All Blacks v Argentina II
-
@brodean said in All Blacks v Argentina II:
Finau did enough against England to maintain his place.
Finau did nothing though in his 2 starts he was missing big time so if that is enough to keep your spot nothing, it is not going to get better.
Papali'i I haven't watched close enough to be honest but I will from now on as I don't remember him achieving a lot during the last test.
@Chris said in All Blacks v Argentina II:
@brodean said in All Blacks v Argentina II:
Finau did enough against England to maintain his place.
Finau did nothing though in his 2 starts he was missing big time so if that is enough to keep your spot nothing, it is not going to get better.
Papali'i I haven't watched close enough to be honest but I will from now on as I don't remember him achieving a lot during the last test.
If you mean this as he's not going to get better then this is a silly comment. Lots of players take time to adjust to test rugby. Hell SI fan favourite Blackadder is still taking that time now 5 years into his test career - maybe he'll finally add effectiveness to his busyness.
If you don't mean that what exactly do you mean?
-
@nostrildamus said in All Blacks v Argentina II:
@MN5 said in All Blacks v Argentina II:
Still a but dynamic for my liking.
You might like to clarify this or some of the less generous might suggest you are pumping for more dynamic butts..
I’m not sure what you mean but I gave it an upvote anyway based on your history of good bants.
@MN5 said in All Blacks v Argentina II:
Still a but dynamic for my liking.
Thank you for your generous spirit.
I meant, WTH does "Still a but dynamic for my liking" mean? -
@Chris said in All Blacks v Argentina II:
@brodean said in All Blacks v Argentina II:
Finau did enough against England to maintain his place.
Finau did nothing though in his 2 starts he was missing big time so if that is enough to keep your spot nothing, it is not going to get better.
Papali'i I haven't watched close enough to be honest but I will from now on as I don't remember him achieving a lot during the last test.
If you mean this as he's not going to get better then this is a silly comment. Lots of players take time to adjust to test rugby. Hell SI fan favourite Blackadder is still taking that time now 5 years into his test career - maybe he'll finally add effectiveness to his busyness.
If you don't mean that what exactly do you mean?
@Nepia said in All Blacks v Argentina II:
@Chris said in All Blacks v Argentina II:
@brodean said in All Blacks v Argentina II:
Finau did enough against England to maintain his place.
Finau did nothing though in his 2 starts he was missing big time so if that is enough to keep your spot nothing, it is not going to get better.
Papali'i I haven't watched close enough to be honest but I will from now on as I don't remember him achieving a lot during the last test.
If you mean this as he's not going to get better then this is a silly comment. Lots of players take time to adjust to test rugby. Hell SI fan favourite Blackadder is still taking that time now 5 years into his test career - maybe he'll finally add effectiveness to his busyness.
If you don't mean that what exactly do you mean?
A general comment that if players hold their spot for doing nothing it will not get better, performance levels will always stay at the same level targeted at everyone who does nothing if that is the selection criteria.
-
@brodean said in All Blacks v Argentina II:
Finau did enough against England to maintain his place.
Finau did nothing though in his 2 starts he was missing big time so if that is enough to keep your spot nothing, it is not going to get better.
Papali'i I haven't watched close enough to be honest but I will from now on as I don't remember him achieving a lot during the last test.
On what basis do you think he did nothing?
Finaus carry rate and tackle rate per 80 minutes were both in the top 3 for forwards and he hit rucks too.
-
On what basis do you think he did nothing?
Finaus carry rate and tackle rate per 80 minutes were both in the top 3 for forwards and he hit rucks too.
@brodean said in All Blacks v Argentina II:
On what basis do you think he did nothing?
Finaus carry rate and tackle rate per 80 minutes were both in the top 3 for forwards and he hit rucks too.
For me he made no impact his tackles and clean outs were soft.
and I actually would love to see him hit beast mode we need a 6 who can.
-
@Nepia said in All Blacks v Argentina II:
@Chris said in All Blacks v Argentina II:
@brodean said in All Blacks v Argentina II:
Finau did enough against England to maintain his place.
Finau did nothing though in his 2 starts he was missing big time so if that is enough to keep your spot nothing, it is not going to get better.
Papali'i I haven't watched close enough to be honest but I will from now on as I don't remember him achieving a lot during the last test.
If you mean this as he's not going to get better then this is a silly comment. Lots of players take time to adjust to test rugby. Hell SI fan favourite Blackadder is still taking that time now 5 years into his test career - maybe he'll finally add effectiveness to his busyness.
If you don't mean that what exactly do you mean?
A general comment that if players hold their spot for doing nothing it will not get better, performance levels will always stay at the same level targeted at everyone who does nothing if that is the selection criteria.
@Chris said in All Blacks v Argentina II:
@Nepia said in All Blacks v Argentina II:
@Chris said in All Blacks v Argentina II:
@brodean said in All Blacks v Argentina II:
Finau did enough against England to maintain his place.
Finau did nothing though in his 2 starts he was missing big time so if that is enough to keep your spot nothing, it is not going to get better.
Papali'i I haven't watched close enough to be honest but I will from now on as I don't remember him achieving a lot during the last test.
If you mean this as he's not going to get better then this is a silly comment. Lots of players take time to adjust to test rugby. Hell SI fan favourite Blackadder is still taking that time now 5 years into his test career - maybe he'll finally add effectiveness to his busyness.
If you don't mean that what exactly do you mean?
A general comment that if players hold their spot for doing nothing it will not get better, performance levels will always stay at the same level targeted at everyone who does nothing if that is the selection criteria.
Oh you mean like a perm injured player who continually waltzes back into the side off minimal gametime? Then yes I agree.
-
Finau doesn't have legions of fans, he is just the only player in the squad that has the physical attributes to succeed in the 6 jumper at test level. Akira should be the 6 this year, career best form and has shown he can do it in black in the past, but this group of coaches instead selected a bunch of loosies who are the same player bar Finau and a complete rookie. The problems at 6 right now fall squarely on this coaching groups shoulders for their squad selection, they are idiots for not selecting both Akira and Hoskins in this squad.
-
@Chris said in All Blacks v Argentina II:
@Nepia said in All Blacks v Argentina II:
@Chris said in All Blacks v Argentina II:
@brodean said in All Blacks v Argentina II:
Finau did enough against England to maintain his place.
Finau did nothing though in his 2 starts he was missing big time so if that is enough to keep your spot nothing, it is not going to get better.
Papali'i I haven't watched close enough to be honest but I will from now on as I don't remember him achieving a lot during the last test.
If you mean this as he's not going to get better then this is a silly comment. Lots of players take time to adjust to test rugby. Hell SI fan favourite Blackadder is still taking that time now 5 years into his test career - maybe he'll finally add effectiveness to his busyness.
If you don't mean that what exactly do you mean?
A general comment that if players hold their spot for doing nothing it will not get better, performance levels will always stay at the same level targeted at everyone who does nothing if that is the selection criteria.
Oh you mean like a perm injured player who continually waltzes back into the side off minimal gametime? Then yes I agree.
@Nepia said in All Blacks v Argentina II:
@Chris said in All Blacks v Argentina II:
@Nepia said in All Blacks v Argentina II:
@Chris said in All Blacks v Argentina II:
@brodean said in All Blacks v Argentina II:
Finau did enough against England to maintain his place.
Finau did nothing though in his 2 starts he was missing big time so if that is enough to keep your spot nothing, it is not going to get better.
Papali'i I haven't watched close enough to be honest but I will from now on as I don't remember him achieving a lot during the last test.
If you mean this as he's not going to get better then this is a silly comment. Lots of players take time to adjust to test rugby. Hell SI fan favourite Blackadder is still taking that time now 5 years into his test career - maybe he'll finally add effectiveness to his busyness.
If you don't mean that what exactly do you mean?
A general comment that if players hold their spot for doing nothing it will not get better, performance levels will always stay at the same level targeted at everyone who does nothing if that is the selection criteria.
Oh you mean like a perm injured player who continually waltzes back into the side off minimal gametime? Then yes I agree.
And that could be Sam Cane this week.
-
@Nepia said in All Blacks v Argentina II:
@Chris said in All Blacks v Argentina II:
@brodean said in All Blacks v Argentina II:
Finau did enough against England to maintain his place.
Finau did nothing though in his 2 starts he was missing big time so if that is enough to keep your spot nothing, it is not going to get better.
Papali'i I haven't watched close enough to be honest but I will from now on as I don't remember him achieving a lot during the last test.
If you mean this as he's not going to get better then this is a silly comment. Lots of players take time to adjust to test rugby. Hell SI fan favourite Blackadder is still taking that time now 5 years into his test career - maybe he'll finally add effectiveness to his busyness.
If you don't mean that what exactly do you mean?
A general comment that if players hold their spot for doing nothing it will not get better, performance levels will always stay at the same level targeted at everyone who does nothing if that is the selection criteria.
@Chris said in All Blacks v Argentina II:
@Nepia said in All Blacks v Argentina II:
@Chris said in All Blacks v Argentina II:
@brodean said in All Blacks v Argentina II:
Finau did enough against England to maintain his place.
Finau did nothing though in his 2 starts he was missing big time so if that is enough to keep your spot nothing, it is not going to get better.
Papali'i I haven't watched close enough to be honest but I will from now on as I don't remember him achieving a lot during the last test.
If you mean this as he's not going to get better then this is a silly comment. Lots of players take time to adjust to test rugby. Hell SI fan favourite Blackadder is still taking that time now 5 years into his test career - maybe he'll finally add effectiveness to his busyness.
If you don't mean that what exactly do you mean?
A general comment that if players hold their spot for doing nothing it will not get better, performance levels will always stay at the same level targeted at everyone who does nothing if that is the selection criteria.
Maybe what Razor has been saying about the players not following the coaches instructions is indicative of them not having trust in Holland and McDonald's attacking systems? Or the messages are not getting through because the coaching is poor - I couldn't see us being in this situation if Tony Brown was in their position.
-
@Chris said in All Blacks v Argentina II:
@Nepia said in All Blacks v Argentina II:
@Chris said in All Blacks v Argentina II:
@brodean said in All Blacks v Argentina II:
Finau did enough against England to maintain his place.
Finau did nothing though in his 2 starts he was missing big time so if that is enough to keep your spot nothing, it is not going to get better.
Papali'i I haven't watched close enough to be honest but I will from now on as I don't remember him achieving a lot during the last test.
If you mean this as he's not going to get better then this is a silly comment. Lots of players take time to adjust to test rugby. Hell SI fan favourite Blackadder is still taking that time now 5 years into his test career - maybe he'll finally add effectiveness to his busyness.
If you don't mean that what exactly do you mean?
A general comment that if players hold their spot for doing nothing it will not get better, performance levels will always stay at the same level targeted at everyone who does nothing if that is the selection criteria.
Maybe what Razor has been saying about the players not following the coaches instructions is indicative of them not having trust in Holland and McDonald's attacking systems? Or the messages are not getting through because the coaching is poor - I couldn't see us being in this situation if Tony Brown was in their position.
@darylmitchell said in All Blacks v Argentina II:
@Chris said in All Blacks v Argentina II:
@Nepia said in All Blacks v Argentina II:
@Chris said in All Blacks v Argentina II:
@brodean said in All Blacks v Argentina II:
Finau did enough against England to maintain his place.
Finau did nothing though in his 2 starts he was missing big time so if that is enough to keep your spot nothing, it is not going to get better.
Papali'i I haven't watched close enough to be honest but I will from now on as I don't remember him achieving a lot during the last test.
If you mean this as he's not going to get better then this is a silly comment. Lots of players take time to adjust to test rugby. Hell SI fan favourite Blackadder is still taking that time now 5 years into his test career - maybe he'll finally add effectiveness to his busyness.
If you don't mean that what exactly do you mean?
A general comment that if players hold their spot for doing nothing it will not get better, performance levels will always stay at the same level targeted at everyone who does nothing if that is the selection criteria.
Maybe what Razor has been saying about the players not following the coaches instructions is indicative of them not having trust in Holland and McDonald's attacking systems? or the messages are not getting through because coaching is poor - I couldn't see us being in this situation if if Tony Brown was here instead.
You could be dead right.
-
Finau doesn't have legions of fans, he is just the only player in the squad that has the physical attributes to succeed in the 6 jumper at test level. Akira should be the 6 this year, career best form and has shown he can do it in black in the past, but this group of coaches instead selected a bunch of loosies who are the same player bar Finau and a complete rookie. The problems at 6 right now fall squarely on this coaching groups shoulders for their squad selection, they are idiots for not selecting both Akira and Hoskins in this squad.
Yeah I agree with this. Finau wasn't the best 6 in Super Rugby but he's the only long term option in the squad
-
@Nepia said in All Blacks v Argentina II:
@Chris said in All Blacks v Argentina II:
@Nepia said in All Blacks v Argentina II:
@Chris said in All Blacks v Argentina II:
@brodean said in All Blacks v Argentina II:
Finau did enough against England to maintain his place.
Finau did nothing though in his 2 starts he was missing big time so if that is enough to keep your spot nothing, it is not going to get better.
Papali'i I haven't watched close enough to be honest but I will from now on as I don't remember him achieving a lot during the last test.
If you mean this as he's not going to get better then this is a silly comment. Lots of players take time to adjust to test rugby. Hell SI fan favourite Blackadder is still taking that time now 5 years into his test career - maybe he'll finally add effectiveness to his busyness.
If you don't mean that what exactly do you mean?
A general comment that if players hold their spot for doing nothing it will not get better, performance levels will always stay at the same level targeted at everyone who does nothing if that is the selection criteria.
Oh you mean like a perm injured player who continually waltzes back into the side off minimal gametime? Then yes I agree.
And that could be Sam Cane this week.
@Chris said in All Blacks v Argentina II:
@Nepia said in All Blacks v Argentina II:
@Chris said in All Blacks v Argentina II:
@Nepia said in All Blacks v Argentina II:
@Chris said in All Blacks v Argentina II:
@brodean said in All Blacks v Argentina II:
Finau did enough against England to maintain his place.
Finau did nothing though in his 2 starts he was missing big time so if that is enough to keep your spot nothing, it is not going to get better.
Papali'i I haven't watched close enough to be honest but I will from now on as I don't remember him achieving a lot during the last test.
If you mean this as he's not going to get better then this is a silly comment. Lots of players take time to adjust to test rugby. Hell SI fan favourite Blackadder is still taking that time now 5 years into his test career - maybe he'll finally add effectiveness to his busyness.
If you don't mean that what exactly do you mean?
A general comment that if players hold their spot for doing nothing it will not get better, performance levels will always stay at the same level targeted at everyone who does nothing if that is the selection criteria.
Oh you mean like a perm injured player who continually waltzes back into the side off minimal gametime? Then yes I agree.
And that could be Sam Cane this week.
Hope so (if only to piss off @cantab79/Ali's Choice on PR) Well he has managed to get through 95 tests in his 10 year career so he might be slightly less perma injured ...
-
@brodean said in All Blacks v Argentina II:
On what basis do you think he did nothing?
Finaus carry rate and tackle rate per 80 minutes were both in the top 3 for forwards and he hit rucks too.
For me he made no impact his tackles and clean outs were soft.
and I actually would love to see him hit beast mode we need a 6 who can.
I agree it was a workrate effort so it wasn't high impact.
He contributed to limit England's scoring and helped the ABs deliver more and faster ruck ball.
He didn't set the world on fire but it was enough to build on. He's a genuine athlete with a big ceiling with the right coaching.
Confidence will come with game time.
The lack of go forward at the moment from all the forwards is due to the lateral nature of the attack and the width.
-
@nzzp said in All Blacks v Argentina II:
@darylmitchell said in All Blacks v Argentina II:
I actually don’t think it’s our carriers so much. I think it’s more our attack that's the problem - we’re not putting any deception into how we attack
The carriers are getting stopped on teh gain line all night. And we don't have many effective ball runners. FFS they asked Ardie to do that 19 times - that's ridiculous.
Deception helps, but at some point you need power carries with clarity. So much flat footed ball that we thought would disappear ... but it seems to be a tactic.
True, but also the backline is so lateral and is not asking any questions of the defense - maybe Razor should've got Tony Brown before the South African’s did.
It also seems that Jason Holland's strike moves are about as complex as 'Jordie cart it up the middle' off lineouts and scrums.
@darylmitchell said in All Blacks v Argentina II:
@nzzp said in All Blacks v Argentina II:
@darylmitchell said in All Blacks v Argentina II:
I actually don’t think it’s our carriers so much. I think it’s more our attack that's the problem - we’re not putting any deception into how we attack
The carriers are getting stopped on teh gain line all night. And we don't have many effective ball runners. FFS they asked Ardie to do that 19 times - that's ridiculous.
Deception helps, but at some point you need power carries with clarity. So much flat footed ball that we thought would disappear ... but it seems to be a tactic.
True, but also the backline is so lateral and is not asking any questions of the defense - maybe Razor should've got Tony Brown before the South African’s did.
It also seems that Jason Holland's strike moves are about as complex as 'Jordie cart it up the middle' off lineouts and scrums.
It's not just the backline. A number of other nations look better coached and better structured than we do (and have done for about ~seven years).
I don't think we have the clear distinction of better skills under pressure to rely on anymore.
When was the last time we saw something other than the split pod at lineout time to a runner barrelling through unscathed?
-
@MN5 said in All Blacks v Argentina II:
Still a but dynamic for my liking.
Thank you for your generous spirit.
I meant, WTH does "Still a but dynamic for my liking" mean?@nostrildamus said in All Blacks v Argentina II:
@MN5 said in All Blacks v Argentina II:
Still a but dynamic for my liking.
Thank you for your generous spirit.
I meant, WTH does "Still a but dynamic for my liking" mean?I must have been saying “bit” with a kiwi accent. Good spotting
-
@Chris said in All Blacks v Argentina II:
@Nepia said in All Blacks v Argentina II:
@Chris said in All Blacks v Argentina II:
@Nepia said in All Blacks v Argentina II:
@Chris said in All Blacks v Argentina II:
@brodean said in All Blacks v Argentina II:
Finau did enough against England to maintain his place.
Finau did nothing though in his 2 starts he was missing big time so if that is enough to keep your spot nothing, it is not going to get better.
Papali'i I haven't watched close enough to be honest but I will from now on as I don't remember him achieving a lot during the last test.
If you mean this as he's not going to get better then this is a silly comment. Lots of players take time to adjust to test rugby. Hell SI fan favourite Blackadder is still taking that time now 5 years into his test career - maybe he'll finally add effectiveness to his busyness.
If you don't mean that what exactly do you mean?
A general comment that if players hold their spot for doing nothing it will not get better, performance levels will always stay at the same level targeted at everyone who does nothing if that is the selection criteria.
Oh you mean like a perm injured player who continually waltzes back into the side off minimal gametime? Then yes I agree.
And that could be Sam Cane this week.
Hope so (if only to piss off @cantab79/Ali's Choice on PR) Well he has managed to get through 95 tests in his 10 year career so he might be slightly less perma injured ...
@Nepia said in All Blacks v Argentina II:
@Chris said in All Blacks v Argentina II:
@Nepia said in All Blacks v Argentina II:
@Chris said in All Blacks v Argentina II:
@Nepia said in All Blacks v Argentina II:
@Chris said in All Blacks v Argentina II:
@brodean said in All Blacks v Argentina II:
Finau did enough against England to maintain his place.
Finau did nothing though in his 2 starts he was missing big time so if that is enough to keep your spot nothing, it is not going to get better.
Papali'i I haven't watched close enough to be honest but I will from now on as I don't remember him achieving a lot during the last test.
If you mean this as he's not going to get better then this is a silly comment. Lots of players take time to adjust to test rugby. Hell SI fan favourite Blackadder is still taking that time now 5 years into his test career - maybe he'll finally add effectiveness to his busyness.
If you don't mean that what exactly do you mean?
A general comment that if players hold their spot for doing nothing it will not get better, performance levels will always stay at the same level targeted at everyone who does nothing if that is the selection criteria.
Oh you mean like a perm injured player who continually waltzes back into the side off minimal gametime? Then yes I agree.
And that could be Sam Cane this week.
Hope so (if only to piss off @cantab79/Ali's Choice on PR) Well he has managed to get through 95 tests in his 10 year career so he might be slightly less perma injured ...
Don’t forget @Tim
-
@Chris said in All Blacks v Argentina II:
@Nepia said in All Blacks v Argentina II:
@Chris said in All Blacks v Argentina II:
@brodean said in All Blacks v Argentina II:
Finau did enough against England to maintain his place.
Finau did nothing though in his 2 starts he was missing big time so if that is enough to keep your spot nothing, it is not going to get better.
Papali'i I haven't watched close enough to be honest but I will from now on as I don't remember him achieving a lot during the last test.
If you mean this as he's not going to get better then this is a silly comment. Lots of players take time to adjust to test rugby. Hell SI fan favourite Blackadder is still taking that time now 5 years into his test career - maybe he'll finally add effectiveness to his busyness.
If you don't mean that what exactly do you mean?
A general comment that if players hold their spot for doing nothing it will not get better, performance levels will always stay at the same level targeted at everyone who does nothing if that is the selection criteria.
Maybe what Razor has been saying about the players not following the coaches instructions is indicative of them not having trust in Holland and McDonald's attacking systems? Or the messages are not getting through because the coaching is poor - I couldn't see us being in this situation if Tony Brown was in their position.
@darylmitchell Razor himself has admitted a few times whenever he's referencing the players not doing what they've been told to do, it's on the coaches.
Ambiguous to determine what that means currently, if there are scenarios on the field where they have been told to have a go or play a certain way but have been reverting to habits from previous years.
He seems to want a lot of width. After every match so far in the interview he indicates (literally with his hands) that there were opportunities to shift it where we didn't take it.
Could even be a problem where a team like the Crusaders from previous years had a bunch of guys who aren't stars and are happy to move the ball on.
While being in the All Blacks now, most of these guys have been the 'star' in every team they've been in and are choosing to take contact and have a go rather than move the ball where there is space.
This is all complete speculation and possibly complete crap.
-
I agree it was a workrate effort so it wasn't high impact.
He contributed to limit England's scoring and helped the ABs deliver more and faster ruck ball.
He didn't set the world on fire but it was enough to build on. He's a genuine athlete with a big ceiling with the right coaching.
Confidence will come with game time.
The lack of go forward at the moment from all the forwards is due to the lateral nature of the attack and the width.
@brodean said in All Blacks v Argentina II:
The lack of go forward at the moment from all the forwards is due to the lateral nature of the attack and the width.
The few times we went hard and fast up the middle we scored. So there is the basis of a winning strategy there, as long as we don't keep going away from it (like our runners going away from their support...)
-
@darylmitchell Razor himself has admitted a few times whenever he's referencing the players not doing what they've been told to do, it's on the coaches.
Ambiguous to determine what that means currently, if there are scenarios on the field where they have been told to have a go or play a certain way but have been reverting to habits from previous years.
He seems to want a lot of width. After every match so far in the interview he indicates (literally with his hands) that there were opportunities to shift it where we didn't take it.
Could even be a problem where a team like the Crusaders from previous years had a bunch of guys who aren't stars and are happy to move the ball on.
While being in the All Blacks now, most of these guys have been the 'star' in every team they've been in and are choosing to take contact and have a go rather than move the ball where there is space.
This is all complete speculation and possibly complete crap.
@kpkanz said in All Blacks v Argentina II:
@darylmitchell Razor himself has admitted a few times whenever he's referencing the players not doing what they've been told to do, it's on the coaches.
Ambiguous to determine what that means currently, if there are scenarios on the field where they have been told to have a go or play a certain way but have been reverting to habits from previous years.
He seems to want a lot of width. After every match so far in the interview he indicates (literally with his hands) that there were opportunities to shift it where we didn't take it.
Could even be a problem where a team like the Crusaders from previous years had a bunch of guys who aren't stars and are happy to move the ball on.
While being in the All Blacks now, most of these guys have been the 'star' in every team they've been in and are choosing to take contact and have a go rather than move the ball where there is space.
This is all complete speculation and possibly complete crap.
You could be right the signs point to something similar to that is happening.
-
@darylmitchell Razor himself has admitted a few times whenever he's referencing the players not doing what they've been told to do, it's on the coaches.
Ambiguous to determine what that means currently, if there are scenarios on the field where they have been told to have a go or play a certain way but have been reverting to habits from previous years.
He seems to want a lot of width. After every match so far in the interview he indicates (literally with his hands) that there were opportunities to shift it where we didn't take it.
Could even be a problem where a team like the Crusaders from previous years had a bunch of guys who aren't stars and are happy to move the ball on.
While being in the All Blacks now, most of these guys have been the 'star' in every team they've been in and are choosing to take contact and have a go rather than move the ball where there is space.
This is all complete speculation and possibly complete crap.
