All Blacks vs Argentina I
-
People forget that we cracked open the dry powder under Fozzie for the last RWC. We were outstanding in the quarter, semi and final. Really direct, low risk rugby. But for a red card that should have been negated by a red to SA we would have won the whole thing. It was a far cry from the rugby we'd seen in the leadup.
-
People forget that we cracked open the dry powder under Fozzie for the last RWC. We were outstanding in the quarter, semi and final. Really direct, low risk rugby. But for a red card that should have been negated by a red to SA we would have won the whole thing. It was a far cry from the rugby we'd seen in the leadup.
@No-Quarter said in All Blacks vs Argentina I - 10 August:
People forget that we cracked open the dry powder under Fozzie for the last RWC. We were outstanding in the quarter, semi and final. Really direct, low risk rugby. But for a red card that should have been negated by a red to SA we would have won the whole thing. It was a far cry from the rugby we'd seen in the leadup.
it wasn't just Foster though was it? If we looked at the play and stats before and after Schmidt (and Ryan if one wishes) ... they tell a story.
-
@taniwharugby in fairness, there are a lot of good teams that have said that about the ABs. Remember 2019 RWC pool game v SA: 5 minutes of magic scored us two tries and won us that game. Otherwise you'd say SA had the better of us
-
People forget that we cracked open the dry powder under Fozzie for the last RWC. We were outstanding in the quarter, semi and final. Really direct, low risk rugby. But for a red card that should have been negated by a red to SA we would have won the whole thing. It was a far cry from the rugby we'd seen in the leadup.
@No-Quarter said in All Blacks vs Argentina I - 10 August:
People forget that we cracked open the dry powder under Fozzie for the last RWC. We were outstanding in the quarter, semi and final. Really direct, low risk rugby. But for a red card that should have been negated by a red to SA we would have won the whole thing. It was a far cry from the rugby we'd seen in the leadup.
Yeah I thought we looked far better last year than the 3 years previously, not so much in results even if that was better too, but in just how we played .
Boks at mt smart , and the quarter final in particular were games where I didn’t feel like throwing shit at the tv for a change .
-
@nzzp oh I know, I just think we were a drop away form potentially going 0-3 in that series too...similarly, but for the 2nd test card, we win the 2nd test, then thier confidence knocked, we go 3-0...
This is fun
@taniwharugby said in All Blacks vs Argentina I - 10 August:
This is fun
can we have the 1995 final then please? No way Mehrts missed those droppies
-
We entered this year super thin in a few positions because the last two years every game was a must win and the same old side rolled out.
We have to start playing some new guys, or we will enter the next RWC with some broken old men and lots of barely-played newbs.
Edit: and by "playing" I mean playing under red hot conditions, like in South Africa. Merely giving the next tier of players a spell or two in lighter games simply is not preparing them, or the team, properly.
Whose to say that the new guys aren't better? We'll never know if we never give them a chance.
@Chester-Draws said in All Blacks vs Argentina I - 10 August:
We entered this year super thin in a few positions because the last two years every game was a must win and the same old side rolled out.
We have to start playing some new guys, or we will enter the next RWC with some broken old men and lots of barely-played newbs.
Edit: and by "playing" I mean playing under red hot conditions, like in South Africa. Merely giving the next tier of players a spell or two in lighter games simply is not preparing them, or the team, properly.
Whose to say that the new guys aren't better? We'll never know if we never give them a chance.
You realise we have something like 45 tests before the next WC right?
-
People forget that we cracked open the dry powder under Fozzie for the last RWC. We were outstanding in the quarter, semi and final. Really direct, low risk rugby. But for a red card that should have been negated by a red to SA we would have won the whole thing. It was a far cry from the rugby we'd seen in the leadup.
@No-Quarter said in All Blacks vs Argentina I - 10 August:
People forget that we cracked open the dry powder under Fozzie for the last RWC. We were outstanding in the quarter, semi and final. Really direct, low risk rugby. But for a red card that should have been negated by a red to SA we would have won the whole thing. It was a far cry from the rugby we'd seen in the leadup.
Don't forget that ridiculous YC where SF was smacked in the face by Kitsoff's elbow. In fact, Kitsoff was using his forearm a lot in that final.
-
People forget that we cracked open the dry powder under Fozzie for the last RWC. We were outstanding in the quarter, semi and final. Really direct, low risk rugby. But for a red card that should have been negated by a red to SA we would have won the whole thing. It was a far cry from the rugby we'd seen in the leadup.
@No-Quarter said in All Blacks vs Argentina I - 10 August:
People forget that we cracked open the dry powder under Fozzie for the last RWC. We were outstanding in the quarter, semi and final. Really direct, low risk rugby. But for a red card that should have been negated by a red to SA we would have won the whole thing. It was a far cry from the rugby we'd seen in the leadup.
One thing that's been good under Razor is that we've gone three matches without a card. I don't think we've even had an incident reviewed, have we?
It might just be coincidence - but, it seems it would be a long time ago that we last went three consecutive tests without a card.
Edit: A quick scan and looks like we did it at the start of last year! Unfortunately, we couldn't keep it up!
-
@Chester-Draws said in All Blacks vs Argentina I - 10 August:
We entered this year super thin in a few positions because the last two years every game was a must win and the same old side rolled out.
We have to start playing some new guys, or we will enter the next RWC with some broken old men and lots of barely-played newbs.
Edit: and by "playing" I mean playing under red hot conditions, like in South Africa. Merely giving the next tier of players a spell or two in lighter games simply is not preparing them, or the team, properly.
Whose to say that the new guys aren't better? We'll never know if we never give them a chance.
You realise we have something like 45 tests before the next WC right?
@LatsToTheMax said in All Blacks vs Argentina I - 10 August:
@Chester-Draws said in All Blacks vs Argentina I - 10 August:
We entered this year super thin in a few positions because the last two years every game was a must win and the same old side rolled out.
We have to start playing some new guys, or we will enter the next RWC with some broken old men and lots of barely-played newbs.
Edit: and by "playing" I mean playing under red hot conditions, like in South Africa. Merely giving the next tier of players a spell or two in lighter games simply is not preparing them, or the team, properly.
Whose to say that the new guys aren't better? We'll never know if we never give them a chance.
You realise we have something like 45 tests before the next WC right?
There are players that will make the 2027 RWC squad that haven’t even been picked for the ABs yet.
Think about players like Sam Whitelock, Dagg and Cruden, they played their first tests in 2010 and were starters in the RWC final in 2011. Vito was in the same class too, just didn’t play in the final but played other RWC11 matches.
Joe Moody played his first test in 2014 and was starting at loosehead in the RWC15 final.
-
@LatsToTheMax said in All Blacks vs Argentina I - 10 August:
@Chester-Draws said in All Blacks vs Argentina I - 10 August:
We entered this year super thin in a few positions because the last two years every game was a must win and the same old side rolled out.
We have to start playing some new guys, or we will enter the next RWC with some broken old men and lots of barely-played newbs.
Edit: and by "playing" I mean playing under red hot conditions, like in South Africa. Merely giving the next tier of players a spell or two in lighter games simply is not preparing them, or the team, properly.
Whose to say that the new guys aren't better? We'll never know if we never give them a chance.
You realise we have something like 45 tests before the next WC right?
There are players that will make the 2027 RWC squad that haven’t even been picked for the ABs yet.
Think about players like Sam Whitelock, Dagg and Cruden, they played their first tests in 2010 and were starters in the RWC final in 2011. Vito was in the same class too, just didn’t play in the final but played other RWC11 matches.
Joe Moody played his first test in 2014 and was starting at loosehead in the RWC15 final.
@ACT-Crusader you forgot Milner-Skudder, debuted in a RWC year
-
@ACT-Crusader you forgot Milner-Skudder, debuted in a RWC year
@taniwharugby said in All Blacks vs Argentina I - 10 August:
@ACT-Crusader you forgot Milner-Skudder, debuted in a RWC year
Yeah but he’s a winger so barely a rugby player….
-
@taniwharugby said in All Blacks vs Argentina I - 10 August:
@ACT-Crusader you forgot Milner-Skudder, debuted in a RWC year
Yeah but he’s a winger so barely a rugby player….
@ACT-Crusader fair point, still got a jersey and medal though
-
@ACT-Crusader fair point, still got a jersey and medal though
@taniwharugby said in All Blacks vs Argentina I - 10 August:
@ACT-Crusader fair point, still got a jersey and medal though
NMS's timing was impeccable. He caught fire just at the right time. Sadly he was blighted by injuries
-
@taniwharugby said in All Blacks vs Argentina I - 10 August:
@ACT-Crusader you forgot Milner-Skudder, debuted in a RWC year
Yeah but he’s a winger so barely a rugby player….
@ACT-Crusader said in All Blacks vs Argentina I - 10 August:
Yeah but he’s a winger so barely a rugby player….
how positionist!
-
@ACT-Crusader said in All Blacks vs Argentina I - 10 August:
Yeah but he’s a winger so barely a rugby player….
how positionist!
@nostrildamus said in All Blacks vs Argentina I - 10 August:
@ACT-Crusader said in All Blacks vs Argentina I - 10 August:
Yeah but he’s a winger so barely a rugby player….
how positionist!
Back Lives Matter!
-
The All Blacks squad is named at 3pm on Sunday.
-
@canefan said in All Blacks vs Argentina I - 10 August:
@Bones said in All Blacks vs Argentina I - 10 August:
I'm gonna be sick a little but look at Ireland when they were good, they had JGP with quick service in close, not just passing but movement too - and then forward runners at pace and angled. Not forward runners standing still running straight with supporting runners hesitating whilst also running straight.
When they beat us in the series at home they totally schooled us
Did they though?
We beat them first up. I argued Foster got dudded as with decent refereeing we don't see the imbalance in red cards.
They sneaked over the top of us with 14 in test 2, then beat us fair and square in 3 ... Although we got to learn about soaking tackles that break cheek bones
They were slightly better over three tests.i don't think that's schooled.
@nzzp said in All Blacks vs Argentina I - 10 August:
@canefan said in All Blacks vs Argentina I - 10 August:
@Bones said in All Blacks vs Argentina I - 10 August:
I'm gonna be sick a little but look at Ireland when they were good, they had JGP with quick service in close, not just passing but movement too - and then forward runners at pace and angled. Not forward runners standing still running straight with supporting runners hesitating whilst also running straight.
When they beat us in the series at home they totally schooled us
Did they though?
We beat them first up. I argued Foster got dudded as with decent refereeing we don't see the imbalance in red cards.
They sneaked over the top of us with 14 in test 2, then beat us fair and square in 3 ... Although we got to learn about soaking tackles that break cheek bones
They were slightly better over three tests.i don't think that's schooled.
They schooled us first half of Test 3. Other than that, spot on.
-
@Chester-Draws said in All Blacks vs Argentina I - 10 August:
We entered this year super thin in a few positions because the last two years every game was a must win and the same old side rolled out.
We have to start playing some new guys, or we will enter the next RWC with some broken old men and lots of barely-played newbs.
Edit: and by "playing" I mean playing under red hot conditions, like in South Africa. Merely giving the next tier of players a spell or two in lighter games simply is not preparing them, or the team, properly.
Whose to say that the new guys aren't better? We'll never know if we never give them a chance.
You realise we have something like 45 tests before the next WC right?
@LatsToTheMax said in All Blacks vs Argentina I - 10 August:
@Chester-Draws said in All Blacks vs Argentina I - 10 August:
We entered this year super thin in a few positions because the last two years every game was a must win and the same old side rolled out.
We have to start playing some new guys, or we will enter the next RWC with some broken old men and lots of barely-played newbs.
Edit: and by "playing" I mean playing under red hot conditions, like in South Africa. Merely giving the next tier of players a spell or two in lighter games simply is not preparing them, or the team, properly.
Whose to say that the new guys aren't better? We'll never know if we never give them a chance.
You realise we have something like 45 tests before the next WC right?
Yeah, and I also know we won a RWC with our fourth-string 1st-5 who had played 24 tests by that point. We may not even get our reserve 1st-5 to that many tests at this rate by the next RWC, given that it won't be Beauden Barrett and even Mo'unga will be 33.
At some point we have to stop being conservative. It's not Razor's fault that Foster didn't want to try any new players, but it is his responsibility to deal with the problem.
-
With the use of subs any player can have a decent showing now.
