6 Nations 2019
-
@sparky said in 6 Nations 2019:
Disagree profoundly, how much of the Wales games this year have you actually watched?
Alyn Wyn Jones, Justin Tipuric, Josh Navidi, LiamWilliams and George North are all world class players and great to watch. Wales remind me a lot in style to the 2011 All Blacks.
You don't win 14 Rugby internationals in a row without being a very good side indeed.
yes, because what i clearly said was Wales are shit team with ordinary players.
They play a very limited game plan, and they do it very well. Doesn't make for the most attractive of spectacles though (again, as per my previous post, i doubt the Welsh team or their supporters have any fucks to give about that).
They scored 10 tries all tournament, which is not many when you get to play Scotland and Italy.
Wales scored three tries against England and Ireland, but the All Blacks scored only one try in those two games in November.
They put out a reserve team against Italy.
-
-
@MiketheSnow good little Grand Slam there Mike, solid levels of piss drinking going on?
-
@MiketheSnow good little Grand Slam there Mike, solid levels of piss drinking going on?
@mariner4life said in 6 Nations 2019:
@MiketheSnow good little Grand Slam there Mike, solid levels of piss drinking going on?
Cheers.
Several bottles of red were enjoyed
-
@mariner4life said in 6 Nations 2019:
@MiketheSnow good little Grand Slam there Mike, solid levels of piss drinking going on?
Cheers.
Several bottles of red were enjoyed
@MiketheSnow said in 6 Nations 2019:
@mariner4life said in 6 Nations 2019:
@MiketheSnow good little Grand Slam there Mike, solid levels of piss drinking going on?
Cheers.
Several bottles of red were enjoyed
excellent. very sophisticated.
-
Posted in another thread, but just in case
Sure you boys want Joe?
Schmidt claiming Gatland had an unfair advantage when an Irish website published the Irish team on Wednesday.
Once Liam Williams was declared fit Wales had an unchanged side, and even if Williams hadn't made it, it was a straight swap with Halfpenny.
So Schmidt had 14/15 of the side confirmed at the final whistle against Scotland a week in advance.
Then 15/15 of the starting 15 on Tuesday.
Take your medicine like Eddie did Joe.
You were outcoached.
And outplayed.
https://www.forum.thesilverfern.com/topic/2859/who-does-tsf-want-to-be-the-next-ab-coach/126
-
And now Neil is having a cry. Must have had Sexton in his ear
Love this
He added: "Could Ireland beat Wales at the Aviva in two weeks' time with nothing to play for? Of course they would, but this rubber stamps the notion that international rugby is about doing it when it really matters."
Would not could. Rather confident that Neil.
And surely RWC tournaments are all "about doing it when it really matters."
What a buffoon.
-
And now Neil is having a cry. Must have had Sexton in his ear
Love this
He added: "Could Ireland beat Wales at the Aviva in two weeks' time with nothing to play for? Of course they would, but this rubber stamps the notion that international rugby is about doing it when it really matters."
Would not could. Rather confident that Neil.
And surely RWC tournaments are all "about doing it when it really matters."
What a buffoon.
@MiketheSnow said in 6 Nations 2019:
From the article:
"Conventional wisdom told us that over the course of this championship Wales didn't create much, they didn't score many tries.
But they were difficult to break down and hard to score against and they were very comfortable in their own skin doing practically nothing. There was evidence of this as the final whistle blew. Wales had run 110 metres with the ball all day. "All they had to do was tackle and wait for the mistakes to come."
It's called having a successful game-plan, you wally.
Doubt if I've ever read a more stupid, idiotic moan about losing a game in decades. It even beats Stephen Jones quoting out-of-date rugby laws to prove England were cheated by the ref when losing to us in November
-
Posted in another thread, but just in case
Sure you boys want Joe?
Schmidt claiming Gatland had an unfair advantage when an Irish website published the Irish team on Wednesday.
Once Liam Williams was declared fit Wales had an unchanged side, and even if Williams hadn't made it, it was a straight swap with Halfpenny.
So Schmidt had 14/15 of the side confirmed at the final whistle against Scotland a week in advance.
Then 15/15 of the starting 15 on Tuesday.
Take your medicine like Eddie did Joe.
You were outcoached.
And outplayed.
https://www.forum.thesilverfern.com/topic/2859/who-does-tsf-want-to-be-the-next-ab-coach/126
@MiketheSnow said in 6 Nations 2019:
Posted in another thread, but just in case
Sure you boys want Joe?
It's walesonline. You will never find a more wretched hive of scum and villainy.
-
@MiketheSnow said in 6 Nations 2019:
From the article:
"Conventional wisdom told us that over the course of this championship Wales didn't create much, they didn't score many tries.
But they were difficult to break down and hard to score against and they were very comfortable in their own skin doing practically nothing. There was evidence of this as the final whistle blew. Wales had run 110 metres with the ball all day. "All they had to do was tackle and wait for the mistakes to come."
It's called having a successful game-plan, you wally.
Doubt if I've ever read a more stupid, idiotic moan about losing a game in decades. It even beats Stephen Jones quoting out-of-date rugby laws to prove England were cheated by the ref when losing to us in November
@Victor-Meldrew said in 6 Nations 2019:
Doubt if I've ever read a more stupid, idiotic moan about losing a game in decades. It even beats Stephen Jones quoting out-of-date rugby laws to prove England were cheated by the ref when losing to us in November
Not sure Ireland created much against us last November. They played the way Wales did - suffocating defence and forcing errors. Fair play to them - but you rely on a ref, and it's hard to chase a game that way.
-
Yeah it might be boring as fuck, but it can be effective. Neil is not wrong, Wales didn't create much all tournament. But neither did Italy, Ireland, France outside of one half, Scotland managed a few flashes, and England scored heaps & played some of the best rugby - shame for them that rugby is an eighty minute game & they have only one plan (also a common thread in this year's tournament).
The other story it's a total click bait headline, as Schmidt says it have an advantage, and it does. Only the all blacks don't give a fuck about that advantage and publish their team a day before anyone else. Not a bloody 25 point advantage tho!
-
@Victor-Meldrew said in 6 Nations 2019:
Doubt if I've ever read a more stupid, idiotic moan about losing a game in decades. It even beats Stephen Jones quoting out-of-date rugby laws to prove England were cheated by the ref when losing to us in November
Not sure Ireland created much against us last November. They played the way Wales did - suffocating defence and forcing errors. Fair play to them - but you rely on a ref, and it's hard to chase a game that way.
Ireland have been v.poor this 6Ns. Tactically inept against England and Wales
Ireland relied on attacking the breakdown, suffocating D and their opponents mistakes. Wales mixed their tactics up and made it hard for their opponents to get into any rhythm - and Wales made bugger all mistakes.
-
Yeah it might be boring as fuck, but it can be effective. Neil is not wrong, Wales didn't create much all tournament. But neither did Italy, Ireland, France outside of one half, Scotland managed a few flashes, and England scored heaps & played some of the best rugby - shame for them that rugby is an eighty minute game & they have only one plan (also a common thread in this year's tournament).
The other story it's a total click bait headline, as Schmidt says it have an advantage, and it does. Only the all blacks don't give a fuck about that advantage and publish their team a day before anyone else. Not a bloody 25 point advantage tho!
@Machpants said in 6 Nations 2019:
Wales didn't create much all tournament
..well, apart from 5 wins out of 5.
It might not have been champagne rugby but their games against England and Ireland were bloody absorbing to watch,
-
@Victor-Meldrew said in 6 Nations 2019:
Doubt if I've ever read a more stupid, idiotic moan about losing a game in decades. It even beats Stephen Jones quoting out-of-date rugby laws to prove England were cheated by the ref when losing to us in November
Not sure Ireland created much against us last November. They played the way Wales did - suffocating defence and forcing errors. Fair play to them - but you rely on a ref, and it's hard to chase a game that way.
@nzzp said in 6 Nations 2019:
Not sure Ireland created much against us last November. They played the way Wales did
Yeah, and for much of that game, we played the same was as Ireland did on Saturday.
-
No one's saying it's not winning rugby, just that it is pretty unexciting rugby, Victor. The contest can be tense and exciting even if the rugby isn't. Two different things. I'd prefer tense and exciting contests of quality rugby, but it doesn't happen often!
I don't agree with his conclusion but the stats he quotes tell a story
https://www.theroar.com.au/2019/03/19/six-nations-a-personal-triumph-for-warren-gatland-but-not-wales/ -
@Victor-Meldrew said in 6 Nations 2019:
Doubt if I've ever read a more stupid, idiotic moan about losing a game in decades. It even beats Stephen Jones quoting out-of-date rugby laws to prove England were cheated by the ref when losing to us in November
Not sure Ireland created much against us last November. They played the way Wales did - suffocating defence and forcing errors. Fair play to them - but you rely on a ref, and it's hard to chase a game that way.
@nzzp said in 6 Nations 2019:
@Victor-Meldrew said in 6 Nations 2019:
Doubt if I've ever read a more stupid, idiotic moan about losing a game in decades. It even beats Stephen Jones quoting out-of-date rugby laws to prove England were cheated by the ref when losing to us in November
Not sure Ireland created much against us last November. They played the way Wales did - suffocating defence and forcing errors. Fair play to them - but you rely on a ref, and it's hard to chase a game that way.
Did we create much against Ireland last November?
Genuine question, need someone 20 years younger than me and with a better memory to answer, I can't recall. I don't really recall us bombing scoring opportunities all afternoon. I think we just got smashed (backwards). -
@nzzp said in 6 Nations 2019:
@Victor-Meldrew said in 6 Nations 2019:
Doubt if I've ever read a more stupid, idiotic moan about losing a game in decades. It even beats Stephen Jones quoting out-of-date rugby laws to prove England were cheated by the ref when losing to us in November
Not sure Ireland created much against us last November. They played the way Wales did - suffocating defence and forcing errors. Fair play to them - but you rely on a ref, and it's hard to chase a game that way.
Did we create much against Ireland last November?
Genuine question, need someone 20 years younger than me and with a better memory to answer, I can't recall. I don't really recall us bombing scoring opportunities all afternoon. I think we just got smashed (backwards).@Rapido said in 6 Nations 2019:
@nzzp said in 6 Nations 2019:
@Victor-Meldrew said in 6 Nations 2019:
Doubt if I've ever read a more stupid, idiotic moan about losing a game in decades. It even beats Stephen Jones quoting out-of-date rugby laws to prove England were cheated by the ref when losing to us in November
Not sure Ireland created much against us last November. They played the way Wales did - suffocating defence and forcing errors. Fair play to them - but you rely on a ref, and it's hard to chase a game that way.
Did we create much against Ireland last November?
Genuine question, need someone 20 years younger than me and with a better memory to answer, I can't recall. I don't really recall us bombing scoring opportunities all afternoon. I think we just got smashed (backwards).Yep, out-passioned to use an old John Hartism. We were never in that game, and played terribly. 9 points is a horrible outcome.
We're going to see this in the RWC unless refs get more aggressive with the offside line. Modern defences are hard to unlock; I just hope we've got some tactics up our sleeve that are hard to negate in a few weeks.
-
@Rapido said in 6 Nations 2019:
@nzzp said in 6 Nations 2019:
@Victor-Meldrew said in 6 Nations 2019:
Doubt if I've ever read a more stupid, idiotic moan about losing a game in decades. It even beats Stephen Jones quoting out-of-date rugby laws to prove England were cheated by the ref when losing to us in November
Not sure Ireland created much against us last November. They played the way Wales did - suffocating defence and forcing errors. Fair play to them - but you rely on a ref, and it's hard to chase a game that way.
Did we create much against Ireland last November?
Genuine question, need someone 20 years younger than me and with a better memory to answer, I can't recall. I don't really recall us bombing scoring opportunities all afternoon. I think we just got smashed (backwards).Yep, out-passioned to use an old John Hartism. We were never in that game, and played terribly. 9 points is a horrible outcome.
We're going to see this in the RWC unless refs get more aggressive with the offside line. Modern defences are hard to unlock; I just hope we've got some tactics up our sleeve that are hard to negate in a few weeks.
@nzzp said in 6 Nations 2019:
@Rapido said in 6 Nations 2019:
@nzzp said in 6 Nations 2019:
@Victor-Meldrew said in 6 Nations 2019:
Doubt if I've ever read a more stupid, idiotic moan about losing a game in decades. It even beats Stephen Jones quoting out-of-date rugby laws to prove England were cheated by the ref when losing to us in November
Not sure Ireland created much against us last November. They played the way Wales did - suffocating defence and forcing errors. Fair play to them - but you rely on a ref, and it's hard to chase a game that way.
Did we create much against Ireland last November?
Genuine question, need someone 20 years younger than me and with a better memory to answer, I can't recall. I don't really recall us bombing scoring opportunities all afternoon. I think we just got smashed (backwards).Yep, out-passioned to use an old John Hartism. We were never in that game, and played terribly. 9 points is a horrible outcome.
We're going to see this in the RWC unless refs get more aggressive with the offside line. Modern defences are hard to unlock; I just hope we've got some tactics up our sleeve that are hard to negate in a few weeks.
Yeah, I was trying to take more notice of the offside line in the final two 6N games and everyone was at it. It was policed very poorly in general. I’m not really in favour of interference by the TMO but maybe this is an area that it might be useful?
-
@nzzp said in 6 Nations 2019:
@Victor-Meldrew said in 6 Nations 2019:
Doubt if I've ever read a more stupid, idiotic moan about losing a game in decades. It even beats Stephen Jones quoting out-of-date rugby laws to prove England were cheated by the ref when losing to us in November
Not sure Ireland created much against us last November. They played the way Wales did - suffocating defence and forcing errors. Fair play to them - but you rely on a ref, and it's hard to chase a game that way.
Did we create much against Ireland last November?
Genuine question, need someone 20 years younger than me and with a better memory to answer, I can't recall. I don't really recall us bombing scoring opportunities all afternoon. I think we just got smashed (backwards).@Rapido no. we did what we frequently do when we get beaten. this usually happens when we play a team that wants the ball, plays simple and direct on attack, and has a rush defence: we allow them to retain the ball and build momentum, then when we finally do get the ball we try shitty short kicks that give the ball straight back.
everyone says 'the opposition is up quick, put it in behind them'. bullshit. the grubber is not something you should do just because the opposition rushes, it is something you do because there is a gap. the potatoes have covered the damn gap, so don't kick the ball away dickheads.
i am still cross about this.
-
@nzzp said in 6 Nations 2019:
@Rapido said in 6 Nations 2019:
@nzzp said in 6 Nations 2019:
@Victor-Meldrew said in 6 Nations 2019:
Doubt if I've ever read a more stupid, idiotic moan about losing a game in decades. It even beats Stephen Jones quoting out-of-date rugby laws to prove England were cheated by the ref when losing to us in November
Not sure Ireland created much against us last November. They played the way Wales did - suffocating defence and forcing errors. Fair play to them - but you rely on a ref, and it's hard to chase a game that way.
Did we create much against Ireland last November?
Genuine question, need someone 20 years younger than me and with a better memory to answer, I can't recall. I don't really recall us bombing scoring opportunities all afternoon. I think we just got smashed (backwards).Yep, out-passioned to use an old John Hartism. We were never in that game, and played terribly. 9 points is a horrible outcome.
We're going to see this in the RWC unless refs get more aggressive with the offside line. Modern defences are hard to unlock; I just hope we've got some tactics up our sleeve that are hard to negate in a few weeks.
Yeah, I was trying to take more notice of the offside line in the final two 6N games and everyone was at it. It was policed very poorly in general. I’m not really in favour of interference by the TMO but maybe this is an area that it might be useful?
@Catogrande said in 6 Nations 2019:
@nzzp said in 6 Nations 2019:
@Rapido said in 6 Nations 2019:
@nzzp said in 6 Nations 2019:
@Victor-Meldrew said in 6 Nations 2019:
Doubt if I've ever read a more stupid, idiotic moan about losing a game in decades. It even beats Stephen Jones quoting out-of-date rugby laws to prove England were cheated by the ref when losing to us in November
Not sure Ireland created much against us last November. They played the way Wales did - suffocating defence and forcing errors. Fair play to them - but you rely on a ref, and it's hard to chase a game that way.
Did we create much against Ireland last November?
Genuine question, need someone 20 years younger than me and with a better memory to answer, I can't recall. I don't really recall us bombing scoring opportunities all afternoon. I think we just got smashed (backwards).Yep, out-passioned to use an old John Hartism. We were never in that game, and played terribly. 9 points is a horrible outcome.
We're going to see this in the RWC unless refs get more aggressive with the offside line. Modern defences are hard to unlock; I just hope we've got some tactics up our sleeve that are hard to negate in a few weeks.
Yeah, I was trying to take more notice of the offside line in the final two 6N games and everyone was at it. It was policed very poorly in general. I’m not really in favour of interference by the TMO but maybe this is an area that it might be useful?
It's a reality though, and expect rush defence and borderline offside to continue. NZ are currently pretty hopeless at dealing with it (from an attacking POV). It's a leveller, makes the world cup even more wide open (NZ probably on the decline anyway).
Test rugby these days is reminding me more of old school tests. Hard to score tries.
