from the Guardian...usually we are the team under pressure of expectation. This time it's mainly France and Ireland IMO.
"No one, to be clear, is remotely counting out the defending champions South Africa or the flying Fijians but there is a chance that France, Ireland, Wales and England could all make the last four."
@Billy-Tell said in RWC Week 4: All Blacks v Italy:
We are in the weird position of being on no-one's radar. Here is an excerpt from the Guardian...usually we are the team under pressure of expectation. This time it's mainly France and Ireland IMO.
"No one, to be clear, is remotely counting out the defending champions South Africa or the flying Fijians but there is a chance that France, Ireland, Wales and England could all make the last four."
Instead of aura, we now wear a cloak of irrelevancy
-
When is the team really named?
@ACT-Crusader said in RWC Week 4: All Blacks v Italy:
When is the team really named?
11.30pm NZ time today, 12.30 CET in official channels..generally 24 hours early though it is known
-
It's the Italy match thread and we're talking about Ireland. FWIW I recall Ireland were number one in the world (briefly) just over four years ago entering the RWC. They lost to Japan and then got flogged in the quarter-final by us.
-
It's the Italy match thread and we're talking about Ireland. FWIW I recall Ireland were number one in the world (briefly) just over four years ago entering the RWC. They lost to Japan and then got flogged in the quarter-final by us.
@antipodean said in RWC Week 4: All Blacks v Italy:
It's the Italy match thread and we're talking about Ireland. FWIW I recall Ireland were number one in the world (briefly) just over four years ago entering the RWC. They lost to Japan and then got flogged in the quarter-final by us.
They certainly weren't coming in on the back of a 16 game streak tho
-
Beauden Barrett is shit now. He’s lost his speed, doesn’t tackle and avoids contact and taking the ball to the line. He’s not a threat. Still a classy kicker or passer.
We need a threat at 15. Look at someone like Reece Walsh from the NRL. Fast, doesn’t avoid contact and ball playing, the triple threat to create opportunities.
Damian is our man. If fozzie moves Damian to 15 we become World Cup favourites. Would rather risk him making some errors for the chance that we can actually threaten on attack. Go down swinging with Damian instead of being comfortable and only losing by less than 20 with Beaudy.
FYI, Beauden is one of the best players I have seen in his prime. He is an all black legend and should always be remember as one. His time is done now.
@Yeahtheboys said in RWC Week 4: All Blacks v Italy:
Damian is our man. If fozzie moves Damian to 15 we become World Cup favourites
Lol
-
@antipodean said in RWC Week 4: All Blacks v Italy:
It's the Italy match thread and we're talking about Ireland. FWIW I recall Ireland were number one in the world (briefly) just over four years ago entering the RWC. They lost to Japan and then got flogged in the quarter-final by us.
They certainly weren't coming in on the back of a 16 game streak tho
@Machpants I read in that streak they have conceded on average 13.8 points per game...only really 3 scoring chances.
-
I don’t think it is a conscious thing, it is just something that happens through playing together winning together and finding ways to win together when perhaps they shouldn’t have.
It’s an intangible thing, much like the All Black aura. But Ireland certainly have this now.
Like many great AB sides have before them.
The current one doesn’t. That doesn’t mean they can’t win though.
@DaGrubster said in RWC Week 4: All Blacks v Italy:
I don’t think it is a conscious thing, it is just something that happens through playing together winning together and finding ways to win together when perhaps they shouldn’t have.
It’s an intangible thing, much like the All Black aura. But Ireland certainly have this now.
Like many great AB sides have before them.
The current one doesn’t. That doesn’t mean they can’t win though.
I think we should utilize some of the more outgoing passionate characters in the AB side.
DMac, LF, Blackadder and Samisoni spring to mind.
I fear we may fire a blank squib. -
i might have missed it but what makes guys like LF and Blackadder "outgoing passionate characters"?
-
i might have missed it but what makes guys like LF and Blackadder "outgoing passionate characters"?
@Kiwiwomble said in RWC Week 4: All Blacks v Italy:
i might have missed it but what makes guys like LF and Blackadder "outgoing passionate characters"?
Leicester's father: "After listening to a Johnny Cash song, I knew if I called him Leicester he'd have to get tough or die"
Ethan's father: "I wish I thought of that, I just wrote down the swear word his mum uttered on the birthing table when those shoulders came out..." -
Muliaina is suggesting that Whitelock should be on the bench, and I agree, but for different reasons. To make the most of the three locks I would obviously play SB for the full 80 mins. Tell BBBR to smash some bodies and empty the tank for 50-60 mins, and then bring on Whitelock to finish the game.
-
Muliaina is suggesting that Whitelock should be on the bench, and I agree, but for different reasons. To make the most of the three locks I would obviously play SB for the full 80 mins. Tell BBBR to smash some bodies and empty the tank for 50-60 mins, and then bring on Whitelock to finish the game.
@Bovidae said in RWC Week 4: All Blacks v Italy:
.. and then bring on Whitelock to finish the game.
Plus ensure some leadership, hopefully!
-
@Bovidae said in RWC Week 4: All Blacks v Italy:
.. and then bring on Whitelock to finish the game.
Plus ensure some leadership, hopefully!
@nostrildamus said in RWC Week 4: All Blacks v Italy:
@Bovidae said in RWC Week 4: All Blacks v Italy:
.. and then bring on Whitelock to finish the game.
Plus ensure some leadership, hopefully!
In theory.
-
I can see the ABs have really been following an exact science in diet and preparation:
https://www.stuff.co.nz/sport/rugby-world-cup-2023/300978351/rugby-world-cup-less-is-best-for-tamaiti-williams-ahead-of-pivotal-all-blacks-clash"there’s been a few less Big Macs and a few more smoothies"
-
I can see the ABs have really been following an exact science in diet and preparation:
https://www.stuff.co.nz/sport/rugby-world-cup-2023/300978351/rugby-world-cup-less-is-best-for-tamaiti-williams-ahead-of-pivotal-all-blacks-clash"there’s been a few less Big Macs and a few more smoothies"
@nostrildamus said in RWC Week 4: All Blacks v Italy:
I can see the ABs have really been following an exact science in diet and preparation:
https://www.stuff.co.nz/sport/rugby-world-cup-2023/300978351/rugby-world-cup-less-is-best-for-tamaiti-williams-ahead-of-pivotal-all-blacks-clash"there’s been a few less Big Macs and a few more smoothies"
( MN5 forces his hand away from the keyboard so as not to make predictable Fozzie fat joke…..)
