Foster, Robertson etc
-
@nostrildamus said in Foster:
Ian Jones got Jordie's height conversion wrong so I wouldn't rely on him for weight: 196cm is I think 6 foot 5, not 6 foot 4.
And when was that height taken, was it with shoes or his rugby boots on?
The only thing more inaccurate than rugby weights and heights is NBA weights and heights.
@ACT-Crusader said in Foster:
@nostrildamus said in Foster:
Ian Jones got Jordie's height conversion wrong so I wouldn't rely on him for weight: 196cm is I think 6 foot 5, not 6 foot 4.
And when was that height taken, was it with shoes or his rugby boots on?
The only thing more inaccurate than rugby weights and heights is NBA weights and heights.
Yup but his height does seem to be usually reported as that and he looks that height he's no Ardie Savea.
-
@nostrildamus said in Foster:
Ian Jones got Jordie's height conversion wrong so I wouldn't rely on him for weight: 196cm is I think 6 foot 5, not 6 foot 4.
And when was that height taken, was it with shoes or his rugby boots on?
The only thing more inaccurate than rugby weights and heights is NBA weights and heights.
@ACT-Crusader said in Foster:
@nostrildamus said in Foster:
Ian Jones got Jordie's height conversion wrong so I wouldn't rely on him for weight: 196cm is I think 6 foot 5, not 6 foot 4.
And when was that height taken, was it with shoes or his rugby boots on?
The only thing more inaccurate than rugby weights and heights is NBA weights and heights.
They should do a weigh in before each game for accuracies sake just like fighting sports.
Behind closed doors is fine, we don’t need 46 players going through the motions on live TV.
-
@nostrildamus said in Foster:
With midfielders one stepper and one straight is the way. Doesn't matter which way around(12,13) or even if one or other can do both. As long as one player looks for a weakness and one straightens. That checks the defensive enough that the fullback can watch and direct the next move, either shooting up as an extra or calling it wide and going to support.
Until JB stepped in I feel like we lacked the straightener
https://www.sen.com.au/news/2022/11/07/alatinis-all-blacks-midfield-for-2023-world-cup/
“I think we have to definitely have a look at the performances that Jordie has produced in the 12 jersey in the last two Tests,” Alatini told SENZ’s The Run Home. “Jordie at 12 is a weapon, an absolute weapon,” Jones told SENZ’s The Rugby Run. “The guy is six-foot-four, he’s 108, 109 kgs, gets over the gain line … once we get over the gain line and we analyse the game, then we can play. “If you can’t dominate the gain line, if you can’t get go-forward ball, if you can’t push the opposition back … the game of rugby’s hard. “We don’t want to make it hard, we want to be able to dominate the gain line and dominate the game.”Sounds like a crash-ball merchant to me...
Kidding kidding - but seriously, he is listed at 95-96kgs depending where you look, not quite the 108-109kgs Alatini (apparently Jones, thanks Bones) has him at.
Anyone got a line on an accurate count?
@nostrildamus said in Foster:
With midfielders one stepper and one straight is the way. Doesn't matter which way around(12,13) or even if one or other can do both. As long as one player looks for a weakness and one straightens. That checks the defensive enough that the fullback can watch and direct the next move, either shooting up as an extra or calling it wide and going to support.
Until JB stepped in I feel like we lacked the straightener
https://www.sen.com.au/news/2022/11/07/alatinis-all-blacks-midfield-for-2023-world-cup/
“I think we have to definitely have a look at the performances that Jordie has produced in the 12 jersey in the last two Tests,” Alatini told SENZ’s The Run Home. “Jordie at 12 is a weapon, an absolute weapon,” Jones told SENZ’s The Rugby Run. “The guy is six-foot-four, he’s 108, 109 kgs, gets over the gain line … once we get over the gain line and we analyse the game, then we can play. “If you can’t dominate the gain line, if you can’t get go-forward ball, if you can’t push the opposition back … the game of rugby’s hard. “We don’t want to make it hard, we want to be able to dominate the gain line and dominate the game.”Sounds like a crash-ball merchant to me...
Kidding kidding - but seriously, he is listed at 95-96kgs depending where you look, not quite the 108-109kgs Alatini (apparently Jones, thanks Bones) has him at.
Anyone got a line on an accurate count?
was talking to him at a weetbix breakfast a couple of years back and he said he was 90kg then. Skinny as fark.
no way in hell has he put on 20kgs since then
95 would be pretty accurate I'd say -
I think in the scale of things, Jones will be pretty much on the money.
Jordie has to be a minimum of 105kgs - which is what Rieko is listed at and I think is pretty much right. Bovidae posted a gold standard video of ALB weighing himself at 102.8kgs and Jordie's height has to have him more than that these days.
And there's no shortage of photos of the Barrett boys together - Scott around 120kgs, Beauden 94kgs - and Jordie about halfway between.
-
Whichever way you lean, this is a much better use of a thread than going around in circles talking about bloody Foster and Robertson
Wasn't Foster Backs coach when Nonu really developed after 2011 from being a potentially great 12 into arguably the best in Black ever? :fishing_pole:
-
I think in the scale of things, Jones will be pretty much on the money.
Jordie has to be a minimum of 105kgs - which is what Rieko is listed at and I think is pretty much right. Bovidae posted a gold standard video of ALB weighing himself at 102.8kgs and Jordie's height has to have him more than that these days.
And there's no shortage of photos of the Barrett boys together - Scott around 120kgs, Beauden 94kgs - and Jordie about halfway between.
@Chris-B said in Foster:
I think in the scale of things, Alatini will be pretty much on the money.
Jordie has to be a minimum of 105kgs - which is what Rieko is listed at and I think is pretty much right. Bovidae posted a gold standard video of ALB weighing himself at 102.8kgs and Jordie's height has to have him more than that these days.
And there's no shortage of photos of the Barrett boys together - Scott around 120kgs, Beauden 94kgs - and Jordie about halfway between.
there is zero chance that Reeks is 105. His old man gave a bunch of his training kit from last season to a mate of mine.. he's about 185 not carrying much body fat crossfitter who's about 93kgs and he couldn't even get the jersey on!
He's skinny as fark - remember how he made an effort was it last year to drop a bit of weight to improve his sharpness.
ALB carries a lot more errr.. 'beef' than Jordie -
@Chris-B said in Foster:
I think in the scale of things, Alatini will be pretty much on the money.
Jordie has to be a minimum of 105kgs - which is what Rieko is listed at and I think is pretty much right. Bovidae posted a gold standard video of ALB weighing himself at 102.8kgs and Jordie's height has to have him more than that these days.
And there's no shortage of photos of the Barrett boys together - Scott around 120kgs, Beauden 94kgs - and Jordie about halfway between.
there is zero chance that Reeks is 105. His old man gave a bunch of his training kit from last season to a mate of mine.. he's about 185 not carrying much body fat crossfitter who's about 93kgs and he couldn't even get the jersey on!
He's skinny as fark - remember how he made an effort was it last year to drop a bit of weight to improve his sharpness.
ALB carries a lot more errr.. 'beef' than Jordie@WillieTheWaiter yeah he’s got a bit of muscle on the arms but other than that he’s got a very slim build.
-
@DaGrubster said in Foster:
Yes he was.
By the end of 2015, Nonu was arguably the best 12 ever, not just NZ’s
As this thread has a nostalgic bent, I'll throw this in....
Seen many of the great players and Ireland's Mike Gibson is way, way up there - an absolute legend and those who played against him - Meads, Kirkpatrick, Batty, BG Williams, Laidlaw, etc - thought him the best player of their generation. I saw Gibson live as a teenager, seen loads of videos and never thought I'd see a better 12 - until Ma'a came along.
He is the best 12 I've seen based on his form from 2011 onward. Not just his size and speed but his skill and guile and also the way he played the game. Delaying going to hospital with a broken arm so he could hang his jersey on JP de Villiers peg as it was the latter's 100th Test sums up the bloke - class and humility in spades.
-
@DaGrubster said in Foster:
Yes he was.
By the end of 2015, Nonu was arguably the best 12 ever, not just NZ’s
As this thread has a nostalgic bent, I'll throw this in....
Seen many of the great players and Ireland's Mike Gibson is way, way up there - an absolute legend and those who played against him - Meads, Kirkpatrick, Batty, BG Williams, Laidlaw, etc - thought him the best player of their generation. I saw Gibson live as a teenager, seen loads of videos and never thought I'd see a better 12 - until Ma'a came along.
He is the best 12 I've seen based on his form from 2011 onward. Not just his size and speed but his skill and guile and also the way he played the game. Delaying going to hospital with a broken arm so he could hang his jersey on JP de Villiers peg as it was the latter's 100th Test sums up the bloke - class and humility in spades.
@Victor-Meldrew The old man always said the same thing about Mike Gibson.
-
@Victor-Meldrew The old man always said the same thing about Mike Gibson.
@Old-Samurai-Jack said in Foster:
@Victor-Meldrew The old man always said the same thing about Mike Gibson.
He was a pretty fair 10, too!
-
Tim Horan, in a very striney 'strayian accent, enters the chat.
Best 12 i have seen, a beautiful footballer.
The ultimate compliment i can pay Ma'a Nonu is that, at his peak, he matched what Horan could do on a footy field
-
Tim Horan, in a very striney 'strayian accent, enters the chat.
Best 12 i have seen, a beautiful footballer.
The ultimate compliment i can pay Ma'a Nonu is that, at his peak, he matched what Horan could do on a footy field
@mariner4life said in Foster:
Tim Horan, in a very striney 'strayian accent, enters the chat.
Best 12 i have seen, a beautiful footballer.
The ultimate compliment i can pay Ma'a Nonu is that, at his peak, he matched what Horan could do on a footy field
+1. Horan is best 12 I’ve seen.
-
I never thought I'd see a 12 to rate up with Horan, and if you'd have told me in 2003-2007 that it would be Ma'a I would have called you as thick as Dagg. Not sure if I can split them as there's pros and cons either way (recency bias, whatever the opposite of recency bias is, am I biased towards Ma'a because he's a Kiwi or do I play it down a bit to not look bias, ... etc). I'm just going to sit on the fence. Anyway, we all know former Magpie Bert Cooke was the greatest 12 to play the game (although in the 20s he would have been wearing a different number).
My old man reckoned that Brett Papworth was the best 12 he'd seen and that if he hadn't gone to league (and got injured) he would have been remembered as a great of the game.
-
I used to like coming to this thread to read about how bad Foster is. It was very cathartic. Helped me get through the hard times. Now it's turned into a who's better than Nonu and Smith thread and I don't think I can cope.
-
I used to like coming to this thread to read about how bad Foster is. It was very cathartic. Helped me get through the hard times. Now it's turned into a who's better than Nonu and Smith thread and I don't think I can cope.
@Crazy-Horse said in Foster:
I used to like coming to this thread to read about how bad Foster is. It was very cathartic. Helped me get through the hard times. Now it's turned into a who's better than Nonu and Smith thread and I don't think I can cope.
I will help you out. Foster is a still a terrible AB coach,Selector motivator and pretty much shit at most things .
-
@Crazy-Horse said in Foster:
I used to like coming to this thread to read about how bad Foster is. It was very cathartic. Helped me get through the hard times. Now it's turned into a who's better than Nonu and Smith thread and I don't think I can cope.
I will help you out. Foster is a still a terrible AB coach,Selector motivator and pretty much shit at most things .
-
@mariner4life said in Foster:
Tim Horan, in a very striney 'strayian accent, enters the chat.
Best 12 i have seen, a beautiful footballer.
The ultimate compliment i can pay Ma'a Nonu is that, at his peak, he matched what Horan could do on a footy field
+1. Horan is best 12 I’ve seen.
@Billy-Tell said in Foster:
@mariner4life said in Foster:
Tim Horan, in a very striney 'strayian accent, enters the chat.
Best 12 i have seen, a beautiful footballer.
The ultimate compliment i can pay Ma'a Nonu is that, at his peak, he matched what Horan could do on a footy field
+1. Horan is best 12 I’ve seen.
I saw Horan play live at least 20 times. Thought he was easily the best...until I saw Nonu play live. He had all the skills of Horan plus PI beast mode. Absolute freak of a player.
-
I never thought I'd see a 12 to rate up with Horan, and if you'd have told me in 2003-2007 that it would be Ma'a I would have called you as thick as Dagg. Not sure if I can split them as there's pros and cons either way (recency bias, whatever the opposite of recency bias is, am I biased towards Ma'a because he's a Kiwi or do I play it down a bit to not look bias, ... etc). I'm just going to sit on the fence. Anyway, we all know former Magpie Bert Cooke was the greatest 12 to play the game (although in the 20s he would have been wearing a different number).
My old man reckoned that Brett Papworth was the best 12 he'd seen and that if he hadn't gone to league (and got injured) he would have been remembered as a great of the game.
I never thought I'd see a 12 to rate up with Horan, and if you'd have told me in 2003-2007 that it would be Ma'a I would have called you as thick as Dagg. Not sure if I can split them as there's pros and cons either way (recency bias, whatever the opposite of recency bias is, am I biased towards Ma'a because he's a Kiwi or do I play it down a bit to not look bias, ... etc). I'm just going to sit on the fence. Anyway, we all know former Magpie Bert Cooke was the greatest 12 to play the game (although in the 20s he would have been wearing a different number).
My old man reckoned that Brett Papworth was the best 12 he'd seen and that if he hadn't gone to league (and got injured) he would have been remembered as a great of the game.
I've heard similar assessments. Trevor Gillmeister played with him for about 2 seconds at the Roosters and rated him the GOAT. Could see he was in another universe even based on such a minimal length of time.
