World rugby 15
-
Form based on last 12 months. Presumes everyone's fit - I wouldn't know .
15 - BFA
14 - Boffelli
13 - Davies
12 - Farrell
11 - Ioane
10 - GoldenBalls
9 - After David
8 - Read
7 - Cane
6 - POM
5 - Whitelock
4 - POTY 2018
3 - Furlong
2 - Marx
1 - Moody23 - ALB
22 - DMac
21 - Genia
20 - Leguizamon
19 - Etzebeth
18 -
17 -
16 - TaylorPick your own reserve props, my team would beat all comers.
@antipodean said in World rugby 15:
Form based on last 12 months. Presumes everyone's fit - I wouldn't know .
15 - BFA
14 - Boffelli
13 - Davies
12 - Farrell
11 - Ioane
10 - GoldenBalls
9 - After David
8 - Read
7 - Cane
6 - POM
5 - Whitelock
4 - POTY 2018
3 - Furlong
2 - Marx
1 - Moody23 - ALB
22 - DMac
21 - Genia
20 - Leguizamon
19 - Etzebeth
18 -
17 -
16 - TaylorPick your own reserve props, my team would beat all comers.
Leguizamon ? He is not even in the Jaguares starting XV ! Matera could be a better option on the bench.
-
Pfft
Easy peasy
15 Folau
14 Thomas
13 Ringrose
12 O Farrell
11 B Smith
10 Sexton
9 Genia
8 Read
7 Pocock
6 POM
5 Whitelock
4 Retallick
3 Furlong
2 Creevy
1 Moody16 Coles
17 Healy
18 Tui
19 Ryan
20 Nakawara
21 A Smith
22 Barrett
23 E Daly@derm-mccrum said in World rugby 15:
Pfft
Easy peasy
15 Folau
14 Thomas
13 Ringrose
12 O Farrell
11 B Smith
10 Sexton
9 Genia
8 Read
7 Pocock
6 POM
5 Whitelock
4 Retallick
3 Furlong
2 Creevy
1 Moody16 Coles
17 Healy
18 Tui
19 Ryan
20 Nakawara
21 A Smith
22 Barrett
23 E DalyThomas ? Are you serious ? This guy does not know how to defend and runs sometimes like a headless chicken (please watch the ERC 2018 cup final against Leinster). I reckon he has serious wheels but there are far better right wings on the international scene.
-
@nepia said in World rugby 15:
@derm-mccrum said in World rugby 15:
@nepia said in World rugby 15:
@kiwimurph said in World rugby 15:
@derm-mccrum No Rieko in the 23 at all? At the very least I'd suggest Rieko would make the 23 jersey as Barrett and Ben Smith can cover fullback.
I'd suggest that Reiko would make the 11 jersey considering he's the premier wing in the world and as far as I know Ben Smith has never played on the left?
In MY team, I expect players to try things they’ve never done before...
Sexton must be shitting himself worrying about having to run with the ball.
He’s used to that by now.
@derm-mccrum what shitting himself.
-
I'd play Beauden Barrett at 15, allowing him to come up to first receiver a lot. The best of both worlds. Murray can take the exit plays, moves etc, but Beauden comes in if he sees a hole.
I want a goalkicker somewhere in the team, and Beauden isn't it.
@chester-draws said in World rugby 15:
I'd play Beauden Barrett at 15, allowing him to come up to first receiver a lot. The best of both worlds. Murray can take the exit plays, moves etc, but Beauden comes in if he sees a hole.
I want a goalkicker somewhere in the team, and Beauden isn't it.
When did we start using bogan ball terms, first receiver. 1st 5 or stand off please.
-
- Moody
- Marx
- Furlong
- Brodie the goat
- Whitelock
- POM
- ?
- Read
- Smith
- Barrett
- Rieko
- ?
- ?
- ?
- Smith
-
@chester-draws said in World rugby 15:
I'd play Beauden Barrett at 15, allowing him to come up to first receiver a lot. The best of both worlds. Murray can take the exit plays, moves etc, but Beauden comes in if he sees a hole.
I want a goalkicker somewhere in the team, and Beauden isn't it.
When did we start using bogan ball terms, first receiver. 1st 5 or stand off please.
@wreck-diver said in World rugby 15:
@chester-draws said in World rugby 15:
I'd play Beauden Barrett at 15, allowing him to come up to first receiver a lot. The best of both worlds. Murray can take the exit plays, moves etc, but Beauden comes in if he sees a hole.
I want a goalkicker somewhere in the team, and Beauden isn't it.
When did we start using bogan ball terms, first receiver. 1st 5 or stand off please.
Pot, kettle
-
Post your guys actual 15s to see what you do instead of just picking the odd players you’d take out
-
Post your guys actual 15s to see what you do instead of just picking the odd players you’d take out
@yeahtheboys said in World rugby 15:
Post your guys actual 15s to see what you do instead of just picking the odd players you’d take out
But that's so much easier
-
@wreck-diver said in World rugby 15:
@chester-draws said in World rugby 15:
I'd play Beauden Barrett at 15, allowing him to come up to first receiver a lot. The best of both worlds. Murray can take the exit plays, moves etc, but Beauden comes in if he sees a hole.
I want a goalkicker somewhere in the team, and Beauden isn't it.
When did we start using bogan ball terms, first receiver. 1st 5 or stand off please.
Pot, kettle
@booboo said in World rugby 15:
@wreck-diver said in World rugby 15:
@chester-draws said in World rugby 15:
I'd play Beauden Barrett at 15, allowing him to come up to first receiver a lot. The best of both worlds. Murray can take the exit plays, moves etc, but Beauden comes in if he sees a hole.
I want a goalkicker somewhere in the team, and Beauden isn't it.
When did we start using bogan ball terms, first receiver. 1st 5 or stand off please.
Pot, kettle
Sorry I meant to write fly half, but its to late now.
-
@yeahtheboys said in World rugby 15:
Post your guys actual 15s to see what you do instead of just picking the odd players you’d take out
But that's so much easier
@booboo fair point
-
@derm-mccrum what shitting himself.
@wreck-diver said in World rugby 15:
@derm-mccrum what shitting himself.
Someone already knocked that easy ball out of the park hours ago. Swinging at empty air is not a good look on here. You need to be on your toes.
-
Moody, Taylor, Franks, Whitelock, Barrett, Samu, Todd, Read....
-
@wreck-diver said in World rugby 15:
@derm-mccrum what shitting himself.
Someone already knocked that easy ball out of the park hours ago. Swinging at empty air is not a good look on here. You need to be on your toes.
@derm-mccrum said in World rugby 15:
@wreck-diver said in World rugby 15:
@derm-mccrum what shitting himself.
Someone already knocked that easy ball out of the park hours ago. Swinging at empty air is not a good look on here. You need to be on your toes.
Mate 'swinging at empty air' is what the Fern is about. We excel at it.
-
@wreck-diver said in World rugby 15:
@derm-mccrum what shitting himself.
Someone already knocked that easy ball out of the park hours ago. Swinging at empty air is not a good look on here. You need to be on your toes.
@derm-mccrum said in World rugby 15:
@wreck-diver said in World rugby 15:
@derm-mccrum what shitting himself.
Someone already knocked that easy ball out of the park hours ago. Swinging at empty air is not a good look on here. You need to be on your toes.
Neither is using logic.
-
Moody
Any of these : Taylor, Creevy, Marx, Guirado
Furlong
Retallick
Whitelock
Matera
Pocock
Read
Genia
Barrett
Ioane
Beale
Fofana
Watson
SmithSub :
Mtwawarira
Any of Taylor, Creevy and Marx
Franks (not sure of him as an impact player)
Etzebeth
Mafi
Smith
Sexton
Folau -
@chester-draws said in World rugby 15:
I'd play Beauden Barrett at 15, allowing him to come up to first receiver a lot. The best of both worlds. Murray can take the exit plays, moves etc, but Beauden comes in if he sees a hole.
What's the point if the ball is too slow coming to him?
@antipodean said in World rugby 15:
@chester-draws said in World rugby 15:
I'd play Beauden Barrett at 15, allowing him to come up to first receiver a lot. The best of both worlds. Murray can take the exit plays, moves etc, but Beauden comes in if he sees a hole.
What's the point if the ball is too slow coming to him?
Oops, not Murray, Sexton. Beauden at fullback, but with the option to come forward on attack.
Genia or Smith at halfback.
Every team needs a kicker.
-
Good to see everyone is coming round to my way of thinking.... :smiling_face_with_horns:
-
Universal selection of Moody.
Am I missing something?
Best in NZ but best in the world?
Come December we'll have a clearer idea I guess.
-
Universal selection of Moody.
Am I missing something?
Best in NZ but best in the world?
Come December we'll have a clearer idea I guess.
@mikethesnow said in World rugby 15:
Universal selection of Moody.
Am I missing something?
Best in NZ but best in the world?
Come December we'll have a clearer idea I guess.
I have to admit that I was surprised that everyone was rating him that high, although I'm unsure of the alternative standouts.
It comes down to style again though. Does best loosehead mean best scrummager? For some teams that's the criteria. For the ABs he needs to be able to run, draw and pass, make attack decisions etc -
Who else ?
Healy and McGrath share the position for Ireland. Both are solid but not world beaters.
Vunipola ? Very good in the loose but rather meh at scrum time and penalty magnet.
Mtawarira ? Goes missing after his first (very good) 30 minutes.
Evans ?
Very good in the loose but weak at scrum time.
Poirot ? Good at everything but nothing flashy.
Sio ? More than a journeyman but not much more.
Kitshoff ? Is rated behind Mtawarira by the SA selectors.
