All Blacks 2021
-
@nostrildamus cant say I am sold on Laumape either , and it’s more around consistency, there are games where he absolutely rips up , but the best way you can ever gauge a player is when he comes up against the best team , locally the Crusaders and unfortunately most of the time , he’s either very quiet and that’s primarily because he gets shut down..
I see more as an impact player than a starter .@steven-harris said in All Blacks 2021:
@nostrildamus cant say I am sold on Laumape either , and it’s more around consistency, there are games where he absolutely rips up , but the best way you can ever gauge a player is when he comes up against the best team , locally the Crusaders and unfortunately most of the time , he’s either very quiet and that’s primarily because he gets shut down..
I see more as an impact player than a starter .And no one has room for a specialist 12 on the bench.
I think Laumape is a very good player and one that (when he steps up) can change the shape of a game. Even when not fully firing he plays a role well, especially if you want a hard running 12 to play a hit and recycle game.
Sadly for him I don't think his future lies in the ABs. He would make very good money in Europe though and probably be a good piece of a coaches plans in a club season strategy.
-
Imo laumape has been borderline diabolical this season. A blind man would have more vision at times.
@billy-tell said in All Blacks 2021:
Imo laumape has been borderline diabolical this season. A blind man would have more vision at times.
He actually has a really good kicking and passing game to go with his strong running, but as you say he has no vision at all to use them to his advantage. He's shown glimpses but he's not the answer at test level.
-
I didn't watch all the canes games so this is on a small sample set
if fozzie has the same approach as last year with 12 often looking for the crash ball and recycle, like Goodhue was doing...that might work for Laumape
-
It's evident to me that Laumape is trying to develop/ demonstrate more strings for his bow but in doing so he seems near invisible/ ineffective for large parts of games. Hardly showing form that would make him a strong contender for the 12 jersey.
-
It's evident to me that Laumape is trying to develop/ demonstrate more strings for his bow but in doing so he seems near invisible/ ineffective for large parts of games. Hardly showing form that would make him a strong contender for the 12 jersey.
-
@antipodean I'd rather try Jordie at 12. Massive boot, big frame, ability to pass. Honestly, he'd fill a hole for us.
I know this sounds very Hayman to 8, and it won't happen, but he ticks a lot of the boxes
@nzzp said in All Blacks 2021:
@antipodean I'd rather try Jordie at 12. Massive boot, big frame, ability to pass. Honestly, he'd fill a hole for us.
I know this sounds very Hayman to 8, and it won't happen, but he ticks a lot of the boxes
Na, I’m hoping they’ll see how he goes on the wing. The lack of pace could really surprise a lot of defences.
-
@nzzp said in All Blacks 2021:
@antipodean I'd rather try Jordie at 12. Massive boot, big frame, ability to pass. Honestly, he'd fill a hole for us.
I know this sounds very Hayman to 8, and it won't happen, but he ticks a lot of the boxes
Na, I’m hoping they’ll see how he goes on the wing. The lack of pace could really surprise a lot of defences.
@mn5 said in All Blacks 2021:
@nzzp said in All Blacks 2021:
@antipodean I'd rather try Jordie at 12. Massive boot, big frame, ability to pass. Honestly, he'd fill a hole for us.
I know this sounds very Hayman to 8, and it won't happen, but he ticks a lot of the boxes
Na, I’m hoping they’ll see how he goes on the wing. The lack of pace could really surprise a lot of defences.
finally some out of the box thinking, really feel that will fix everything
-
@mn5 said in All Blacks 2021:
@nzzp said in All Blacks 2021:
@antipodean I'd rather try Jordie at 12. Massive boot, big frame, ability to pass. Honestly, he'd fill a hole for us.
I know this sounds very Hayman to 8, and it won't happen, but he ticks a lot of the boxes
Na, I’m hoping they’ll see how he goes on the wing. The lack of pace could really surprise a lot of defences.
finally some out of the box thinking, really feel that will fix everything
@kiwiwomble said in All Blacks 2021:
@mn5 said in All Blacks 2021:
@nzzp said in All Blacks 2021:
@antipodean I'd rather try Jordie at 12. Massive boot, big frame, ability to pass. Honestly, he'd fill a hole for us.
I know this sounds very Hayman to 8, and it won't happen, but he ticks a lot of the boxes
Na, I’m hoping they’ll see how he goes on the wing. The lack of pace could really surprise a lot of defences.
finally some out of the box thinking, really feel that will fix everything
Speed is overrated. Who needs a guy running quickly ? When someone glides as slow as Jordie it gives defenders far more time to doubt themselves.
-
I don't get the impression Foster et al. are sold on Laumape. And he lacks the versatility of his competitors like DH et alone a comparable kicking game.
NB I'm assuming JB has a lock on FB, (I mean, he was starting on the wing so the coaches love him, that they have enough wings (one or two of whom can FB, Jordan, Bridge?*) but that DH being a FB as well and being more consistently in form gives him the edge over NL.
And givn ALB is competing at 12 against DH/NL and at 13 against Ioane (I assume PUJ has not had enough game time to shine) they'd probably prefer DH/ALB to ALB/RI but RI has a chance on the bench as he also provides fairly handy wing cover.
*I wonder how highly they rate DMac at 15/10 cover.
**I'm not sure what is happening with RM/BB at 10 or BB at 15. I'd assume JB is ahead of his bro at 15.
apologies: perhaps this belongs in All Black not Blues thread..(oh, thanks mods!).@nostrildamus said in All Blacks 2021:
*I wonder how highly they rate DMac at 15/10 cover.
**I'm not sure what is happening with RM/BB at 10 or BB at 15. I'd assume JB is ahead of his bro at 15.Beaudy came out and said he wanted to play 10, so if he holds that line with Foster it will be him and Richie in the 10 and 22 jerseys.
However, if he's still willing to bend to Foster's two playmakers thing, then I don't think your assumption that Jordie is ahead is necessarily correct, because at the last AB waypoint Beauden was at fullback and Jordie on the wing.
I reckon they'll be pretty happy with DMac as their third first five - because from what I've seen this year, next in line is probably Mitch Hunt. Nothing against Mitch, but he's a substantial drop from our top two and I wouldn't want to see him as the number one goal kicker in a tight test.
-
@kiwiwomble said in All Blacks 2021:
@mn5 said in All Blacks 2021:
@nzzp said in All Blacks 2021:
@antipodean I'd rather try Jordie at 12. Massive boot, big frame, ability to pass. Honestly, he'd fill a hole for us.
I know this sounds very Hayman to 8, and it won't happen, but he ticks a lot of the boxes
Na, I’m hoping they’ll see how he goes on the wing. The lack of pace could really surprise a lot of defences.
finally some out of the box thinking, really feel that will fix everything
Speed is overrated. Who needs a guy running quickly ? When someone glides as slow as Jordie it gives defenders far more time to doubt themselves.
@mn5 he's also quite tall, ticks all the boxes
-
@nostrildamus said in All Blacks 2021:
*I wonder how highly they rate DMac at 15/10 cover.
**I'm not sure what is happening with RM/BB at 10 or BB at 15. I'd assume JB is ahead of his bro at 15.Beaudy came out and said he wanted to play 10, so if he holds that line with Foster it will be him and Richie in the 10 and 22 jerseys.
However, if he's still willing to bend to Foster's two playmakers thing, then I don't think your assumption that Jordie is ahead is necessarily correct, because at the last AB waypoint Beauden was at fullback and Jordie on the wing.
I reckon they'll be pretty happy with DMac as their third first five - because from what I've seen this year, next in line is probably Mitch Hunt. Nothing against Mitch, but he's a substantial drop from our top two and I wouldn't want to see him as the number one goal kicker in a tight test.
@chris-b i can see your line of argument but I don't think they will put JB at wing again but they won't start without him so I doubt they'd start BB at 15. Then again I've been wrong before, I mean I wanted a Crusader to coach the ABs, what was I thinking!?
-
@chris-b i can see your line of argument but I don't think they will put JB at wing again but they won't start without him so I doubt they'd start BB at 15. Then again I've been wrong before, I mean I wanted a Crusader to coach the ABs, what was I thinking!?
@nostrildamus said in All Blacks 2021:
@chris-b i can see your line of argument but I don't think they will put JB at wing again
I found a still from his last test there
-
@nostrildamus said in All Blacks 2021:
@chris-b i can see your line of argument but I don't think they will put JB at wing again
I found a still from his last test there
@nzzp said in All Blacks 2021:
@nostrildamus said in All Blacks 2021:
@chris-b i can see your line of argument but I don't think they will put JB at wing again
I found a still from his last test there
And one of him going for the high ball.
-
@nzzp said in All Blacks 2021:
@nostrildamus said in All Blacks 2021:
@chris-b i can see your line of argument but I don't think they will put JB at wing again
I found a still from his last test there
And one of him going for the high ball.
-
@nzzp said in All Blacks 2021:
@crucial said in All Blacks 2021:
NO LIFTING IN THE LINOUTS
oh, wati ... as you were
Hard to tell as the photo quality isn't the best but that could just be an old shot of Caleb Ralph.
-
@nzzp said in All Blacks 2021:
@crucial said in All Blacks 2021:
NO LIFTING IN THE LINOUTS
oh, wati ... as you were
Hard to tell as the photo quality isn't the best but that could just be an old shot of Caleb Ralph.
-
@nzzp said in All Blacks 2021:
@crucial said in All Blacks 2021:
NO LIFTING IN THE LINOUTS
oh, wati ... as you were
Hard to tell as the photo quality isn't the best but that could just be an old shot of Caleb Ralph.
@crucial said in All Blacks 2021:
@nzzp said in All Blacks 2021:
@crucial said in All Blacks 2021:
NO LIFTING IN THE LINOUTS
oh, wati ... as you were
Hard to tell as the photo quality isn't the best but that could just be an old shot of Caleb Ralph.
The legend of the cart horse lives on
-
@chris-b i can see your line of argument but I don't think they will put JB at wing again but they won't start without him so I doubt they'd start BB at 15. Then again I've been wrong before, I mean I wanted a Crusader to coach the ABs, what was I thinking!?
@nostrildamus said in All Blacks 2021:
@chris-b i can see your line of argument but I don't think they will put JB at wing again but they won't start without him so I doubt they'd start BB at 15. Then again I've been wrong before, I mean I wanted a Crusader to coach the ABs, what was I thinking!?
I don't think they'll put him on the wing again either (I'll be heading for the "Fozzie Must Go" bandwagon if he gets played there ahead of Will Jordan). But, I also don't see that he's indispensable - I could readily see a team with Jordie on the bench - or even missing out on that to DMac.
-
@nostrildamus said in All Blacks 2021:
@chris-b i can see your line of argument but I don't think they will put JB at wing again but they won't start without him so I doubt they'd start BB at 15. Then again I've been wrong before, I mean I wanted a Crusader to coach the ABs, what was I thinking!?
I don't think they'll put him on the wing again either (I'll be heading for the "Fozzie Must Go" bandwagon if he gets played there ahead of Will Jordan). But, I also don't see that he's indispensable - I could readily see a team with Jordie on the bench - or even missing out on that to DMac.
@chris-b said in All Blacks 2021:
@nostrildamus said in All Blacks 2021:
@chris-b i can see your line of argument but I don't think they will put JB at wing again but they won't start without him so I doubt they'd start BB at 15. Then again I've been wrong before, I mean I wanted a Crusader to coach the ABs, what was I thinking!?
I don't think they'll put him on the wing again either (I'll be heading for the "Fozzie Must Go" bandwagon if he gets played there ahead of Will Jordan). But, I also don't see that he's indispensable - I could readily see a team with Jordie on the bench - or even missing out on that to DMac.
Biggest puzzle is fitting RM, BB, Dmac and JB into the same 23.
Maybe we could ask John Hart what to do?
-
@chris-b said in All Blacks 2021:
@nostrildamus said in All Blacks 2021:
@chris-b i can see your line of argument but I don't think they will put JB at wing again but they won't start without him so I doubt they'd start BB at 15. Then again I've been wrong before, I mean I wanted a Crusader to coach the ABs, what was I thinking!?
I don't think they'll put him on the wing again either (I'll be heading for the "Fozzie Must Go" bandwagon if he gets played there ahead of Will Jordan). But, I also don't see that he's indispensable - I could readily see a team with Jordie on the bench - or even missing out on that to DMac.
Biggest puzzle is fitting RM, BB, Dmac and JB into the same 23.
Maybe we could ask John Hart what to do?
@crucial said in All Blacks 2021:
@chris-b said in All Blacks 2021:
@nostrildamus said in All Blacks 2021:
@chris-b i can see your line of argument but I don't think they will put JB at wing again but they won't start without him so I doubt they'd start BB at 15. Then again I've been wrong before, I mean I wanted a Crusader to coach the ABs, what was I thinking!?
I don't think they'll put him on the wing again either (I'll be heading for the "Fozzie Must Go" bandwagon if he gets played there ahead of Will Jordan). But, I also don't see that he's indispensable - I could readily see a team with Jordie on the bench - or even missing out on that to DMac.
Biggest puzzle is fitting RM, BB, Dmac and JB into the same 23.
Maybe we could ask John Hart what to do?
the harsh reality is, not a single one of those players is so good that they absolutely must be in the 23.
I can only think of 3 players in the whole country to who that applies.
