6N 2018
-
I wondered if that Cian Healy head knock would come up post match. It was poor form all around. I can understand the ref not noticing but the AR was there and the trainers should be embarrassed.
Healy was in la-la landI wondered if that Cian Healy head knock would come up post match. It was poor form all around. I can understand the ref not noticing but the AR was there and the trainers should be embarrassed.
Healy was in la-la landSurely they have a match doctor too whose job would also include looking for any possible HIAs? Sam Whitelock was assessed on Sat night based on the doctor's decision not any official.
-
I wondered if that Cian Healy head knock would come up post match. It was poor form all around. I can understand the ref not noticing but the AR was there and the trainers should be embarrassed.
Healy was in la-la landSurely they have a match doctor too whose job would also include looking for any possible HIAs? Sam Whitelock was assessed on Sat night based on the doctor's decision not any official.
@bovidae I once saw an introduction clip about the HIA's and the doctor had a laptop there and said the first check is an eye-test, he watches a replay from the incident and if he doesn't like the look of it, the player fails and also said he watches the game if he sees something worth checking he can inform the refereeing team to get a player for the test.
-
@bovidae I once saw an introduction clip about the HIA's and the doctor had a laptop there and said the first check is an eye-test, he watches a replay from the incident and if he doesn't like the look of it, the player fails and also said he watches the game if he sees something worth checking he can inform the refereeing team to get a player for the test.
@bovidae I once saw an introduction clip about the HIA's and the doctor had a laptop there and said the first check is an eye-test, he watches a replay from the incident and if he doesn't like the look of it, the player fails and also said he watches the game if he sees something worth checking he can inform the refereeing team to get a player for the test.
Aren't Ireland claiming it was not a head injury but a stinger? The video some what disputes this.
-
I have never seen worse game management by an international team then I saw in that France England game.
With 3 minutes to go and a lead of 3 points France win a penalty deep in the English half.
Why would you ever decide to kick that? England were never playing for the draw. So even if you kick it they still need a try to win. Insurance against the conversion thats pretty shit insurance at this level. They needed to bang that into the corner and burn up the 3 minutes going for the try.
Then once time is up. Beauxis putting a beautiful spiral on the ball and not finding touch is unthinkable he was only 10 meters from the side line he could have put it on the second deck from there.
France deserved to lose for being so dumb. They would have learnt a lot more if they had lost.
-
@stargazer said in 6N 2018:
@taniwharugby said in 6N 2018:
an unwanted record...and a shitty headline.
http://www.nzherald.co.nz/sport/news/article.cfm?c_id=4&objectid=12010929
I actually find it a disgusting article and headline. He's an international, a good player in a team that may be the weakest in the 6 Nations and no. 14 in the world rankings, but reaching 133 test caps is a huge achievement nevertheless. He deserves respect, not rubbish like this.
Come on Scotland! Get him to the milestone in style !
Italy are lucky that Scotland have been pretty dire particularly in the mid 2000s when it was always an entertaining scrap for bottom place. In saying that they've still picked up 13 wooden spoons in 18 years.
They've brought precisely 3 5ths of 5 8ths of fuck all to the tournament as a whole.
Money . They bought money to tournament. That it though, they’ve bought fuck all else.
The Ferald having a cheap shot? There’s a surprise.
@stargazer said in 6N 2018:
@taniwharugby said in 6N 2018:
an unwanted record...and a shitty headline.
http://www.nzherald.co.nz/sport/news/article.cfm?c_id=4&objectid=12010929
I actually find it a disgusting article and headline. He's an international, a good player in a team that may be the weakest in the 6 Nations and no. 14 in the world rankings, but reaching 133 test caps is a huge achievement nevertheless. He deserves respect, not rubbish like this.
Come on Scotland! Get him to the milestone in style !
Italy are lucky that Scotland have been pretty dire particularly in the mid 2000s when it was always an entertaining scrap for bottom place. In saying that they've still picked up 13 wooden spoons in 18 years.
They've brought precisely 3 5ths of 5 8ths of fuck all to the tournament as a whole.
Money . They bought money to tournament. That it though, they’ve bought fuck all else.
The Ferald having a cheap shot? There’s a surprise.
I wonder if Georgia or Romania could have managed their level of consistent shitness?
-
@bovidae I once saw an introduction clip about the HIA's and the doctor had a laptop there and said the first check is an eye-test, he watches a replay from the incident and if he doesn't like the look of it, the player fails and also said he watches the game if he sees something worth checking he can inform the refereeing team to get a player for the test.
Aren't Ireland claiming it was not a head injury but a stinger? The video some what disputes this.
-
I have never seen worse game management by an international team then I saw in that France England game.
With 3 minutes to go and a lead of 3 points France win a penalty deep in the English half.
Why would you ever decide to kick that? England were never playing for the draw. So even if you kick it they still need a try to win. Insurance against the conversion thats pretty shit insurance at this level. They needed to bang that into the corner and burn up the 3 minutes going for the try.
Then once time is up. Beauxis putting a beautiful spiral on the ball and not finding touch is unthinkable he was only 10 meters from the side line he could have put it on the second deck from there.
France deserved to lose for being so dumb. They would have learnt a lot more if they had lost.
@mooshld Couldn't agree more. Taking the 3 with 3 minutes to go was as dumb a decision as I have seen. Was surprised that none of the commentators mentioned anything. All that the penalty achieved was to hand back field position to England.
-
Reading more comments from Eddie and the English players I am glad to see they are still fixated on size and power over speed.
It was plain to see that their forwards were too slow to support the ball carrier but apparently the problem is not having enough power.
Jake the Muss would be happy to explain. -
@mooshld Couldn't agree more. Taking the 3 with 3 minutes to go was as dumb a decision as I have seen. Was surprised that none of the commentators mentioned anything. All that the penalty achieved was to hand back field position to England.
@mooshld Couldn't agree more. Taking the 3 with 3 minutes to go was as dumb a decision as I have seen. Was surprised that none of the commentators mentioned anything. All that the penalty achieved was to hand back field position to England.
The Argies did a similar thing during the Summer tests and the comms guys were spluttering about it, so yeah strange they had nothing to say. Maybe they realised England were never going to string enough phases together.
-
@stargazer said in 6N 2018:
@taniwharugby said in 6N 2018:
an unwanted record...and a shitty headline.
http://www.nzherald.co.nz/sport/news/article.cfm?c_id=4&objectid=12010929
I actually find it a disgusting article and headline. He's an international, a good player in a team that may be the weakest in the 6 Nations and no. 14 in the world rankings, but reaching 133 test caps is a huge achievement nevertheless. He deserves respect, not rubbish like this.
Come on Scotland! Get him to the milestone in style !
Italy are lucky that Scotland have been pretty dire particularly in the mid 2000s when it was always an entertaining scrap for bottom place. In saying that they've still picked up 13 wooden spoons in 18 years.
They've brought precisely 3 5ths of 5 8ths of fuck all to the tournament as a whole.
Money . They bought money to tournament. That it though, they’ve bought fuck all else.
The Ferald having a cheap shot? There’s a surprise.
I wonder if Georgia or Romania could have managed their level of consistent shitness?
@stargazer said in 6N 2018:
@taniwharugby said in 6N 2018:
an unwanted record...and a shitty headline.
http://www.nzherald.co.nz/sport/news/article.cfm?c_id=4&objectid=12010929
I actually find it a disgusting article and headline. He's an international, a good player in a team that may be the weakest in the 6 Nations and no. 14 in the world rankings, but reaching 133 test caps is a huge achievement nevertheless. He deserves respect, not rubbish like this.
Come on Scotland! Get him to the milestone in style !
Italy are lucky that Scotland have been pretty dire particularly in the mid 2000s when it was always an entertaining scrap for bottom place. In saying that they've still picked up 13 wooden spoons in 18 years.
They've brought precisely 3 5ths of 5 8ths of fuck all to the tournament as a whole.
Money . They bought money to tournament. That it though, they’ve bought fuck all else.
The Ferald having a cheap shot? There’s a surprise.
I wonder if Georgia or Romania could have managed their level of consistent shitness?
Romania definitely
-
So Healey only got a 'stinger' to the shoulder/traps
No Head injury
Eddie missed a trick on this
-
So Healey only got a 'stinger' to the shoulder/traps
No Head injury
Eddie missed a trick on this
@taniwharugby said in 6N 2018:
So Healey only got a 'stinger' to the shoulder/traps
No Head injury
Eddie missed a trick on this
What a crock of shit. It's not mentally affecting Ireland. Imagine if NZ started wheeling out these excuses.
-
@Billy-Tell @taniwharugby To be fair to Guscott and to re-confirm Stuff's status as a journalistic cesspool, his article was much longer than that and his reasons (which he accompanied with a rationale), were, in order:-
- England are over thinking it at the moment.
- People assume the team lack leaders.
- England's best players are playing well below their best.
- England have only 3-4 world class players
- Eddie is the main leader and he's not preparing the team well enough at present.
- England are plodding in attack.
- A Lions tour is so mentally draining.
- There's no clarity at the breakdown.
- George Ford has been almost anonymous.
So, a bit more to it than Stuff would have you believe.
-
@Billy-Tell @taniwharugby To be fair to Guscott and to re-confirm Stuff's status as a journalistic cesspool, his article was much longer than that and his reasons (which he accompanied with a rationale), were, in order:-
- England are over thinking it at the moment.
- People assume the team lack leaders.
- England's best players are playing well below their best.
- England have only 3-4 world class players
- Eddie is the main leader and he's not preparing the team well enough at present.
- England are plodding in attack.
- A Lions tour is so mentally draining.
- There's no clarity at the breakdown.
- George Ford has been almost anonymous.
So, a bit more to it than Stuff would have you believe.
@catogrande Yeah, you are right Cato, that stuff article is not exactly telling the whole picture. I read Guscotts column today as he's pretty good and usually on the money.
The biggest thing that shocked me though, was he didn't list Itoje in his world class players. That's certainly going against the grain of England rugby journalism, who almost seem to have some sort of illness which prevents them saying anything negative, or even neutral about him.
FWIW I think he's been relatively anonymous in this years 6N.
-
@catogrande Yeah, you are right Cato, that stuff article is not exactly telling the whole picture. I read Guscotts column today as he's pretty good and usually on the money.
The biggest thing that shocked me though, was he didn't list Itoje in his world class players. That's certainly going against the grain of England rugby journalism, who almost seem to have some sort of illness which prevents them saying anything negative, or even neutral about him.
FWIW I think he's been relatively anonymous in this years 6N.
@majorrage said in 6N 2018:
@catogrande Yeah, you are right Cato, that stuff article is not exactly telling the whole picture. I read Guscotts column today as he's pretty good and usually on the money.
The biggest thing that shocked me though, was he didn't list Itoje in his world class players. That's certainly going against the grain of England rugby journalism, who almost seem to have some sort of illness which prevents them saying anything negative, or even neutral about him.
FWIW I think he's been relatively anonymous in this years 6N.
Yeah English rugby journalism have a love affair with Itoje and I sometimes wonder if he asks himself "is it because I'm a poster boy for the black community"? For sure he's a very good player and also he had that long winning streak last season but the wankfest over him has been excessive. He's a pretty intelligent guy so I'd hope it doesn't go to his head - it certainly doesn't seem as though it has affected him going by the odd interview I've seen.
His form since the Lions has not been up there and I'd guess that is for a mixture of reasons. Tiredness, staleness, playing in sides that are not as dominant as they were, mixed messages in game management and likely more. I do think that he's got real potential though, both as a player and as a leader and I really hope he fulfils both.
He has been a fair bit quieter in this years 6N (and far from the only culprit here) but oddly made some impressive line out steals v France. Maybe he's getting his mojo back?
-
Who are the world class players in Guscott's view? I assume Farrell is one but I'm curious about who he thinks the others are.
-
@majorrage said in 6N 2018:
@catogrande Yeah, you are right Cato, that stuff article is not exactly telling the whole picture. I read Guscotts column today as he's pretty good and usually on the money.
The biggest thing that shocked me though, was he didn't list Itoje in his world class players. That's certainly going against the grain of England rugby journalism, who almost seem to have some sort of illness which prevents them saying anything negative, or even neutral about him.
FWIW I think he's been relatively anonymous in this years 6N.
Yeah English rugby journalism have a love affair with Itoje and I sometimes wonder if he asks himself "is it because I'm a poster boy for the black community"? For sure he's a very good player and also he had that long winning streak last season but the wankfest over him has been excessive. He's a pretty intelligent guy so I'd hope it doesn't go to his head - it certainly doesn't seem as though it has affected him going by the odd interview I've seen.
His form since the Lions has not been up there and I'd guess that is for a mixture of reasons. Tiredness, staleness, playing in sides that are not as dominant as they were, mixed messages in game management and likely more. I do think that he's got real potential though, both as a player and as a leader and I really hope he fulfils both.
He has been a fair bit quieter in this years 6N (and far from the only culprit here) but oddly made some impressive line out steals v France. Maybe he's getting his mojo back?
@catogrande said in 6N 2018:
@majorrage said in 6N 2018:
@catogrande Yeah, you are right Cato, that stuff article is not exactly telling the whole picture. I read Guscotts column today as he's pretty good and usually on the money.
The biggest thing that shocked me though, was he didn't list Itoje in his world class players. That's certainly going against the grain of England rugby journalism, who almost seem to have some sort of illness which prevents them saying anything negative, or even neutral about him.
FWIW I think he's been relatively anonymous in this years 6N.
Yeah English rugby journalism have a love affair with Itoje and I sometimes wonder if he asks himself "is it because I'm a poster boy for the black community"? For sure he's a very good player and also he had that long winning streak last season but the wankfest over him has been excessive. He's a pretty intelligent guy so I'd hope it doesn't go to his head - it certainly doesn't seem as though it has affected him going by the odd interview I've seen.
His form since the Lions has not been up there and I'd guess that is for a mixture of reasons. Tiredness, staleness, playing in sides that are not as dominant as they were, mixed messages in game management and likely more. I do think that he's got real potential though, both as a player and as a leader and I really hope he fulfils both.
He has been a fair bit quieter in this years 6N (and far from the only culprit here) but oddly made some impressive line out steals v France. Maybe he's getting his mojo back?
I've often wondered similar from the journo community, not from his.
Don't get me wrong ... he's a great player ... and to call him over rated is not because he's not a fantastic player, it's because (as yet) he's not the once in a generation sort of player which is a mantle many have given him.
-
Time for Eddie to admit that his selections have been off / players not playing to their ability.
Farrell to 10
Daly and Joseph in midfield@mikethesnow said in 6N 2018:
Time for Eddie to admit that his selections have been off / players not playing to their ability.
Farrell to 10
Daly and Joseph in midfieldFord has not been influencing games like he should, so I can understand the call for Farrell to move in one and TBH I wouldn't be averse to that nowadays. I wouldn't have that midfield though, Daly and Joseph are too much alike. I'd be OK with either Slade or Teo at 12 and then either of the other two at 13. Just which one would likely be dictated by the available wings. With Nowell out and Watson probably at 15 then it would be Daly on the wing.
