All Black Coach - Ian Foster
-
@Crucial said in [Poll] Next All Black Coach:
Like Hansen then?
There is a difference though, Hansen took over a team that came with an instruction manual and he probably had a hand in writing a third of it.
All but one of the leadership group were coming back and sans Kaino the entire spine of the team was too. There was a very strong case for succession at the time. The fact we capped four or potentially five 100 test ABs in 2013 (plus two more 50 test ABs including the second highest try scorer in AB history) perhaps made things easier than they otherwise would have been also. The argument against change were there a candidate stronger than Cotter would have been a Nucifora/Brumbies type situation.
This time they never fully figured it out, the captaincy is vacant and at various times over the next two years the most convenient meeting spot for leadership meetings will be Tokyo. Almost everything in terms of style of play including first-five and loose forward mix is up for grabs. If he is bringing institutional knowledge what is it? And what danger is there in rocking the boat - Hansen made multiple big calls in the past year that changed the entire composition of the side?
This is probably why I'm a big fan of Rennie getting the post. The ABs are at a very similar state as the Chiefs when he took over he has a bit of an island of misfit toys and pieces that while brilliant don't exactly go together. That and like Henry I would rather the head coach be overcooked than undercooked.
@rotated said in [Poll] Next All Black Coach:
@Crucial said in [Poll] Next All Black Coach:
Like Hansen then?
There is a difference though, Hansen took over a team that came with an instruction manual and he probably had a hand in writing a third of it.
All but one of the leadership group were coming back and sans Kaino the entire spine of the team was too. There was a very strong case for succession at the time. The fact we capped four or potentially five 100 test ABs in 2013 (plus two more 50 test ABs including the second highest try scorer in AB history) perhaps made things easier than they otherwise would have been also. The argument against change were there a candidate stronger than Cotter would have been a Nucifora/Brumbies type situation.
This time they never fully figured it out, the captaincy is vacant and at various times over the next two years the most convenient meeting spot for leadership meetings will be Tokyo. Almost everything in terms of style of play including first-five and loose forward mix is up for grabs. If he is bringing institutional knowledge what is it? And what danger is there in rocking the boat - Hansen made multiple big calls in the past year that changed the entire composition of the side?
This is probably why I'm a big fan of Rennie getting the post. The ABs are at a very similar state as the Chiefs when he took over he has a bit of an island of misfit toys and pieces that while brilliant don't exactly go together. That and like Henry I would rather the head coach be overcooked than undercooked.
I don't disagree with that, I came around a while back that refresh is possibly better than continuity this time.
My gripe was people saying that the reason Foster shouldn't get the job was because he had a poor record as a coach before being involved at an international level. The comparison was Hansen, who also had a poor track record and ended up doing OK.
-
JJ and Brown is so clearly the best option. It will reflect extremely poorly on the NZRU if they aren't appointed
Joseph will an outstanding front person for the ABs. He looks like an adult.
Robertson looks like too much of a lad still. Fine for Canterbury and the Crusaders. But not for the ABs. And he isn't proven outside the Canterbury / Crusaders environment. He needs to leave and get some overseas experience. And hopefully mature a bit
Another factor. Can Robinson relate to all players from throughout NZ. Rather than reverting back to a Crusaders team. Has he this maturity (I doubt it)
@Winger said in [Poll] Next All Black Coach:
JJ and Brown is so clearly the best option. It will reflect extremely poorly on the NZRU if they aren't appointed
Joseph will an outstanding front person for the ABs. He looks like an adult.
Robertson looks like too much of a lad still. Fine for Canterbury and the Crusaders. But not for the ABs. And he isn't proven outside the Canterbury / Crusaders environment. He needs to leave and get some overseas experience. And hopefully mature a bit
Another factor. Can Robinson relate to all players from throughout NZ. Rather than reverting back to a Crusaders team. Has he this maturity (I doubt it)
I don't care about how they look but do agree that if a JJ/Brown combo are in the mix I would take a bit of persuading to get away from them.
I don't even know if Rennie has applied but Rennie/O'Halloran is also an exciting mix (although without the visible high level achievements) -
@Winger said in [Poll] Next All Black Coach:
JJ and Brown is so clearly the best option. It will reflect extremely poorly on the NZRU if they aren't appointed
Joseph will an outstanding front person for the ABs. He looks like an adult.
Robertson looks like too much of a lad still. Fine for Canterbury and the Crusaders. But not for the ABs. And he isn't proven outside the Canterbury / Crusaders environment. He needs to leave and get some overseas experience. And hopefully mature a bit
Another factor. Can Robinson relate to all players from throughout NZ. Rather than reverting back to a Crusaders team. Has he this maturity (I doubt it)
I don't care about how they look but do agree that if a JJ/Brown combo are in the mix I would take a bit of persuading to get away from them.
I don't even know if Rennie has applied but Rennie/O'Halloran is also an exciting mix (although without the visible high level achievements)@Crucial said in [Poll] Next All Black Coach:
@Winger said in [Poll] Next All Black Coach:
JJ and Brown is so clearly the best option. It will reflect extremely poorly on the NZRU if they aren't appointed
Joseph will an outstanding front person for the ABs. He looks like an adult.
Robertson looks like too much of a lad still. Fine for Canterbury and the Crusaders. But not for the ABs. And he isn't proven outside the Canterbury / Crusaders environment. He needs to leave and get some overseas experience. And hopefully mature a bit
Another factor. Can Robinson relate to all players from throughout NZ. Rather than reverting back to a Crusaders team. Has he this maturity (I doubt it)
I don't care about how they look but do agree that if a JJ/Brown combo are in the mix I would take a bit of persuading to get away from them.
I don't even know if Rennie has applied but Rennie/O'Halloran is also an exciting mix (although without the visible high level achievements)It is important
verse this
-
JJ and Brown is so clearly the best option. It will reflect extremely poorly on the NZRU if they aren't appointed
Joseph will an outstanding front person for the ABs. He looks like an adult.
Robertson looks like too much of a lad still. Fine for Canterbury and the Crusaders. But not for the ABs. And he isn't proven outside the Canterbury / Crusaders environment. He needs to leave and get some overseas experience. And hopefully mature a bit
Another factor. Can Robinson relate to all players from throughout NZ. Rather than reverting back to a Crusaders team. Has he this maturity (I doubt it)
@Winger said in [Poll] Next All Black Coach:
JJ and Brown is so clearly the best option. It will reflect extremely poorly on the NZRU if they aren't appointed
Joseph will an outstanding front person for the ABs. He looks like an adult.
Robertson looks like too much of a lad still. Fine for Canterbury and the Crusaders. But not for the ABs. And he isn't proven outside the Canterbury / Crusaders environment. He needs to leave and get some overseas experience. And hopefully mature a bit
Another factor. Can Robinson relate to all players from throughout NZ. Rather than reverting back to a Crusaders team. Has he this maturity (I doubt it)
Yo say this based on an intimate knowledge of the applicants, their applications and propossals?
-
@Crucial said in [Poll] Next All Black Coach:
@Winger said in [Poll] Next All Black Coach:
JJ and Brown is so clearly the best option. It will reflect extremely poorly on the NZRU if they aren't appointed
Joseph will an outstanding front person for the ABs. He looks like an adult.
Robertson looks like too much of a lad still. Fine for Canterbury and the Crusaders. But not for the ABs. And he isn't proven outside the Canterbury / Crusaders environment. He needs to leave and get some overseas experience. And hopefully mature a bit
Another factor. Can Robinson relate to all players from throughout NZ. Rather than reverting back to a Crusaders team. Has he this maturity (I doubt it)
I don't care about how they look but do agree that if a JJ/Brown combo are in the mix I would take a bit of persuading to get away from them.
I don't even know if Rennie has applied but Rennie/O'Halloran is also an exciting mix (although without the visible high level achievements)It is important
verse this
@Winger said in [Poll] Next All Black Coach:
@Crucial said in [Poll] Next All Black Coach:
@Winger said in [Poll] Next All Black Coach:
JJ and Brown is so clearly the best option. It will reflect extremely poorly on the NZRU if they aren't appointed
Joseph will an outstanding front person for the ABs. He looks like an adult.
Robertson looks like too much of a lad still. Fine for Canterbury and the Crusaders. But not for the ABs. And he isn't proven outside the Canterbury / Crusaders environment. He needs to leave and get some overseas experience. And hopefully mature a bit
Another factor. Can Robinson relate to all players from throughout NZ. Rather than reverting back to a Crusaders team. Has he this maturity (I doubt it)
I don't care about how they look but do agree that if a JJ/Brown combo are in the mix I would take a bit of persuading to get away from them.
I don't even know if Rennie has applied but Rennie/O'Halloran is also an exciting mix (although without the visible high level achievements)It is important
verse this
Yep.
JJ would NEVER wear a track suit.
Robertson would NEVER wear a suit and tie.Coz what they wear is the most important consideration.
-
@Winger said in [Poll] Next All Black Coach:
@Crucial said in [Poll] Next All Black Coach:
@Winger said in [Poll] Next All Black Coach:
JJ and Brown is so clearly the best option. It will reflect extremely poorly on the NZRU if they aren't appointed
Joseph will an outstanding front person for the ABs. He looks like an adult.
Robertson looks like too much of a lad still. Fine for Canterbury and the Crusaders. But not for the ABs. And he isn't proven outside the Canterbury / Crusaders environment. He needs to leave and get some overseas experience. And hopefully mature a bit
Another factor. Can Robinson relate to all players from throughout NZ. Rather than reverting back to a Crusaders team. Has he this maturity (I doubt it)
I don't care about how they look but do agree that if a JJ/Brown combo are in the mix I would take a bit of persuading to get away from them.
I don't even know if Rennie has applied but Rennie/O'Halloran is also an exciting mix (although without the visible high level achievements)It is important
verse this
Yep.
JJ would NEVER wear a track suit.
Robertson would NEVER wear a suit and tie.Coz what they wear is the most important consideration.
It certainly helps if the person looks the part. That JJ certainly does. He looks the part 100% and has all the requirement. Including not being from Canterbury
And SBW will give him a tick too.and he got an outstanding assistant in Tony Brown.
To me its almost a no-brainer.
Compare to Robertson below. smart vs scruffy
-
Quite Happy to leave Razor to rebuild the Crusaders who ever gets the job has a hard job ahead.
It will make or break the coaching unit, its never easy after a WC failure( and not winning is always a failure in The ABs eyes)
The way we play the game over the next 4 years is going to be mighty interesting because whoever comes in better not wast 4 years with the wrong gameplays and selections. -
Quite Happy to leave Razor to rebuild the Crusaders who ever gets the job has a hard job ahead.
It will make or break the coaching unit, its never easy after a WC failure( and not winning is always a failure in The ABs eyes)
The way we play the game over the next 4 years is going to be mighty interesting because whoever comes in better not wast 4 years with the wrong gameplays and selections.@Chris said in [Poll] Next All Black Coach:
Quite Happy to leave Razor to rebuild the Crusaders who ever gets the job has a hard job ahead.
It will make or break the coaching unit, its never easy after a WC failure( and not winning is always a failure in The ABs eyes)
The way we play the game over the next 4 years is going to be mighty interesting because whoever comes in better not wast 4 years with the wrong gameplays and selections.Would be interesting if the JJ/Brown model was to apply the speed approach they used with Japan along with a stronger set piece and defence (and higher player quality). It is very close to the Hansen/Foster design though. We just didn't execute it well at times.
-
@Chris said in [Poll] Next All Black Coach:
Quite Happy to leave Razor to rebuild the Crusaders who ever gets the job has a hard job ahead.
It will make or break the coaching unit, its never easy after a WC failure( and not winning is always a failure in The ABs eyes)
The way we play the game over the next 4 years is going to be mighty interesting because whoever comes in better not wast 4 years with the wrong gameplays and selections.Would be interesting if the JJ/Brown model was to apply the speed approach they used with Japan along with a stronger set piece and defence (and higher player quality). It is very close to the Hansen/Foster design though. We just didn't execute it well at times.
@Crucial said in [Poll] Next All Black Coach:
@Chris said in [Poll] Next All Black Coach:
Quite Happy to leave Razor to rebuild the Crusaders who ever gets the job has a hard job ahead.
It will make or break the coaching unit, its never easy after a WC failure( and not winning is always a failure in The ABs eyes)
The way we play the game over the next 4 years is going to be mighty interesting because whoever comes in better not wast 4 years with the wrong gameplays and selections.Would be interesting if the JJ/Brown model was to apply the speed approach they used with Japan along with a stronger set piece and defence (and higher player quality). It is very close to the Hansen/Foster design though. We just didn't execute it well at times.
It's all very well to be able to play fast. But sometimes you have to play direct and a little bit ugly, so the new coach needs to be able to tighten up our play as well
-
No one really knows who the top 3 or 4 candidates are wanting as their preferred assistant coaches, so it becomes speculation on our part as to the strength of their coaching group. The only thing we do know for certain is that Tony Brown was in demand with 2, if not 3, of those coaches and his loyalty to Joseph is a big plus in his favour, and a blow to Foster and Robertson. McLeod also has some relationship with both Joseph and Foster.
I'm surprised there hasn't been more leaked via the media about potential assistants but maybe that will be known when a shortlist is confirmed.
-
@Crucial said in [Poll] Next All Black Coach:
@Winger said in [Poll] Next All Black Coach:
JJ and Brown is so clearly the best option. It will reflect extremely poorly on the NZRU if they aren't appointed
Joseph will an outstanding front person for the ABs. He looks like an adult.
Robertson looks like too much of a lad still. Fine for Canterbury and the Crusaders. But not for the ABs. And he isn't proven outside the Canterbury / Crusaders environment. He needs to leave and get some overseas experience. And hopefully mature a bit
Another factor. Can Robinson relate to all players from throughout NZ. Rather than reverting back to a Crusaders team. Has he this maturity (I doubt it)
I don't care about how they look but do agree that if a JJ/Brown combo are in the mix I would take a bit of persuading to get away from them.
I don't even know if Rennie has applied but Rennie/O'Halloran is also an exciting mix (although without the visible high level achievements)It is important
verse this
@Winger said in [Poll] Next All Black Coach:
@Crucial said in [Poll] Next All Black Coach:
@Winger said in [Poll] Next All Black Coach:
JJ and Brown is so clearly the best option. It will reflect extremely poorly on the NZRU if they aren't appointed
Joseph will an outstanding front person for the ABs. He looks like an adult.
Robertson looks like too much of a lad still. Fine for Canterbury and the Crusaders. But not for the ABs. And he isn't proven outside the Canterbury / Crusaders environment. He needs to leave and get some overseas experience. And hopefully mature a bit
Another factor. Can Robinson relate to all players from throughout NZ. Rather than reverting back to a Crusaders team. Has he this maturity (I doubt it)
I don't care about how they look but do agree that if a JJ/Brown combo are in the mix I would take a bit of persuading to get away from them.
I don't even know if Rennie has applied but Rennie/O'Halloran is also an exciting mix (although without the visible high level achievements)It is important
verse this
Looks are totally irrelevant. But here you are. Joseph wears tracksuits, too, and Robertson looks good in a suit. Big deal.
-
No one really knows who the top 3 or 4 candidates are wanting as their preferred assistant coaches, so it becomes speculation on our part as to the strength of their coaching group. The only thing we do know for certain is that Tony Brown was in demand with 2, if not 3, of those coaches and his loyalty to Joseph is a big plus in his favour, and a blow to Foster and Robertson. McLeod also has some relationship with both Joseph and Foster.
I'm surprised there hasn't been more leaked via the media about potential assistants but maybe that will be known when a shortlist is confirmed.
@Bovidae Yeah, I can't wait to find out who the candidates are, and particularly, the combos. People also seem to forget that Joseph and Brown are negotiating with Japan and may get an offer they can't refuse. So they might not be available or pull out. We simply don't know. Is it even a certainty that Robertson doesn't want to be an assistant, or was that just speculation or misinterpretation by a journo? I'd be most happy with a trio of Joseph, Brown and Robertson. I'd would be most unhappy if either Hammett or Philpott are somehow involved in whatever capacity. I also hope Plumtree isn't one of the candidates, or Boyd, or Lam. I don't think Foster would be a disaster, but a lot will depend on who he picks as his assistants.
-
@Machpants :face_with_tears_of_joy: Now that would be something I'd want to watch!!
-
@Crucial said in [Poll] Next All Black Coach:
@Chris said in [Poll] Next All Black Coach:
Quite Happy to leave Razor to rebuild the Crusaders who ever gets the job has a hard job ahead.
It will make or break the coaching unit, its never easy after a WC failure( and not winning is always a failure in The ABs eyes)
The way we play the game over the next 4 years is going to be mighty interesting because whoever comes in better not wast 4 years with the wrong gameplays and selections.Would be interesting if the JJ/Brown model was to apply the speed approach they used with Japan along with a stronger set piece and defence (and higher player quality). It is very close to the Hansen/Foster design though. We just didn't execute it well at times.
It's all very well to be able to play fast. But sometimes you have to play direct and a little bit ugly, so the new coach needs to be able to tighten up our play as well
@canefan said in [Poll] Next All Black Coach:
@Crucial said in [Poll] Next All Black Coach:
@Chris said in [Poll] Next All Black Coach:
Quite Happy to leave Razor to rebuild the Crusaders who ever gets the job has a hard job ahead.
It will make or break the coaching unit, its never easy after a WC failure( and not winning is always a failure in The ABs eyes)
The way we play the game over the next 4 years is going to be mighty interesting because whoever comes in better not wast 4 years with the wrong gameplays and selections.Would be interesting if the JJ/Brown model was to apply the speed approach they used with Japan along with a stronger set piece and defence (and higher player quality). It is very close to the Hansen/Foster design though. We just didn't execute it well at times.
It's all very well to be able to play fast. But sometimes you have to play direct and a little bit ugly, so the new coach needs to be able to tighten up our play as well
Highlanders style when they were under these two was good. Direct and hard when needed but rapid when on a roll.
Don't forget JJ is renowned as a hard task master and demands toughness -
@canefan said in [Poll] Next All Black Coach:
@Crucial said in [Poll] Next All Black Coach:
@Chris said in [Poll] Next All Black Coach:
Quite Happy to leave Razor to rebuild the Crusaders who ever gets the job has a hard job ahead.
It will make or break the coaching unit, its never easy after a WC failure( and not winning is always a failure in The ABs eyes)
The way we play the game over the next 4 years is going to be mighty interesting because whoever comes in better not wast 4 years with the wrong gameplays and selections.Would be interesting if the JJ/Brown model was to apply the speed approach they used with Japan along with a stronger set piece and defence (and higher player quality). It is very close to the Hansen/Foster design though. We just didn't execute it well at times.
It's all very well to be able to play fast. But sometimes you have to play direct and a little bit ugly, so the new coach needs to be able to tighten up our play as well
Highlanders style when they were under these two was good. Direct and hard when needed but rapid when on a roll.
Don't forget JJ is renowned as a hard task master and demands toughness@Crucial said in [Poll] Next All Black Coach:
Highlanders style when they were under these two was good. Direct and hard when needed but rapid when on a roll.
Don't forget JJ is renowned as a hard task master and demands toughnessThey kicked more than other teams too. Contestable kicks and backing the defence was a big part of that season.
Very different from the possession game Japan played.
