• Categories
Collapse

The Silver Fern

C

cgrant

@cgrant
About
Posts
2.7k
Topics
51
Groups
1
Followers
0
Following
0

Posts

Recent Best Controversial

    NH Club Rugby
  • C cgrant

    French annual salaries in the Top 14 by position :

    LHP : 245 000 euros
    Hooker : 247 000 euros
    THP : 260 000 euros
    Lock 4 : 290 000 euros
    Lock 5 : 302 000 euros
    LF : 242 000 euros
    Nr. 8 : 296 000 euros
    Halfback : 261 000 euros
    1st Five : 343 000 euros
    Centres : 274 000 euros
    Wings : 223 000 euros
    Fullback : 251 000 euros


  • Exodus
  • C cgrant

    He is a good prop but not good enough for the current English squad IMO.


  • NH Club Rugby
  • C cgrant

    Tom Jordan is excellent at 1st Five for Bristol. How could his talent be ignored by NZ provincial teams ?


  • Hurricanes 2026
  • C cgrant

    @DurryMexted said in Hurricanes 2026:

    @Canes4life From the post looks like Zach Taulapapa is tagged. Wonder if hes a relation of Jack Taulapapa who played a fair bit of club footy in wellies and played for Samoa I

    He looks quite big for a winger !


  • Exodus
  • C cgrant

    @canefan
    It's for the 2026 - 2027 season. So yes, he still has the possibility to play for the All Blacks before August 2026. But usually, players who are leaving are not selected.


  • Exodus
  • C cgrant

    Sevu Reece has signed a three year contract with Perpignan (USAP) so the game against Wales was his last with the black jersey.


  • NH Club Rugby
  • C cgrant

    @OomPB
    Bayonne fielded a B-C team too.
    For those who haven't watched the Saracens vs Clermont game, Harry Plummer had a mare. From what I have seen, he could not have been the answer for the All Blacks at first five (meh kicking, weak tackling, kick directly into touch from a restart, unseen with ball in hand, standing still as a first receiver ...). But maybe it was an off-day for him.


  • NH Club Rugby
  • C cgrant

    @cgrant said in NH Club Rugby:

    @sparky said in NH Club Rugby:

    @Duluth From what I've seen he fits very much in the "club legend" model. A very good player but not world class.

    He's had the benefit of playing for France's and probably Europe's best team in recent years.

    When fit, he's been Toulouse's top choice 12 for about about seven years. He looked very good during Covid times. A mid-fielder in the Garry Ringrose model. A very good organiser who others like Dupont and Ntamack could play around. He's won five French Championships and two European Championship with Toulouse.

    That's said I can't remember him shining on a big occasion. He went off early in the 2024 European Cup Final and he's had a lot of injuries in the last 18 months.

    He's a solid signing for the Blues, especially as they will miss Reiko's calmness in midfield next year. But I don't expect him to play the house down.

    I agree. He rarely sets the world on fire but he is a good distributor, defends well and has a good vision of the game. At 31, after multiple injuries, he is on the downside IMO. He could be as valuable as Bryce Heems was a few years ago.

    downslide (not downside).


  • NH Club Rugby
  • C cgrant

    @sparky said in NH Club Rugby:

    @Duluth From what I've seen he fits very much in the "club legend" model. A very good player but not world class.

    He's had the benefit of playing for France's and probably Europe's best team in recent years.

    When fit, he's been Toulouse's top choice 12 for about about seven years. He looked very good during Covid times. A mid-fielder in the Garry Ringrose model. A very good organiser who others like Dupont and Ntamack could play around. He's won five French Championships and two European Championship with Toulouse.

    That's said I can't remember him shining on a big occasion. He went off early in the 2024 European Cup Final and he's had a lot of injuries in the last 18 months.

    He's a solid signing for the Blues, especially as they will miss Reiko's calmness in midfield next year. But I don't expect him to play the house down.

    I agree. He rarely sets the world on fire but he is a good distributor, defends well and has a good vision of the game. At 31, after multiple injuries, he is on the downside IMO. He could be as valuable as Bryce Heems was a few years ago.


  • 2025 The Silver Fern Team of the Year
  • C cgrant

    @Canes4life said in 2025 The Silver Fern Team of the Year:

    My 1st XV for the year:

    1. Ox Niche (South Africa)
    2. Malcolm Marx (South Africa)
    3. Thomas Du Toit (South Africa)
    4. Maro Itoje (England)
    5. RG Snyman (South Africa)
    6. Pieter Steph-Du Toit (South Africa)
    7. Pablo Matera (Argentina)
    8. Harry Wilson (Australia)
    9. Cam Roigard (New Zealand)
    10. Sacha Feinberg-Mngomezulu (South Africa)
    11. Louie Bielle-Biarrey (France)
    12. Len Ikitau (Australia)
    13. Huw Jones (Scotland)
    14. Cheslin Kolbe (South Africa)
    15. Damian Willemse (South Africa)

    Excellent team ! Maybe Earl or Wiese instead of Wilson.
    Here is my becnh :

    1. Sheahan (Ireland)
    2. Fischetti (Italy)
    3. Louw (SA)
    4. Holland (NZ)
    5. McReight (Australia)
    6. Gibson-Parkes (Ireland)
    7. Carreras (Argentina)
    8. Kriel (SA)

  • Chiefs 2026
  • C cgrant

    @Bovidae said in Chiefs 2026:

    These training jerseys look better.

    587144676_18543449407028148_1725585510825759236_n.jpg

    Who is the big guy on the left ?


  • France vs Australia
  • C cgrant

    @NTA said in France vs Australia:

    @cgrant said in France vs Australia:

    Wallabies not clinical enough. Two big try-scoring opportunities were wasted (Valetini dropping the ball and Tizzano with a stupid ruck clearing). Despite NTA's claims, I still think that the Wallabies depth or rather lack of depth is costing them dearly, especially up front. When Skelton is not there, their locks lack the required physicality at this level. They should look at Staniforth (Castres) who is a real enforcer, one of Top 14 best locks.

    One πŸ‘ player πŸ‘ is πŸ‘ not πŸ‘ a πŸ‘ Test πŸ‘ team πŸ‘

    Sure, but some of your players are not up to the task : you lack the necessary depth to find players who could be an upgrade. One player is not a test team but several better players can make things going better.


  • November International, England v Argies
  • C cgrant

    Argentina > All Blacks in 2025.


  • 2025 The Silver Fern Team of the Year
  • C cgrant

    @booboo said in 2025 The Silver Fern Team of the Year:

    Jet has posted some food for thought.

    @Jet said in All Blacks 2025:

    Screenshot 2025-11-23 at 20.12.35.png

    Damian Willemsee at 2nd Five ? De Allende and Esterhuizen are standing in front of him the Boks selection. Same with Tagh Beirne. He spent most of the season at lock, Ireland's blindside loose forward being Ryan Baird. Kremer or Matera should be in this team. Furlong and Jordan are nowhere near the best in their respective positions IMO. Du Toit and Louw were better than Furlong in 2025. Ramos is the best fullback.


  • All Blacks 2025
  • C cgrant

    My All Blacks / All Blacks XV team of the year :

    Williams
    Taylor
    Tosi
    Holland
    Tuipolutu
    Flanders
    Papali'i
    Sititi
    Roigard
    DMac
    Clarke
    Barrett
    Ennor
    Jordan
    Nanai-Seturo


  • New All Black Coach
  • C cgrant

    I'd like a Cotter - Bleyendaal combo.


  • What new players would you like to see in all blacks next year
  • C cgrant

    Is Higgins the new Charlie Ngatai ? First, let's see if he can play regularly next year for the Canes before making him an All Black.


  • France vs Australia
  • C cgrant

    Wallabies not clinical enough. Two big try-scoring opportunities were wasted (Valetini dropping the ball and Tizzano with a stupid ruck clearing). Despite NTA's claims, I still think that the Wallabies depth or rather lack of depth is costing them dearly, especially up front. When Skelton is not there, their locks lack the required physicality at this level. They should look at Staniforth (Castres) who is a real enforcer, one of Top 14 best locks.


  • Wales v All Blacks
  • C cgrant

    Once Ratima decided not to kick and instead pass the pill, the All Blacks played better. His kicks were awful and put the ABs under pressure. Overall, not a bad game from the starting backs from 10 to 15.


  • All Blacks 2025
  • C cgrant

    @Bones said in All Blacks 2025:

    This thing about Love not being fast enough seems odd to me and seems to be cropping up more and more. He's certainly never looked to lack for pace and I'd be interested in what express fullbacks other top tier nations have (outside SA).

    He looked really slow during this year's NPC. This did not strike me particularly during the 2025 SR.

  • Login

  • Don't have an account? Register

  • Login or register to search.
  • First post
    Last post
0
  • Categories
  • Login

  • Don't have an account? Register

  • Login or register to search.