RWC QF: All Blacks v Ireland
-
@kiwiinmelb said in RWC QF: All Blacks v Ireland:
Watching irelands attacking patterns , body’s in motion everywhere, it’s impressive,
Much has been made of our somewhat outdated defensive structures where we still go man on man.
I have a fear we get a few reads wrong and it costs us .
Some of it can be pretty borderline. In a way it reminds me of the excellent Brumbies teams who used to put a lot of runners ahead of the ball, until they weren't allowed to anymore
-
So with Lomax pronounced fit, I think this is the likely 23?
- de Groot
- Taylor
- Lomax
- Barrett
- Retallick
- Frizell
- Cane
- Savea
- Smith
- Mo'unga
- Telea
- Barrett
- Ioane
- Jordan
- Barrett
- Coles
- Tu'ungafasi
- Newell
- Whitelock
- Papalii
- Roigard
- McKenzie
- Lienert-Brown
-
Got a feeling on the bench they will go for Christie over Roigard as well , experience needed
@george33 said in RWC QF: All Blacks v Ireland:
Got a feeling on the bench they will go for Christie over Roigard as well , experience needed
can we get one of the "fluffy bunny" filters set up for the word "experience"?
experience at being bang "average"? he's only got 19 tests so hardly a veteran who has been through some shit and come out on top...playing smith for 60-70 minutes is the fucking experience we need
-
This week I sort of feel the same as the Aussies fans did last week.
Hoping we win and keep the WC dreams alive, also in the back of the mind thinking we could be going home after this weekend, what a shit feeling.@Chris said in RWC QF: All Blacks v Ireland:
This week I sort of feel the same as the Aussies fans did last week.
Hoping we win and keep the WC dreams alive, also in the back of the mind thinking we could be going home after this weekend, what a shit feeling.We have more hope than they did!!!
-
@george33 said in RWC QF: All Blacks v Ireland:
Got a feeling on the bench they will go for Christie over Roigard as well , experience needed
can we get one of the "fluffy bunny" filters set up for the word "experience"?
experience at being bang "average"? he's only got 19 tests so hardly a veteran who has been through some shit and come out on top...playing smith for 60-70 minutes is the fucking experience we need
@Kiwiwomble said in RWC QF: All Blacks v Ireland:
@george33 said in RWC QF: All Blacks v Ireland:
Got a feeling on the bench they will go for Christie over Roigard as well , experience needed
can we get one of the "fluffy bunny" filters set up for the word "experience"?
experience at being bang "average"? he's only got 19 tests so hardly a veteran who has been through some shit and come out on top...playing smith for 60-70 minutes is the fucking experience we need
Ask yourself, in the last 15 minutes when everyone is tiring, and we want someone to do something brilliant that might just turn the game, does Roigard or Christie spring to mind?
-
Roigard should be there, but I reckon there is a slightly more than 50/50 chance that Foster picks Christie. He's got a lot of history of picking the more experienced but poorer performing player in big games, and Roigard made a few mistakes in his last outing that Foster can point to. To be fair, Roigard is something of a risk - a risk worth taking - and of course if Foster had played Roigard more sooner, then he wouldn't be - those mistakes would have been ironed out, or at worst we'd have known properly what the cost/benefit looks like. Still, fingers crossed for the selections - Christie isn't experienced enough to be in the Foster undroppable group.
Foster almost certainly starts Beauden again, despite McKenzie playing miles better all season, though even he must be seeing it by now, surely. I fear we're going to see McKenzie brought on with 10 minutes to play, making a few mistakes when forced to play catch-up footy, not being able to save us and then copping flak for being error-prone. That will shit me.
-
@Kiwiwomble said in RWC QF: All Blacks v Ireland:
@george33 said in RWC QF: All Blacks v Ireland:
Got a feeling on the bench they will go for Christie over Roigard as well , experience needed
can we get one of the "fluffy bunny" filters set up for the word "experience"?
experience at being bang "average"? he's only got 19 tests so hardly a veteran who has been through some shit and come out on top...playing smith for 60-70 minutes is the fucking experience we need
Ask yourself, in the last 15 minutes when everyone is tiring, and we want someone to do something brilliant that might just turn the game, does Roigard or Christie spring to mind?
@canefan said in RWC QF: All Blacks v Ireland:
@Kiwiwomble said in RWC QF: All Blacks v Ireland:
@george33 said in RWC QF: All Blacks v Ireland:
Got a feeling on the bench they will go for Christie over Roigard as well , experience needed
can we get one of the "fluffy bunny" filters set up for the word "experience"?
experience at being bang "average"? he's only got 19 tests so hardly a veteran who has been through some shit and come out on top...playing smith for 60-70 minutes is the fucking experience we need
Ask yourself, in the last 15 minutes when everyone is tiring, and we want someone to do something brilliant that might just turn the game, does Roigard or Christie spring to mind?
i say this as someone that actually quite liked christie...roigard every day...its just such an obvious step up
-
Arrgh!! It has infected the All Blacks! I cannot forgive Foster for this!
https://www.independent.ie/sport/rugby/rugby-world-cup/i-wouldnt-call-it-a-hatred-all-blacks-respect-ireland-but-are-relishing-the-chance-to-set-the-record-straight/a650957055.html
“Last year matters in a sense of taking the learnings, but I believe we're a totally different team to July last year,” Smith insisted. -
So with Lomax pronounced fit, I think this is the likely 23?
- de Groot
- Taylor
- Lomax
- Barrett
- Retallick
- Frizell
- Cane
- Savea
- Smith
- Mo'unga
- Telea
- Barrett
- Ioane
- Jordan
- Barrett
- Coles
- Tu'ungafasi
- Newell
- Whitelock
- Papalii
- Roigard
- McKenzie
- Lienert-Brown
-
@Chris said in RWC QF: All Blacks v Ireland:
This week I sort of feel the same as the Aussies fans did last week.
Hoping we win and keep the WC dreams alive, also in the back of the mind thinking we could be going home after this weekend, what a shit feeling.We have more hope than they did!!!
@canefan said in RWC QF: All Blacks v Ireland:
@Chris said in RWC QF: All Blacks v Ireland:
This week I sort of feel the same as the Aussies fans did last week.
Hoping we win and keep the WC dreams alive, also in the back of the mind thinking we could be going home after this weekend, what a shit feeling.We have more hope than they did!!!
The hope will ultimately bring you down with this team. I am resigned to NZ not winning the cup. We may lose this weekend or the next or the next. It will most likely happen. I have accepted that. As a result I am not at all nervous about this week.
I still want NZ to win though and they have my support.
-
I'd forgotten that Barnes reffed the third Irish test...
Interesting that BBBR can point out the quality of Ireland's ruck play and their exit, and yet we aren't particularly good at either...
I wonder if the TMO should ultimately be replaced by AI. Just as chatGPT can rapidly summarise large amounts of information into a document, surely they could do the same with replay decisions. Set parameters, and allow the tech to see what are considered correct decisions, pretty soon it will get the idea and probably be far more consistent than the guys doing the job right now
-
I'd forgotten that Barnes reffed the third Irish test...
Interesting that BBBR can point out the quality of Ireland's ruck play and their exit, and yet we aren't particularly good at either...
I wonder if the TMO should ultimately be replaced by AI. Just as chatGPT can rapidly summarise large amounts of information into a document, surely they could do the same with replay decisions. Set parameters, and allow the tech to see what are considered correct decisions, pretty soon it will get the idea and probably be far more consistent than the guys doing the job right now
-
@canefan ha I imagine if we relied on AI, they would pick up all the technicalities we see, and then some...
@taniwharugby said in RWC QF: All Blacks v Ireland:
@canefan ha I imagine if we relied on AI, they would pick up all the technicalities we see, and then some...
Its all about setting parameters. I don't know if you have used chat GPT. The tech is amazing. Build a bank of correct decisions, especially in terms of tackling, and it could be taught to match up similar situations and make a ruling based on that
-
@taniwharugby said in RWC QF: All Blacks v Ireland:
@canefan ha I imagine if we relied on AI, they would pick up all the technicalities we see, and then some...
Its all about setting parameters. I don't know if you have used chat GPT. The tech is amazing. Build a bank of correct decisions, especially in terms of tackling, and it could be taught to match up similar situations and make a ruling based on that
-
@canefan not sure I'm with you then.
Wouldnt you be setting parameters for it to allow stuff to be let go?
It is either a knock on/forward pass, or it isnt, it is through the gate or it isnt, no leeway really?
@taniwharugby said in RWC QF: All Blacks v Ireland:
@canefan not sure I'm with you then.
Wouldnt you be setting parameters for it to allow stuff to be let go?
It is either a knock on/forward pass, or it isnt, it is through the gate or it isnt, no leeway really?
I wouldn't use it for everything. The thought occurred because I read that article about Irish test 3 and Porter getting away with a similar tackle to Angus. AI should be able to recognise that both incidents were similar enough to warrant the same penalty
-
Ouch...
-
Not the week TR...
-
@frugby Ofa for Newell that's a certain and Christie/ Roigard 50/50, experience mite count tho Schmidt will have a say I imagine on that call
@george33 said in RWC QF: All Blacks v Ireland:
@frugby Ofa for Newell that's a certain and Christie/ Roigard 50/50, experience mite count tho Schmidt will have a say I imagine on that call
@pakman said in RWC QF: All Blacks v Ireland:
@frugby Laulala will be in 23. Otherwise agree.
To me it seems they like Newell as their impact man in 18, guess we will see.
-
I just had flashbacks to the "tactics" employed in the last test against the Irish, i.e. putting up a bomb on every single farking attack. Good Christ I hope the Guts Trust have shelved that winning approach.
