All Blacks v Argentina - Nelson

Wreck Diver

@taniwharugby said in All Blacks v Argentina - Nelson:

@akan004 yeah I know, same applies to Cane, and I expect with the head knocks it is largely bad luck (poor technique the odd time) so if they are right then they are right...although they are still learning when it comes to the effects of concussion arent they.

I think you are right there. I lot of players have bad tackle techniques, getting the head in the wrong position, tackling off the wrong shoulder resulting in HIA for them.

Magpie_in_aus

Interesting fact that I don't know where else it would go. Barrett is two tries outside of the top ten all time for the All Blacks, although Ben Smith is ahead of him at 10th. So probably 4 more tries to crack it providing Ben Smith scores at a similar pace.

Stargazer

Sonny Bill Williams to miss Argentina test in Nelson

The All Blacks and Sonny Bill Williams have re-evaluated his return timetable.

The Blues second-five missed the opening two games of the Rugby Championship while he recovered from shoulder surgery with coach Steve Hansen indicating a return against Argentina in Nelson as the likely comeback date.

Despite Williams' recovery from surgery being on schedule, the 33-year-old isn't isn't confident he will be fully fit for Saturday's test with the Pumas.

Williams said he doesn't believe he is ready for 80 minutes of rugby, but is keen to get back onto the doctors table to get an update.

"It's going okay," Williams told Newshub.

"The doctors said recovery would be anywhere from 10 to 14 weeks - it's 10 weeks at the moment so keen to get back into camp and talk with the medical staff and see how I am tracking. But fingers crossed we are all good to go.

"Probably not right now (ready for 80 minutes) but again, it’s important that I get back into the environment, chat with the medical team and go through a couple good weeks training with the boys."

Hansen agreed, identifying the following week against the Springboks as a more likely estimate.

pakman

My take (excluding Crotty, notwithstanding AB suggestions he's fully recovered):

15 Jordie Barrett
14 milner skuddar
13 Jack goodhue
12 Anton Lienert-Brown
11 waisake Naholo
10 richie mo'unga
9 aaron Smith
8 Kieran Reid
7 ardie savea
6 Liam Squire
5 Brodie retallick
4 scott Barrett
3 owen Franks
2 Codie Taylor
1 Karl tuuinukuafe

Replacements-
Tim Perry
Ofa Tu’ungafasi
nathan Harris
Sam cane
Jason Hemopo
Te taraua tahuriorangi
Damian McKenzie
ngani laumape

Bovidae

The fact that they released TJP late to play for Welly suggests to me that he'll be starting. He did start the home test vs Argentina last year.

cgrant

When is Rieko Ioane back ?

Crucial

@pakman said in All Blacks v Argentina - Nelson:

My take (excluding Crotty, notwithstanding AB suggestions he's fully recovered):

15 Jordie Barrett
14 milner skuddar
13 Jack goodhue
12 Anton Lienert-Brown
11 waisake Naholo
10 richie mo'unga
9 aaron Smith
8 Kieran Reid
7 ardie savea
6 Liam Squire
5 Brodie retallick
4 scott Barrett
3 owen Franks
2 Codie Taylor
1 Karl tuuinukuafe

Replacements-
Tim Perry
Ofa Tu’ungafasi
nathan Harris
Sam cane
Jason Hemopo
Te taraua tahuriorangi
Damian McKenzie
ngani laumape

Too many changes I think. I get the opportunity to give some guys a break before the rest of the year but if BB is going to rest we need BFA at 15 to keep an experienced read on things.
Also think that if/when RM is going to start, they will pair him with Crotty.

pakman

@crucial I don't particularly disagree.

If Mo'unga starts I suspect Crotty will be there to support him, which opens door to TJP start. But I was working from wanting to give Crotty rest, in which case ALB needs to be at twelve (at least for first half) and Nugget at 9.

As I was typing it did strike me that back three quite raw. I think they want NMS to get a start, so including BFA, which I agree is logical/likely, means resting Barrett (J) or Naholo. On balance I'd give Jordie another run, given he is on a learning curve.

ACT Crusader

I can’t see them starting a test match with Richie at 10 and Jordie at 15. Not this early in their careers. Given the importance of our 10 and 15 in counter attack, playmaking etc, they need at least one of our experienced heads to be there.

Crucial

@act-crusader said in All Blacks v Argentina - Nelson:

I can’t see them starting a test match with Richie at 10 and Jordie at 15. Not this early in their careers. Given the importance of our 10 and 15 in counter attack, playmaking etc, they need at least one of our experienced heads to be there.

Exactly.

The spine runs from 2 to 8, 9, 10 and 15. A rookie 10 should be supported with experience at 12 and 15.

Victor Meldrew

@mn5 said in All Blacks v Argentina - Nelson:

They should be thankful it's not Levin or Gore

My ancestors came from Gore. Explains a lot actually, come to think of it.....

Wreck Diver

@crucial said in All Blacks v Argentina - Nelson:

@act-crusader said in All Blacks v Argentina - Nelson:

I can’t see them starting a test match with Richie at 10 and Jordie at 15. Not this early in their careers. Given the importance of our 10 and 15 in counter attack, playmaking etc, they need at least one of our experienced heads to be there.

Exactly.

The spine runs from 2 to 8, 9, 10 and 15. A rookie 10 should be supported with experience at 12 and 15.

That's another bogan ball term that's crept into rugby

pakman

@wreck-diver In the day people used to joke that there was a shiver running up and down Bill Rowlings's back looking for a spine.

pakman

@crucial said in All Blacks v Argentina - Nelson:

@act-crusader said in All Blacks v Argentina - Nelson:

I can’t see them starting a test match with Richie at 10 and Jordie at 15. Not this early in their careers. Given the importance of our 10 and 15 in counter attack, playmaking etc, they need at least one of our experienced heads to be there.

Exactly.

The spine runs from 2 to 8, 9, 10 and 15. A rookie 10 should be supported with experience at 12 and 15.

Again, broadly agree. That said, BFA at 14 would allow quite a lot of input. If more required Waiseke gets a day off.

P.S. I'd be surprised in Crotty doesn't get a start in the land of his father.

ACT Crusader

@pakman said in All Blacks v Argentina - Nelson:

@crucial said in All Blacks v Argentina - Nelson:

@act-crusader said in All Blacks v Argentina - Nelson:

I can’t see them starting a test match with Richie at 10 and Jordie at 15. Not this early in their careers. Given the importance of our 10 and 15 in counter attack, playmaking etc, they need at least one of our experienced heads to be there.

Exactly.

The spine runs from 2 to 8, 9, 10 and 15. A rookie 10 should be supported with experience at 12 and 15.

Again, broadly agree. That said, BFA at 14 would allow quite a lot of input. If more required Waiseke gets a day off.

P.S. I'd be surprised in Crotty doesn't get a start in the land of his father.

I wouldn’t be changing Naholo. He’s in the same camp as Squire for me and starts every test match in this RC. Since first making the ABs he’s been more broken than available, so as long as he’s fit he needs game time. Plus we need his pace against the quick Argie backs.

On Crotty, Hansen doesn’t really do sentimentality.

Machpants

https://www.stuff.co.nz/sport/rugby/all-blacks/106815599/Ryan-Crotty-and-Sam-Cane-both-declared-fit-for-All-Blacks-selection-on-Saturday

Cane and Crotty both down on game time, and a steady 12 outside Mo'unga?

Stargazer

Ian Foster explains why Mo'unga wasn't released for Mitre 10 Cup (video in article):

tvnz.co.nz/one-news/sport/rugby/we-felt-hed-benefit-richie-moungas-all-blacks-waterboy-stint-explained

Machpants

Forum is stuffing up links, you'll have to copy and paste link, then cut out the forum part of the url

Stargazer

@machpants Cheers, I've removed the https://www part from the url and the link seems to work now.

Wreck Diver

@pakman said in All Blacks v Argentina - Nelson:

@wreck-diver In the day people used to joke that there was a shiver running up and down Bill Rowlings's back looking for a spine.

Thats probably because he was a Labour muppet

The Silver Fern

All Blacks v Argentina - Nelson