AB squad for the Rugby Championship
-
@pukunui He didn't have any that weren't straight, did he? They were just "a bit short" and picked off by the Argies.
Same thing used to happen when we had a loose trio of Jerry, Richie and Rodders. Our hookers just couldn't throw....
@Chris-B said in AB squad for the Rugby Championship:
@pukunui He didn't have any that weren't straight, did he? They were just "a bit short" and picked off by the Argies.
Same thing used to happen when we had a loose trio of Jerry, Richie and Rodders. Our hookers just couldn't throw....
I can’t remember if the length was his only issue. Still think it is a long bow to draw to blame his poor throwing on the height of the back row when he was throwing low to the guys who supposedly too short.
To be honest i agree height is important and ideally your 6 would have it all but along with speed i would have height well down the list of attributes that are essential in an AB 6.
Hard hitting defence and work rate would be the top and probably ball carrying next. I think you get those things and the attributes of an AB 7 in a combination of Cane and Savea with Savea bring the ball carrying.Scott Barrett or Hemopo may be the answer too.
Fifita is not and Jacobson is an unknown. Time is running out. -
@Chris-B said in AB squad for the Rugby Championship:
@pukunui He didn't have any that weren't straight, did he? They were just "a bit short" and picked off by the Argies.
Same thing used to happen when we had a loose trio of Jerry, Richie and Rodders. Our hookers just couldn't throw....
I can’t remember if the length was his only issue. Still think it is a long bow to draw to blame his poor throwing on the height of the back row when he was throwing low to the guys who supposedly too short.
To be honest i agree height is important and ideally your 6 would have it all but along with speed i would have height well down the list of attributes that are essential in an AB 6.
Hard hitting defence and work rate would be the top and probably ball carrying next. I think you get those things and the attributes of an AB 7 in a combination of Cane and Savea with Savea bring the ball carrying.Scott Barrett or Hemopo may be the answer too.
Fifita is not and Jacobson is an unknown. Time is running out.@pukunui As I recall, I don't think there were any scrums - I think the Argies just got in front of our jumpers and knocked them down. Someone else might have the game recorded and look at who we were throwing to, but I bet at least one was aimed at Retallick - and everyone else would likely have been jumping against someone taller without a lot of deception.
B&I Lions did the same against the Crusaders - double-teamed Sam Whitelock when our other options were poor.
Size is important in all things. A number of instances where its been reported that the AB coaches have asked players to put on a few more kgs. Hookers and loosies especially. They wouldn't be doing that if it wasn't important - and for more than lineouts. Winning rugby is about winning the collisions and good big guys win the collisions against good little guys.
(They've also asked a few fat props to trim down for obvious reasons).
Hansen likes big opensides - McCaw and Cane have been his first choices. He likes big blindsides as well.
We're dug into a bit of a hole at 6 and you're dead right - time is running out.
-
@Chris-B Not to bring up player height again, but outside of Lavanini, you might be surprised at how short the Argentinean locks/loosies are.
@Bovidae You're probably right - I've got little idea- apart from that Matera is a decent size and seems exactly what we need.
I guess that Jaguares guy got banned again, since he doesn't appear to be weighing in on anything. He'd doubtless have some stats at his fingertips...
-
It does seem to me that if you’re throwing to a shorter target in a contested line out you have a smaller margin for error. You’d be pretty confident you could put it high for BBBR, Whitelock & Read and back them to haul it in as they’re both tall and good jumpers.
Height may not be the only factor but being good in the line out is pretty important, you don’t want your Hooker under pressure as it’s a tough job at the best of times.
-
It does seem to me that if you’re throwing to a shorter target in a contested line out you have a smaller margin for error. You’d be pretty confident you could put it high for BBBR, Whitelock & Read and back them to haul it in as they’re both tall and good jumpers.
Height may not be the only factor but being good in the line out is pretty important, you don’t want your Hooker under pressure as it’s a tough job at the best of times.
@No-Quarter Don't believe anyone who tries to tell you different!
We've had a dominant lineout with:
Retallick 2.04 m
Whitelock 2.02 m
Kaino 1.96 m
Read 1.94 mAll tall men for their position - and Read and Whitelock are superb jumpers. Read's been IMO opinion the best 3rd option in the world for a long time - and Whitelock probably the best overall - though there's doubtless some NH people who would tout their own guys.
-
@SammyC said in AB squad for the Rugby Championship:
Patronising bulshit from Fox.
How so?
I'm firmly in the camp that Hansen & co have reached their used-by date and are bottling this RWC campaign but I don't quite get how how that is patronising.
-
@Chris-B Not to bring up player height again, but outside of Lavanini, you might be surprised at how short the Argentinean locks/loosies are.
@Bovidae said in AB squad for the Rugby Championship:
@Chris-B Not to bring up player height again, but outside of Lavanini, you might be surprised at how short the Argentinean locks/loosies are.
ARG v NZL
Starting locks:
Tomás Lavanini - 2.01m | 123 KG
Guido Petti Pagadizábal - 1.94m | 110 KGReserve lock (replaced Kremer):
Matías Alemanno - 1.98m | 112 KGStarting loosies:
6 Pablo Matera – 1.93m | 107 KG
7 Marcos Kremer – 1.95m | 116 KG (also plays at lock)
8 Javier Ortega Desio - 1.93m | 109 KGReserve loosie (replaced Lavanini):
Tomás Lezana - 1.87m | 102 KG -
Regarding 6, I'm still kind of hoping Fifita comes good, and that TWM see something in him we don't in training/data etc.
I think of the start of Kaino's career, he played the BaaBaas games in 2003 (I think) then was nowhere for years, before finally becoming an AB regular post 2007 RWC. And by 2011 RWC was the best in the world (how did he not win player of the year in '11 over Dusatoir?!). Like Fifita, he was a super athlete at the start of his career, but too loose. I think he was the fastest player in the Auckland team at one stage? Then as he matured, tightened his game up, and then just crushed ppl at Test level for nearly a decade.
Only issue with this comparison is Fifita isn't that young at 27...
-
Yes - you've got to get a man in front. But, that guy has to be tall and fast enough to be competitive.
Last weekend's game saw us get some soft wins at the front from Frizell - no-one up against him.
Contrast that with what we saw at the end of the Argentina game - Liam Coltman being singled out for wonky lineout throwing - but, who were his targets?
Retallick (good), Hemopo, Jacobson, Savea, Cane.
The Argies took us down!
@Chris-B said in AB squad for the Rugby Championship:
Yes - you've got to get a man in front. But, that guy has to be tall and fast enough to be competitive.
Last weekend's game saw us get some soft wins at the front from Frizell - no-one up against him.
Contrast that with what we saw at the end of the Argentina game - Liam Coltman being singled out for wonky lineout throwing - but, who were his targets?
Retallick (good), Hemopo, Jacobson, Savea, Cane.
The Argies took us down!
I can't recall exactly who was jumping in the lineouts your talking about (although I know we lost a couple of key ones when Coltman came on), but my recollection is that they were bad calls (i.e. 2 ball very obviously being targeted even before the throw) compounded by shit throws. I'm not saying that height doesn't play a role (in some cases it clearly will), but that calls, throwing and timing (i.e. as you say a quick jump / lift) are far more important.
-
@Chris-B said in AB squad for the Rugby Championship:
Yes - you've got to get a man in front. But, that guy has to be tall and fast enough to be competitive.
Last weekend's game saw us get some soft wins at the front from Frizell - no-one up against him.
Contrast that with what we saw at the end of the Argentina game - Liam Coltman being singled out for wonky lineout throwing - but, who were his targets?
Retallick (good), Hemopo, Jacobson, Savea, Cane.
The Argies took us down!
I can't recall exactly who was jumping in the lineouts your talking about (although I know we lost a couple of key ones when Coltman came on), but my recollection is that they were bad calls (i.e. 2 ball very obviously being targeted even before the throw) compounded by shit throws. I'm not saying that height doesn't play a role (in some cases it clearly will), but that calls, throwing and timing (i.e. as you say a quick jump / lift) are far more important.
@junior said in AB squad for the Rugby Championship:
@Chris-B said in AB squad for the Rugby Championship:
Yes - you've got to get a man in front. But, that guy has to be tall and fast enough to be competitive.
Last weekend's game saw us get some soft wins at the front from Frizell - no-one up against him.
Contrast that with what we saw at the end of the Argentina game - Liam Coltman being singled out for wonky lineout throwing - but, who were his targets?
Retallick (good), Hemopo, Jacobson, Savea, Cane.
The Argies took us down!
I can't recall exactly who was jumping in the lineouts your talking about (although I know we lost a couple of key ones when Coltman came on), but my recollection is that they were bad calls (i.e. 2 ball very obviously being targeted even before the throw) compounded by shit throws. I'm not saying that height doesn't play a role (in some cases it clearly will), but that calls, throwing and timing (i.e. as you say a quick jump / lift) are far more important.
Thinking about it a bit more, height is likely to be far more important defensively, where you might have a short guy, right at the end of his reach, competing for a ball against a tall guy catching a ball right between his eyes. (Conversely, on attacking lineouts, sometimes the taller guy has to "reach down" to compete against a shorter guy.) But, as I said, on defence, you're really only going to have 2 jumpers, both of whom are likely to be your best and tallest jumpers.
-
In summary, if our lineout turns to complete shit, because our 4th option is a few cms shorter than his opposite, I'd be asking questions of the first 3 (supposedly world class) options before getting too caught up on someone else's height.
@junior said in AB squad for the Rugby Championship:
In summary, if our lineout turns to complete shit, because our 4th option is a few cms shorter than his opposite, I'd be asking questions of the first 3 (supposedly world class) options before getting too caught up on someone else's height.
Yes, not entirely convinced that the current set up with three world class options is worse than 2011 when we had a non-jumping lock.
Who were the third and fourth options behind Matfield and Botha when they used to towel us in the 00's again?
-
@junior said in AB squad for the Rugby Championship:
In summary, if our lineout turns to complete shit, because our 4th option is a few cms shorter than his opposite, I'd be asking questions of the first 3 (supposedly world class) options before getting too caught up on someone else's height.
Yes, not entirely convinced that the current set up with three world class options is worse than 2011 when we had a non-jumping lock.
Who were the third and fourth options behind Matfield and Botha when they used to towel us in the 00's again?
@rotated said in AB squad for the Rugby Championship:
@junior said in AB squad for the Rugby Championship:
In summary, if our lineout turns to complete shit, because our 4th option is a few cms shorter than his opposite, I'd be asking questions of the first 3 (supposedly world class) options before getting too caught up on someone else's height.
Yes, not entirely convinced that the current set up with three world class options is worse than 2011 when we had a non-jumping lock.
Who were the third and fourth options behind Matfield and Botha when they used to towel us in the 00's again?
Danie Russouw probably - a big bastard, but hardly a notable lineout jumper
-
@junior said in AB squad for the Rugby Championship:
In summary, if our lineout turns to complete shit, because our 4th option is a few cms shorter than his opposite, I'd be asking questions of the first 3 (supposedly world class) options before getting too caught up on someone else's height.
Yes, not entirely convinced that the current set up with three world class options is worse than 2011 when we had a non-jumping lock.
Who were the third and fourth options behind Matfield and Botha when they used to towel us in the 00's again?
-
I am thinking that the ABs lost a lot when Broadhurst decided to end his career because of his concussion symptoms. I know he was just OKish against SA but he would have improved. NZ don't have too many locks with such a physique.
By the way, Afeaki would probably be the current starter at TH if he hadn't suffered from concussion. -
@Bones said in AB squad for the Rugby Championship:
It seems there's a bit too much stock/trust put in things Hansen says in pressers. How many times has he said things like Hemopo is a 6 only, Barrett is a 10 only, Cane/Savea/Read won't play together...
he absolutely just makes shit up on the fly to throw everyone off what he is actually thinking
@mariner4life said in AB squad for the Rugby Championship:
he absolutely just makes shit up on the fly to throw everyone off what he is actually thinking
Cunning way to keep the powder dry, I reckon.
-
I am thinking that the ABs lost a lot when Broadhurst decided to end his career because of his concussion symptoms. I know he was just OKish against SA but he would have improved. NZ don't have too many locks with such a physique.
By the way, Afeaki would probably be the current starter at TH if he hadn't suffered from concussion.@cgrant said in AB squad for the Rugby Championship:
I am thinking that the ABs lost a lot when Broadhurst decided to end his career because of his concussion symptoms. I know he was just OKish against SA but he would have improved. NZ don't have too many locks with such a physique.
By the way, Afeaki would probably be the current starter at TH if he hadn't suffered from concussion.Dom Bird is only 28. He never reached the required level in NZ (despite the 2 caps) but I still think he'd be very handy to have around.
-
@cgrant said in AB squad for the Rugby Championship:
I am thinking that the ABs lost a lot when Broadhurst decided to end his career because of his concussion symptoms. I know he was just OKish against SA but he would have improved. NZ don't have too many locks with such a physique.
By the way, Afeaki would probably be the current starter at TH if he hadn't suffered from concussion.Dom Bird is only 28. He never reached the required level in NZ (despite the 2 caps) but I still think he'd be very handy to have around.
@mofitzy_ said in AB squad for the Rugby Championship:
@cgrant said in AB squad for the Rugby Championship:
I am thinking that the ABs lost a lot when Broadhurst decided to end his career because of his concussion symptoms. I know he was just OKish against SA but he would have improved. NZ don't have too many locks with such a physique.
By the way, Afeaki would probably be the current starter at TH if he hadn't suffered from concussion.Dom Bird is only 28. He never reached the required level in NZ (despite the 2 caps) but I still think he'd be very handy to have around.
And... let the Bird puns fly...
-
@cgrant said in AB squad for the Rugby Championship:
I am thinking that the ABs lost a lot when Broadhurst decided to end his career because of his concussion symptoms. I know he was just OKish against SA but he would have improved. NZ don't have too many locks with such a physique.
By the way, Afeaki would probably be the current starter at TH if he hadn't suffered from concussion.Dom Bird is only 28. He never reached the required level in NZ (despite the 2 caps) but I still think he'd be very handy to have around.
@mofitzy_ said in AB squad for the Rugby Championship:
@cgrant said in AB squad for the Rugby Championship:
I am thinking that the ABs lost a lot when Broadhurst decided to end his career because of his concussion symptoms. I know he was just OKish against SA but he would have improved. NZ don't have too many locks with such a physique.
By the way, Afeaki would probably be the current starter at TH if he hadn't suffered from concussion.Dom Bird is only 28. He never reached the required level in NZ (despite the 2 caps) but I still think he'd be very handy to have around.
So what you’re saying is a bird in the hand is better than...
