Brumbies v Crusaders

[African Monkey]

@Bones Haha great minds think alike.

[Bones]

@African-Monkey said in Brumbies v Crusaders:

@Bones It's the rule though.

SBW did it in a test against France in 2017 with no one near him but the rule is the rule, you can't do that.

The rule is it's a penalty try? No it's not.

[African Monkey]

@Bones If someone is near the ball and gets denied a chance to catch it then it is.

[nzzp]

Astonishingly the 2-10 Crusaders aren't out of the playoffs yet. They could get there with two wins.

[Damo]

I think it was a PK but a penalty try was a bit harsh. Can it really be said it prevented a "probable try"?

Likely depends on th definition of "probable".

To put my lawyer hat on I recall there was a Court of Appeal precedent about the meaning of probable in the context of murder. If I recall correctly the CA said it did not mean "more likely than not" but just a reasonable likelihood.

I digress.

Makes no difference because it would have been a PK in front of the posts and a loss anyway.

[Victor Meldrew]

I'm watching the interviews with two pantomime horses dancing in the background. Mrs M comes in, notices and asks if I've tuned to a kids channel...

[African Monkey]

Despite the last play, the Crusaders can feel annoyed after that shocking forward pass that Tom Wright threw was missed.

I thought I saw the Canes get away with some shockers last night, but that just took the piss.

[Bones]

@African-Monkey said in Brumbies v Crusaders:

@Bones If someone is near the ball and gets denied a chance to catch it then it is.

It might be somewhere in the laws, but that's not what happened.

[KiwiMurph]

@Victor-Meldrew said in Brumbies v Crusaders:

I'm watching the interviews with two pantomime horses dancing in the background. Mrs M comes in, notices and asks if I've tuned to a kids channel...

That's Brumby Jack and Brumby Jill

[sparky]

@Victor-Meldrew The pantomime horses could have done a better job than the Crusaders' coaching team this season.

[Chris B.]

Lots of endeavour laced with suicidal errors.

I'd sack Rob just because he's clearly not a lucky coach.

[African Monkey]

@Bones I thought it was a penalty try, Strange denied the Brumbies chaser a chance to get there by doing something completely illegal. A dumb play.

[Bones]

@African-Monkey said in Brumbies v Crusaders:

@Bones I thought it was a penalty try, Strange denied the Brumbies chaser a chance to get there by doing something completely illegal. A dumb play.

Watch the replay and what the chaser was trying to do (hint: he wasn't trying to catch it)

[SBW1]

Can we safely say the Saders chance for the final 8 are gone?

[Bones]

@SBW1 said in Brumbies v Crusaders:

Can we safely say the Saders chance for the final 8 are gone?

[Damo]

I don't think it was likely the Brumby would have caught it even if Strange. He may have but if I was a betting man I reckon he wouldn't.

On that basis I don't agree with the call. However can't argue with it too strongly either.

[nzzp]

@SBW1 said in Brumbies v Crusaders:

Can we safely say the Saders chance for the final 8 are gone?

No.

Two wins and the Drua not getting points and they get there.

Nuts eh

[Yeetyaah]

Just been leaked to me that Quinten Strange has been approached by the One New Zealand Warriors to swap codes effective immediately.

[KiwiMurph]

@nzzp said in Brumbies v Crusaders:

@SBW1 said in Brumbies v Crusaders:

Can we safely say the Saders chance for the final 8 are gone?

No.

Two wins and the Drua not getting points and they get there.

Nuts eh

Ironically even if that happened Drua would have 5 wins and Crusaders would have 4

[African Monkey]

@Bones Well he should have removed all doubt by not punching the ball dead, and if he does it with the Brumbies player that close to the ball which he did, he left the refs with no choice. It was a complete brain explosion.