Argentina v All Blacks
-
Weak defence down the left side in particular is a worry. RI And CC positional defensive work has not been great.. Usually saved by Reikos pace, but that's often after the damage has been done.
And I am also not convinced BB is a strong defensive 15.
Hope Lord has a good game, and Frizzel needs to show why he's even in the squad as SB can't do it on his own..Can see Pumas winning this one.
-
May not be team I would of picked, but no probs really, it's WC year, and we got Boks next week, so guess they want to look at a few thing? I a little surpised but pleased that Lord has got a start, makes sense to see how DMac goes running the ship too, no real big prob with a fairly heavy start for players who have not played for a few weeks, freshen up won't hurt them. Perhaps Stevenson may have been worth a look, but as he really only injury replacement for Telea who seems is close to right, maybe he will be out of squad nest week anyway.
-
Makes sense to see how D Mac runs the ship?? How many games do you think we have before the World Cup? If BB is a FB why wasn’t he playing there all SR. I get that some players need a rest, but this is a weird team. Ofa and Casey’s little brother should have been gone a long time ago. I think Fozzie is up to his same old tricks and we’re going to see the same old results. I would love to be proven wrong.
-
Weak defence down the left side in particular is a worry. RI And CC positional defensive work has not been great.. Usually saved by Reikos pace, but that's often after the damage has been done.
And I am also not convinced BB is a strong defensive 15.
Hope Lord has a good game, and Frizzel needs to show why he's even in the squad as SB can't do it on his own..Can see Pumas winning this one.
@Mattasaurus said in Argentina v All Blacks:
Weak defence down the left side in particular is a worry. RI And CC positional defensive work has not been great.. Usually saved by Reikos pace, but that's often after the damage has been done.
And I am also not convinced BB is a strong defensive 15.
Hope Lord has a good game, and Frizzel needs to show why he's even in the squad as SB can't do it on his own..Can see Pumas winning this one.
Another foster first
-
I’m gutted for Stevenson. What does that guy have to do to get a break?
-
@KiwiMurph said in Argentina v All Blacks:
Beauden at 15.
That will go down well
That was always going to happen.
Again, he can't be rated as a 1st 5 if Mo'unga is on the bench.
-
@KiwiMurph said in Argentina v All Blacks:
Beauden at 15.
That will go down well
That was always going to happen.
Again, he can't be rated as a 1st 5 if Mo'unga is on the bench.
@Bovidae said in Argentina v All Blacks:
@KiwiMurph said in Argentina v All Blacks:
Beauden at 15.
That will go down well
That was always going to happen.
Again, he can't be rated as a 1st 5 if Mo'unga is on the bench.
Small mercies
-
Well fuck. I know I said I expected BBBR or SW would be rested, but I did expect to see ONE of them on the bench at least. And if I have to suffer a Frizzle, then Paps, Cane and Ardie better play their arses off. Pleased for Narawa and Lord. Christie is still ginga. Meh.
@Jailbreak7 Whitelock was never going to play as he hadn't been involved in training in NZ.
Hopefully this selection means that many of the players not in the 23 are playing SA.
-
I’m gutted for Stevenson. What does that guy have to do to get a break?
@Darth-Sader said in Argentina v All Blacks:
I’m gutted for Stevenson. What does that guy have to do to get a break?
I’m guessing if telia was available he and narewa would have had a start each in these first two games at 14 ,
Because he’s brought in as cover for telia maybe he’s a chance in the second game at 14, but I wasn’t optimistic for him at fb considering they thought they had that position covered with their original selections
-
@Darth-Sader said in Argentina v All Blacks:
I’m gutted for Stevenson. What does that guy have to do to get a break?
I’m guessing if telia was available he and narewa would have had a start each in these first two games at 14 ,
Because he’s brought in as cover for telia maybe he’s a chance in the second game at 14, but I wasn’t optimistic for him at fb considering they thought they had that position covered with their original selections
@kiwiinmelb Telea is in Argentina and has been training, so assume he is a shot at starting next week as I doubt they will give SS a shot v SA...poor fella has been probably one of the best players in Super and NPC in the past year or so and cant get a shot.
-
@kiwiinmelb Telea is in Argentina and has been training, so assume he is a shot at starting next week as I doubt they will give SS a shot v SA...poor fella has been probably one of the best players in Super and NPC in the past year or so and cant get a shot.
@taniwharugby said in Argentina v All Blacks:
@kiwiinmelb Telea is in Argentina and has been training, so assume he is a shot at starting next week as I doubt they will give SS a shot v SA...poor fella has been probably one of the best players in Super and NPC in the past year or so and cant get a shot.
Unless their planning was also to give Jordan a crack at fb , and the migraine issues continue, a door may open there .
-
@taniwharugby said in Argentina v All Blacks:
@kiwiinmelb Telea is in Argentina and has been training, so assume he is a shot at starting next week as I doubt they will give SS a shot v SA...poor fella has been probably one of the best players in Super and NPC in the past year or so and cant get a shot.
Unless their planning was also to give Jordan a crack at fb , and the migraine issues continue, a door may open there .
@kiwiinmelb hopefully, he has earnt a shot.
-
Most gutted for Stevenson, this was likely his biggest shot for time given he is only there as cover for Telea.
A few good calls otherwise, based on actual form, some on reputation, however tarnished.
@taniwharugby said in Argentina v All Blacks:
Most gutted for Stevenson, this was likely his biggest shot for time given he is only there as cover for Telea.
A few good calls otherwise, based on actual form, some on reputation, however tarnished.
Seems like a wasted opportunity to see what the form back in SR could do at test level
-
Which top level test sides would the following get a game for in 2023?
Coles
Lord
Frizzell
BB
Vaai
Christie
EnnorHell even JB at 12?
While i.get this isn't the first 23, it's still super average
I hope they play well, but shit.... -
Which top level test sides would the following get a game for in 2023?
Coles
Lord
Frizzell
BB
Vaai
Christie
EnnorHell even JB at 12?
While i.get this isn't the first 23, it's still super average
I hope they play well, but shit.... -
@mariner4life Actually I quite rate Vaai, but point taken about the rest. They would get no where near a French or Irish starting line-up.
@sparky well I reckon other international coaches would get better from most of them, so maybe they would.
-
