Electric Vehicles
-
Drove the Taycan.
It’s unbelievably good. Porsche handling, beautiful to ride in, fast as all hell & is the first electric car I’ve driven since the original Tesla roadster which delivers performance with some drama (still less than petrol drama, but has some).
It’s a real deal game changer for petrol heads like me.
-
And drove the iX3. Summary is that it's a cracking wagon, but comes with the same problem as a lot of electric cars. Its over priced. It's not a 60k GBP car, not even close.
Still, if we can lock in a tax efficient leasing deal it's a bit of a no brainer. So far ahead of the Q4 and XC40 on driving dynamics. Would like to see an iX first though, but that's not likely til 2022.
-
-
@jc said in Electric Vehicles:
Just saw the Audi e-tron GT ad. If I buy one will I be as cool as Tom Hardy?
no
-
-
@jc said in Electric Vehicles:
Just saw the Audi e-tron GT ad. If I buy one will I be as cool as Tom Hardy?
is Tom Hardy cool?
-
@nostrildamus said in Electric Vehicles:
@jc said in Electric Vehicles:
Just saw the Audi e-tron GT ad. If I buy one will I be as cool as Tom Hardy?
is Tom Hardy cool?
The Coolest!
-
@nostrildamus said in Electric Vehicles:
@jc said in Electric Vehicles:
Just saw the Audi e-tron GT ad. If I buy one will I be as cool as Tom Hardy?
is Tom Hardy cool?
-
@nostrildamus said in Electric Vehicles:
@jc said in Electric Vehicles:
Just saw the Audi e-tron GT ad. If I buy one will I be as cool as Tom Hardy?
is Tom Hardy cool?
Cooler than me at least. I get that’s a low bar.
-
@jc said in Electric Vehicles:
@nostrildamus said in Electric Vehicles:
@jc said in Electric Vehicles:
Just saw the Audi e-tron GT ad. If I buy one will I be as cool as Tom Hardy?
is Tom Hardy cool?
Cooler than me at least. I get that’s a low bar.
Low bars help short people get drunk.
-
@mariner4life said in Electric Vehicles:
@nostrildamus said in Electric Vehicles:
@jc said in Electric Vehicles:
Just saw the Audi e-tron GT ad. If I buy one will I be as cool as Tom Hardy?
is Tom Hardy cool?
@mariner4life I think you've confused TSF with your Tinder profile.
-
@majorrage said in Electric Vehicles:
@jc No, but you’ll be the guy who bought the wrong car.
So you've driven a few of these now, what's the right car? Don't quibble about 30kms of range or $10k, what would you get from cars available today?
-
@voodoo said in Electric Vehicles:
@majorrage said in Electric Vehicles:
@jc No, but you’ll be the guy who bought the wrong car.
So you've driven a few of these now, what's the right car? Don't quibble about 30kms of range or $10k, what would you get from cars available today?
It really depends on what you want it for. I've driven and been in most, the only one I think I haven't is the original Audi E-Tron, which are basically impossible to get hold of around here. But here's my summary
If your a driver - Porsche Taycan. By a freaking mile. Best driving experience, best handling, best car. Pricey, but it is a Porsche.
If you want an SUV - BMW iX3. Drives like a car, good space, good practicality. Bit pricey for what it is tho.
IF you want a car - Tesla Model 3. Tech in it is awesome, class leading. Not the quality of BMW / Audi and not cheaper tho. BMW i4 really close here.
If you want a runner- Mini. Has mini handling, a bit of street cred. Range is not great tho.Others I've driven / Seen
Volvo XC40. Looks great I reckon and has good practicality.
Mercedes EQC - absolutely stunning inside, and drives well. But looks very American / Cheap and there is better value to be add. Mercedes pricing doesn't make any sense to me.
Mercedes EQA is a better proposition, but simplyisnt' very big inside.
BMW i4. Basically an electric 3-series. In Gran coupe mode, I think it's a great proposition. Not driven though, but it's a BMW so it will drive well. It's probably what I would buy if could only have one car.
Jaguar I-Pace also goes really well and looks great. But the support infrastructure in the UK is really weak (and it's JLR so it won't be reliable),
Audi E-Tron GT. Cannot see why you'd buy one over a Taycan.
Audi Q4. Not fast, not premium feel, not large range, not worth it.Other Comments
If you want an SUV, the BMW iX could be well worth waiting for
I really like the Hyundai Ioniq, but my wife is a car snob, so there is zero point me looking at it
Same goes for Volkswagen ID-4. Q4 platform, but much cheaper.
Mustang E-Mach, I have the wife car snob issue again so not seen. But I think it could be brilliant. Looks great, but has the wrong name. It's not a fucking mustang.Avoid at All Costs
Tesla Model X. Extremely ugly and far far too expensive.
BMW i3. It's a statement car, not a real proposition
Anything Chinese - DS / Great Wall / MG. Poor quality and bullshit range.There's a few others floating around, but thats the extent of my research.
-
@majorrage said in Electric Vehicles:
Mustang E-Mach, I have the wife car snob issue again so not seen. But I think it could be brilliant. Looks great, but has the wrong name. It's not a fucking mustang
Dunno, I like the name...
-
You haven't looked at the iX3 yet?
I think it looks great, but no AWD option seems a real shame.
-
-
There's a video in this article, but basically it is describing a process Nissan and a Japanese university have been working on to recover rare earth elements from electric motors. They reckon they can get 98% of REE back. More efficient that the present method as well.
Nissan tests an EV motor-magnet recycling breakthrough
Nissan and Waseda University claim they've been able to recover 98% of a motor’s rare-earth elements using their new recycling process.
-
@majorrage said in Electric Vehicles:
@gt12 yeah see the second line!
It’s great. But it’s 60k for an x3.
Oops, reading posts and the fern, yeah right.
I can't see us being in the market for one with no AWD, but the PHEV version is looking more and more likely. We went to look at the Outlander and my wife took one look at the interior build quality and went 'nope' (although that was not the 2022, so it still might be possible). If we end up going to NZ, I assume that having a JP car will be significantly better than something European. Anyone local who can give any thoughts on that?
-
@majorrage said in Electric Vehicles:
Audi E-Tron GT. Cannot see why you'd buy one over a Taycan.
Not trying to wind you up genuinely interested coz the respective sites here in NZ give the Audi more range, power and acceleration for a comparable price. Of course you can go all out on the Porsche but that really comes with a hefty premium.
The reviews I've read of the Audi have all been very positive while acknowledging it's not in the same league as a top of the range Taycan.
Maybe the pricings different in UK.
-
@dogmeat Yeah, it could be a pricing thing.
It really is each to their own, for those who love the feel of the Audi, they may well think it's superior to the Porsche. Yes, I'm a Porsche guy through and through (I currently run a 911) so I'm biased, but I just felt like the Porsche was the superior car. My mate who I drove it with has absolutely no commitment to Porsche, but agreed with me entirely.
We drove the E-Tron GT RS - the fast one. 120k base, I think it was 125 as tested. Then for the Taycan, we drove the base model - the 2WD Taycan. 81k base, 95k as tested (Porsche options are freaking expensive).
Yes, the E-Tron GT RS had the faster acceleration, but there is more to performance than that. Once you've rammed it home a couple of time and had a laugh at it, who knows how often you'll use it. But basic driving dynamics are there 100% of the time. And you really feel the difference in the Porsche. It drives, feels and handles like a proper sorted performance / high spec car. The E-Tron GT feels like an Audi A5. And there's nothing wrong with that, but you feel al little short changed at the price.
Honestly mate if you are potentially interested, you should drive them both. I probably wouldn't recommend anybody buying one without driving the other. But in my situation, I'd buy the slower, cheaper, bottom of the range Taycan, over the faster top of the range E-Tron GT, every day of the week.
BTW, you mention Range ... same platform, same batteries ... difference won't be enough IMHO to really be worth worrying about.
