All Blacks MOTM v Argentina II
-
Staggering to think Taukieaho couldn't get a start against Ireland and then got dropped.
Best hooker in the world for me.
@Bones said in All Blacks MOTM v Argentina II:
Staggering to think Taukieaho couldn't get a start against Ireland and then got dropped.
Best hooker in the world for me.
Hard to think the results would not have been pretty different if he started all 3 tests. He has such an impact on any game he plays in. Would we have won? Who knows, but we would have been a damn sight better.
-
Hard choice this week as there was good stuff all over the park.
Slamming Sami stands out for his impact and doing the basics like lineout throwing right and David Havilli who was rock solid in midfield and gave Ritche & Reiko a great foundation. Third choice was Cane who played and captained well - may be a bit of a sympathy vote but he deserves one (tough on Ardie, I know, but his time will come...)
-
Hard choice this week as there was good stuff all over the park.
Slamming Sami stands out for his impact and doing the basics like lineout throwing right and David Havilli who was rock solid in midfield and gave Ritche & Reiko a great foundation. Third choice was Cane who played and captained well - may be a bit of a sympathy vote but he deserves one (tough on Ardie, I know, but his time will come...)
I thought Ardie Sami and Rieko were standouts but understand if Cane De Groot etc were picked.
-
Actually hard to pick 3 this week
Went for Savea, Whitelock, Sami T. All three trucked the ball up in close with great effect. Plus all the other stuff - tackles, clean outs, well functioning lineout,
Ioane and Cane very close behind.
De Groot the next best.
-
Cane
Ioane
SamiBloody hard audience here as far as Cane is concerned. He did exactly what people have been asking for all year. Lead by example in the tackle and was much more assertive in captaincy. Was important in keeping things focused for the game and sticking to the plans. I haven’t noticed so many intense talkings to the troops in a long time. Would lecture the forwards then run across and do the same to the backs. Huge performance.
Also, how can anyone not have Sami in their 3? Also did exactly what everyone has been demanding from our forwards and got us moving forward in every one of his carries.
Ioane for being able to add some flash.
Least effective player would have to be Jordan. Is he having a sulk or something?
-
Sami T - dude just looks like a man against boys and I don't get that weird icky feeling in my tummy when he's throwing to the lineout! Could it be ... accuracy!? Also he is fit as anything, massive engine.
Reiko
Cane just pipped Ardie as I felt like I saw some leadership out there alongside some big hits and smart play. -
voted earlier, about to go through the match thread. Cane, Rieko and ST for me. Ardie superb, but Cane played a dominant game. In the context of the pressure he's under, that was massive.
Awesome, dominant, high skill, high cohesion performance. Sensational.
-
This looks about right to me, but I would've given WJ a 5
https://www.rugbypass.com/news/all-blacks-player-ratings-vs-pumas-rugby-championship-2/
@Machpants said in All Blacks MOTM v Argentina II:
This looks about right to me, but I would've given WJ a 5
https://www.rugbypass.com/news/all-blacks-player-ratings-vs-pumas-rugby-championship-2/
Tougher rating system but if 7 is “played well” but not outstanding and 8 is a great game I am also not sure how Jordan is a 6.
5.5 maybe if I am generous. That’s on a rating of “did nothing wrong but didn’t add much” -
@Machpants said in All Blacks MOTM v Argentina II:
This looks about right to me, but I would've given WJ a 5
https://www.rugbypass.com/news/all-blacks-player-ratings-vs-pumas-rugby-championship-2/
Tougher rating system but if 7 is “played well” but not outstanding and 8 is a great game I am also not sure how Jordan is a 6.
5.5 maybe if I am generous. That’s on a rating of “did nothing wrong but didn’t add much” -
@Machpants said in All Blacks MOTM v Argentina II:
This looks about right to me, but I would've given WJ a 5
https://www.rugbypass.com/news/all-blacks-player-ratings-vs-pumas-rugby-championship-2/
Tougher rating system but if 7 is “played well” but not outstanding and 8 is a great game I am also not sure how Jordan is a 6.
5.5 maybe if I am generous. That’s on a rating of “did nothing wrong but didn’t add much” -
i went with Cane, Savea and ST
still not sure if one world class performance from our skipper every 5-6 games is worth it but cant argue he stepped up this time
-
i went with Cane, Savea and ST
still not sure if one world class performance from our skipper every 5-6 games is worth it but cant argue he stepped up this time
Did Cane but in a MOTM game if we don't consider the pressure he was under? Not sure about that, but he was bloody good. Would like to see more of that linking and running game again too.
-
Did Cane but in a MOTM game if we don't consider the pressure he was under? Not sure about that, but he was bloody good. Would like to see more of that linking and running game again too.
@nostrildamus i think he did, for every run savea made cane was putting in a big hit
