Skip to content
  • Categories
Collapse

The Silver Fern

  • Tipping
  • Team Sheets
  • Highlights
  • Results
    • All Blacks

      Search every All Blacks Test. Filter results by year, opposition, location, venue, city and RWC stage

    • Super Rugby

      Search every Super Rugby since match 1996

    • NPC

      Search NPC results. Only first division matches from 1976-2005. All results from the 14 team competition (2006-present) are included

All Blacks v France, 2021 NH Tour

Scheduled Pinned Locked Moved Rugby Matches
allblacksfrance
1.3k Posts 87 Posters 172.7k Views 3 Watching
  • Oldest to Newest
  • Newest to Oldest
  • Most Votes
Reply
  • Reply as topic
Log in to reply
This topic has been deleted. Only users with topic management privileges can see it.
  • juniorJ junior

    @victor-meldrew said in All Blacks v France, 2021 NH Tour:

    @kiwiwomble said in All Blacks v France, 2021 NH Tour:

    @stodders thats where we we get into the pure speculation territory

    whats more likely, a coach drills the team in the basics (passing, catching, tackling, which is where we're seeing a lot of deficiencies) and then these professional sportsmen just forget....or the coach is focusing on other aspects of the game (broken play, counter attack) leaving the players to get rusty at the basics

    i dont know, both seem a stupid idea but i get the feeling one of the two is happening

    I would have thought a professional player good enough to make the ABs would have the basics of tackling, passing and catching pretty much baked in and not need much drilling from an AB coach.

    If those skills are rusty, that's down to the coaches at the lower levels and the players themselves. I'm quite sure the likes of Nonu & Smith practised passing in their own time and set their own high standards and I'm sure plenty of todays player are the same.

    With respect, you’d be very wrong about that. About 2010 or so I had dinner with some friends and a newly capped AB happened to be there. We talked about him being new to the AB environmental and the difference with what he experienced with his Super franchise. He said the biggest difference was the amount of time they out into the basics - catching, passing, tackling, rucking, pushing in scrums, jumping in lineouts. He said in few short weeks in camp his basic skills had improved massively. Whereas at Super level the skills were almost assumed and a bit of afterthought, something they did as a bit of warmup before working on set piece moves and general patterns.

    Victor MeldrewV Offline
    Victor MeldrewV Offline
    Victor Meldrew
    wrote on last edited by Victor Meldrew
    #416

    @junior said in All Blacks v France, 2021 NH Tour:

    He said the biggest difference was the amount of time they out into the basics - catching, passing, tackling, rucking, pushing in scrums, jumping in lineouts. He said in few short weeks in camp his basic skills had improved massively. Whereas at Super level the skills were almost assumed and a bit of afterthought, something they did as a bit of warmup before working on set piece moves and general patterns.

    Then I'd suggest someone in the NZRFU should be asking bloody hard questions about the quality of coaching at Super Rugby level and how it feeds into and impacts the coaching and performance of the national team.

    KiwiwombleK KiwiMurphK 2 Replies Last reply
    4
    • Victor MeldrewV Victor Meldrew

      @junior said in All Blacks v France, 2021 NH Tour:

      He said the biggest difference was the amount of time they out into the basics - catching, passing, tackling, rucking, pushing in scrums, jumping in lineouts. He said in few short weeks in camp his basic skills had improved massively. Whereas at Super level the skills were almost assumed and a bit of afterthought, something they did as a bit of warmup before working on set piece moves and general patterns.

      Then I'd suggest someone in the NZRFU should be asking bloody hard questions about the quality of coaching at Super Rugby level and how it feeds into and impacts the coaching and performance of the national team.

      KiwiwombleK Offline
      KiwiwombleK Offline
      Kiwiwomble
      wrote on last edited by
      #417

      @victor-meldrew said in All Blacks v France, 2021 NH Tour:

      @junior said in All Blacks v France, 2021 NH Tour:

      He said the biggest difference was the amount of time they out into the basics - catching, passing, tackling, rucking, pushing in scrums, jumping in lineouts. He said in few short weeks in camp his basic skills had improved massively. Whereas at Super level the skills were almost assumed and a bit of afterthought, something they did as a bit of warmup before working on set piece moves and general patterns.

      Then I'd suggest someone in the NZRFU should be asking bloody hard questions about the quality of coaching at Super Rugby level and how it feeds into and impacts the coaching and performance of the national team.

      agreed, i know it was my point originally that they should be working on these aspects thats have been failing, but it would be a huge concern if they are doing MORE on the basics in an AB camp than in the MONTHS they are with their super teams

      1 Reply Last reply
      0
      • Victor MeldrewV Victor Meldrew

        @junior said in All Blacks v France, 2021 NH Tour:

        He said the biggest difference was the amount of time they out into the basics - catching, passing, tackling, rucking, pushing in scrums, jumping in lineouts. He said in few short weeks in camp his basic skills had improved massively. Whereas at Super level the skills were almost assumed and a bit of afterthought, something they did as a bit of warmup before working on set piece moves and general patterns.

        Then I'd suggest someone in the NZRFU should be asking bloody hard questions about the quality of coaching at Super Rugby level and how it feeds into and impacts the coaching and performance of the national team.

        KiwiMurphK Offline
        KiwiMurphK Offline
        KiwiMurph
        wrote on last edited by
        #418

        @victor-meldrew said in All Blacks v France, 2021 NH Tour:

        @junior said in All Blacks v France, 2021 NH Tour:

        He said the biggest difference was the amount of time they out into the basics - catching, passing, tackling, rucking, pushing in scrums, jumping in lineouts. He said in few short weeks in camp his basic skills had improved massively. Whereas at Super level the skills were almost assumed and a bit of afterthought, something they did as a bit of warmup before working on set piece moves and general patterns.

        Then I'd suggest someone in the NZRFU should be asking bloody hard questions about the quality of coaching at Super Rugby level and how it feeds into and impacts the coaching and performance of the national team.

        That was over a decade ago if that was from 2010.

        2010 was back when Foster was coaching the Chiefs so of course the skills were lacking at Super level.......:fishing_pole:

        1 Reply Last reply
        8
        • gt12G Offline
          gt12G Offline
          gt12
          wrote on last edited by
          #419

          A bit of a tale of two stories - one for the backs, where everyone paid for their errors (to the extent that injuries permit), but in the forwards it seems like they still want to trust some old heads but punish/rest a few.

          • Taylor pays with his spot, despite being probably the best of the three starting front row
          • Brodie gets another chance, thus Vaa'ii may be just as likely to not take the field
          • Paps and Blackadder pay for doing their jobs, and the player who put in the least effort of the three gets rewarded with another test
          • Frizell gets bought in to bring a big body, despite having almost zero rugby, and we've not seen him be the type of player who makes an instant impact (or much impact at all)

          I don't think we'll end the year with any better idea of what our best team is, compared to before rugby kicked off in February. That says something.

          antipodeanA ARHSA 2 Replies Last reply
          4
          • NepiaN Offline
            NepiaN Offline
            Nepia
            wrote on last edited by
            #420

            Bridge and Frizell? WTF. Hope Bridge has a good game. Hope Frizell trips on a pothole in the warmups and injures himself out of the game.

            Also, odd that Weber is recovered enough to be on the bench.

            1 Reply Last reply
            2
            • gt12G gt12

              A bit of a tale of two stories - one for the backs, where everyone paid for their errors (to the extent that injuries permit), but in the forwards it seems like they still want to trust some old heads but punish/rest a few.

              • Taylor pays with his spot, despite being probably the best of the three starting front row
              • Brodie gets another chance, thus Vaa'ii may be just as likely to not take the field
              • Paps and Blackadder pay for doing their jobs, and the player who put in the least effort of the three gets rewarded with another test
              • Frizell gets bought in to bring a big body, despite having almost zero rugby, and we've not seen him be the type of player who makes an instant impact (or much impact at all)

              I don't think we'll end the year with any better idea of what our best team is, compared to before rugby kicked off in February. That says something.

              antipodeanA Offline
              antipodeanA Offline
              antipodean
              wrote on last edited by
              #421

              @gt12 said in All Blacks v France, 2021 NH Tour:

              A bit of a tale of two stories - one for the backs, where everyone paid for their errors (to the extent that injuries permit), but in the forwards it seems like they still want to trust some old heads but punish/rest a few.

              • Taylor pays with his spot, despite being probably the best of the three starting front row
              • Brodie gets another chance, thus Vaa'ii may be just as likely to not take the field
              • Paps and Blackadder pay for doing their jobs, and the player who put in the least effort of the three gets rewarded with another test
              • Frizell gets bought in to bring a big body, despite having almost zero rugby, and we've not seen him be the type of player who makes an instant impact (or much impact at all)

              I don't think we'll end the year with any better idea of what our best team is, compared to before rugby kicked off in February. That says something.

              I'd suggest a big part of that is the nature of this year's congested fixture list. They'd have to have managed workloads in the camp to get through two blocks of five Tests in a row.

              FWIW given injuries and workloads, I'd say this is pretty close to the best team they can put out. Paps must be sore and tired now given his efforts this far. Vaa'i needs to continue his managed introduction to get more accuracy. Taylor started the season well and has dropped off so it makes sense to me that you'd replace him with a fit Dane.

              mariner4lifeM gt12G 2 Replies Last reply
              1
              • antipodeanA antipodean

                @gt12 said in All Blacks v France, 2021 NH Tour:

                A bit of a tale of two stories - one for the backs, where everyone paid for their errors (to the extent that injuries permit), but in the forwards it seems like they still want to trust some old heads but punish/rest a few.

                • Taylor pays with his spot, despite being probably the best of the three starting front row
                • Brodie gets another chance, thus Vaa'ii may be just as likely to not take the field
                • Paps and Blackadder pay for doing their jobs, and the player who put in the least effort of the three gets rewarded with another test
                • Frizell gets bought in to bring a big body, despite having almost zero rugby, and we've not seen him be the type of player who makes an instant impact (or much impact at all)

                I don't think we'll end the year with any better idea of what our best team is, compared to before rugby kicked off in February. That says something.

                I'd suggest a big part of that is the nature of this year's congested fixture list. They'd have to have managed workloads in the camp to get through two blocks of five Tests in a row.

                FWIW given injuries and workloads, I'd say this is pretty close to the best team they can put out. Paps must be sore and tired now given his efforts this far. Vaa'i needs to continue his managed introduction to get more accuracy. Taylor started the season well and has dropped off so it makes sense to me that you'd replace him with a fit Dane.

                mariner4lifeM Offline
                mariner4lifeM Offline
                mariner4life
                wrote on last edited by
                #422

                @antipodean said in All Blacks v France, 2021 NH Tour:

                @gt12 said in All Blacks v France, 2021 NH Tour:

                A bit of a tale of two stories - one for the backs, where everyone paid for their errors (to the extent that injuries permit), but in the forwards it seems like they still want to trust some old heads but punish/rest a few.

                • Taylor pays with his spot, despite being probably the best of the three starting front row
                • Brodie gets another chance, thus Vaa'ii may be just as likely to not take the field
                • Paps and Blackadder pay for doing their jobs, and the player who put in the least effort of the three gets rewarded with another test
                • Frizell gets bought in to bring a big body, despite having almost zero rugby, and we've not seen him be the type of player who makes an instant impact (or much impact at all)

                I don't think we'll end the year with any better idea of what our best team is, compared to before rugby kicked off in February. That says something.

                I'd suggest a big part of that is the nature of this year's congested fixture list. They'd have to have managed workloads in the camp to get through two blocks of five Tests in a row.

                FWIW given injuries and workloads, I'd say this is pretty close to the best team they can put out. Paps must be sore and tired now given his efforts this far. Vaa'i needs to continue his managed introduction to get more accuracy. Taylor started the season well and has dropped off so it makes sense to me that you'd replace him with a fit Dane.

                i was winding myself up to just kick off but

                you look at that side, and a fair bit screams "this is who we have left".

                I'm still so pissed Savea is the one guy who can't be dropped despite being fucking average
                Frizzell is a fucking joke selection.
                I'm completely over DMac in the team, but that loops back to "who is left"
                George Bridge? jesus.

                Couple of guys in teh tight 5 very lucky that there is literally no one else.

                Just play hard and straight boys, please?

                antipodeanA 1 Reply Last reply
                6
                • mariner4lifeM mariner4life

                  @antipodean said in All Blacks v France, 2021 NH Tour:

                  @gt12 said in All Blacks v France, 2021 NH Tour:

                  A bit of a tale of two stories - one for the backs, where everyone paid for their errors (to the extent that injuries permit), but in the forwards it seems like they still want to trust some old heads but punish/rest a few.

                  • Taylor pays with his spot, despite being probably the best of the three starting front row
                  • Brodie gets another chance, thus Vaa'ii may be just as likely to not take the field
                  • Paps and Blackadder pay for doing their jobs, and the player who put in the least effort of the three gets rewarded with another test
                  • Frizell gets bought in to bring a big body, despite having almost zero rugby, and we've not seen him be the type of player who makes an instant impact (or much impact at all)

                  I don't think we'll end the year with any better idea of what our best team is, compared to before rugby kicked off in February. That says something.

                  I'd suggest a big part of that is the nature of this year's congested fixture list. They'd have to have managed workloads in the camp to get through two blocks of five Tests in a row.

                  FWIW given injuries and workloads, I'd say this is pretty close to the best team they can put out. Paps must be sore and tired now given his efforts this far. Vaa'i needs to continue his managed introduction to get more accuracy. Taylor started the season well and has dropped off so it makes sense to me that you'd replace him with a fit Dane.

                  i was winding myself up to just kick off but

                  you look at that side, and a fair bit screams "this is who we have left".

                  I'm still so pissed Savea is the one guy who can't be dropped despite being fucking average
                  Frizzell is a fucking joke selection.
                  I'm completely over DMac in the team, but that loops back to "who is left"
                  George Bridge? jesus.

                  Couple of guys in teh tight 5 very lucky that there is literally no one else.

                  Just play hard and straight boys, please?

                  antipodeanA Offline
                  antipodeanA Offline
                  antipodean
                  wrote on last edited by
                  #423

                  @mariner4life said in All Blacks v France, 2021 NH Tour:

                  @antipodean said in All Blacks v France, 2021 NH Tour:

                  @gt12 said in All Blacks v France, 2021 NH Tour:

                  A bit of a tale of two stories - one for the backs, where everyone paid for their errors (to the extent that injuries permit), but in the forwards it seems like they still want to trust some old heads but punish/rest a few.

                  • Taylor pays with his spot, despite being probably the best of the three starting front row
                  • Brodie gets another chance, thus Vaa'ii may be just as likely to not take the field
                  • Paps and Blackadder pay for doing their jobs, and the player who put in the least effort of the three gets rewarded with another test
                  • Frizell gets bought in to bring a big body, despite having almost zero rugby, and we've not seen him be the type of player who makes an instant impact (or much impact at all)

                  I don't think we'll end the year with any better idea of what our best team is, compared to before rugby kicked off in February. That says something.

                  I'd suggest a big part of that is the nature of this year's congested fixture list. They'd have to have managed workloads in the camp to get through two blocks of five Tests in a row.

                  FWIW given injuries and workloads, I'd say this is pretty close to the best team they can put out. Paps must be sore and tired now given his efforts this far. Vaa'i needs to continue his managed introduction to get more accuracy. Taylor started the season well and has dropped off so it makes sense to me that you'd replace him with a fit Dane.

                  i was winding myself up to just kick off but

                  you look at that side, and a fair bit screams "this is who we have left".

                  I'm still so pissed Savea is the one guy who can't be dropped despite being fucking average
                  Frizzell is a fucking joke selection.
                  I'm completely over DMac in the team, but that loops back to "who is left"
                  George Bridge? jesus.

                  Preaching to the converted here.

                  1 Reply Last reply
                  2
                  • antipodeanA antipodean

                    @gt12 said in All Blacks v France, 2021 NH Tour:

                    A bit of a tale of two stories - one for the backs, where everyone paid for their errors (to the extent that injuries permit), but in the forwards it seems like they still want to trust some old heads but punish/rest a few.

                    • Taylor pays with his spot, despite being probably the best of the three starting front row
                    • Brodie gets another chance, thus Vaa'ii may be just as likely to not take the field
                    • Paps and Blackadder pay for doing their jobs, and the player who put in the least effort of the three gets rewarded with another test
                    • Frizell gets bought in to bring a big body, despite having almost zero rugby, and we've not seen him be the type of player who makes an instant impact (or much impact at all)

                    I don't think we'll end the year with any better idea of what our best team is, compared to before rugby kicked off in February. That says something.

                    I'd suggest a big part of that is the nature of this year's congested fixture list. They'd have to have managed workloads in the camp to get through two blocks of five Tests in a row.

                    FWIW given injuries and workloads, I'd say this is pretty close to the best team they can put out. Paps must be sore and tired now given his efforts this far. Vaa'i needs to continue his managed introduction to get more accuracy. Taylor started the season well and has dropped off so it makes sense to me that you'd replace him with a fit Dane.

                    gt12G Offline
                    gt12G Offline
                    gt12
                    wrote on last edited by
                    #424

                    @antipodean said in All Blacks v France, 2021 NH Tour:

                    @gt12 said in All Blacks v France, 2021 NH Tour:

                    A bit of a tale of two stories - one for the backs, where everyone paid for their errors (to the extent that injuries permit), but in the forwards it seems like they still want to trust some old heads but punish/rest a few.

                    • Taylor pays with his spot, despite being probably the best of the three starting front row
                    • Brodie gets another chance, thus Vaa'ii may be just as likely to not take the field
                    • Paps and Blackadder pay for doing their jobs, and the player who put in the least effort of the three gets rewarded with another test
                    • Frizell gets bought in to bring a big body, despite having almost zero rugby, and we've not seen him be the type of player who makes an instant impact (or much impact at all)

                    I don't think we'll end the year with any better idea of what our best team is, compared to before rugby kicked off in February. That says something.

                    I'd suggest a big part of that is the nature of this year's congested fixture list. They'd have to have managed workloads in the camp to get through two blocks of five Tests in a row.

                    FWIW given injuries and workloads, I'd say this is pretty close to the best team they can put out. Paps must be sore and tired now given his efforts this far. Vaa'i needs to continue his managed introduction to get more accuracy. Taylor started the season well and has dropped off so it makes sense to me that you'd replace him with a fit Dane.

                    I think it shows that they've picked too many players they don't seem to want to play - we've hardly seen Aumua, De Groot, Ta'avao, Ennor, Sotutu, and Lord (understandable).

                    So, this week we've gone back to future with Bridge when we could have gone with Ennor (conceivably, giving better 13 cover), and we're still yet to see opportunities for De Groot who might be our best young prop with ball in hand. We also don't see Sotutu or Jacobson, when this test would be the ideal one (if rest is needed) to put Ardie back on the bench where he belongs.

                    KirwanK BovidaeB 2 Replies Last reply
                    7
                    • gt12G gt12

                      @antipodean said in All Blacks v France, 2021 NH Tour:

                      @gt12 said in All Blacks v France, 2021 NH Tour:

                      A bit of a tale of two stories - one for the backs, where everyone paid for their errors (to the extent that injuries permit), but in the forwards it seems like they still want to trust some old heads but punish/rest a few.

                      • Taylor pays with his spot, despite being probably the best of the three starting front row
                      • Brodie gets another chance, thus Vaa'ii may be just as likely to not take the field
                      • Paps and Blackadder pay for doing their jobs, and the player who put in the least effort of the three gets rewarded with another test
                      • Frizell gets bought in to bring a big body, despite having almost zero rugby, and we've not seen him be the type of player who makes an instant impact (or much impact at all)

                      I don't think we'll end the year with any better idea of what our best team is, compared to before rugby kicked off in February. That says something.

                      I'd suggest a big part of that is the nature of this year's congested fixture list. They'd have to have managed workloads in the camp to get through two blocks of five Tests in a row.

                      FWIW given injuries and workloads, I'd say this is pretty close to the best team they can put out. Paps must be sore and tired now given his efforts this far. Vaa'i needs to continue his managed introduction to get more accuracy. Taylor started the season well and has dropped off so it makes sense to me that you'd replace him with a fit Dane.

                      I think it shows that they've picked too many players they don't seem to want to play - we've hardly seen Aumua, De Groot, Ta'avao, Ennor, Sotutu, and Lord (understandable).

                      So, this week we've gone back to future with Bridge when we could have gone with Ennor (conceivably, giving better 13 cover), and we're still yet to see opportunities for De Groot who might be our best young prop with ball in hand. We also don't see Sotutu or Jacobson, when this test would be the ideal one (if rest is needed) to put Ardie back on the bench where he belongs.

                      KirwanK Offline
                      KirwanK Offline
                      Kirwan
                      wrote on last edited by
                      #425

                      @gt12 said in All Blacks v France, 2021 NH Tour:

                      @antipodean said in All Blacks v France, 2021 NH Tour:

                      @gt12 said in All Blacks v France, 2021 NH Tour:

                      A bit of a tale of two stories - one for the backs, where everyone paid for their errors (to the extent that injuries permit), but in the forwards it seems like they still want to trust some old heads but punish/rest a few.

                      • Taylor pays with his spot, despite being probably the best of the three starting front row
                      • Brodie gets another chance, thus Vaa'ii may be just as likely to not take the field
                      • Paps and Blackadder pay for doing their jobs, and the player who put in the least effort of the three gets rewarded with another test
                      • Frizell gets bought in to bring a big body, despite having almost zero rugby, and we've not seen him be the type of player who makes an instant impact (or much impact at all)

                      I don't think we'll end the year with any better idea of what our best team is, compared to before rugby kicked off in February. That says something.

                      I'd suggest a big part of that is the nature of this year's congested fixture list. They'd have to have managed workloads in the camp to get through two blocks of five Tests in a row.

                      FWIW given injuries and workloads, I'd say this is pretty close to the best team they can put out. Paps must be sore and tired now given his efforts this far. Vaa'i needs to continue his managed introduction to get more accuracy. Taylor started the season well and has dropped off so it makes sense to me that you'd replace him with a fit Dane.

                      I think it shows that they've picked too many players they don't seem to want to play - we've hardly seen Aumua, De Groot, Ta'avao, Ennor, Sotutu, and Lord (understandable).

                      So, this week we've gone back to future with Bridge when we could have gone with Ennor (conceivably, giving better 13 cover), and we're still yet to see opportunities for De Groot who might be our best young prop with ball in hand. We also don't see Sotutu or Jacobson, when this test would be the ideal one (if rest is needed) to put Ardie back on the bench where he belongs.

                      Ennor on the wing is a good call. Get him used to Test rugby so he can be a centre option (he's a million miles away at the moment).

                      Bridge is a failure at Test level and it's a waste of a spot. Problem solves itself when Clarke comes back next year, but for this weekend going back to Bridge just means no attack from his wing.

                      N 1 Reply Last reply
                      2
                      • P pakman

                        @frye said in All Blacks v France, 2021 NH Tour:

                        https://www.instagram.com/p/CWbFIndvqQ6/?utm_medium=copy_link

                        Bugger me, about twenty minutes ago I had the thought, 'Have TWM abandonded the idea of Bridge as the 'reliable' wing'?!

                        Pretty tough on Paps!!!!

                        TJP and Reece didn't survive review of Irish match.

                        Can only assume Frizell there to allow extra physicality in last 20, if required.

                        Overall fairly happy with team.

                        FrankF Offline
                        FrankF Offline
                        Frank
                        wrote on last edited by
                        #426

                        @pakman said in All Blacks v France, 2021 NH Tour:

                        Can only assume Frizell there to allow extra physicality in last 20, if required.

                        LOL

                        KirwanK 1 Reply Last reply
                        6
                        • FrankF Frank

                          @pakman said in All Blacks v France, 2021 NH Tour:

                          Can only assume Frizell there to allow extra physicality in last 20, if required.

                          LOL

                          KirwanK Offline
                          KirwanK Offline
                          Kirwan
                          wrote on last edited by
                          #427

                          @frank said in All Blacks v France, 2021 NH Tour:

                          @pakman said in All Blacks v France, 2021 NH Tour:

                          Can only assume Frizell there to allow extra physicality in last 20, if required.

                          LOL

                          Could tell him that the French identify as women? Will get pretty physical then.

                          1 Reply Last reply
                          5
                          • gt12G gt12

                            A bit of a tale of two stories - one for the backs, where everyone paid for their errors (to the extent that injuries permit), but in the forwards it seems like they still want to trust some old heads but punish/rest a few.

                            • Taylor pays with his spot, despite being probably the best of the three starting front row
                            • Brodie gets another chance, thus Vaa'ii may be just as likely to not take the field
                            • Paps and Blackadder pay for doing their jobs, and the player who put in the least effort of the three gets rewarded with another test
                            • Frizell gets bought in to bring a big body, despite having almost zero rugby, and we've not seen him be the type of player who makes an instant impact (or much impact at all)

                            I don't think we'll end the year with any better idea of what our best team is, compared to before rugby kicked off in February. That says something.

                            ARHSA Offline
                            ARHSA Offline
                            ARHS
                            wrote on last edited by
                            #428

                            @gt12 Are you being serious with those charges? Just looks like the whole squad is being managed through a long arduous program and opportunities given on merit for the commitment made and rest given where required. The rotation seems largely planned around who the opposition is and not about playing the supposed top xv each week regardless of circumstances.
                            If you are serious then I would hate to be in any squad you are involved in. Just flog your favourites and deny others opportunities when they are selected.
                            I don't care if we lose the odd match when we are building depth and combinations and giving fair opportunities to those selected to improve their experience in international conditions with different refereeing styles and constant hometown scrutiny of possible incidents while playing away from home and covid restrictions on the usual touring activities and distancing from friends and family.
                            So I totally disagree with the criticism of selections when this management crew has probably had the biggest challenge of the professional era in keeping the players motivated and unified as a team. Just witness the Lions tours issues with the dirt trackers for a comparison.

                            BonesB boobooB 2 Replies Last reply
                            1
                            • gt12G gt12

                              @antipodean said in All Blacks v France, 2021 NH Tour:

                              @gt12 said in All Blacks v France, 2021 NH Tour:

                              A bit of a tale of two stories - one for the backs, where everyone paid for their errors (to the extent that injuries permit), but in the forwards it seems like they still want to trust some old heads but punish/rest a few.

                              • Taylor pays with his spot, despite being probably the best of the three starting front row
                              • Brodie gets another chance, thus Vaa'ii may be just as likely to not take the field
                              • Paps and Blackadder pay for doing their jobs, and the player who put in the least effort of the three gets rewarded with another test
                              • Frizell gets bought in to bring a big body, despite having almost zero rugby, and we've not seen him be the type of player who makes an instant impact (or much impact at all)

                              I don't think we'll end the year with any better idea of what our best team is, compared to before rugby kicked off in February. That says something.

                              I'd suggest a big part of that is the nature of this year's congested fixture list. They'd have to have managed workloads in the camp to get through two blocks of five Tests in a row.

                              FWIW given injuries and workloads, I'd say this is pretty close to the best team they can put out. Paps must be sore and tired now given his efforts this far. Vaa'i needs to continue his managed introduction to get more accuracy. Taylor started the season well and has dropped off so it makes sense to me that you'd replace him with a fit Dane.

                              I think it shows that they've picked too many players they don't seem to want to play - we've hardly seen Aumua, De Groot, Ta'avao, Ennor, Sotutu, and Lord (understandable).

                              So, this week we've gone back to future with Bridge when we could have gone with Ennor (conceivably, giving better 13 cover), and we're still yet to see opportunities for De Groot who might be our best young prop with ball in hand. We also don't see Sotutu or Jacobson, when this test would be the ideal one (if rest is needed) to put Ardie back on the bench where he belongs.

                              BovidaeB Offline
                              BovidaeB Offline
                              Bovidae
                              wrote on last edited by
                              #429

                              @gt12 said in All Blacks v France, 2021 NH Tour:

                              I think it shows that they've picked too many players they don't seem to want to play - we've hardly seen Aumua, De Groot, Ta'avao, Ennor, Sotutu, and Lord (understandable).

                              For some of those players there seems to be a valid reason (from the outside). Aumua was originally selected as the 3rd hooker but has clearly been overtaken by Taukei’aho. The fact that Coles was taken on this tour meant 4 hookers was always going to be one too many once he joined the squad. Ta'avao has been injured in recent weeks so wasn't available for selection.

                              As I said, I would have picked de Groot for this test. Bower, like Ta'avao, seems to be a placeholder. Sotutu or Jacobson should have been on the bench instead of Frizell (who shouldn't be there to begin with) - that's on Foster and Plumtree.

                              1 Reply Last reply
                              4
                              • BerniesCornerB Offline
                                BerniesCornerB Offline
                                BerniesCorner
                                wrote on last edited by
                                #430

                                Sotutu or Jacobson havent had a fair go this tour. Both decent players

                                CrucialC ACT CrusaderA 2 Replies Last reply
                                9
                                • BerniesCornerB BerniesCorner

                                  Sotutu or Jacobson havent had a fair go this tour. Both decent players

                                  CrucialC Offline
                                  CrucialC Offline
                                  Crucial
                                  wrote on last edited by
                                  #431

                                  @berniescorner said in All Blacks v France, 2021 NH Tour:

                                  Sotutu or Jacobson havent had a fair go this tour. Both decent players

                                  Certainly not in comparison to others.

                                  1 Reply Last reply
                                  0
                                  • ChrisC Offline
                                    ChrisC Offline
                                    Chris
                                    wrote on last edited by
                                    #432

                                    And the headless chook circus act continues from this coaching staff.
                                    Fuck knows what this game brings, same game plan probably.
                                    Same Result as many other losses under this regime.

                                    boobooB 1 Reply Last reply
                                    0
                                    • A akan004

                                      KiwiMurphK Offline
                                      KiwiMurphK Offline
                                      KiwiMurph
                                      wrote on last edited by
                                      #433

                                      @akan004 said in All Blacks v France, 2021 NH Tour:

                                      I really don't understand the 'growth and development' of the team this season that Foster is talking about.

                                      What development? The attacking shape and defensive system look exactly the same with the same weaknesses.

                                      M No QuarterN 2 Replies Last reply
                                      8
                                      • KiwiMurphK KiwiMurph

                                        @akan004 said in All Blacks v France, 2021 NH Tour:

                                        I really don't understand the 'growth and development' of the team this season that Foster is talking about.

                                        What development? The attacking shape and defensive system look exactly the same with the same weaknesses.

                                        M Offline
                                        M Offline
                                        Machpants
                                        wrote on last edited by
                                        #434

                                        @kiwimurph said in All Blacks v France, 2021 NH Tour:

                                        @akan004 said in All Blacks v France, 2021 NH Tour:

                                        I really don't understand the 'growth and development' of the team this season that Foster is talking about.

                                        What development? The attacking shape and defensive system look exactly the same with the same weaknesses.

                                        They are in a bubble of mutual confirmation, the team seriously needs an outside/external review

                                        1 Reply Last reply
                                        5
                                        • KiwiMurphK KiwiMurph

                                          @akan004 said in All Blacks v France, 2021 NH Tour:

                                          I really don't understand the 'growth and development' of the team this season that Foster is talking about.

                                          What development? The attacking shape and defensive system look exactly the same with the same weaknesses.

                                          No QuarterN Offline
                                          No QuarterN Offline
                                          No Quarter
                                          wrote on last edited by
                                          #435

                                          @kiwimurph said in All Blacks v France, 2021 NH Tour:

                                          @akan004 said in All Blacks v France, 2021 NH Tour:

                                          I really don't understand the 'growth and development' of the team this season that Foster is talking about.

                                          What development? The attacking shape and defensive system look exactly the same with the same weaknesses.

                                          It did look like we were building nicely this year, with better selections and more physicality from the forwards. Up until we met the Boks, then we just reverted to type and put ourselves under all sorts of pressure. Then we saw the same against the Irish, except they were more clinical and exploited our weaknesses better.

                                          I was willing to cut Foster some slack for the first season which was badly disrupted, but it just doesn't seem like we have figured out how to play the more physical teams with the organised rush defense. It looks like Foster and co are somewhat out of ideas and are hoping we'll get over the line through individual brilliance more than anything.

                                          KiwiwombleK taniwharugbyT 2 Replies Last reply
                                          7
                                          Reply
                                          • Reply as topic
                                          Log in to reply
                                          • Oldest to Newest
                                          • Newest to Oldest
                                          • Most Votes


                                          • Login

                                          • Don't have an account? Register

                                          • Search
                                          • First post
                                            Last post
                                          0
                                          • Categories
                                          • Search