All Blacks XV - New second tier team

Tim

@Bones Akira Ioane is an optimistic pick from me at this point. Wouldn't be surprised if Josh Ioane is 3rd ten in the ABs.

voodoo

@Tim said in All Blacks XV - New second tier team:

Be interesting to see if Jordie Barrett plays at 12.

Would he be the tallest 12 we have ever fielded?

Kirwan

@antipodean said in All Blacks XV - New second tier team:

@Bovidae said in All Blacks XV - New second tier team:

@antipodean My reading of it, is the use of All Blacks in the team name, like the Sevens team. This point has been raised in this thread.

Oh no, the precedent! Next they'll have the Maori All Blacks, or the All Black Sevens...

The Junior All Blacks....

pakman

@Tim said in All Blacks XV - New second tier team:

Locks

Whitelock, Tuipulotu, Barrett + 1 in the ABs.

Contenders:

Allardice
Cowley-Tuioti
IWL
Dunshea
Strange
Dickson

Maybe Strange to the ABs, leaving IWL, GCT, and Dunshea for the B team. Dickson for fourth lock?

For me a weak area. Compare England, who can choose from Kruis, Itoje, Lawes and Launchbury, not to mention Ewels, etc..

Kruse

@voodoo said in All Blacks XV - New second tier team:

@Tim said in All Blacks XV - New second tier team:

Be interesting to see if Jordie Barrett plays at 12.

Would he be the tallest 12 we have ever fielded?

QUICK - to the "Tallest All Blacks XV" thread!
I can't remember who started that, so apologies in advance - but jeez, I'm embarrassed that it really does(/did) exist.

Stargazer

From the Planet Rugby website:

The newly formed All Blacks XV, Fiji, USA and Canada will participate in the inaugural Halloween Rugby Weekend, at BC Place Stadium in Vancouver this October.

The games will feature the All Blacks XV squaring off against the Flying Fijians on Halloween night, Saturday, October 30, and Canada hitting the pitch against their continental rivals the USA on Friday, October 30.

The event is the first leg of a three-city world tour by the All Blacks XV team and was announced prior to the final of the wildly successful Vancouver Sevens tournament also staged at BC Place.

All Blacks hooker Nathan Harris and Fiji fly-half Ben Volavola were in attendance at the Vancouver Sevens and are excited to compete in front of Vancouver fans this October.

More: https://www.planetrugby.com/all-blacks-xv-to-tour-northern-hemisphere/

shark

@Tim said in All Blacks XV - New second tier team:

1st 5:

Big question over third AB ten.

Ioane, Black, and Smith are probably the most prominent this year. Perhaps two of those (Black and Smith) plus a player who covers 10 from another position like Havili, Stevenson, or Perofeta.

With Mo'unga, Barrett and McKenzie in an AB squad, you don't need another 10.

shark

Anyway, I like this concept. Not so much the naming as it appears as much a marketing gimmick and attempt to pull the wool over casual fan's eyes, as it is a genuine reflection of a national team.

shark

@Tim said in All Blacks XV - New second tier team:

Locks

Whitelock, Tuipulotu, Barrett + 1 in the ABs.

Contenders:

Allardice
Cowley-Tuioti
IWL
Dunshea
Strange
Dickson

Maybe Strange to the ABs, leaving IWL, GCT, and Dunshea for the B team. Dickson for fourth lock?

Jeez I heard Jason Pyne on RS this morning name a scratch 15 and he had James Blackwell as a lock. If any senior NZ rep team ever selects a 1.90m lock forward, I'll strap myself to a Nth Korean ICBM and ask them to point it at NZR HQ.

Bones

@shark is there quite a difference between Nth Korean ICBM's and others?

shark

@Bones said in All Blacks XV - New second tier team:

@shark is there quite a difference between Nth Korean ICBM's and others?

I'm relying on it not working.

Tim

@shark Fair enough, although I am wondering if MacKenzie will concentrate on fullback after all the talk about it preseason.

voodoo

@shark said in All Blacks XV - New second tier team:

@Tim said in All Blacks XV - New second tier team:

1st 5:

Big question over third AB ten.

Ioane, Black, and Smith are probably the most prominent this year. Perhaps two of those (Black and Smith) plus a player who covers 10 from another position like Havili, Stevenson, or Perofeta.

With Mo'unga, Barrett and McKenzie in an AB squad, you don't need another 10.

🤮

shark

@voodoo I'm not a big fan of McKenzie at 10 either, but in a squad situation where Richie and BB are your top 10 options, another specialist is probably surplus to requirements. Unless we're talking about an EOYT squad of course.

mofitzy_

Name doesn't bother me too much, after the JABs, AB7s and MABs this is now standard procedure. A bit of too little too late considering the last JAB game was in 2009 and since recently the udpated 5 year residency requirement will mean the number of guys being capped for Scotland, Ireland, Wales etc. will drop significantly (assuming this is a capped side).

Machpants

Unless NZR officialy go to world rugby and change the designated side, which is currenlty JAB, players in this side won't be captured. I don't know if NZR will, I think they will rely on the carrot of possible later full AB rather than tying in players who may never represent NZ again, and then can't anyone else. But maybe I am assigning too much altruism to NZR!

Kirwan

@Machpants said in All Blacks XV - New second tier team:

Unless NZR officialy go to world rugby and change the designated side, which is currenlty JAB, players in this side won't be captured. I don't know if NZR will, I think they will rely on the carrot of possible later full AB rather than tying in players who may never represent NZ again, and then can't anyone else. But maybe I am assigning too much altruism to NZR!

I read this line to mean that's what they were doing?

""The All Blacks XV will be our second-tier team below the All Blacks and made up New Zealand's 'next best' players," Cass said"

And the rest of the article talks about retention of players.

Crucial

@Kirwan said in All Blacks XV - New second tier team:

@Machpants said in All Blacks XV - New second tier team:

Unless NZR officialy go to world rugby and change the designated side, which is currenlty JAB, players in this side won't be captured. I don't know if NZR will, I think they will rely on the carrot of possible later full AB rather than tying in players who may never represent NZ again, and then can't anyone else. But maybe I am assigning too much altruism to NZR!

I read this line to mean that's what they were doing?

""The All Blacks XV will be our second-tier team below the All Blacks and made up New Zealand's 'next best' players," Cass said"

And the rest of the article talks about retention of players.

That’s how I read it too.
Looks like a switch in policy to me. I always thought that having the unused JABs as designated second team was a deliberate ploy to keep pathway options open for some (particularly PI) players. Some may stay developing in NZ and become viable AB options if they know they still have a fallback international option. Gives them two options.
Now it could be the opposite. Will those fringe players want to play for the XV knowing that it may be their peak?

Stargazer

I guess we'll have to wait for the updated version of this document:

Men's and Women's Next Senior National Representative Team 2019

Crucial

As a side issue, should their be different eligibility rules for 'second team' players? That is, maybe a stand-down period before becoming eligible elsewhere rather than a flat out lock in.

Would be good for PI rugby. Plenty of guys that would have been picked in a AB XV team that didn't make the ABs but went on to rep for someone else. The likes of TNW for example.

The Silver Fern

All Blacks XV - New second tier team