All Black Squad for Rugby Championship
-
Liam Coltman out for the season!
This has just been posted on the Otago FB page:
Otago Rugby regretfully announces that Liam ‘the Beast’ Coltman suffered an ankle injury during the Highlanders quarter final which requires surgery. Unfortunately for us, he will miss the 2017 Mitre 10 Cup season but will be back with Otago in 2018! All the best for a speedy recovery mateSo it's Coles, Taylor, Harris .... Parsons, if our hookers go down?
-
Liam Coltman out for the season!
This has just been posted on the Otago FB page:
Otago Rugby regretfully announces that Liam ‘the Beast’ Coltman suffered an ankle injury during the Highlanders quarter final which requires surgery. Unfortunately for us, he will miss the 2017 Mitre 10 Cup season but will be back with Otago in 2018! All the best for a speedy recovery mateSo it's Coles, Taylor, Harris .... Parsons, if our hookers go down?
@Stargazer said in All Black Squad for Rugby Championship:
Liam Coltman out for the season!
This has just been posted on the Otago FB page:
Otago Rugby regretfully announces that Liam ‘the Beast’ Coltman suffered an ankle injury during the Highlanders quarter final which requires surgery. Unfortunately for us, he will miss the 2017 Mitre 10 Cup season but will be back with Otago in 2018! All the best for a speedy recovery mateSo it's Coles, Taylor, Harris .... Parsons, if our hookers go down?
Dixon surely before Parsons. And Funnell. Please ...
-
@Stargazer said in All Black Squad for Rugby Championship:
Liam Coltman out for the season!
This has just been posted on the Otago FB page:
Otago Rugby regretfully announces that Liam ‘the Beast’ Coltman suffered an ankle injury during the Highlanders quarter final which requires surgery. Unfortunately for us, he will miss the 2017 Mitre 10 Cup season but will be back with Otago in 2018! All the best for a speedy recovery mateSo it's Coles, Taylor, Harris .... Parsons, if our hookers go down?
Dixon surely before Parsons. And Funnell. Please ...
-
-
Actually, Parsons played against Australia as a substitute last year. IIRC, he was picked ahead of Coltman.
-
Parsons was also training with the ABs last year, but got injured.
@Tim That photo bears a striking resemblance to Mils.
-
I know he has a number of detractors here, but I'd like to see Brad Shields rewarded for his constant high workrate. With Luata gone north, I think he is the most Kainoesque in terms of physicality. Look how he smashed the big Lions forwards during the first half of the semi final. His tackling is really impressive. He may have tits for hands once in a game but he won't let the team down if selected.
-
I know he has a number of detractors here, but I'd like to see Brad Shields rewarded for his constant high workrate. With Luata gone north, I think he is the most Kainoesque in terms of physicality. Look how he smashed the big Lions forwards during the first half of the semi final. His tackling is really impressive. He may have tits for hands once in a game but he won't let the team down if selected.
@cgrant the big lions forwards? the pack weight was clearly in favour of the hurricanes. now maybe that's because ardie's a giant, but...
luatua is a really big loss. can't help but think he might have stayed if thrown a bit more of a selection bone. -
I can't think of a single AB game where Luatua impressed me. Granted there weren't too many games but I was never convinced. And neither it appears were the AB coaches.
-
I can't think of a single AB game where Luatua impressed me. Granted there weren't too many games but I was never convinced. And neither it appears were the AB coaches.
@Billy-Tell Yeah I feel pretty similar, feel like I've missed something that many others seem to see!
-
@cgrant the big lions forwards? the pack weight was clearly in favour of the hurricanes. now maybe that's because ardie's a giant, but...
luatua is a really big loss. can't help but think he might have stayed if thrown a bit more of a selection bone.@reprobate I think Luatua is a big loss, too. But I think the situation with Read at 8 is the same as Ritchie at 7: the selectors want them to be on the field for every one of the 80. So Luatua likely only to start against teams such as Italy, although maybe riding some pine.
For me, Steve's game is not built round being an enforcer (Christ I love it when JK envelops and manhandles chancers who wander onto his patch and try to make yards close to the ruck, e.g. Itoje, etc.). Squire and Ioane seem to have the potential to grow into this role. Shields, maybe, although the wise men have already had a good look.
So can't begrudge SL earning some bucks for a couple of years. Post the RWC he'll be 27, so young enough to return.
Of course it will all turn to custard if, God forbid, Read gets crocked seriously enough to take time out in the test window. In which case, Luatua's departure will be a major shag up! -
@cgrant the big lions forwards? the pack weight was clearly in favour of the hurricanes. now maybe that's because ardie's a giant, but...
luatua is a really big loss. can't help but think he might have stayed if thrown a bit more of a selection bone.@reprobate said in All Black Squad for Rugby Championship:
@cgrant the big lions forwards? the pack weight was clearly in favour of the hurricanes. now maybe that's because ardie's a giant, but...
luatua is a really big loss. can't help but think he might have stayed if thrown a bit more of a selection bone.I agree; this was shown on screen during the first scrum in the Lions v Canes semi (I've added the differences):
Pack weights (in kg): Lions 881, Hurricanes 912 (+/- 31)
Tight five weights (in kg): Lions 576, Hurricanes 595 (+/- 19)
Frontrow weights (in kg): Lions 351, Hurricanes 358 (+/- 7)So both the Canes' second row and backrow were 12 kg heavier than the Lions'.
-
@Billy-Tell Yeah I feel pretty similar, feel like I've missed something that many others seem to see!
@Bones @Billy-Tell do you remember when kaino was first on the scene? debuted at 21, not a regular starter for another 4 years or so?
luatua was a super-talented and very young (22?)guy, who was a bit loose, but had the ability to do things few others can when first picked. then he got dropped for being unfit or whatever it was, and was never given another proper chance - despite being an absolute standout for the blues, tightening up his game, and being one of their few real leaders. brilliant against the lions. a guy with all the skills to stand out in super rugby, and the size and strength to play with the big boys - a big loss precisely because we haven't got to see him at his best in the AB jersey. -
@Bones @Billy-Tell do you remember when kaino was first on the scene? debuted at 21, not a regular starter for another 4 years or so?
luatua was a super-talented and very young (22?)guy, who was a bit loose, but had the ability to do things few others can when first picked. then he got dropped for being unfit or whatever it was, and was never given another proper chance - despite being an absolute standout for the blues, tightening up his game, and being one of their few real leaders. brilliant against the lions. a guy with all the skills to stand out in super rugby, and the size and strength to play with the big boys - a big loss precisely because we haven't got to see him at his best in the AB jersey.I can't agree more. I see that Reason was arguing (https://www.stuff.co.nz/sport/rugby/opinion/95211847/mark-reason-where-was-the-all-blacks-love-for-growing-number-of-exiles) that Luatua is one example of Hansen being a bit out of touch.
Clocks are right twice a day, because I do think they've fucked up with Luatua. As @taniwharugby says, he's probably just fucking unlucky to be behind Read because he plays his best rugby at 8. However, I think he had the talent to be the next 6 we were loking for - all in all though, I reckon the coaches blew it by not giving him another chance.
Right now, I think he's playing better than Kaino and I'd rather JK was going and SL was staying.
There goes the bat sign at Nepia's, for sure.
-
I can't agree more. I see that Reason was arguing (https://www.stuff.co.nz/sport/rugby/opinion/95211847/mark-reason-where-was-the-all-blacks-love-for-growing-number-of-exiles) that Luatua is one example of Hansen being a bit out of touch.
Clocks are right twice a day, because I do think they've fucked up with Luatua. As @taniwharugby says, he's probably just fucking unlucky to be behind Read because he plays his best rugby at 8. However, I think he had the talent to be the next 6 we were loking for - all in all though, I reckon the coaches blew it by not giving him another chance.
Right now, I think he's playing better than Kaino and I'd rather JK was going and SL was staying.
There goes the bat sign at Nepia's, for sure.
@gt12 said in All Black Squad for Rugby Championship:
I can't agree more. I see that Reason was arguing (https://www.stuff.co.nz/sport/rugby/opinion/95211847/mark-reason-where-was-the-all-blacks-love-for-growing-number-of-exiles) that Luatua is one example of Hansen being a bit out of touch.
Clocks are right twice a day, because I do think they've fucked up with Luatua. As @taniwharugby says, he's probably just fucking unlucky to be behind Read because he plays his best rugby at 8. However, I think he had the talent to be the next 6 we were loking for - all in all though, I reckon the coaches blew it by not giving him another chance.
Right now, I think he's playing better than Kaino and I'd rather JK was going and SL was staying.
There goes the bat sign at Nepia's, for sure.
Luatua was playing better than Kaino for the Blues and was really top notch for them. That said, JK went into full beast mode when he left the 'phone box in his black outfit!
-
@gt12 said in All Black Squad for Rugby Championship:
I can't agree more. I see that Reason was arguing (https://www.stuff.co.nz/sport/rugby/opinion/95211847/mark-reason-where-was-the-all-blacks-love-for-growing-number-of-exiles) that Luatua is one example of Hansen being a bit out of touch.
Clocks are right twice a day, because I do think they've fucked up with Luatua. As @taniwharugby says, he's probably just fucking unlucky to be behind Read because he plays his best rugby at 8. However, I think he had the talent to be the next 6 we were loking for - all in all though, I reckon the coaches blew it by not giving him another chance.
Right now, I think he's playing better than Kaino and I'd rather JK was going and SL was staying.
There goes the bat sign at Nepia's, for sure.
Luatua was playing better than Kaino for the Blues and was really top notch for them. That said, JK went into full beast mode when he left the 'phone box in his black outfit!
Don't get me wrong, I still think JK is playing well. I just have a feeling that SL might be able to match it, with another however many years left to get better. When JK came out, he was loose as, but clearly ridiculously talented. I think that in today's market, keeping Luatua (who is also pretty fucking well rounded) in the tent might have been a better bet.
-
Don't get me wrong, I still think JK is playing well. I just have a feeling that SL might be able to match it, with another however many years left to get better. When JK came out, he was loose as, but clearly ridiculously talented. I think that in today's market, keeping Luatua (who is also pretty fucking well rounded) in the tent might have been a better bet.
@gt12 Not sure much between us.
Sad to say, JK won't make the RWC, so his replacement is top priority, and Read isn't that far behind him.
Comes down to money. It seems to me that NZRFU needs to allocate sufficient funding to ensure the no. 2's in each position are paid market rate. Not sure how far it could have gone, but Shag's reaction to SL news suggests a substantial pay rise WAS on the cards if he'd re-signed.
