Bledisloe One: Wellington, October 11
-
On the 13 selection.. First of all it's difficult to guess which way a new coach will go.
Goodhue has played the bulk of his rugby at 12 this year. Remember NZ rugby is hierarchical and sometimes the word comes down from above. Was Goodhue at 12 always in the Crusaders best interest? Plenty of TSFers thought the Crusaders were making an error (including me)
So the North/South game would've been a chance to correct that? The national selectors then pick him at 12 again.Maybe the selectors are picking for a game plan that requires more pace at 13?
Who played 13 in the North South match? R Ioane, Ennor, PUJ & L Faingaanuku. 3 guys that have played the bulk of their rugby on the wing and PUJ who has played in the back three and is fast enough to be a winger
I'll guess the midfield will be ALB/Ioane initially
-
On the 13 selection.. First of all it's difficult to guess which way a new coach will go.
Goodhue has played the bulk of his rugby at 12 this year. Remember NZ rugby is hierarchical and sometimes the word comes down from above. Was Goodhue at 12 always in the Crusaders best interest? Plenty of TSFers thought the Crusaders were making an error (including me)
So the North/South game would've been a chance to correct that? The national selectors then pick him at 12 again.Maybe the selectors are picking for a game plan that requires more pace at 13?
Who played 13 in the North South match? R Ioane, Ennor, PUJ & L Faingaanuku. 3 guys that have played the bulk of their rugby on the wing and PUJ who has played in the back three and is fast enough to be a winger
I'll guess the midfield will be ALB/Ioane initially
@Duluth If he hasn't already, I think PUJ will make a strong case to be that long term 13. He just looks to be the most natural centre in NZ. He has a great mix of size, speed, and skillset similar to his uncle that is perfect for the game today.
I've said this a few times on the thread aswell that we should also try J Barrett at 12. This means it opens up an opportunity for someone like Jordan to lock down the 15 jersey aswell.
-
@KiwiMurph PUJ is an upgrade on Ennor.
-
ANDREW SLACK’S WALLABIES BACKLINE
- Tom Banks, 14. Filipo Daugunu, 13. Jordan Petaia, 12. Hunter Paisami/James O’Connor/Matt Toomua, 11. Marika Koroibete, 10. Noah Lolesio, 9. Tate McDermott.
@Tim said in Bledisloe One: Wellington, October 11:
ANDREW SLACK’S WALLABIES BACKLINE
- Tom Banks, 14. Filipo Daugunu, 13. Jordan Petaia, 12. Hunter Paisami/James O’Connor/Matt Toomua, 11. Marika Koroibete, 10. Noah Lolesio, 9. Tate McDermott.
Ex-QLD player in shoehorn-QLD-players shock.
-
@Tim said in Bledisloe One: Wellington, October 11:
ANDREW SLACK’S WALLABIES BACKLINE
- Tom Banks, 14. Filipo Daugunu, 13. Jordan Petaia, 12. Hunter Paisami/James O’Connor/Matt Toomua, 11. Marika Koroibete, 10. Noah Lolesio, 9. Tate McDermott.
Ex-QLD player in shoehorn-QLD-players shock.
@NTA said in Bledisloe One: Wellington, October 11:
@Tim said in Bledisloe One: Wellington, October 11:
ANDREW SLACK’S WALLABIES BACKLINE
- Tom Banks, 14. Filipo Daugunu, 13. Jordan Petaia, 12. Hunter Paisami/James O’Connor/Matt Toomua, 11. Marika Koroibete, 10. Noah Lolesio, 9. Tate McDermott.
Ex-QLD player in shoehorn-QLD-players shock.
It's a bit like club/franchise coach insists one of his players should be in the test team shocker
-
If Foster picks Savea at 8 i will be getting the fat effigies out straight away.
-
If Foster picks Savea at 8 i will be getting the fat effigies out straight away.
@mariner4life said in Bledisloe One: Wellington, October 11:
If Foster picks Savea at 8 i will be getting the fat effigies out straight away.
Indeed. Would it kill him to hop on the treadmill once in awhile ?
-
If Foster picks Savea at 8 i will be getting the fat effigies out straight away.
@mariner4life said in Bledisloe One: Wellington, October 11:
If Foster picks Savea at 8 i will be getting the fat effigies out straight away.
if you burn them, do they smell like crackling?
-
@mariner4life said in Bledisloe One: Wellington, October 11:
If Foster picks Savea at 8 i will be getting the fat effigies out straight away.
if you burn them, do they smell like crackling?
@nzzp said in Bledisloe One: Wellington, October 11:
@mariner4life said in Bledisloe One: Wellington, October 11:
If Foster picks Savea at 8 i will be getting the fat effigies out straight away.
if you burn them, do they smell like crackling?
dunno, i import mine from India
-
Surely there is no chance Savea starts at 8 over Sotutu? He can't whack on about bringing physicality back then do that, it'd be a mockery.
@voodoo said in Bledisloe One: Wellington, October 11:
Surely there is no chance Savea starts at 8 over Sotutu? He can't whack on about bringing physicality back then do that, it'd be a mockery.
but the staaaaaaats
-
@NTA said in Bledisloe One: Wellington, October 11:
@Tim said in Bledisloe One: Wellington, October 11:
ANDREW SLACK’S WALLABIES BACKLINE
- Tom Banks, 14. Filipo Daugunu, 13. Jordan Petaia, 12. Hunter Paisami/James O’Connor/Matt Toomua, 11. Marika Koroibete, 10. Noah Lolesio, 9. Tate McDermott.
Ex-QLD player in shoehorn-QLD-players shock.
It's a bit like club/franchise coach insists one of his players should be in the test team shocker
@Machpants said in Bledisloe One: Wellington, October 11:
It's a bit like club/franchise coach insists one of his players should be in the test team shocker
I've been following Ben Darwin on twitter, and one of the things he circles back to is combinations - and backs it up with data as well. The theory of "put the best players together" can work, but I'd rather see Rennie look at key combinations.
Keeping in mind I haven't watched much of SRAU at all:
Tate McDermott seems to be head and shoulders above the other options at 9, so he's a definite pick. It therefore stands to reason - using Darwin's theory
- that you pick James O'Connor next to him, who has also had a good season behind what is a young but inconsistent pack.Nic White therefore goes on the bench IMHO. One good game in Perth a year ago and then fuck all since.
Lolesio is a good player, but he's a kid, and will have his chances in future years. You can't really put him on the bench as he doesn't play any other positions.
I've got serious questions about the liability presented by Petaia. The kid could be anything - mostly broken - so what is going on with his S&C work? Start him, see if he breaks (again), and bring on someone else.
Toomua probably sits in 12 at that point as the logical backup 10, and brings experience and another boot to the backline to opt between a bash n barge inside centre as well as second five in the same shirt.
Koroibete picks himself. I'm not convinced that Daugunu is a positive in terms of being able to kick us out of trouble. That's why Banks is at the back, and maybe Wright on the blindside wing.
I've seen various forward packs listed elsewhere, and would probably go for something akin to Paul Cully's pack:
1 Sio
2 Fainga'a
3 Alalaatoa (Cully picked Tupou but nah)
4 Philip
5 LSL
6 Samu
7 Hooper (capt)
8 Wilson
9 McDermott
10 JOC
11 Koroibete
12 Toomua
13 Petaia
14 Wright
15 Banks16 Uelese
17 Slipper
18 Tupou
19 Hosea (big unit - give him a go)
20 Wright
21 White
22 ?Paisami/Simone?
23 Hodge -
@Machpants said in Bledisloe One: Wellington, October 11:
It's a bit like club/franchise coach insists one of his players should be in the test team shocker
I've been following Ben Darwin on twitter, and one of the things he circles back to is combinations - and backs it up with data as well. The theory of "put the best players together" can work, but I'd rather see Rennie look at key combinations.
Keeping in mind I haven't watched much of SRAU at all:
Tate McDermott seems to be head and shoulders above the other options at 9, so he's a definite pick. It therefore stands to reason - using Darwin's theory
- that you pick James O'Connor next to him, who has also had a good season behind what is a young but inconsistent pack.Nic White therefore goes on the bench IMHO. One good game in Perth a year ago and then fuck all since.
Lolesio is a good player, but he's a kid, and will have his chances in future years. You can't really put him on the bench as he doesn't play any other positions.
I've got serious questions about the liability presented by Petaia. The kid could be anything - mostly broken - so what is going on with his S&C work? Start him, see if he breaks (again), and bring on someone else.
Toomua probably sits in 12 at that point as the logical backup 10, and brings experience and another boot to the backline to opt between a bash n barge inside centre as well as second five in the same shirt.
Koroibete picks himself. I'm not convinced that Daugunu is a positive in terms of being able to kick us out of trouble. That's why Banks is at the back, and maybe Wright on the blindside wing.
I've seen various forward packs listed elsewhere, and would probably go for something akin to Paul Cully's pack:
1 Sio
2 Fainga'a
3 Alalaatoa (Cully picked Tupou but nah)
4 Philip
5 LSL
6 Samu
7 Hooper (capt)
8 Wilson
9 McDermott
10 JOC
11 Koroibete
12 Toomua
13 Petaia
14 Wright
15 Banks16 Uelese
17 Slipper
18 Tupou
19 Hosea (big unit - give him a go)
20 Wright
21 White
22 ?Paisami/Simone?
23 Hodge -
@NTA That looks pretty close to the mark. I think i'd have DHP at fullback ahead of Banks - DHP is no good on the wing but a good fullback and more well rounded than Banks to me.
@KiwiMurph said in Bledisloe One: Wellington, October 11:
@NTA That looks pretty close to the mark. I think i'd have DHP at fullback ahead of Banks - DHP is no good on the wing but a good fullback and more well rounded than Banks to me.
Either Banks fails and I get to tell Brumbies fans (both of them) that he was never worthy despite all their jizzmatic explanations supporting his selection, or he succeeds and I get a Bledisloe win.
There's no loser here.
-
@KiwiMurph said in Bledisloe One: Wellington, October 11:
@NTA That looks pretty close to the mark. I think i'd have DHP at fullback ahead of Banks - DHP is no good on the wing but a good fullback and more well rounded than Banks to me.
Either Banks fails and I get to tell Brumbies fans (both of them) that he was never worthy despite all their jizzmatic explanations supporting his selection, or he succeeds and I get a Bledisloe win.
There's no loser here.
