Skip to content
  • Categories
Collapse

The Silver Fern

  • Tipping
  • Team Sheets
  • Highlights
  • Results
    • All Blacks

      Search every All Blacks Test. Filter results by year, opposition, location, venue, city and RWC stage

    • Super Rugby

      Search every Super Rugby since match 1996

    • NPC

      Search NPC results. Only first division matches from 1976-2005. All results from the 14 team competition (2006-present) are included

Black Caps v India

Scheduled Pinned Locked Moved Sports Talk
cricket
823 Posts 48 Posters 68.1k Views 3 Watching
  • Oldest to Newest
  • Newest to Oldest
  • Most Votes
Reply
  • Reply as topic
Log in to reply
This topic has been deleted. Only users with topic management privileges can see it.
  • canefanC Offline
    canefanC Offline
    canefan
    wrote on last edited by
    #724

    https://stuff.co.nz/sport/cricket/110474758/colin-munros-world-cup-spot-in-jeopardy-after-missing-cut-against-bangladesh

    Seems like Colin will be given limited chances to pad his stats and his CWC chances vs the bangles

    SneakdefreakS 1 Reply Last reply
    0
    • KiwiPieK Offline
      KiwiPieK Offline
      KiwiPie
      wrote on last edited by
      #725

      I don't think India should have recalled him - they couldn't know why the 3rd umpire had decided he was out. And I'm not sure what the umpires were conferring about - unless they were also talking to the 3rd umpire to clarify his decision.

      1 Reply Last reply
      0
      • BonesB Bones

        @booboo so Sharma tells Mitchell he's out and should leave the pitch, Mitchell says let's let the umpires decide. Thanks for explaining.

        boobooB Offline
        boobooB Offline
        booboo
        wrote on last edited by
        #726

        @Bones said in Black Caps v India:

        @booboo so Sharma tells Mitchell he's out and should leave the pitch, Mitchell says let's let the umpires decide. Thanks for explaining.

        So he was showing respect for the umpires? 🙂

        I still prefer my version.

        1 Reply Last reply
        0
        • CyclopsC Offline
          CyclopsC Offline
          Cyclops
          wrote on last edited by Cyclops
          #727

          Third umprie was Shaun Haig who played a reasonable number of seasons batting in the top order for Otago so I'm extra curious about the rationale he worked through, since as a batsman he'd be aware of how much more a poor decision given hurts than a poor not given decision.

          SmudgeS 1 Reply Last reply
          0
          • CyclopsC Cyclops

            Third umprie was Shaun Haig who played a reasonable number of seasons batting in the top order for Otago so I'm extra curious about the rationale he worked through, since as a batsman he'd be aware of how much more a poor decision given hurts than a poor not given decision.

            SmudgeS Offline
            SmudgeS Offline
            Smudge
            wrote on last edited by
            #728

            @Cyclops said in Black Caps v India:

            Third umprie was Shaun Haig who played a reasonable number of seasons batting in the top order for Otago so I'm extra curious about the rationale he worked through, since as a batsman he'd be aware of how much more a poor decision given hurts than a poor not given decision.

            Completely useless Fern link to fame - I played against Haig in his first senior game in Dunedin - he was only 15-16 or so and was appearing for Taieri having only played for The Taieri High School prior to that (which was not a cricketing school at all). I was a wise old 17-year-old at the time.

            It's fair to say he went a bit further than I did...

            BonesB MN5M 2 Replies Last reply
            5
            • SmudgeS Smudge

              @Cyclops said in Black Caps v India:

              Third umprie was Shaun Haig who played a reasonable number of seasons batting in the top order for Otago so I'm extra curious about the rationale he worked through, since as a batsman he'd be aware of how much more a poor decision given hurts than a poor not given decision.

              Completely useless Fern link to fame - I played against Haig in his first senior game in Dunedin - he was only 15-16 or so and was appearing for Taieri having only played for The Taieri High School prior to that (which was not a cricketing school at all). I was a wise old 17-year-old at the time.

              It's fair to say he went a bit further than I did...

              BonesB Offline
              BonesB Offline
              Bones
              wrote on last edited by Bones
              #729

              @Smudge kudos to him for making it out of Taieri. That's a whole other world.

              1 Reply Last reply
              1
              • SmudgeS Smudge

                @Cyclops said in Black Caps v India:

                Third umprie was Shaun Haig who played a reasonable number of seasons batting in the top order for Otago so I'm extra curious about the rationale he worked through, since as a batsman he'd be aware of how much more a poor decision given hurts than a poor not given decision.

                Completely useless Fern link to fame - I played against Haig in his first senior game in Dunedin - he was only 15-16 or so and was appearing for Taieri having only played for The Taieri High School prior to that (which was not a cricketing school at all). I was a wise old 17-year-old at the time.

                It's fair to say he went a bit further than I did...

                MN5M Offline
                MN5M Offline
                MN5
                wrote on last edited by
                #730

                @Smudge said in Black Caps v India:

                @Cyclops said in Black Caps v India:

                Third umprie was Shaun Haig who played a reasonable number of seasons batting in the top order for Otago so I'm extra curious about the rationale he worked through, since as a batsman he'd be aware of how much more a poor decision given hurts than a poor not given decision.

                Completely useless Fern link to fame - I played against Haig in his first senior game in Dunedin - he was only 15-16 or so and was appearing for Taieri having only played for The Taieri High School prior to that (which was not a cricketing school at all). I was a wise old 17-year-old at the time.

                It's fair to say he went a bit further than I did...

                When you have breakfast with Jerome Kaino, Liam Squire, Joe Moody and Damian McKenzie let us know. Otherwise keep your anecdotes to yourself.

                SmudgeS 1 Reply Last reply
                0
                • canefanC canefan

                  https://stuff.co.nz/sport/cricket/110474758/colin-munros-world-cup-spot-in-jeopardy-after-missing-cut-against-bangladesh

                  Seems like Colin will be given limited chances to pad his stats and his CWC chances vs the bangles

                  SneakdefreakS Offline
                  SneakdefreakS Offline
                  Sneakdefreak
                  wrote on last edited by
                  #731

                  @canefan said in Black Caps v India:

                  https://stuff.co.nz/sport/cricket/110474758/colin-munros-world-cup-spot-in-jeopardy-after-missing-cut-against-bangladesh

                  Seems like Colin will be given limited chances to pad his stats and his CWC chances vs the bangles

                  So it seems the players locked in for the CWC are:

                  1. Kane Williamson
                  2. Todd Astle
                  3. Trent Boult
                  4. Colin de Grandhomme
                  5. Lockie Ferguson
                  6. Martin Guptill
                  7. Matt Henry
                  8. Tom Latham
                  9. Jimmy Neesham
                  10. Henry Nicholls
                  11. Ross Taylor
                  12. Mitchell Santner
                  13. Tim Southee

                  Means two spots left and you have to think Sodhi will be one of the two. So Colin Munro, Tim Seifert, Will Young and possibly Corey Anderson to fight it out for the last spot.

                  1 Reply Last reply
                  0
                  • MN5M MN5

                    @Smudge said in Black Caps v India:

                    @Cyclops said in Black Caps v India:

                    Third umprie was Shaun Haig who played a reasonable number of seasons batting in the top order for Otago so I'm extra curious about the rationale he worked through, since as a batsman he'd be aware of how much more a poor decision given hurts than a poor not given decision.

                    Completely useless Fern link to fame - I played against Haig in his first senior game in Dunedin - he was only 15-16 or so and was appearing for Taieri having only played for The Taieri High School prior to that (which was not a cricketing school at all). I was a wise old 17-year-old at the time.

                    It's fair to say he went a bit further than I did...

                    When you have breakfast with Jerome Kaino, Liam Squire, Joe Moody and Damian McKenzie let us know. Otherwise keep your anecdotes to yourself.

                    SmudgeS Offline
                    SmudgeS Offline
                    Smudge
                    wrote on last edited by
                    #732

                    @MN5 said in Black Caps v India:

                    @Smudge said in Black Caps v India:

                    @Cyclops said in Black Caps v India:

                    Third umprie was Shaun Haig who played a reasonable number of seasons batting in the top order for Otago so I'm extra curious about the rationale he worked through, since as a batsman he'd be aware of how much more a poor decision given hurts than a poor not given decision.

                    Completely useless Fern link to fame - I played against Haig in his first senior game in Dunedin - he was only 15-16 or so and was appearing for Taieri having only played for The Taieri High School prior to that (which was not a cricketing school at all). I was a wise old 17-year-old at the time.

                    It's fair to say he went a bit further than I did...

                    When you have breakfast with Jerome Kaino, Liam Squire, Joe Moody and Damian McKenzie let us know. Otherwise keep your anecdotes to yourself.

                    Ben Smith was the owner of my house two owners before me. I asked him about it after a Highlanders game in Melbourne, and he confirmed that was the case. Still probably the strangest question he's ever been asked by a fan post-match.

                    MN5M 1 Reply Last reply
                    5
                    • SmudgeS Smudge

                      @MN5 said in Black Caps v India:

                      @Smudge said in Black Caps v India:

                      @Cyclops said in Black Caps v India:

                      Third umprie was Shaun Haig who played a reasonable number of seasons batting in the top order for Otago so I'm extra curious about the rationale he worked through, since as a batsman he'd be aware of how much more a poor decision given hurts than a poor not given decision.

                      Completely useless Fern link to fame - I played against Haig in his first senior game in Dunedin - he was only 15-16 or so and was appearing for Taieri having only played for The Taieri High School prior to that (which was not a cricketing school at all). I was a wise old 17-year-old at the time.

                      It's fair to say he went a bit further than I did...

                      When you have breakfast with Jerome Kaino, Liam Squire, Joe Moody and Damian McKenzie let us know. Otherwise keep your anecdotes to yourself.

                      Ben Smith was the owner of my house two owners before me. I asked him about it after a Highlanders game in Melbourne, and he confirmed that was the case. Still probably the strangest question he's ever been asked by a fan post-match.

                      MN5M Offline
                      MN5M Offline
                      MN5
                      wrote on last edited by MN5
                      #733

                      @Smudge said in Black Caps v India:

                      @MN5 said in Black Caps v India:

                      @Smudge said in Black Caps v India:

                      @Cyclops said in Black Caps v India:

                      Third umprie was Shaun Haig who played a reasonable number of seasons batting in the top order for Otago so I'm extra curious about the rationale he worked through, since as a batsman he'd be aware of how much more a poor decision given hurts than a poor not given decision.

                      Completely useless Fern link to fame - I played against Haig in his first senior game in Dunedin - he was only 15-16 or so and was appearing for Taieri having only played for The Taieri High School prior to that (which was not a cricketing school at all). I was a wise old 17-year-old at the time.

                      It's fair to say he went a bit further than I did...

                      When you have breakfast with Jerome Kaino, Liam Squire, Joe Moody and Damian McKenzie let us know. Otherwise keep your anecdotes to yourself.

                      Ben Smith was the owner of my house two owners before me. I asked him about it after a Highlanders game in Melbourne, and he confirmed that was the case. Still probably the strangest question he's ever been asked by a fan post-match.

                      Marty Berry sold my folks a house a few years back in the rapa but I can't beat that Ben Smith anecdote.

                      Back to the cricket I think that team of @Sneakdefreak s is spot on. There is enough genuine class to go very far in the tournament if things click.

                      Despite the fern hatred for Colin Munro none of the guys battling for the last spot are terrible players. It's a good spot to be in.

                      G 1 Reply Last reply
                      0
                      • MN5M MN5

                        @Smudge said in Black Caps v India:

                        @MN5 said in Black Caps v India:

                        @Smudge said in Black Caps v India:

                        @Cyclops said in Black Caps v India:

                        Third umprie was Shaun Haig who played a reasonable number of seasons batting in the top order for Otago so I'm extra curious about the rationale he worked through, since as a batsman he'd be aware of how much more a poor decision given hurts than a poor not given decision.

                        Completely useless Fern link to fame - I played against Haig in his first senior game in Dunedin - he was only 15-16 or so and was appearing for Taieri having only played for The Taieri High School prior to that (which was not a cricketing school at all). I was a wise old 17-year-old at the time.

                        It's fair to say he went a bit further than I did...

                        When you have breakfast with Jerome Kaino, Liam Squire, Joe Moody and Damian McKenzie let us know. Otherwise keep your anecdotes to yourself.

                        Ben Smith was the owner of my house two owners before me. I asked him about it after a Highlanders game in Melbourne, and he confirmed that was the case. Still probably the strangest question he's ever been asked by a fan post-match.

                        Marty Berry sold my folks a house a few years back in the rapa but I can't beat that Ben Smith anecdote.

                        Back to the cricket I think that team of @Sneakdefreak s is spot on. There is enough genuine class to go very far in the tournament if things click.

                        Despite the fern hatred for Colin Munro none of the guys battling for the last spot are terrible players. It's a good spot to be in.

                        G Offline
                        G Offline
                        Gunner
                        wrote on last edited by
                        #734

                        @MN5 don’t think it’s hatred of Munro, more a hatred of the fact he’s not scoring any bloody runs....

                        MN5M 1 Reply Last reply
                        2
                        • G Gunner

                          @MN5 don’t think it’s hatred of Munro, more a hatred of the fact he’s not scoring any bloody runs....

                          MN5M Offline
                          MN5M Offline
                          MN5
                          wrote on last edited by
                          #735

                          @Gunner said in Black Caps v India:

                          @MN5 don’t think it’s hatred of Munro, more a hatred of the fact he’s not scoring any bloody runs....

                          Yeah good point. You know what I mean.....

                          I still reckon he'll make the squad though and the selectors will point to his bowling as being part of the reasoning.

                          canefanC SiamS 2 Replies Last reply
                          0
                          • MN5M MN5

                            @Gunner said in Black Caps v India:

                            @MN5 don’t think it’s hatred of Munro, more a hatred of the fact he’s not scoring any bloody runs....

                            Yeah good point. You know what I mean.....

                            I still reckon he'll make the squad though and the selectors will point to his bowling as being part of the reasoning.

                            canefanC Offline
                            canefanC Offline
                            canefan
                            wrote on last edited by
                            #736

                            @MN5 said in Black Caps v India:

                            @Gunner said in Black Caps v India:

                            @MN5 don’t think it’s hatred of Munro, more a hatred of the fact he’s not scoring any bloody runs....

                            Yeah good point. You know what I mean.....

                            I still reckon he'll make the squad though and the selectors will point to his bowling as being part of the reasoning.

                            They've invested a lot of time in him, I think he'll make it too

                            1 Reply Last reply
                            0
                            • MN5M MN5

                              @Gunner said in Black Caps v India:

                              @MN5 don’t think it’s hatred of Munro, more a hatred of the fact he’s not scoring any bloody runs....

                              Yeah good point. You know what I mean.....

                              I still reckon he'll make the squad though and the selectors will point to his bowling as being part of the reasoning.

                              SiamS Offline
                              SiamS Offline
                              Siam
                              wrote on last edited by
                              #737

                              @MN5 said in Black Caps v India:

                              @Gunner said in Black Caps v India:

                              @MN5 don’t think it’s hatred of Munro, more a hatred of the fact he’s not scoring any bloody runs....

                              Yeah good point. You know what I mean.....

                              I still reckon he'll make the squad though and the selectors will point to his bowling experience as being part of the reasoning.

                              My thoughts, possibly Seifert for back up wicketkeeper even though his fucken poor at it.

                              World Cups need experience, or so it's always mentioned, which I believe is true

                              V 1 Reply Last reply
                              0
                              • mikedogzM Offline
                                mikedogzM Offline
                                mikedogz
                                wrote on last edited by
                                #738

                                https://www.nzherald.co.nz/sport/news/article.cfm?c_id=4&objectid=12202477

                                MN5M 1 Reply Last reply
                                0
                                • mikedogzM mikedogz

                                  https://www.nzherald.co.nz/sport/news/article.cfm?c_id=4&objectid=12202477

                                  MN5M Offline
                                  MN5M Offline
                                  MN5
                                  wrote on last edited by MN5
                                  #739

                                  @mikedogz said in Black Caps v India:

                                  https://www.nzherald.co.nz/sport/news/article.cfm?c_id=4&objectid=12202477

                                  I remember he got 50 odd batting at 11. He's no fucken Chris Martin that's for sure.

                                  DamoD Baron Silas GreenbackB 2 Replies Last reply
                                  0
                                  • SiamS Siam

                                    @MN5 said in Black Caps v India:

                                    @Gunner said in Black Caps v India:

                                    @MN5 don’t think it’s hatred of Munro, more a hatred of the fact he’s not scoring any bloody runs....

                                    Yeah good point. You know what I mean.....

                                    I still reckon he'll make the squad though and the selectors will point to his bowling experience as being part of the reasoning.

                                    My thoughts, possibly Seifert for back up wicketkeeper even though his fucken poor at it.

                                    World Cups need experience, or so it's always mentioned, which I believe is true

                                    V Offline
                                    V Offline
                                    Virgil
                                    wrote on last edited by
                                    #740

                                    @Siam said in Black Caps v India:

                                    @MN5 said in Black Caps v India:

                                    @Gunner said in Black Caps v India:

                                    @MN5 don’t think it’s hatred of Munro, more a hatred of the fact he’s not scoring any bloody runs....

                                    Yeah good point. You know what I mean.....

                                    I still reckon he'll make the squad though and the selectors will point to his bowling experience as being part of the reasoning.

                                    My thoughts, possibly Seifert for back up wicketkeeper even though his fucken poor at it.

                                    World Cups need experience, or so it's always mentioned, which I believe is true

                                    Yup where’s 2019s Grant Elliott?

                                    MN5M SneakdefreakS 2 Replies Last reply
                                    0
                                    • V Virgil

                                      @Siam said in Black Caps v India:

                                      @MN5 said in Black Caps v India:

                                      @Gunner said in Black Caps v India:

                                      @MN5 don’t think it’s hatred of Munro, more a hatred of the fact he’s not scoring any bloody runs....

                                      Yeah good point. You know what I mean.....

                                      I still reckon he'll make the squad though and the selectors will point to his bowling experience as being part of the reasoning.

                                      My thoughts, possibly Seifert for back up wicketkeeper even though his fucken poor at it.

                                      World Cups need experience, or so it's always mentioned, which I believe is true

                                      Yup where’s 2019s Grant Elliott?

                                      MN5M Offline
                                      MN5M Offline
                                      MN5
                                      wrote on last edited by MN5
                                      #741

                                      @Virgil said in Black Caps v India:

                                      @Siam said in Black Caps v India:

                                      @MN5 said in Black Caps v India:

                                      @Gunner said in Black Caps v India:

                                      @MN5 don’t think it’s hatred of Munro, more a hatred of the fact he’s not scoring any bloody runs....

                                      Yeah good point. You know what I mean.....

                                      I still reckon he'll make the squad though and the selectors will point to his bowling experience as being part of the reasoning.

                                      My thoughts, possibly Seifert for back up wicketkeeper even though his fucken poor at it.

                                      World Cups need experience, or so it's always mentioned, which I believe is true

                                      Yup where’s 2019s Grant Elliott?

                                      At the time I was so fucked off he took what I believed was the Neeshes spot. I was pleased to be proven wrong.

                                      I saw the jav at trentham last year ( free food and piss in the corporate lounge, ordinarily I'd rather have my teeth pulled than watch horse racing but free is free and I am Scottish ) and people were coming up to him and shaking his hand. Looks to be an absolute top joker.

                                      V 1 Reply Last reply
                                      0
                                      • MN5M MN5

                                        @Virgil said in Black Caps v India:

                                        @Siam said in Black Caps v India:

                                        @MN5 said in Black Caps v India:

                                        @Gunner said in Black Caps v India:

                                        @MN5 don’t think it’s hatred of Munro, more a hatred of the fact he’s not scoring any bloody runs....

                                        Yeah good point. You know what I mean.....

                                        I still reckon he'll make the squad though and the selectors will point to his bowling experience as being part of the reasoning.

                                        My thoughts, possibly Seifert for back up wicketkeeper even though his fucken poor at it.

                                        World Cups need experience, or so it's always mentioned, which I believe is true

                                        Yup where’s 2019s Grant Elliott?

                                        At the time I was so fucked off he took what I believed was the Neeshes spot. I was pleased to be proven wrong.

                                        I saw the jav at trentham last year ( free food and piss in the corporate lounge, ordinarily I'd rather have my teeth pulled than watch horse racing but free is free and I am Scottish ) and people were coming up to him and shaking his hand. Looks to be an absolute top joker.

                                        V Offline
                                        V Offline
                                        Virgil
                                        wrote on last edited by
                                        #742

                                        @MN5 said in Black Caps v India:

                                        @Virgil said in Black Caps v India:

                                        @Siam said in Black Caps v India:

                                        @MN5 said in Black Caps v India:

                                        @Gunner said in Black Caps v India:

                                        @MN5 don’t think it’s hatred of Munro, more a hatred of the fact he’s not scoring any bloody runs....

                                        Yeah good point. You know what I mean.....

                                        I still reckon he'll make the squad though and the selectors will point to his bowling experience as being part of the reasoning.

                                        My thoughts, possibly Seifert for back up wicketkeeper even though his fucken poor at it.

                                        World Cups need experience, or so it's always mentioned, which I believe is true

                                        Yup where’s 2019s Grant Elliott?

                                        At the time I was so fucked off he took what I believed was the Neeshes spot. I was pleased to be proven wrong.

                                        I saw the jav at trentham last year ( free food and piss in the corporate lounge, ordinarily I'd rather have my teeth pulled than watch horse racing but free is free and I am Scottish ) and people were coming up to him and shaking his hand. Looks to be an absolute top joker.

                                        Wouldn’t have been the first time you were wrong...

                                        MN5M 1 Reply Last reply
                                        1
                                        • V Virgil

                                          @MN5 said in Black Caps v India:

                                          @Virgil said in Black Caps v India:

                                          @Siam said in Black Caps v India:

                                          @MN5 said in Black Caps v India:

                                          @Gunner said in Black Caps v India:

                                          @MN5 don’t think it’s hatred of Munro, more a hatred of the fact he’s not scoring any bloody runs....

                                          Yeah good point. You know what I mean.....

                                          I still reckon he'll make the squad though and the selectors will point to his bowling experience as being part of the reasoning.

                                          My thoughts, possibly Seifert for back up wicketkeeper even though his fucken poor at it.

                                          World Cups need experience, or so it's always mentioned, which I believe is true

                                          Yup where’s 2019s Grant Elliott?

                                          At the time I was so fucked off he took what I believed was the Neeshes spot. I was pleased to be proven wrong.

                                          I saw the jav at trentham last year ( free food and piss in the corporate lounge, ordinarily I'd rather have my teeth pulled than watch horse racing but free is free and I am Scottish ) and people were coming up to him and shaking his hand. Looks to be an absolute top joker.

                                          Wouldn’t have been the first time you were wrong...

                                          MN5M Offline
                                          MN5M Offline
                                          MN5
                                          wrote on last edited by
                                          #743

                                          @Virgil said in Black Caps v India:

                                          @MN5 said in Black Caps v India:

                                          @Virgil said in Black Caps v India:

                                          @Siam said in Black Caps v India:

                                          @MN5 said in Black Caps v India:

                                          @Gunner said in Black Caps v India:

                                          @MN5 don’t think it’s hatred of Munro, more a hatred of the fact he’s not scoring any bloody runs....

                                          Yeah good point. You know what I mean.....

                                          I still reckon he'll make the squad though and the selectors will point to his bowling experience as being part of the reasoning.

                                          My thoughts, possibly Seifert for back up wicketkeeper even though his fucken poor at it.

                                          World Cups need experience, or so it's always mentioned, which I believe is true

                                          Yup where’s 2019s Grant Elliott?

                                          At the time I was so fucked off he took what I believed was the Neeshes spot. I was pleased to be proven wrong.

                                          I saw the jav at trentham last year ( free food and piss in the corporate lounge, ordinarily I'd rather have my teeth pulled than watch horse racing but free is free and I am Scottish ) and people were coming up to him and shaking his hand. Looks to be an absolute top joker.

                                          Wouldn’t have been the first time you were wrong...

                                          Or the last. Far from it but happy to admit it which is a trait some ferners could work on.

                                          1 Reply Last reply
                                          0
                                          Reply
                                          • Reply as topic
                                          Log in to reply
                                          • Oldest to Newest
                                          • Newest to Oldest
                                          • Most Votes


                                          • Login

                                          • Don't have an account? Register

                                          • Search
                                          • First post
                                            Last post
                                          0
                                          • Categories
                                          • Search