England v South Africa
-
What a rubbish game of rugby. The Boks really could've / should've won that comfortably. But they were both sloppy and at times just plain dumb against an England team which the nicest thing I can say about is that they hung in courageously - and kicked their penalties.
Annoying game on so many levels:
BOKS:
Poor handling by the Boks.
Shambles of a lineout.
Very stupid managing of the game when they had a one man advantage... Take the scrum ffs!ANGUS GARDINER & AR's:
What is the point of having scrums when you are going to allow England to feed the ball under the feet of their flanker? Gardiner positioned himself on the other side of the scrum at pretty much every England put-in.
Ugh.And in that final phase of the match:
Johnny May a good few meters offsides - how was that missed?
Farrell's tackle... if that is not a shoulder charge then Butch James should never have copped a penalty in his life.But the fact that the above annoyed me so much, is testament to the fact that the Boks were their own worst enemy. Congrats to England for the win, but I can't help feeling that the Boks pretty much beat themselves.
@billy-webb Unfortunately I pretty much agree with all of that. South Africa lost the game more than England won it, and the Farrell tackle was a clear penalty.
I'll take the win but England were extremely lucky. I can't see past an All Black pasting this week though.
-
@bones said in England v South Africa:
Pressure...
https://twitter.com/OmnisportNews/status/1058856348220186624?s=20
After watching that it would almost be cruel if Hansen needled him during the week.
-
@bones said in England v South Africa:
Pressure...
https://twitter.com/OmnisportNews/status/1058856348220186624?s=20
After watching that it would almost be cruel if Hansen needled him during the week.
@rotated said in England v South Africa:
@bones said in England v South Africa:
Pressure...
After watching that it would almost be cruel if Hansen needled him during the week.
Hansen should deadpan some sympathy with him leaving the press to decipher whether he was being sarcastic or not.
After the game maybe something like 'You blokes should stop hassling Eddie, he's doing a great job and we look forward to possibly meeting him again in Japan'
-
What a rubbish game of rugby. The Boks really could've / should've won that comfortably. But they were both sloppy and at times just plain dumb against an England team which the nicest thing I can say about is that they hung in courageously - and kicked their penalties.
Annoying game on so many levels:
BOKS:
Poor handling by the Boks.
Shambles of a lineout.
Very stupid managing of the game when they had a one man advantage... Take the scrum ffs!ANGUS GARDINER & AR's:
What is the point of having scrums when you are going to allow England to feed the ball under the feet of their flanker? Gardiner positioned himself on the other side of the scrum at pretty much every England put-in.
Ugh.And in that final phase of the match:
Johnny May a good few meters offsides - how was that missed?
Farrell's tackle... if that is not a shoulder charge then Butch James should never have copped a penalty in his life.But the fact that the above annoyed me so much, is testament to the fact that the Boks were their own worst enemy. Congrats to England for the win, but I can't help feeling that the Boks pretty much beat themselves.
@billy-webb saved me a post. All of this.
Rassie needs to find a reliable test match kicker. We win this game if Pollard converts the try or the penalty. Neither were gimmies but Morne Steyn nails both and Monty would have hit at least one.
Rassie's year would look a lot better if Pollard could find his kicking boots more regularly.
-
@billy-webb saved me a post. All of this.
Rassie needs to find a reliable test match kicker. We win this game if Pollard converts the try or the penalty. Neither were gimmies but Morne Steyn nails both and Monty would have hit at least one.
Rassie's year would look a lot better if Pollard could find his kicking boots more regularly.
@smuts Cheer up Smuts, if Jantjies had been playing you would have lost by more. :winking_face:
But yeah, agree with @Billy-Webb we didn't win that game so much as the Boks lost it. Many England fans are lauding the "never say die" mentality of the England defence but who knows if that attitude would have lasted if the Boks had converted more of that pressure early on. As an Englishman I'm very pleased with the result but let's not kid ourselves that we were anything other than rubbish and bloody lucky.
-
@smuts Cheer up Smuts, if Jantjies had been playing you would have lost by more. :winking_face:
But yeah, agree with @Billy-Webb we didn't win that game so much as the Boks lost it. Many England fans are lauding the "never say die" mentality of the England defence but who knows if that attitude would have lasted if the Boks had converted more of that pressure early on. As an Englishman I'm very pleased with the result but let's not kid ourselves that we were anything other than rubbish and bloody lucky.
@catogrande said in England v South Africa:
@smuts Cheer up Smuts, if Jantjies had been playing you would have lost by more. :winking_face:
But yeah, agree with @Billy-Webb we didn't win that game so much as the Boks lost it. Many England fans are lauding the "never say die" mentality of the England defence but who knows if that attitude would have lasted if the Boks had converted more of that pressure early on. As an Englishman I'm very pleased with the result but let's not kid ourselves that we were anything other than rubbish and bloody lucky.
Yeah, we'll never know how that game would have developed had the Boks scored quickly after Itoje was sent off. One might guess that they would immediately plug the corner and have another crack. IF that was successful England would have had to start scoring tries and the whole shape of the game is different.
-
@catogrande said in England v South Africa:
@smuts Cheer up Smuts, if Jantjies had been playing you would have lost by more. :winking_face:
But yeah, agree with @Billy-Webb we didn't win that game so much as the Boks lost it. Many England fans are lauding the "never say die" mentality of the England defence but who knows if that attitude would have lasted if the Boks had converted more of that pressure early on. As an Englishman I'm very pleased with the result but let's not kid ourselves that we were anything other than rubbish and bloody lucky.
Yeah, we'll never know how that game would have developed had the Boks scored quickly after Itoje was sent off. One might guess that they would immediately plug the corner and have another crack. IF that was successful England would have had to start scoring tries and the whole shape of the game is different.
@crucial Jantjies probably would have nailed one of the two kicks...
also think he might have found more holes in England defence. Pollard just isn't great at setting other players free. He has other strengths but this game showed his limitations.
I can also understand why the Boks kept trying to punish England's maul, but I really, really wish this bok team would use its scrum as an offensive weapon in the red zone, especially when you've already reduced the opposition to 7 men.
And that is one of pollard's strengths - running at the line off the 5 yard scrum. I mean, either you crush the English scrum (and potentially get a prop sent off) or you set Pollard, DDA or Nkosi at the weak English inside channel. Seems a much higher percentage play than the lineout.
-
@rotated said in England v South Africa:
@bones said in England v South Africa:
Pressure...
After watching that it would almost be cruel if Hansen needled him during the week.
Hansen should deadpan some sympathy with him leaving the press to decipher whether he was being sarcastic or not.
After the game maybe something like 'You blokes should stop hassling Eddie, he's doing a great job and we look forward to possibly meeting him again in Japan'
@crucial said in England v South Africa:
@rotated said in England v South Africa:
@bones said in England v South Africa:
Pressure...
After watching that it would almost be cruel if Hansen needled him during the week.
Hansen should deadpan some sympathy with him leaving the press to decipher whether he was being sarcastic or not.
After the game maybe something like 'You blokes should stop hassling Eddie, he's doing a great job and we look forward to possibly meeting him again in Japan'
-
Nice to see that humour is still a go-to coping mecahnism:
-
-
@machpants bloody hell Rassie looks small in that clip. That's a centre doing the tackling right?
-
@mn5 said in England v South Africa:
@bones they can't all be Andre Venters, some of them are human sized too
I think Venter is a Kaino equivalent and Rassie is a Messam equivalent.
-
@nepia said in England v South Africa:
I saw a tallish but not particularly large bloke in the gym a couple of months ago and was surprised that on closer inspection it was Dallaglio. I'd say he's lost a couple of stone since his playing days. So not too surprising Rassie does seem particularly large against AE who is 6' 4 1/2.
-
@nepia said in England v South Africa:
I saw a tallish but not particularly large bloke in the gym a couple of months ago and was surprised that on closer inspection it was Dallaglio. I'd say he's lost a couple of stone since his playing days. So not too surprising Rassie does seem particularly large against AE who is 6' 4 1/2.
-
My son works with quite a few ex players as a trainer to change their bodies for life after code. Gone are the days when an ex-player just goes to fat (unless that's their choice). Sports science is pretty good now on 'shifting' bulk or removing it gradually.
Many do end up taking up other sports as they realise the competitive drive hasn't gone. -
What a rubbish game of rugby. The Boks really could've / should've won that comfortably. But they were both sloppy and at times just plain dumb against an England team which the nicest thing I can say about is that they hung in courageously - and kicked their penalties.
Annoying game on so many levels:
BOKS:
Poor handling by the Boks.
Shambles of a lineout.
Very stupid managing of the game when they had a one man advantage... Take the scrum ffs!ANGUS GARDINER & AR's:
What is the point of having scrums when you are going to allow England to feed the ball under the feet of their flanker? Gardiner positioned himself on the other side of the scrum at pretty much every England put-in.
Ugh.And in that final phase of the match:
Johnny May a good few meters offsides - how was that missed?
Farrell's tackle... if that is not a shoulder charge then Butch James should never have copped a penalty in his life.But the fact that the above annoyed me so much, is testament to the fact that the Boks were their own worst enemy. Congrats to England for the win, but I can't help feeling that the Boks pretty much beat themselves.
@billy-webb Another annoying thing about the game was the nothingness of the penalties that England scored off
1 off side from a knockon
2 off side where there was no pressure, just poor timing
3 not sure, De Allende was disrupting with his boot, but again a nothing position in the middle of the pitch
4 contact in the air at the line out (I thought that was soft, but Itoje gave away very soft one earlier) - missed
5 - a scrum penalty that went the wrong way, but at least this one was in dangerous position ( we also scored from a incorrect call in the first half).It's not like we were robbed, just really soft points to concede, which sucks hairy ones.
